Postmortem brain tissue acquired from individuals who had autism during life is an important tool for understanding the underlying neurobiology and genetics of autism. Although postmortem techniques have been used for hundreds of years to probe the structure of the human brain, the use of systematic, quantitative tools in the field is still very much in its infancy. Indeed, it is largely only in the last five years that these tools have been applied to the study of autism.
One strength of using postmortem brain tissue to study the neuropathology of autism is that multiple factors, from cell structure to gene expression, can be evaluated within an individual brain and compared between diagnostic groups. Typically, a postmortem brain is sectioned down the midline through the corpus callosum to separate the right and left hemispheres. One hemisphere is immersed in a fixative, such as paraformaldehyde or formalin, to preserve the tissue by disabling damaging enzymes and bacteria as well as maintaining the structural morphology. This preparation is ideal for histological studies of microscopic anatomy and cellular characteristics, such as estimating the number of neurons, quantifying the length of dendritic processes, or using antibodies to localize proteins in a particular brain region. The other hemisphere of the brain is generally sliced into coronal slabs (e.g. 1cm thick) and rapidly frozen to protect the integrity of the cells from protein degradation without the use of a chemical fixative. This preparation allows for molecular studies aimed at identifying, measuring the level of, and localizing proteins, neurotransmitter receptors, or genes expressed in cells in a given region of the brain.
Efforts to carry out postmortem brain studies of autism have historically been hindered by poor tissue quality and small sample sizes, with fewer than 150 autism cases studied to date and a mean sample size of 5 per study. Due to the limited number of cases and documentation available, these studies are currently not well positioned to deal with the heterogeneity of autism spectrum disorders. In addition, nearly all of the brains studied have been from adults with autism, well after the period of peak aberrant neurological growth described by MRI studies. Additionally, postmortem studies are obviously limited to observing the end result of each case's neuropathological course, which is influenced by to their individualized exposure to environmental factors, medications, co-morbid symptoms, cause of death, and particular type of autism. Given the heterogeneity of autism spectrum disorders, apparent age-related changes in pathology, and limited quantities of brain tissue available, well-designed postmortem studies must control for confounding factors such as age and gender, and exclude or segregate co-morbid conditions such as epilepsy, in order to detect interpretable differences in brain structure.
Despite these limitations, the availability of more abundant, high-quality postmortem tissue is rapidly increasing. With the recent adoption of modern neuroanatomical techniques in the field such as stereological estimation of cellular number and in situ hybridization for evaluating expression levels of genes, a more complete picture of the neuropathology of autism spectrum disorders may be assembled in the near future. Postmortem studies may bring us one step closer to discovering the etiology of autism by providing the critical link between macroscopic brain abnormalities reported in MRI studies and specific neuropathology, genetic alteration, or other neurobiological events in development.
What's in an MRI voxel?
The answer depends on many factors, including the resolution of the MRI scan, the age of the individual being scanned, and the brain region being examined. Currently, the typical voxel resolution of a T1-weighted scan is 1mm3
. To give some perspective, a typical pyramidal neuron in the cerebral cortex is 10-50μm in diameter (a micron, μm, is 1/1000th of a millimeter). An interneuron is ~10μm in diameter. depicts the scale between a standard 1mm3
MRI voxel and the underlying neuroanatomy. In the amygdala of a typical 3 year old, there are ~7000 neurons in just a single 1mm3
voxel (Schumann and Amaral, unpublished data). In cerebral gray matter (i.e. neocortex) of a 3 year old, there are ~20 billion neurons (Larsen et al. 2006
, Pakkenberg and Gundersen, 1997
) in ~600cm3
, which is over 40 thousand neurons per 1mm3
voxel! To understand the relationship between the gross macrostructural differences detectable by MRI and the cellular microstructural differences evaluated in postmortem research, a helpful exercise is to review the basic anatomical organization of gray and white matter in the human brain.
