|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
To identify the etiology, incidence and prevalence of ocular bacterial infections, and to assess the in vitro susceptibility of these ocular bacterial isolates to commonly used antibiotics.
Retrospective analysis of consecutive samples submitted for microbiological evaluation from patients who were clinically diagnosed with ocular infections and were treated at a tertiary eye care referral center in South India between January 2002 and December 2007.
A total of 4417 ocular samples was submitted for microbiological evaluation, of which 2599 (58.8%) had bacterial growth, 456 (10.3%) had fungal growth, 15 (0.34%) had acanthamoebic growth, 14 (0.32%) had mixed microbial growth and the remaining 1333 (30.2%) had negative growth. The rate of culture-positivity was found to be 88% (P < 0.001) in eyelids’ infection, 70% in conjunctival, 69% in lacrimal apparatus, 67.4% in corneal, 51.6% in intraocular tissues, 42.9% in orbital and 39.2% in scleral infections. The most common bacterial species isolated were Staphylococcus aureus (26.69%) followed by Streptococcus pneumoniae (22.14%). Sta. aureus was more prevalent more in eyelid infections (51.22%; P = 0.001) coagulase-negative staphylococci in endophthalmitis (53.1%; P = 0.001), Str. pneumoniae in lacrimal apparatus and corneal infections (64.19%; P = 0.001), Corynebacterium species in blepharitis and conjunctivitis (71%; P = 0.001), Pseudomonas aeruginosa in keratitis and dacryocystitis (66.5%; P = 0.001), Haemophilus species in dacryocystitis and conjunctivitis (66.7%; P = 0.001), Moraxella lacunata in blepharitis (54.17%; P = 0.001) and Moraxella catarrhalis in dacryocystitis (63.83%; P = 0.001). The largest number of gram-positive isolates was susceptible to moxifloxacin (98.7%) and vancomycin (97.9%), and gram-negative isolates to amikacin (93.5%) and gatifloxacin (92.7%).
Gram-positive cocci were the most frequent bacteria isolated from ocular infections and were sensitive to moxifloxacin and vancomycin, while gram-negative isolates were more sensitive to amikacin and gatifloxacin.
The eye may be infected from external sources or through intraocular invasion of micro-organisms that are carried by the blood stream. External bacterial infections of the eye are usually localized but may frequently spread to other tissues. The eyelid and conjunctiva have a normal microbial flora controlled by its own mechanism and by the host. Modification of this normal flora contributes to ocular infections such as blepharitis, conjunctivitis, canaliculitis, orbital cellulitis, endophthalmitis, etc.[1–5] Timely institution of appropriate therapy must be initiated to control the infections and thereby minimize ocular morbidity. If they are not treated promptly, it may lead to sight threatening condition. For specific antibacterial treatment, isolation and identification of bacterial pathogens along with antibiotic susceptibility spectrum is essential. The bacterial etiology and their susceptibility as well as resistance patterns may vary with geographic location according to the local population.[6,7] Streptococcus pneumoniae was reported to be the predominant corneal pathogen in Tiruchirapalli and Madurai, whereas in Coimbatore it was Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Ps. aeruginosa was reported to be the most common bacterial pathogen causing postoperative endophthalmitis in Chennai, whereas in Madurai it was Nocardia sp. Similarly, there was a variation in the in vitro efficacy of antibacterial agents against bacterial pathogens causing ocular infections according to the local population. For instance, ciprofloxacin showed higher sensitivity against keratitis pathogens in Tirunelveli (90%) than in Hyderabad (69.3%). Thus, the current trends in the etiology of bacterial ocular infections and their susceptibilities must be updated to make a rational choice of initial antibiotic therapy. The purpose of this study was to identify the etiology, incidence and prevalence of ocular bacterial infections, and to assess the in vitro susceptibility of these ocular bacterial isolates to commonly used antibiotics.
