The BBB can exclude from the CNS many large molecules, including numerous medications. Data comparing HIV RNA responses in CSF and plasma along with knowledge of individual antiretroviral characteristics support the concept that antiretrovirals differ in their ability to permeate the BBB in therapeutic concentrations and have led to the development of CNS penetration-effectiveness (CPE) estimates [
26]. CSF measurements are only a surrogate for concentrations in the brain and may be over or under estimates. A postmortem report noted HIV in brain tissue more frequently than in CSF [
16] and one report from an animal model of SIV encephalitis, a condition most similar to HIV meningitis, demonstrates CNS improvement despite estimated poor BBB penetration of antiretroviral regimens [
27]. An important note is that cART effectiveness, as estimated by suppression of HIV RNA in plasma, is likely the strongest determinant of HIV RNA response in CSF.
There have been reports that the CNS can harbor virus that is discordant from virus in plasma, supporting the concept that the CNS environment, including drug pressure, is distinct from blood and lymphoid tissue. A recent case series identified 11 patients with new-onset neurologic symptoms who were found to have CSF levels of HIV RNA out of proportion to that in plasma [
28]. The investigators modified the cART regimens based on drug resistance patterns in CSF and on CPE estimates, with the result that all responded with clinical improvement and reductions in HIV RNA in CSF. Recent abstracts identified that CSF HIV RNA may occur despite suppression in plasma at a rate of between 3% and 10% among treated individuals [
29]. A separate case report of HAD demonstrated viral evolution in CNS that differed from that in plasma [
30].
While most studies demonstrate that cART with better CPE is associated with viral suppression in CSF, early reports on the clinical impact have been mixed. For example, in a prospective cART initiation observational study, higher CPE ranks were associated with greater improvements in neuropsychological performance among individuals with HAND [
31]. In contrast, a similar prospective study failed to identify a clinical cognitive benefit to initiating regimens with higher CPE ranks [
32]. Among perinatally HIV-infected children, higher CNS-penetrating regimens were associated with a survival benefit [
33]. Furthermore, there are early data to suggest that CSF suppression to below 2 copies/mL may have a cognitive benefit, which may highlight an important clinical need for more sensitive HIV RNA assay [
34].
The observational data to date provide support for considering drug penetration and neurological effectiveness data when selecting new cART for people with HAND [
35] but must be applied with more caution when adjusting stable therapy in people with HAND who have already achieved viral suppression in plasma with their current cART. Importantly, these data cannot be applied with confidence to selection of cART for neurologically asymptomatic individuals for the objective of preventing HAND. Future research efforts should broadly include systemic morbidities and adherence since altering treatment regimens may affect non-CNS outcomes. There is a need for larger sample sizes and a more uniform scientific approach in these studies in a manner that supports cross-cohort comparisons. Several new clinical trials are opening to address these objectives.
The focus on optimization of cART to reach therapeutic concentrations in CNS addresses control of HIV replication in resident cells but does not address the important mechanism of continued transmigration during therapy. Hematopoietic bone marrow cells likely harbor HIV infection before releasing cells into circulation [
36], and recent findings from animal models demonstrate movement of SIV-infected, bone marrow–derived monocytes to the CNS perivascular space [
11•]. Among cART-treated subjects with suppressed plasma HIV RNA, low-level HIV DNA infection of peripheral mononuclear cells correlates to HAND [
37] and levels of HIV DNA in circulating monocytes remain elevated among impaired subjects 1 year after cART with suppression of plasma HIV RNA [
38]. It is increasingly evident that events occurring in the earliest days of infection have a profound immunological impact, possibly altered by early treatment. Antiretroviral treatment initiation during primary compared to chronic infection also impacts peripheral HIV DNA reservoirs, providing some support for potential treatment options (Fig. ) [
39].