Figure 1 A depiction of the various levels of detail provided by MRI images and postmortem human brain tissue. At the top of the image, the sagittal rendering from a high-resolution T1-weighted MRI depicts the location of A) three coronal slices at the levels, (more ...)
The mature brain is comprised of approximately 100 billion neurons, and perhaps three times as many glial cells (Pelvig et al., 2008
, Azevedo et al., 2009
). The cerebral cortex is a laminated sheet of gray matter that is 2 – 4 mm thick, and in most regions, neurons are organized into six horizontally arranged cellular layers (). In general, the input layer is layer IV, projections to other parts of the cortex arise primarily from layers II and III, and projections to subcortical regions arise from layers V and VI (Kandel et al., 2000
). The proportional volume of the layers varies markedly across cortical region in a manner that is frequently speculated to reflect their function, e.g. early sensory cortices often display an enlarged input layer IV. Neurons in subcortical structures are typically clustered by size, shape, and function into bundles called nuclei rather than layers. As in the cortex, most nuclei are not homogeneous, but instead include a variety of cells, and the definition of nuclei may depend on the method by which the cells are visualized.
Figure 2 A–C depicts cell body-stained sections of dorsolateral prefrontal cortex at 1, 6 and 24 months of age. Below each is a representative Golgi-stained section showing the extent of dendritic growth in this same cortical area over these same ages (more ...)
Neurons are extremely diverse in both size and function. Approximately 80% of neurons are excitatory. Many of these are projection neurons, such as pyramidal neurons, which are primarily located in layers III, V, and VI and send long distance connections to other parts of the brain. Smaller interneurons, located in all layers, are primarily inhibitory and project only locally (Kandel et al., 2000
). The remaining cells are predominately glia, which are support cells involved in immunity and synaptic maintentance, but have been found to play a wide array of other roles as well.
The cortex also demonstrates vertical functional units that are arranged as radial columns, or cortical columns, that span across the six cortical layers (Mountcastle, 1997
; Jones, 2000
) (). Each cortical column comprises multiple narrower panlaminar ‘minicolumns’, each of which in turn contains contains 80 – 100 radially arranged neurons (Mountcastle, 1997
). Minicolumn formation has been associated with early stages of cortical development when postmitotic neurons ascend in linear arrays along a radial glial scaffolding (Rakic, 1988
). Neurons in each cortical column are believed to respond to similar stimuli and perform similar functions (Mountcastle, 1997
The area between neuronal cell bodies is called the neuropil and contains neuronal dendrites and axons, synaptic connections, glia, and glial processes. Neurons communicate with one another through synapses; information is typically transmitted through axons and received through dendrites. The synaptic cleft, ~20-40 nm in size, is the space between an axon terminal of a presynaptic cell and the dendrite or soma of a postsynaptic cell (Kandel et al., 2000
). It is estimated that in an adult, each
neuron makes, on average, 1,000 synaptic connections, and receives many more. During early postnatal development, the number of synaptic connections per neuron is much higher. Through a process of activity-dependent synaptic elimination, the number of synapses per neuron decreases during childhood and stabilizes during adulthood.
White matter is more homogenous than gray matter and is comprised primarily of myelinated axons. Within the cerebrum, there are both short distance (10-30 mm) and long distance fibers (30-170 mm). Currently, the highest voxel resolution for DTI studies of white matter tractography is about 2 mm3
, but voxel size may range up to 5 mm, sometimes with a gap in between slices. Again, to provide some perspective, axon diameter typically ranges between .2 - 20μm (Kandel et al., 2000
). Assuming an average diameter of 10μm, one 2mm3
voxel contains about eight million axons. Thus, DTI studies are most useful in providing information about gross changes within large fiber bundles or fascicles. Significant work remains to achieve a consensus on the biological underpinnings of diffusion-weighted measures such as fractional anisotropy.
