Several observational studies have examined the association between sleep and obesity or BMI. Over 65 published articles have presented cross-sectional analyses and most found a significant association between short sleep duration (generally < 6 hours per night) and increased prevalence of obesity or higher BMI in both adults and children from various countries (see [
15–
17] for reviews). Some of these studies also observed higher mean BMI associated with longer sleep durations (generally > 8 hours per night), suggesting a U-shaped association between sleep duration and BMI. Studies that examined self-reported measures of sleep quality have generally found worse sleep quality associated with higher BMI [
18,
19]. Two recent metaanalyses analyzed data from some of these cross-sectional studies. Cappuccio
et al [
20] analyzed data from 17 studies and found that short sleep duration (<5 hours per night for adults, <10h per night for children) significantly predicted obesity in adults (pooled odds ratio [OR] was 1.55, 95% CI: 1.43–1.68) and in children (pooled OR was 1.89, 95% CI: 1.46–2.43) [
20]. Sleep duration as a continuous variable was also significantly associated with BMI: the pooled regression indicated that on average BMI was a 0.35 kg/m
2 lower for every additional hour of sleep [
20]. A second meta-analysis examined sleep and obesity in children and the pooled OR predicting obesity from short sleep duration was 1.58 (95% CI: 1.26–1.98), which means that children who were short sleepers had 58% greater odds of being obese [
21]. Thus, both meta-analyses confirmed that short sleep duration increased the odds of being obese. Most cross-sectional studies used self-reported sleep duration, but a few studies have used more objective measures. In a subset (n=612) of the Coronary Artery Risk Development in Young Adults (CARDIA) study in the US, wrist actigraphy was used to estimate sleep duration when participants were approximately 35–50 years old. Participants with shorter average sleep durations had higher BMI than those with longer sleep durations in cross-sectional analyses [
22]. The Osteoporotic Fractures in Men (MrOS), which included over 2700 men aged 65 years and older, used polysomnography to determine which characteristics of sleep were associated with measures of body composition [
23]. Those with the lowest percentage of slow-wave sleep (SWS) had the highest mean BMI and largest mean waist circumference, but the study did not find an association between SWS and percent body fat. In summary, most studies have reported a significant cross-sectional association where shorter sleep duration and in some studies longer sleep duration were associated with higher BMI or the presence of obesity. Of note, however, is that some studies have reported differences in these associations by age group. In particular, the association between sleep and BMI appears stronger at younger ages, and only one study in children has reported a U-shaped association [
24].
There have also been a few prospective studies of sleep and weight gain in both adults and children (see ). A few of these studies found no statistically significant association between sleep duration and change in body size [
22,
25,
26]. Many studies, however, did report a significant association. For example, in the Nurse’s Health Study women who slept ≤5 hours per night gained 1.14 kg (95% CI: 0.49, 1.79) and those sleeping 6 hours per night gained 0.71 kg (95% CI: 0.41, 1.00) more weight over 16 years than those sleeping 7 hours adjusting for age and baseline BMI [
27]. In the Quebec Family Study, those who reported sleeping 5–6 hours per night gained approximately 1.84 kg (95% CI 1.08–2.61) more over 6 years than those reporting 7–8 hours per night, even after adjustment for numerous potential confounders [
28]. A study in Spain also reported that women who reported sleeping ≤5 hours per night had increased odds of gaining 5 kg or more over 2 years compared to those who slept 7 hours per night (OR 3.41, 95%CI 1.34–8.69) [
29]. This study also reported increased weight gain among women who reported sleeping 8 hours or 9 hours per night. No association was seen in men. A study in Japan found that mean BMI among men who were short (<6h) or long (≥9h/night) sleepers increased more than in men who slept 7-<8 hours per night, however no association was observed among women [
30]. A recent study among two minority groups in the US, African-Americans and Hispanic adults, found that among those aged 18–39 years short self-reported sleep (≤5h/night) was significantly associated with a greater increase in BMI, visceral fat & subcutaneous fat over 5 years compared to those sleeping 6–7 hours per night [
