CF is caused by mutations in the CFTR, which encodes a cAMP-regulated chloride channel activated by phosphorylation by PKA. Events that regulate CFTR-mediated chloride permeability include phosphorylation of the regulatory or
R domain of the protein and binding and, hydrolysis of ATP at the nucleotide-binding folds. Mutations in CFTR have been classified into five groups depending on the effect of the mutation, that is, CFTR synthesis, protein maturation, chloride channel regulation/ gating, chloride conductance, protein stability [
26]. The most common mutation in CFTR, ΔF508, results in a channel with impaired activity that is mislocalized in the cell, although the amount of correctly localized ΔF508 CFTR varies in different cell types [
26]. A mutant CFTR channel with defects in regulation/gating or chloride conductance that is transported to some degree to the plasma membrane may be stimulated pharmacologically by compounds that activate or inhibit components of the PKA pathway, including β
2-AR, phosphodiesterases, adenylyl cyclase, phosphatases, and PKA itself [
8,
9]. Polymorphisms in β
2-AR that stimulate β
2-AR function may also upregulate mutant CFTR activity, perhaps leading to a more favorable disease course.
β
2-AR and CFTR have been colocalized in the apical membrane of airway epithelial cells [
6], where a macromolecular complex comprising CFTR, β
2-AR, and EBP50 has been identified [
6,
7]. CFTR and β
2-AR interact with EBP50 through PDZ-binding motifs in the C-termini of the proteins. Removal of the PDZ-binding motif from CFTR disrupted its interaction with EBP50 and β
2-AR and decreased chloride efflux through CFTR stimulated by β
2-AR activation [
6]. CFTR phosphorylation by PKA inhibited the EBP50 binding, enabling its activation [
6]. Thus, the dynamic complex of CFTR, EBP50, and β
2-AR provides for compartmentalized regulation of CFTR signaling.
Taouil
et al. [
7] found that incubation of airway epithelial cells with salmeterol, a long-acting β
2-AR agonist, increased levels of mature CFTR, which was not due to increased amounts of CFTR mRNA, cAMP, or PKA activity. Although β-agonists increased CFTR levels, those of EBP50 remained the same, and those of β
2-AR decreased. If β
2-AR and CFTR compete for the same binding site on EBP50, polymorphisms that increase desensitization of β
2-AR and removal of β
2-AR from the membrane may also free EBP50-binding sites, thereby increasing the amount of CFTR on the apical membrane. As very little additional CFTR function is necessary to improve a patient’s clinical phenotype [
27], variation in β
2-AR polymorphisms may contribute to the clinical phenotype seen in our older cohort of CF patients.
Beta-2-AR polymorphisms have been studied
in vivo in the airways, vasculature, and cardiac tissue [
12–
17,
19,
28–
30]. Several studies have shown that Gly
16 is associated with a more favorable response to the regular use of β
2-AR agonists, although
in vitro data had shown greater downregulation of such receptors when incubated with agonists [
11,
30,
31]. A meta-study on β
2-AR polymorphisms and asthma concluded that the Glu
27 allele may be more resistant to downregulation than Gln
27 [
19]. Studies of β
2-AR polymorphisms in the vasculature demonstrated that greater maximal isoproterenol-stimulated dilation of a hand vein occurred before desensitization in those homozygous for Gly
16 and Glu
27 than in Arg
16 and Gln
27 or Gly
16 and Gln
27 homozygotes [
15]. After chronic exposure to isoproterenol, participants who were homozygous for Arg
16 showed almost complete desensitization, whereas those homozygous for Gly
16 did not exhibit significant desensitization, irrespective of the allele at position 27 [
14,
15,
17]. An explanation for these data is that Gly
16-containing receptors are significantly desensitized by endogenous catecholamines, as compared with Arg
16 receptors, before chronic exposure to isoproterenol. Data on cardiac responses indicate that Arg
16Gln
27 participants show greater downregulation when treated with the agonist terbutaline than do participants with Gly
16Gln
27, who, in turn, show greater downregulation than do participants with Gly
16Glu
27 [
16].
Such reports provide a useful background for the current findings related to β
2-AR variants in adult patients with CF. We found that the genotype frequencies of β
2-AR differed significantly in the CF and matched control population, with the frequencies of Gly
16 and Glu
27 significantly higher in the CF group. Genotype frequencies in the normal volunteer population are similar to data from the literature [
20,
21,
31]. If CFTR and β
2-AR compete for binding sites on EBP50, the desensitization of the Gly
16 variant by endogenous catecholamines may make extra sites available on EBP50 for CFTR. This would result in more CFTR available for activation at the plasma membrane. In the vasculature, receptors with the Gly
16Glu
27 variant produced a larger venodilative effect in response to acute β-agonist exposure than the Gly
16Gln
27 or Arg
16Gln
27 variants [
15]. If this effect is similar in epithelial cells, then the Gly
16Glu
27 variant would also be able to produce more cAMP, thus leading to activation of CFTR through PKA phosphorylation.