Overlap (or lack thereof) of MRI and postmortem studies of autism
Improved communication between MRI and postmortem research approaches is likely to generate a far more complete understanding of the neuropathology of autism than is possible at present. Below, we briefly review major findings to date from each discipline, beginning with a review of total brain volume studies, then focusing on specific brain regions implicated in autism (Amaral et al., 2008
). For some regions, such as cerebellum and amygdala, a significant amount of work has been carried out in both MRI and postmortem research. However, to date there is little overlap in the conclusions that can be drawn from each discipline; our intent is to identify areas in which one discipline can be informed by findings in the other.
Total brain volume and cerebral lobes with MRI
Collectively, studies of head circumference and MRI brain volume indicate a critical period of abnormal brain growth beginning in the first year of life that results in a persistent enlargement at least through early childhood. (Courchesne et al., 2001
, Hazlett et al., 2005
, Schumann et al., 2010
). Whether the enlargement persists into adulthood is less certain (see Amaral 2008
for review). There is additional evidence suggesting that the frontal (Carper et al., 2002
) and perhaps temporal gray matter may be especially affected during early childhood (Hazlett et al., 2005
, Schumann et al., 2010
). Hazlett et al (2005)
report an increase in temporal and frontal gray matter in two year olds with autism relative a combined control group of typically developing and developmentally delayed children. In a more recent longitudinal study of cerebral cortical development in 2.5 year olds with autism, Schumann and colleagues (2010)
also found selective enlargement in frontal and temporal lobes relative to typically developing controls. They extend the cross-sectional findings to report abnormal growth trajectories in these regions as well.
Several MRI studies have evaluated cortical thickness in adults with autism, but the findings are somewhat inconsistent. Hadjikhani et al (2006)
report cortical thinning in specific regions distributed across frontal, parietal, and temporal lobes while Hardan et al (2006)
report increased cortical thickness in the temporal lobes. More recently, Ecker and colleagues (2010)
evaluated cortical thickness as one of five measures of cortical features in adults with autism and report a distributed pattern of relative increases in cortical thickness in temporal and occipital lobes and relative decreases in cortical thickness in frontal and parietal lobes. A look at the alterations reported by postmortem studies suggests that methodological differences, such as subject selection, may account for some of the disagreements between these studies.
Frontal Cortex with Postmortem Tissue
Although MRI studies suggest that the peak of frontal cortical abnormalities is during early childhood development, no postmortem study has systematically explored the underlying neurobiology of the aberrant growth in children. Two studies indicate the presence of glial abnormalities in frontal cortex that might contribute to this volume increase. One reported qualitative microglial and astroglial activation (Vargas et al., 2005
). A more recent study demonstrated increased microglial volume and number suggestive of neuroinflammation in dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (Morgan et al., 2010
Four studies of neuronal features have utilized frontocortical tissue from small groups of subjects. Two studies examined spindle neurons (a.k.a. Von Economo neurons) which are large cells that are localized to the frontal insular region and are unique in great apes and man. This uniqueness has led several researchers to suggest that spindle neurons may play a role in higher order cognitive function and emotional behavior (Allman et al., 2001
, Allman et al., 2005
). The studies appear contradictory, finding either no difference in numbers in adults (Kennedy et al., 2007
) or an increased ratio of spindle neurons to pyramidal neurons in children (Santos et al., 2010
), but this disagreement may reflect the developmental trajectory of the disorder. Two studies of neuronal organization revealed ill-defined cortical layers in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (Mukaetova-Ladinska et al., 2004
) as well as a poorly defined boundary between gray matter and white matter (Avino and Hutsler, 2010
), suggesting the possibility of abnormalities in neurogenesis or neuronal migration.
The frontal cortex has also been the focus of studies of the minicolumnar organization of neurons. As described earlier, neurons in cortical gray matter are arranged in radial “minicolumns” during prenatal cortical development (). The space between the minicolumns is occupied by dendritic and axonal processes that extend throughout several layers of cortex (Jones, 2000
, Rockland and Ichinohe, 2004
), which dramatically increases with age in the first two years of life in typical development (). Three independent studies using varying techniques have suggested a reduction in intercolumnar width and increased cell density in dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in groups of subjects with autism not segregated by age (Casanova et al., 2002
, Buxhoeveden et al., 2006
, Casanova et al., 2006
). These findings imply
that there should be a greater number of neurons and a decrease in dendritic arborization given early overgrowth followed by normal brain volume. However, a rigorous stereological study of neuron number in the frontal cortex has yet to be carried out.
