We have identified two genes
COLEC11 and
MASP1 which when mutated cause four syndromes: Carnevale, Mingarelli, Malpuech and Michels. Mutations in
MASP1 have also recently been reported in two families with Carnevale syndrome
14. Both these genes were mutated in all 16 patients (from 11 families) tested. We identified six different mutations in
COLEC11 and three different mutations in
MASP1, all of which were found in the homozygous state. For each gene, there were patients presenting with each of the four diagnoses (
Suppl Table 1), thus confirming that these disorders are allelic variants of the same disease category and should henceforth be referred to as the 3MC syndrome or the more descriptive Craniofacial-Ulnar-Renal Syndrome. Furthermore, we could not discern any consistent differences in the presenting phenotype between patients carrying the respective gene mutations ( and
Suppl Table 1).
COLEC11 was first identified in 2006 as a new member of the collectin family, named CL-K1 (collectin kidney 1)
8,9, and reported to be ubiquitously expressed. It is a secreted protein that contains two characteristic domains; a collagen-like domain and a carbohydrate recognition domain similar to another member of the collectin family, MBL (mannan-binding lectin), a serum protein
15 that binds to various ligands leading to opsonization and activation of the complement cascade eventually forming the membrane attack complex for cell lysis. CL-K1 could act through the lectin complement pathway, similar to MBL. However, measurement of serum complement (C2, C3 and C4) levels in two unrelated patients were found to be normal indicating that downstream complement factor processing remains intact possibly through activation by the classical and alternative pathways. Moreover, we have observed that a mutation in
COLEC11 caused depletion of CL-K1 in the sera of two patients, indicating that it must have direct roles, independent of downstream complement cascade activation, in 3MC.
MASP-1 is a serine protease that binds to MBL, as well as MASP2, and triggers complement activation by cleaving C2 to form C3 convertase, C4bC2b
9.
MASP1 codes for three different isoforms: The long MASP-1 is isoform 1 with a light chain containing the serine protease domain encoded by exons 13 to 18.
MASP1 isoform 2, also known as MASP-3, has the same heavy chain as isoform 1 but a different serine protease domain encoded by the single exon 12
10. It is also purported to process IGFBP5
16,17. A third isoform has been recently identified and is composed of a single shortened heavy chain
18,19. All our
MASP1 3MC patients had mutations in exon 12. It has been proposed that this isoform lacks processing abilities such that upon binding to MBL it does not cleave C2 or C4
20, or even inhibits formation of C3 convertase
9. Compared to the other isoforms, MASP-3 expression appears ubiquitous
18,21. CL-K1 is highly conserved between vertebrate species which clearly share a common origin (
Suppl Fig 5).
The identification of mutations in
COLEC11 and
MASP1 was surprising as no complement-related components have previously been implicated in the pathogenesis of developmental disorders. This raises the possibility of a role for further constituent proteins in embryonic development. In contrast to MASP-1, little is known of the precise function of CL-K1 and we therefore sought to understand its role in early developmental processes. CL-K1 expression is widespread and seemingly abundant in ectodermal tissues. Strikingly, the craniofacial disruption observed in zebrafish morphants (and humans) was reminiscent of neural crest migration disorders. As we observed expansion of migrating streams of CNCC in
colec11 and
masp1 morphants this indicates that these proteins probably act as guidance cues. To this end, we show that CL-K1 has chemoattractant properties affecting migrating NCCs. It remains to be determined how CL-K1 influences migrating cell populations and whether or not it directionally stabilizes cell protrusions promoted by cell contact as recently published for the chemokine Sdf1
22.
CL-K1 and MASP-3, members of the lectin activation pathway are clearly important secreted proteins with novel functions which we now demonstrate here for the first time, include the orchestration of cell migration during vertebrate embryogenesis. This is further supported by the expression of colec11 along the path of migration of NCCs. The consequence of absence of these proteins during development culminates in multisystem abnormalities including craniofacial defects, skeletal, renal and neuronal aberrations in humans. It is important that we now turn our attentions to the more fundamental roles for this complex cascade in regulating embryogenesis in general and craniofacial development in particular.