This retrospective, noncomparative and consecutive analysis included samples submitted for microbiological evaluation, from patients clinically diagnosed with ocular infections such as blepharitis, conjunctivitis, internal and external hordeolum, suppurative scleritis, canaliculitis, keratitis, dacryocystitis, preseptal cellulitis, endophthalmitis and panophthalmitis, and treated at a tertiary eye care referral center located at Tirunelveli district, Tamil Nadu, South India, between January 2002 and December 2007. All the patients were examined on the slit-lamp biomicroscope and infective diseases included in this study were diagnosed clinically by a group of ophthalmologists.[4,5]
After detailed ocular examinations using standard techniques,[15,16] specimens for culture and smear were obtained by scraping the eyelid margin using a sterile blade (#15) on a Bard-Parker handle and by swabbing the lid margins with sterile broth-moistened cotton swabs in cases of blepharitis. Similarly, specimens were also obtained from the corneal ulcers by scraping. For cases of suppurative scleritis, specimens were collected by scraping and swabbing the area of the suppurative abscess. Conjuctival cultures were obtained by wiping a broth-moistened swab across the lower conjunctival cul-de-sac in conjunctivitis cases, and thick, tenacious purulent punctal discharge was collected from the canaliculus by pressure applied over the area of the eyelid that overlies the canaliculus in cases of canaliculitis. In cases of external and internal hordeolum, the abscesses were incised and the drained pus was obtained. From the cases of dacryocystitis, purulent material was collected from everted punta by applying pressure over the lacrimal sac area, and from the surgically excised lacrimal sac. Specimens from cases of preseptal cellulitis were obtained after stab incision or through an open wound or drainage site, if present. In patients in whom infectious endophthalmitis and panophthalmitis are suspected, lid and conjunctival specimens along with anterior chamber and vitreous fluids were obtained.
The obtained extraocular and intraocular specimens were inoculated directly onto the blood agar (5% defibrinated sheep blood in tryptose blood agar base with yeast extract), chocolate agar, Sabouraud’s dextrose agar (Emmons modification), thioglycolate medium and brain-heart infusion broth, and specimens from lacrimal apparatus, cornea and vitreous were also inoculated onto Lowenstein-Jensen agar slant. In addition, all corneal scrapes were inoculated onto non-nutrient agar for Acanthamoeba culture. A part of the collected specimens was subjected to 10% KOH wet mounting, Gram’s and Giemsa’s staining procedures, and if needed, Kinyoun’s and Ziehl-Neelsen acid-fast staining procedures were also performed. A positive culture was defined as a growth of the same organisms on more than two solid phase media or confluent growth on one solid medium. A standardized protocol was followed for each ocular specimen for the evaluation of significant microbiological features.[15,16] In vitro susceptibility testing was performed by Kirby-Bauer disc diffusion method and interpreted using Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute’s serum standards. The antibacterial agents (Hi-media Laboratories Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai, India) used were amikacin (30 μg/disk), tobramycin (10 μg/disk), gentamicin (10 μg/disk), cefazolin (30 μg/disk), cephotaxime (30 μg/disk), ceftazidime (30 μg/disk), ciprofloxacin (5 μg/disk), norfloxacin (10 μg/disk), ofloxacin (5 μg/disk), gatifloxacin (5 μg/disk), moxifloxacin (5 μg/disk), chloramphenicol (30 μg/disk) and vancomycin (30 μg/disk) and were consistently tested for their efficacy against standard American Type Culture Collection (ATCC) bacteria (Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923, Str. pneumoniae ATCC 49619, Haemophilus influenzae ATCC 49241, Ps. aeruginosa ATCC 27853, Escherichia coli ATCC 25922) as a general quality control laboratory procedure.
Statistical software (STATA 8.1, Stata Corporation, Texas, USA) was used for statistical analysis. The statistical analysis was carried out to determine the difference in the rate of recovery of microbes from various ocular specimens and also to determine the significance in the prevalence of common bacterial species in causing ocular infections. Pearson’s chi-square test was used for analysis and a P value <0.05 was considered statistically significant.
