Among the 16 studies meeting review criteria,
14–29 none provided
models developed for the purpose of comparing hospital-level readmission rates (Aim
1) and none reported patient-level statistical models or risk scores predicting
readmission (Aim 2). All 16 studies identified patient-level and/or process-of-care
predictors of post-stroke readmission (Aim 3). Characteristics of these studies are
presented in . The majority of studies
were conducted in populations within the United States (10 of the 16 studies),
14–16, 19, 21–24,
26, 27 with the remaining cohorts from Canada,
20 Australia,
18,
25 Singapore,
28 and Taiwan.
17,
29 Thirteen studies used administrative
data,
14–16, 18–20, 22–24,
26–29 five used medical record abstraction,
14, 15, 21, 22,
25 and three used data from patient
interviews.
15, 17, 21 | Table 1Characteristics of Identified Publications Examining Predictors of
Readmission after Stroke Hospitalization |
Study samples varied from 228 to 366,551 patients, and methods for patient
selection varied across studies, with some restricted to those with ischemic
stroke
14, 15, 23, 24, 26–28 and others
including a broader cohort of stroke patients.
16–22, 25, 29 Most
identified the index stroke based on ICD-9 or diagnostic related group (DRG)
codes;
16–24, 26–29 however, the
specific codes varied across studies, as did the inclusion of codes from either
primary or secondary diagnoses. Several studies further limited their populations to
patients who were veterans,
16, 19 65 years or older,
16, 21, 23, 26,
27 free of stroke for at least one year
prior to the index event,
20, 22, 28 had at
least one limitation in either activities of daily living (ADL) or instrumental
ADLs,
17 had at least three health care
encounters during the follow-up period,
19 or
were cared for by physicians classified as a general internist, family physician, or
hospitalist.
24The selection of outcomes differed across studies. Fourteen studies reported
all-cause readmission,
14–17, 19–21, 23–29 with
five of these also reporting stroke-related outcomes;
19, 23, 26–28 two studies reported stroke-related readmission as the sole
outcome.
18, 22 Duration of follow-up was either within 30 days ()
16, 17, 23–27 or 1
year (),
14, 15, 18–22, 28, 29 with one study reporting models for both time
periods.
26 Readmission rates at both time
points were high and varied across studies: 30-day all-cause readmission ranged from
6.5% to 24.3%, 1-year all-cause readmission from 30.0% to
62.2%, 30-day stroke-related readmission from 7.4% to 9.4%,
and 1-year stroke-related readmission from 10.5% to 31.1%.
| Table 2Variables Identified in Publications Examining Hospital Readmission within 30
Days |
| Table 3Variables Identified in Publications Examining Hospital Readmission within 1
Year |
Analytic methods used to examine predictors of readmission included logistic
regression,
14, 15, 17–20, 29 proportional hazards regression,
16, 23, 26–28 generalized estimating equations,
24 truncated negative binomial regression,
22 log-linear analysis,
25 and instrumental variables estimation.
21 Only four of the 13 studies using data from multiple sites reported
adjusting analyses for site or patient clustering within site.
23, 24, 26, 27
Accounting for death within the study period varied by analytic method. Most studies
utilizing proportional hazards models reported censoring for events,
16, 23, 26, 27
whereas studies utilizing other types of analytic models either excluded patients
who died prior to the interview/analysis date (in either primary or secondary
analyses),
17, 19, 29 adjusted
for death,
19 or did not specify in the
methods.
18, 21, 24, 25 Most studies reported excluding patients who
died during the index hospitalization,
14–16, 18–21,
23, 25–29 with only one
including in-hospital death as a covariate for risk-adjustment
22 and one not reporting the information.
24 None presented measures of model performance or power
calculations to determine whether the study had a sample size adequate to detect the
associations of interest.
There was little consistency in the variables presented in analytic models
across studies ( and ). Of the 15 studies that clearly stated the covariates
used in their models, commonly included demographic variables were age,
14, 15,
17–20, 22–29 sex,
14, 15, 17–20, 22–29 and race.
14–17, 19, 22–24, 26–28
Nearly all studies included a stroke severity scale
14–16 or individual
variables related to stroke severity.
14–17, 19, 22, 23, 25–27, 29 Of these severity indicators, length of index
hospitalization
14–17, 19, 22, 26,
29 and discharge location/need for
nursing care
14–17, 22, 26, 27
were the most common. Most studies included one or more cardiovascular-related
premorbid or comorbid conditions either as individual variables
14–20,
22–24, 26–28 or as part of a
comorbidity index,
19, 23, 29 with many
specifically including diabetes.
15, 16, 18,
20, 22–24, 26–28 The
definition of these and other model variables and the reporting of the magnitude and
direction of the association were inconsistent, with eight studies reporting results
for only the primary variable(s) of interest.
20, 21, 23–28
Variables associated with higher readmission rates in at least two studies included
advanced age,
18, 19, 29 longer
hospital stay,
16, 22, 29 poorer
post-stroke physical functioning,
15, 17 and an increased number of prior
hospitalizations.
16, 19 Other variables associated with readmission were
insurance type,
19, 26 stroke type,
19,
22 incident stroke,
17, 19 discharge
destination,
17, 21, 26
diabetes,
18, 22, 28 physician
specialty,
25, 27, 29 and
hospital characteristics/certification status.
19, 22, 23, 29
provides detailed information on
variables significantly associated with readmission identified in and .
| Table 4Details of Relationships Between Variables Associated with Patient
Readmission after Stroke* |