Anterior Cingulate with Postmortem Tissue
The anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) is classically considered to be associated with higher-order cognitive functions such as error detection. In the seminal postmortem studies carried out by Kemper and Bauman (Kemper and Bauman, 1993
), ACC was the only region of neocortex noted to show abnormalities; it was observed to be unusually coarse and poorly laminated in subjects with autism compared to controls. Abnormalities in the ACC have since been reported by others, including decreases in cell size (Simms et al., 2009
) and decreases in the mean density of GABA(A) receptors and benzodiazepine binding sites (Oblak et al., 2009
). This last finding suggests an alteration in GABAergic innervation that could potentially lead to a disturbance of the delicate balance between excitation and inhibition in this cortical area. Structural MRI studies have not highlighted the ACC as an area of obvious pathology in autism, however, there is significant evidence from functional imaging studies that suggests abnormal activation and connectivity in the ACC (see Minshew and Keller, 2010
Temporal Cortex with Postmortem Tissue
Postmortem studies designed to examine the underlying pathology of abnormal growth in the temporal cortex have yet to be carried out. The only such study to date and only one of two stereological studies of neuron number in the autism brain (besides Schumann and Amaral, 2006
on the amygdala) was carried out on the fusiform gyrus, which is known to be involved in face processing, a notable deficiency in many subjects with autism. The autism group showed significantly lower neuronal densities within layer III, lower total neuron numbers in layers III, V and VI, and smaller mean perikaryal volumes of neurons in layers V and VI (van Kooten et al., 2008
). This finding stands in notable contrast to longitudinal MRI studies indicating enlargement of the temporal cortex early in development (Hazlett et al., 2005
, Schumann et al., 2010
), although a postmortem study of temporal cortex in young children has yet to be carried out.
Amygdala with MRI
MRI studies indicate that the amygdala follows an aberrant trajectory of growth in individuals with autism, with amygdala enlargement present as early as age 2 (Sparks et al., 2002
, Mosconi et al., 2009
, Schumann et al., 2009
). Schumann et al. (2004)
demonstrated that, on average, amygdala enlargement remains present in 7-12 year old children with autism, but not in 12.5-18 year olds with autism. This general pattern of age-related changes in the amygdala has been observed in other cross-sectional studies covering a broad range of age intervals (Aylward et al., 1999
, Haznedar et al., 2000
, Pierce, 2001
, Sparks et al., 2002
, Schumann et al., 2004
, Nacewicz et al., 2006
, Mosconi et al., 2009
, Schumann et al., 2009
). To date, there has only been one published longitudinal study of amygdala volume, reporting bilateral enlargement at ages 2-3 and 5 but no group differences in the rate of growth between the time points (Mosconi et al., 2009
). More recently, Nordahl et al. found 3 distinct autism subgroups in the rate of growth between 2 and 3.5 years of age (Nordahl et al., 2010
, IMFAR abstract
). One subgroup demonstrated rapid amygdala growth and slow total brain volume growth, the second demonstrated slow amygdala growth and rapid total brain growth, and the final subgroup demonstrated growth trajectories consistent with those of typically developing children.
Amygdala with Postmortem Tissue
To date, no studies have evaluated younger postmortem cases with autism to determine what cellular properties account for the early overgrowth in amygdala volume. In contrast to MRI findings of early enlargement, the one quantitative stereological study conducted to date reported a ~15% decrease in the number of neurons in adolescents and adults with autism (Schumann and Amaral, 2006
), This finding suggests that either neuron number does not account for the increase in amygdala size in young children with autism, or, there is considerable neuron loss later in life. Intriguingly, this alteration was particularly pronounced in the lateral nucleus, a subregion responsible for sensory integration.