A total of 4417 ocular samples obtained from 4372 patients clinically diagnosed with o cular infections, was submitted for microbiological evaluation during the study period of 6 years. Of the 4372 patients, single eye was infected in 4327 (98.97%) patients and both the eyes were infected in 45 (1.03%) patients; thus, a total of 4417 (4327 + 90) eyes with ocular infections was studied [Table 1]. Of the 4417 ocular specimens subjected to cultures, 2599 (58.8%) had bacterial growth, 456 (10.3%) had fungal growth, 15 (0.34%) had acanthamoebic growth and 14 (0.32%) had mixed microbial growth. The remaining 1333 (30.2%) ocular specimens were culture negative for microbial growth [Table 2]. The rate of culture-positivity was found to be significantly higher among eyes with eyelids’ infection (88%; 677 of 766) than eyes with conjunctival (69.7%; 576 of 826) (P = 0.001), lacrimal apparatus (69%; 729 of 1057) (P = 0.001), corneal (67.4%; 846 of 1256) (P = 0.001), intraocular tissues (51.6%; 227 of 440) (P = 0.001), orbital (42.9%; 9 of 21) (P = 0.001) and scleral (39.2%; 20 of 51) (P = 0.001) infections [Table 1].
Of 2599 eyes with bacterial growth alone, 2587 (99.54%) had infection with single species of bacteria and the remaining 12 (0.46%) had infection with two species of bacteria, and thus, a total of 2611 (2587 + 24) bacterial isolates was recovered [Table 3]. The predominant bacterial species isolated was Sta. aureus (26.69%; 697 of 2611), followed by Str. pneumoniae (22.14%; 578 of 2611), Ps. aeruginosa (8.35%; 218 of 2611), Corynebacterium species (7.93%; 207 of 2611), Haemophilus species (5.86%; 153 of 2611) and Moraxella catarrhalis (3.6%; 94 of 2611) [Table 4].
The predominant bacterial species isolated from eyes with blepharitis (46.7%; 230 of 493 total blepharitis bacterial isolates), hordeolum (71.9%; 123 of 171 total hordeolum bacterial isolates), preseptal cellulitis (26.7%; 4 of 15 total preseptal cellulitis bacterial isolates), conjunctivitis (41.3%; 231 of 560 total conjunctivitis bacterial isolates) and canaliculitis (33.8%; 22 of 65 total canaliculitis isolates) was Sta. aureus. From cases of dacryocystitis (31.4%; 205 of 654 total dacryocystitis isolates) and keratitis (37.02%; 154 of 416 total keratitis isolates) Str. pneumoniae was isolated, and from cases of postoperative (68.27%; 71 of 104 total postoperative endophthalmitis isolates) and post-traumatic endophthalmitis (37.5%; 15 of 45 total post-traumatic endophthalmitis isolates), coagulase negative staphylococci (CoNS) were predominantly recovered. Of 12 post-corneal infective endophthalmitis, 6 (50%) were found to be due to Ps. aeruginosa growth [Table 5].
Significantly more number of Sta. aureus was recovered from eyes with eyelid infections (51.22%; 357 of 697 total Sta. aureus isolates) than from eyes with other ocular infections (48.79%; 340 of 697) (P = 0.001). CoNS were recovered more from eyes with endophthalmitis (53.1%; 86 of 162) than from eyes with any other ocular infections (46.9%; 76 of 162) (P = 0.001). Str. pneumoniae was recovered significantly from more number of eyes with lacrimal apparatus infections and corneal infections [64.19%; 371 (217 from lacrimal apparatus and 154 from corneal infection) of 578 of total Str. pneumoniae isolates] than any other ocular infections (35.8%; 207 of 578) (P = 0.001). Streptococcus viridans was isolated frequently from eyes with dacryocystitis (43.24%; 32 of 74 total Str. viridans isolates) (P = 0.001). More number of Corynebacterium species was isolated from eyes with blepharitis and conjunctivitis [71%; 147 of 207 total Corynebacterium isolates (74 isolates from blepharitis and 73 from conjunctivitis)] than any other ocular infection (29%; 60 of 207) (P = 0.001). Ps. aeruginosa was isolated at a higher frequency from eyes with dacryocystitis and keratitis (66.5%; 145 of 218) (P = 0.001). The recovery of Moraxella lacunata (54.17%; 26 of 48 total M. lacunata isolates) (P = 0.001) and M. catarrhalis (63.83%; 60 of 94 total M. catarrhalis isolates) (P = 0.001) was significantly more in number from eyes with blepharitis and dacryocystitis, respectively, than from eyes with any other ocular infections. Larger numbers of Nocardia asteroids (49.06%; 26 of 53 total Nocardia isolates) were isolated from corneal ulcers than from any other ocular infections (50.9%; 27 of 53). Haemophilus species were isolated from larger number of ocular samples obtained from eyes with dacryocystitis and conjunctivitis [73.2%; 112 (73 from dacryocystitis and 39 from conjunctivitis) of 153 total Haemophilus isolates] than from samples with other ocular infections (33.33%; 51 of 153) (P = 0.001).