Buscher
et al. [
20] found an increase in the frequency of the Arg
16 allele compared with controls in a young population (average age 13 years of age), whereas Hart
et al. [
21] found no differences in allelic frequencies for either codon compared with controls, with an average age of 20 years. The CF population in our study was older than those in these studies with an average age 31 years and with a lower percentage of patients who were ΔF508 homozygotes. These results suggest an age-dependency of β
2-AR allelic frequencies in CF; however, as the studies draw on different groups of patients, this cannot be definitively stated. A selection bias may exist in our study on the basis of the ability of patients to travel to the research site, the inclusion of an adult population, and the recruitment from across the United States, especially because β
2-AR variants occur with different frequency among participants with different ethnicities [
10,
11,
32]. The differences in genotype frequencies are not due to differences in ΔF508 homozygosity, as we found that the β
2-AR frequencies are similar when only the ΔF508 homozygous CF patients are considered.
In our CF population, 36% responded to bronchodilators, with a higher percentage (46%) among the ΔF508 homozygotes, but the genotype frequencies of the β
2-AR polymorphisms among bronchodilator responders and nonresponders were not different. Although FVC, FEV
1, and DL
CO did not differ among different β
2-AR genotypes of ΔF508 homozygous patients, among non-responders, those homozygous for Arg
16 or Gln
27 had significantly higher FVC values than did patients with a Gly
16 or Glu
27 allele. In addition, patients homozygous for Arg
16 also had significantly higher FEV
1 than did Arg
16Gly or Gly
16Gly individuals. Hart
et al. [
21] found the Gly
16Glu
27 haplotype associated with a greater magnitude of response to bronchodilator. Both we and Hart
et al. [
21] found that bronchodilator responders had lower baseline FEV
1 values than nonresponders, but, in contrast to Hart
et al. [
21], we observed no association between magnitude of bronchodilator response and β
2-AR genotype.
In the ΔF508 homozygotes CF population that responded to bronchodilators, FVC was significantly higher for the Gln
27Glu heterozygous group than the Gln
27Gln or Glu
27Glu homozygotes; FEV
1 and DL
CO were also higher, although of borderline significance. Buscher
et al. [
20] reported that ΔF508 homozygotes CF patients, who were homozygous for Arg
16, had significantly higher FVC, FEV
1, and mid-expiratory flow at 50% of vital capacity than those with at least one Gly
16 allele. Gln
27Gln individuals had higher FVC, FEV
1, and MEF
50%VC values than did Gln
27Glu and Glu
27Glu patients; the differences, however, were not significant. Buscher
et al. [
20] also reported that the presence of Gly
16 was associated with a worse 5-year clinical course. In contrast, Hart
et al. [
21] did not find any association between β
2-AR genotype and rate of decline of FEV
1 over a 5-year period. Neither Buscher
et al. [
20] nor Hart
et al. [
21] examined the relationship between β
2-AR polymorphisms and pulmonary function by segregating the populations into bronchodilator responders and nonresponders. The major limitation of our study is the small sample sizes once the patient population is divided into subgroups on the basis of response to bronchodilators and genotypes. Although the differences have been found to be statistically significant, a larger study will be required to confirm the results.
In addition to their potential role as a modifier of CFTR function, β
2-adrenergic receptors, as a consequence of their ability to raise cellular cAMP levels, may also influence activity and/or number of amiloride-sensitive epithelial sodium channels (ENaC), which can increase the Na+ transport and fluid clearance in the airway [
33,
34]. Thus, if ENaC were to contribute to the regulation of airway function in CF, genetic variants of β
2-AR would be predicted to modulate such regulation and would likely contribute to alveolar fluid accumulation and clearance, especially in injured lungs [
35,
36]. Although poor Na+ conductance has been suggested to contribute to reduced salt absorption in CF [
37], recent studies of airways indicate that CF glands do not demonstrate excessive, ENaC-mediated fluid absorption [
38]. Thus, the actual role of β
2-AR variants in regulation of ENaC remains to be determined [
13].
The notion that modifying genes influence the clinical manifestations of CF is an important and timely issue [
5]. As its role as an activator of cAMP formation and ability of cAMP/PKA to regulate CFTR function, the β
2-AR is potentially one such disease modifier. Beta-2-AR polymorphisms may influence the CF disease process by regulating responses of smooth muscle cells to bronchodilators or permitting direct CFTR activation in airway epithelial cells. β
2-AR polymorphisms have been studied predominately in the context of smooth muscle cells, that is, their effects on asthma or the vasculature, whereas CFTR has been studied mainly in epithelial cells, where the effects of the β
2-AR polymorphisms have not been studied rigorously. The latter may be a useful, future line of investigation.