Cerebellum with MRI
The cerebellum has long been an area of interest for both MRI and postmortem studies of autism. Five MRI studies of individuals with autism at a wide range of ages have found the cerebellum to be enlarged relative to controls (Minshew et al., 2005
). However, this increase in cerebellar volume is generally proportional to total brain volume, with one exception in which the difference exceeded that of the cerebrum (Hardan et al., 2001
). Only one published study to date has examined children younger than age 3, and this study did not find a difference in cerebellar size between the children at risk for autism and typically developing controls (Hazlett et al., 2005
). In contrast to the total cerebellum, the size of the vermis appears to be slightly smaller in some individuals with autism (Kaufmann, et al., 2003, Courchesne et al., 1994, Scott et al., 2009
), though this may not be specific to autism but rather a common feature of neurodevelopmental disorders in general (Kaufmann, et al., 2003, Piven et al., 1997
Cerebellum with Postmortem Tissue
The cerebellum is the most studied postmortem structure to date. Of the 30 postmortem cases of autism in which the cerebellum has been studied, 22 (or 73%) cases showed lower density of Purkinje cells, particularly in the more lateral regions of the structure (Ritvo et al., 1986
, Kemper and Bauman, 1993
, Bailey et al., 1998a
, Palmen et al., 2004
, Whitney et al., 2008a
). Even though this is one of the most striking and consistent descriptive findings in neuropathological analyses in the autistic brain, a comprehensive stereological study of the actual number of Purkinje neurons in the whole cerebellum has yet to be carried out. Recent studies from Blatt and colleagues have found that some, but not all, cases of autism show a reduction in the linear density of Purkinje neurons as well as decreases in basket and stellate cell densities (Whitney et al., 2008b
) and substantial alterations in the GABAergic system (Yip et al., 2007
). Others have reported no difference in the density of Purkinje cells in the cerebellum, but a 24% decrease in the size of Purkinje neurons in the autism group (Fatemi et al., 2002
). Finally, neuroinflammation has been reported in the region (Vargas et al., 2005
). This inflammation may be associated with the reported reductions in neuronal density. While these findings appear to conflict with MRI studies reporting an enlarged cerebellum in autism (Courchesne et al., 2007
) they may simply reflect very different cohorts of subjects. In addition to differences in age, 22 of 24 subjects reported some degree of mental retardation and nearly half were taking medication for epilepsy (Ritvo et al., 1986
, Kemper and Bauman, 1993
, Bailey et al., 1998b
, Palmen et al., 2004
Bridging the gap - Translating between MRI and postmortem research
Using as an example the notion that the brain grows too big too fast in autism, we explore how the MRI and postmortem research fields may look to one another for guidance. If the rate of brain growth is indeed accelerated, which factors are likely to account for this growth? If brain size is an indication of aberrant neurological development, what does this really tell us about the neuropathology of autism? Is it likely that volume differences reflect a single cellular alteration (neuron number/size, glia number, dendritic arborization)?
The number of neurons
An increase in the number of neurons is unlikely to be the sole factor in accelerated cortical growth in autism. Head circumference and MRI studies suggest that brain size at birth does not differ (see Redcay and Courchesne, 2005
for review), and it is not until sometime between 6-12 months of age that brain enlargement becomes evident. Neurogenesis, the process by which neurons are generated, is, with a few notable exceptions, a prenatal event (Rakic, 2002
for review). Other processes, such as disruption of programmed cell death (Haydar et al., 1999
), could produce increases in neuron number relative to control subjects; however, this would not account for accelerated growth
of the brain as head circumference studies have proposed (Hazlett et al., 2005
, Dawson et al., 2007
It is possible that there are more neurons already present at birth in a newborn with autism, but without extensive neuronal arborization this increase does not translate into a significant change in head size. To give some perspective, if there are ~20 billion neurons in the neocortex from birth to adulthood (Larsen et al., 2006
), neuronal cell bodies on average have a ~20μm diameter, and cerebral gray matter is ~600cm3
in a typical 2 year old, then the cell bodies of neurons only occupy 15% of the total neocortical volume. Therefore, even a 20% increase in the number of neurons, would only result in less than a 1% increase in cortical gray volume.