Overall, large numbers of bacterial isolates were susceptible to gatifloxacin (93.68%; 326 of 348) [Table 6]. The highest percentage of gram-positive organisms was susceptible to moxifloxacin (99.1%; 226 of 228), followed by vancomycin (97.93%; 1750 of 1787), gatifloxacin (93.86%; 214 of 228), cefazolin (91.77%; 1640 of 1787) and chloramphenicol (88.86%; 1588 of 1787). The gram-negative organisms were susceptible in highest percentage to amikacin (93.51%; 721 of 771), followed by gatifloxacin (92.66%; 101 of 109), ofloxacin (88.72%; 684 of 771) and ciprofloxacin (86.64%; 668 of 771). Amikacin (100%) and vancomycin (100%) showed highest efficacy against Nocardia spp.
A combination of mechanical, anatomic, immunologic and microbiologic factors prevents ocular infections and do not allow the survival of pathogenic species in the eye.[18,19] However, in certain circumstances, they gain access to the eye and cause a variety of infections. Prompt and specific therapy can be instituted if the microbes can be isolated and their susceptibility to the antimicrobials is known. However, the ability to isolate the causative organism depends on a variety of factors including the amount of inoculum, the site from which it is taken, the media used for culture (whether enriched media are used or not) and also on the empirical treatment received before collection of the samples. Hence, the culture-positivity varies from center to center. In this study, the overall culture-positivity was 69.8%. We found the highest rate of culture-positivity among the samples collected from eyelid infections probably due to two reasons, that is, being the outermost defense mechanism it harbors a large number of microorganisms and the amount of inoculum is also sufficient to inoculate the various media.
In this study, bacteria (58.8%) were the most common pathogens and were involved in infections of all the tissues of the eye, whereas fungi (10.3%) caused keratitis and endophtalmitis and Acanthamoeba (0.34%) caused only keratitis. The most common bacteria isolated from ocular specimens were Sta. aureus (26.69%) followed by Str. pneumoniae (22.14%). Sta. aureus caused infections of the eyelids (52.57%), conjunctiva (40.45%) and canaliculus (33.85%), whereas Str. pneumoniae caused lacrimal sac (31.35%) and corneal infections (37%) and CoNS, postoperative (68.27%) and post-traumatic endophthalmitis (33%). Though Staphylococci and Streptococci along with other bacteria like Corynebacterium, Haemophilus, Moraxella and Neisseria are part of the normal flora of the conjunctiva, under appropriate conditions they cause infections.[2,23,24] Sta. aureusis commonly involved in primary pyoderma and acts as a secondary invader on diseased skin. It produces coagulase, a factor capable of clotting the plasma which may play a role in the development of staphylococcal abscess by producing local fibrin thrombi that protect organisms and concentrate toxic factors. CoNS elaborate a surface slime that facilitates adherence to the surface and may play a role in the pathogenesis of endophthalmitis. The surface slime protects the organism from phagocytosis and the action of antimicrobial agents. CoNS, especially Staphylococcus epidermidis is the commonest cause for postoperative endophthalmitis.[6,7] Being a normal inhabitant of the upper respiratory tract, Str. pneumoniae is frequently found in the lacrimal apparatus and conjunctiva.[2,3] Any minor corneal epithelial disruption facilitates invasion of the bacteria, hence causing corneal ulcer.