31]. Of note, the association between short sleep and change in visceral fat was similar to the association between short sleep and change in subcutaneous fat. No association between sleep and change in BMI or fat was observed for those aged 40 years or older [
31]. Among children in the UK, the odds of becoming obese between 38 months and 7 years of age was higher for children sleeping <10.5 hours per night (OR 1.45, 95% CI 1.10–1.89) and children sleeping 10.5–11.4 hours per night (OR 1.32, 95% CI 1.02–1.79) relative to children sleeping 12 hours per night at 38 months of age [
32]. A study that collected time diaries in children also found a small but significant association between sleep duration and 5-year change in BMI (beta = −.115, p<.01), however, when stratified by age group, the association was only significant among the younger children who were aged 3–7.9 years at baseline (beta = −.153, p<.010) [
33]. Finally, a study in the US collected parental reports of sleep duration when the children were 6 months, 1 year and 2 years of age and sleep duration was averaged over the three time points [
34]. Average sleep duration<12 hours per night (versus >12 hours) was positively associated with BMI z score, sum of skinfolds and odds of being overweight at 3 years of age, even after multiple adjustments [
34]. These prospective studies together suggest that sleep duration is associated with changes in body size, which could increase the risk of developing obesity and associated cardiometabolic disease.
| Table 1Summary of prospective observational studies that examine association between sleep and changes in body size. |
Two hormones that are involved in appetite regulation are leptin, a satiety factor, and ghrelin, an appetite stimulant. Previous laboratory studies found that sleep restriction resulted in decreased leptin and increased ghrelin in peripheral blood [
35,
36]. A few observational studies have also examined levels of leptin and ghrelin in relation to habitual sleep duration. The Wisconsin Sleep Cohort Study, a population-based study that enrolled Wisconsin State employees aged 30–60 years, collected sleep diaries to assess habitual sleep, conducted one night of polysomnography (PSG) in the laboratory, and in the morning following the PSG, obtained a single blood sample [
37]. Total sleep time from PSG was inversely associated with ghrelin levels (beta = −0.69, p=0.008) while average habitual sleep duration was positively associated with leptin levels independently of BMI (beta = 0.11, p=0.01) [
37]. Data from the Quebec Family Study of 740 men and women aged 21–64 years indicated that leptin levels in those sleeping 5–6 hours per night were approximately 15–17% lower than predicted based on body fat alone [
38]. These two studies are consistent with some of the laboratory studies but two other studies in women did not observe similar associations. The Nurse’s Health Study, which asked participants to return a blood sample through the mail, did not observe a significant association between self-reported sleep duration and leptin levels [
39]. Also, a randomized trial of moderate-intensity exercise among 173 obese, sedentary postmenopausal women aged 50–74 found no cross-sectional associations between self-reported sleep duration and leptin or total ghrelin levels nor any significant associations between change in sleep duration and changes in leptin or ghrelin after the exercise intervention [
40]. These discrepant results may be due to differences in the association between sleep and appetite regulation in women, particularly obese older women, or may be due to methodological issues such as self-reported sleep duration, sample collection or assay procedures. Finally, the Women’s Health Initiative study examined the relationship between sleep and dietary intake in 459 postmenopausal women aged 50–81 years [
41]. Average sleep duration from 1 week of wrist actigraphy was negatively correlated with dietary fat intake and total calories, which suggests that short sleepers have a greater food intake particularly in the form of fat. A study in adolescents did not find an association between hunger ratings and average nocturnal sleep from 7-day sleep diaries, however, those who slept 3 hours or more during the daytime reported greater caloric intake and food cravings and this association did not appear to be confounded by nocturnal sleep duration [
42]. More research is required to assess whether habitual insufficient sleep is truly associated with greater appetite and greater food intake.