The extent of neuronal dendritic growth and number of synapses
If only one factor accounts for early overgrowth, this is the most likely candidate. In the typically developing newborn brain, dendritic arbors have barely sprouted and synaptic connections between neurons are sparse (Conel, 1939
-1959, Huttenlocher, 2002
) (). Over the next few years, there is a dramatic increase in neuronal dendritic volume as dendrites establish synaptic connections with a wide array of neurons. During this “critical period” of development, synapses compete for neural growth factors to survive (McAllister, 2002). Connections that are inhibited, or underutilized, are subsequently pruned, resulting in a mature network of functioning synaptic connections between neurons. If dendrites grow in an excessive, dysregulated manner or do not undergo the same degree of efficient synaptic pruning, the result may be aberrant connectivity between neurons alongside overall brain enlargement. Although this is the most likely candidate, few postmortem studies have looked at neuronal dendritic arborization or synapses in autism (Raymond et al., 1996; Hutsler and Zhang, 2010); there is not a single study of dendritic arbors in chidren with autism to date.
The number and size of glial cells
There is an intermediate chance that the number of glia alone could account for increased brain size. The majority
of gliogenesis, the process by which new glial cells are generated, occurs prenatally. However, this rule is not absolute and has recently been challenged (Pelvig et al., 2008
). The extent to which gliogenesis is prenatally limited also varies between the three main populations: oligodendrocytes, astrocytes, and microglia. Oligodendrocytes, whose main function is to insulate axons in a myelin sheath, comprise ~75% of the number of glial cells in gray matter (Pelvig et al., 2008
); thus, there are ~25 billion in the neocortex. Although the number of oligodendrocytes does not increase dramatically after birth, the processes that form the myelin sheath around neurons do extend out and wrap axons throughout postnatal development. Astrocytes comprise ~17% of glia in the brain and, although there are subtypes of astrocytes, their main function is to regulate the external chemical environment of neurons. There are ~6 billion astrocytes in cerebral gray matter (Pelvig et al., 2008
). Astrocytes are thought to be generated almost entirely prenatally from the same progenitor cell population as neurons, but they are capable of demonstrating significant changes in volume in response to inflammatory signaling, with swelling of both the soma and the inflammation-sensing processes.
If glia do account for some of the increased cerebral volume in children with autism, a neuroinflammatory response involving microglia may be a likely culprit. Microglia are resident phagocytes, constantly eliminating damaged neurons, accumulated debris, and infectious agents. Although Microglia only comprise ~6% of the glia in the brain (~2 billion) (Pelvig et al., 2008
), unlike neurons and the other glial populations, microglia readily increase in number in response to immune challenges. In addition, although they are normally small relative to other glia, they are capable of dramatic morphological changes if strongly stimulated with proinflammatory factors. Under these completely normal conditions, microglia become “activated,” and the cell body may swell as much as 2-4 times its normal volume while processes thicken and then retract (Morgan et al, 2010
). “Amoeboid” microglia in a fully activated state are commonly found in the typically developing brain in high concentrations in response to the large amounts of extracellular debris and neuronal apoptosis that is a consequence of programmed cell death (Rezaie and Male, 1999
). If there is a chronic state of inflammation as some have proposed in autism (Pardo et al., 2005
, Vargas et al., 2005
, Morgan et al., 2010
), perhaps in response to autoantibodies or infection (Shi et al., 2009
, Singh, 2009
, Goines and Van de Water, 2010
) both microglia and astroglia may be larger and more abundant. Another possibility is a neuroinflammatory response leading to edema, resulting in an increase in overall brain size; however, edema has not been consistently detected in children with autism via MRI.