Among gram-negative bacilli, the most common pathogen was Pseudomonas spp. (8.4%), followed by Haemophilus spp. (5.9%), Klebsiella spp. (3.2%) and Enterobacter spp. (2.7%). Prevalence of Pseudomonas spp. was more in keratitis (34.9%; 76 of 218) and dacrocystitis (31.7%; 69 of 218), Haemophilus spp. in dacryocystitis (47.7%; 73 of 153) and conjunctivitis (25.5%; 39 of 153), Klebsiella spp. in dacryocystitis (62.4%; 53 of 85) and Enterobcater spp. in both keratitis (35.7%; 25 of 70) and dacryocystitis (34.3%; 24 of 70). Pseudomonas keratitis has been attributed to the action of proteases and glycocalyx that allow the organisms that adhere to the host cells forming micro colonies that resist phagocytosis. Natural pathogenicity of Haemophilus appears to be directly related to the capsule formation which renders resistance to complement-mediated immunity. The gram-negative bacilli, Klebsiella spp., Enterobacter spp., Citrobacter spp., Proteus spp., Serratia spp. etc., are found in soil and sewage and are opportunistic pathogens causing conjunctivitis, keratitis, dacryocystitis, orbital cellulitis and endophthalmitis when the host defenses are low.[4,5]
Among the gram-negative coccobacilli, the predominant isolate, M. catarrhalis demonstrated 3.6% of incidence and was more frequently present in dacryocystitis (63.8%; 60 of 94), whereas M. lacunata was prevalent more in blepharitis (54.2%; 26 of 48), Neisseria in conjunctivitis (57%; 8 of 14). M. cararrhalis, a constant inhabitant of the respiratory tract, tends to cause dacryocystitis and less frequently meibomitis, conjunctivitis, keratitis and rarely postoperative endophthalmitis. M. lacunata is commonly found in hot and dry areas of the world and causes angular conjunctivitis in alcoholics and debilitated patients. Neisseria spp. infects mucosa of genitourinary tract and conjunctiva of neonates, adolescents and adults.
The filamentous bacteria, Nocardia, accounted for 2% of the incidence and its prevalence was 49% in keratitis and 20.7% in canaliculitis. In comparison, the incidence of gram-positive bacilli was 9%, of which Corynebacterium spp. accounted a higher rate of prevalence in blepharitis (35.7%; 74 of 207) and conjunctivitis (35.3%; 73 of 207), whereas Bacillus species was present in conjunctivitis (40.7%; 11 of 27) and in post-traumatic endophthalmitis (26%; 7 of 27). Nocardia infection usually occurs following trauma with objects contaminated with soil, and there have been sporadic reports of conjunctivitis, dacryocystitis, canaliculitis, scleritis, keratits, episcleral granuloma and endophthalmitis. Corynebacterium spp. are almost constant saprophytes in the conjunctiva, however, Corynebacterium diphtheriae causes severe membranous conjunctivitis associated with pharyngeal diphtheria. Bacillus spp. are ubiquitous in nature and are known to cause severe endophthalmitis following penetrating injury with metallic or vegetative foreign bodies and also by endogenous spread in drug abusers.
Resistance and sensitivity based on in vitro testing may not reflect true clinical resistance and response to an antibiotic because of the host factors and penetration of the drug. In this study, moxifloxacin and vancomycin revealed a higher efficacy against gram-positive isolates compared with other antibacterial agents. Vancomycin is a glycopeptide; it inhibits early stages in cell wall mucopeptide synthesis and it exhibited greatest potency against ocular gram-positive isolates. Moxifloxacin was specifically developed with methoxy group in the C-8 position and bicyclic side-chain in the C-7 position, which was specifically engineered to increase the potency and further inhibit bacterial resistance by hindering the cell’s efflux pump mechanism, increasing the drug’s length of stay within bacterial cells. Recent studies have also shown the excellent gram-positive coverage of moxifloxacin in ocular infections. However, moxifloxacin has incomplete coverage against gram-negative isolates. We found greatest coverage of gatifloxacin and amikacin against gram-negative isolates. Ciprofloxacin and ofloxacin were introduced earlier and have been widely used since 1990, whereas gatifloxacin’s usage has started in recent years. In addition to methoxy side chain at the C-8 position, gatifloxacin carries a methyl group on the piperazinyl ring. There was a slight decrease in all pathogens’ susceptibilities to ciprofloxacin and ofloxacin, with a subsequent increase in the efficacy of gatifloxacin. The relationship between antibiotic use and resistance is complex. Improper selection of antibiotics, inadequate dosing and poor compliance to therapy may play as important a role in increasing resistance as their overuse. This report documents the prevalence of bacterial species causing ocular infections in South India. The information provided in this article would aid the clinician in formulating rationale-based decisions in the antibiotic treatment of bacterial ocular infections that cause major public health problems.
Source of Support: Nil
Conflict of Interest: None declared.