Our search for previously undescribed phosphoinositide/phospholipid binding domains identified a small C-terminal domain in S. cerevisiae septin-associated kinases that binds acidic phospholipids. Crystallographic studies revealed that this is a KA1 domain, a module previously identified at the C-termini of kinases from the mammalian MARK/PAR1 family. We show that KA1 domains from both yeast and human kinases bind acidic phospholipids including PtdSer. For yeast Kcc4p, we also present data using KA1 domain mutations that implicate PtdSer as an important determinant for targeting this kinase to its site of action at the bud neck.
Our findings with Kcc4p and Gin4p argue that – in addition to its documented dependence on septin binding (
Barral et al., 1999;
Longtine et al., 1998) – bud neck localization of septin-associated kinases requires KA1 domain/phospholipid interactions. On their own, neither the KA1 domain nor the septin-binding region of Kcc4p/Gin4p/Hsl1p is sufficient for specific bud neck targeting – but C-terminal fragments encompassing both are efficiently localized to bud necks (
Crutchley et al., 2009;
Longtine et al., 1998;
Okuzaki and Nojima, 2001). Thus, simultaneous engagement of the septin- and phospholipid-binding domains appears to be required for Kcc4p, Gin4p and Hsl1p recruitment to septin assemblies at the bud neck for kinase activation. This combination of septin-binding and phospholipid-binding domains may function as an effective “coincidence detector”, allowing the kinases to bind septins only at membrane locations. The septins themselves also bind weakly to anionic phospholipids (
Casamayor and Snyder, 2003;
Zhang et al., 1999), suggesting further that kinase/phospholipid, kinase/septin and septin/phospholipid interactions all cooperate to organize a well-defined assembly at the bud neck. Coincidence-detection of this sort, in which multivalent interactions involving both protein-binding and lipid-binding domains drive complex formation, has been suggested for several systems (
Carlton and Cullen, 2005;
Lemmon, 2008). It is particularly interesting for Kcc4p that the KA1 domain can promote kinase targeting to a specific location (the bud neck) despite binding non-specifically to anionic phospholipids: it appears to restrict the ability of Kcc4p to bind septins only in the context of a negatively-charged membrane surface, as a logical ‘AND’ gate. Similar coincidence-detection mechanisms may also be relevant for specific membrane targeting of human MARK/PAR1 family proteins. Indeed, we show here that – like their structural counterparts in the yeast septin-associated kinases – KA1 domains of human MARK/PAR1 family proteins bind acidic phospholipids in cells and
in vitro.
Several reports have suggested that the C-terminal tail of MARK/PAR1 kinases (which includes the KA1 domain) plays a role in reversible autoinhibition of kinase activity (
Elbert et al., 2005;
Marx et al., 2010;
Timm et al., 2008). For example, the C-terminal KA1 domain-containing region of the
S. cerevisiae Kin1 and Kin2 kinases was reported to interact with the N-terminal catalytic domain (
Elbert et al., 2005) – suggesting direct intramolecular autoinhibitory interactions. A similar model was also proposed for
S. cerevisiae Hsl1p (
Hanrahan and Snyder, 2003), and septins were suggested to activate Hsl1p by binding close to the C-terminal region and disrupting autoinhibitory intramolecular interactions. One concern raised about this model (
Crutchley et al., 2009;
Szkotnicki et al., 2008) is that it cannot explain why Hs1lp is activated only by assembled septins at the bud neck, and not by free septin complexes. Our findings provide an explanation: that the C-terminal region of Hsl1p (and other septin-associated kinases) must bind to both septins and anionic membrane phospholipids (via its KA1 domain) to drive the protein to the bud neck and relieve the proposed intramolecular autoinhibition.
Reversing intramolecular autoinhibitory interactions by engaging one or more phospholipid-binding domains is a recurring theme in kinase regulation, with protein kinase C (PKC) and other AGC kinases providing well characterized examples (
Newton, 2009). Our studies suggest that the mechanistic role of the KA1 domain in septin-associated kinases may be broadly analogous to that of C1 and C2 domains in PKC or the PH domain in Akt (
Newton, 2009). The KA1 domain lacks the lipid selectivity of these other modules, but appears to restrict specific recognition of other targets (such as septins) to a membrane context. Extending our observations to the MARK/PAR1 family kinases, the KA1 domain was previously implicated as a determinant of membrane localization for MARK3 (
Göransson et al., 2006), and dissociation of hMARK2 from the plasma membrane coincides with reduced activity (
Hurov et al., 2004). Thus, phospholipid-engagement of the KA1 domain may also play a role in the activation of these kinases at particular membrane locations. Intriguingly, the KA1 domain fold has recently been seen in additional kinase contexts that warrant further investigation. A C-terminal domain in the
Arabidopsis AtSOS2 kinase has a KA1 domain fold (
Sánchez-Barrena et al., 2007), and includes a protein phosphatase-interacting (PPI) motif (in strand β1 and helix α1). It is not known whether this domain binds phospholipids. A C-terminal domain in the α-subunit of heterotrimeric AMPK orthologs also has a KA1 domain fold, and is intimately associated with the C-terminal region of the β-subunit (
Townley and Shapiro, 2007). Since KA1 domain-containing proteins are implicated in a wide range of diseases, from Alzheimer’s disease to cancer to diabetes, understanding the regulatory role of this domain is an important goal. Our studies show that at least a subgroup of KA1 domains bind non-specifically to acidic phospholipids and allow kinase activation to be coordinated with membrane association, in an unexpected variation of a theme used by other kinases that employ C1, C2, PH, and other domains.