A combination of all three cellular factors
This appears most likely, particularly given the interaction between these cellular features during early development. One possible scenario is that excess neurons are generated prenatally, perhaps due to genetic abnormalities and/or environmental interference. For example, mutations in the PTEN gene, which normally regulates cell division, growth, and programmed cell death (Chu &, Tarnawski, 2004
), have been associated with large head size and autism (Zori et al., 1998
, Goffin et al., 2001
; McBride et al., 2010
, Varga et al., 2009
, Orrico et al., 2009
). There is also evidence for an association between the short allele of the serotonin transporter gene (5-HTTLPR) and increased cerebral gray matter (Wassink et al., 2007
). We predict, though, that excess neurons alone does not result in a detectable increase in overall brain size or head circumference at birth. However, this initial interference in otherwise typical development might set off a cascade of events over the next 2 years leading to enlargement and ultimately resulting in aberrant, dysfunctional communication between neurons. For instance, as mentioned above, there is an explosion of neuronal dendritic growth and synapse formation in the first few years of life (). This same process likely occurs in the brain of a child with autism, yet if there are more neurons, this would then lead to even more dendrites, synapses, myelin, etc. Glia could also be overproduced via similar genetic mechanisms, or become activated in an inflammatory response to neuronal overproliferation, contributing further to early volume increases. In addition, glial activation could bias maturation of dendritic arbors via release of neurotrophins and other modulatory factors (Christopherson et al., 2005
, Bessis et al., 2007
The scenario described above is just one of several possible combinations of neuropathology that might occur in the autistic brain during this early critical period of development. Only by carrying out a comprehensive postmortem study of early brain development using modern quantitative methods will we unveil the process by which the brain becomes enlarged in autism. While MRI studies point to exuberant growth and enlargement in children, postmortem studies have found reductions in neuron number possibly related to neuroinflammatory and degenerative processes. However, it is critical to point out that there is not a single postmortem study focused on brain development in children with autism published to date; all studies have been carried out in adolescents and adults well past the peak time of aberrant growth described in MRI studies.
Closing the Gap
Independently, MRI and postmortem studies have made significant contributions towards elucidating the neuropathology of autism. Greater communication and understanding between the fields could lead to even more significant progress being made. MRI and postmortem researchers working in the field of autism could learn much from each other's work and use findings from each field to better guide specific hypotheses about certain brain areas and periods of development. For example, MRI studies suggest that early childhood is a critical time of aberrant brain development in autism, yet there have been no postmortem studies of young children. Postmortem researchers might, therefore, use MRI studies to guide them in where in the brain and when in development to focus. It is important for postmortem researchers to keep in mind that MRI studies suggest that pathology changes with age in individuals with autism. Thus, studies done thus far on adult postmortem cases do not apply to trying to understand the anatomical underpinnings of the early overgrowth observed in MRI studies.
On the flip side, MRI researchers need to look to postmortem studies to understand the neurobiological underpinnings of gross findings detectable by MRI. What, exactly, does the finding of a certain structure being bigger, smaller, thicker, or thinner mean? MRI researchers could also look to postmortem studies to guide hypotheses and theories. For example, a widely cited, but completely speculative theory in the imaging field is that there is a disruption in the process of synaptic elimination or ‘pruning’ that may account for early brain enlargement despite the fact that there is to date little or no postmortem evidence to support this notion.
As researchers begin to describe the developmental trajectory of autism and identify the likely heterogeneous subgroups in the disorder, the MRI and postmortem fields will benefit markedly from communicating with one another and generating hypotheses together. MRI studies can provide the framework by identifying different subgroups with distinct patterns of affected brain areas or the timing of aberrant development, while postmortem studies can tackle the neurobiological underpinnings and etiologies of the different subgroups. Together, the two fields will make significant advancements towards elucidating the neuropathology of this often devastating disorder.