|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Inhibition of growth signaling pathways protects against aging and age-related diseases in parallel with reduced oxidative stress. The relationships between growth signaling, oxidative stress and aging remain unclear. Here we report that in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, alterations in growth signaling pathways impact levels of superoxide anions that promote chronological aging and inhibit growth arrest of stationary phase cells in G0/G1. Factors that decrease intracellular superoxide anions in parallel with enhanced longevity and more efficient G0/G1 arrest include genetic inactivation of growth signaling pathways that inhibit Rim15p, which activates oxidative stress responses, and downregulation of these pathways by caloric restriction. Caloric restriction also reduces superoxide anions independently of Rim15p by elevating levels of H2O2, which activates superoxide dismutases. In contrast, high glucose or mutations that activate growth signaling accelerate chronological aging in parallel with increased superoxide anions and reduced efficiency of stationary phase G0/G1 arrest. High glucose also activates DNA damage responses and preferentially kills stationary phase cells that fail to arrest growth in G0/G1. These findings suggest that growth signaling promotes chronological aging in budding yeast by elevating superoxide anions that inhibit quiescence and induce DNA replication stress. A similar mechanism likely contributes to aging and age-related diseases in complex eukaryotes.
Inhibition of growth signaling by caloric restriction (CR) or mutational inactivation of conserved insulin/IGF-1-like and Target of Rapamycin (TOR) signaling pathways prolongs the lifespans of eukaryotic organisms as diverse as yeasts and humans. In complex eukaryotes, inhibition of growth signaling also protects against age-related diseases, including cancer, cardiovascular disease and neurodegenerative disorders . The lifespan-extending effects of reduced growth signaling occur in parallel with the induction of oxidative stress responses that reduce levels of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and oxidative damage to macromolecules. This is consistent with the longstanding free radical theory of aging, which posits oxidative damage to macromolecules as a primary determinant of lifespan .
A number of recent studies have investigated the impact of conserved growth signaling pathways on chronological lifespan (CLS) in the model organism Saccharomyces cerevisiae (budding yeast). CLS of this organism is determined by measuring the length of time cells maintain viability or reproductive capacity after nutrient depletion induces a stationary phase growth arrest. Growth arrest in stationary phase mimics the quiescent, postmitotic state that occurs in higher eukaryotes when growth-signaling pathways are downregulated during differentiation. The results of many of these studies support the free radical theory. For example, CLS is extended by inactivation of the budding yeast SCH9 gene encoding a homologue of the mammalian AKT protein . Stationary phase sch9Δ cells express elevated levels of the Mn-dependent superoxide dismutase Sod2p  and exhibit lower levels of superoxide anions (O2-) . CLS is also extended by inactivation of the mammalian Ras homologue RAS2 via a mechanism that depends on Sod2p  and by inactivation of conserved TOR growth signaling pathways, which also leads to a reduction in levels of O2- [5,6]. When active, Tor1p, Sch9p and Ras2p inhibit the Rim15p kinase and its induction of superoxide dismutases and other oxidative stress defenses, and reduced signaling through these pathways in calorie-restricted cells extends CLS in a Rim15p-dependent fashion . CR or inactivation of catalases also extends CLS by inducing elevated levels of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), which inhibits the accumulation of intracellular O2- by activating superoxide dismutases . Conversely, a shorter CLS in concert with elevated levels of O2- have been detected in stationary phase budding yeast cells in which the cAMP phosphodiesterase Pde2p has been inactivated . Pde2 inhibits Ras2p-dependent growth signaling, which is constitutively active in pde2Δ cells .
All of these findings are consistent with a role for oxidative stress produced in association with growth signaling through highly conserved AKT, TOR and RAS-dependent pathways as an important pro-aging factor in the budding yeast chronological aging model. Similar connections have been established between levels of ROS and growth signaling through AKT, mTOR and RAS-dependent pathways in more complex eukaryotes . However, the mechanisms by which oxidative stress is increased by growth signaling and promotes aging remain unclear. For example, although some of the CLS-extending effects of CR in budding yeast depend on the induction of oxidative and other stress defenses by Rim15p, CR also extends CLS via an Sch9p, Ras2p and Rim15p-independent mechanism . Furthermore, it was recently reported that chronological aging is caused by toxic effects of acetic acid that accumulate in the medium of stationary phase cultures. According to this model, CR or deletion of SCH9 or RAS2 extend CLS independently of effects on oxidative stress by inhibiting the accumulation of acetic acid (in the case of CR) or by creating resistance to acetic acid toxicity via unknown mechanisms (in the case of the deletion of SCH9 or RAS2) . In addition, inactivation of catalases extends CLS in parallel with increased levels of oxidative damage to proteins and other macromolecules despite a reduction in intracellular O2- . Although this latter finding is consistent with the model that O2- shortens CLS, it is not consistent with the free radical theory postulate that oxidative damage to macromolecules is a primary cause of aging.
DNA replication stress - i.e., inefficient DNA replication that causes DNA damage - in stationary phase budding yeast cells that fail to arrest in G0/G1 is an additional factor determining CLS of budding yeast. Growth arrest in G0/G1 prevents replication stress that arises when stationary phase cells arrest growth in S phase instead . Experimental manipulations that shorten CLS and inhibit stationary phase growth arrest in G0/G1 include constitutive activation of Ras2p [13,14] and mutational inactivation of Rim15p . In contrast, CR or mutational inactivation of Ras2p or Sch9p promote a more frequent G0/G1 arrest of stationary phase budding yeast cells in concert with an extended CLS . CR was also recently shown to extend the CLS of fission yeast (S. pombe) in association with more frequent growth arrest in G0/G1 .
To better understand the effects of growth signaling and CR on aging and how they relate to both oxidative and replication stress, in this study we examined levels of ROS in budding yeast stationary phase cells under a variety of experimental conditions in parallel with measurements of CLS and the frequency with which stationary phase cells growth arrest in G0/G1. Our findings indicate that in general, growth signaling enhances the age-dependent accumulation of O2-, and inhibition of growth signaling inhibits O2- accumulation. Furthermore, the reduction in O2- induced by elevated H2O2 in calorie-restricted cells occurs independently of Rim15p. Although CR inhibits the accumulation of acetic acid in stationary phase cultures under some conditions, it can also reduce intracellular levels of O2- and extend CLS in the absence of changes in levels of acetic acid. Factors that enhance the accumulation of O2- independently of acetic acid include elevated concentrations of glucose, which block the accumulation of H2O2 and selectively kill cells that fail to arrest in G0/G1 in stationary phase. Together, these findings suggest that growth signaling promotes aging in the chronological aging model in part by inducing O2- that inhibit the growth arrest of stationary phase cells in G0/G1, thus leading to DNA replication stress.
Chronological lifespan experiments require the establishment of exponentially dividing cultures of cells that eventually deplete nutrients from the medium, leading to entry into a non-dividing stationary phase state a few days later. Compared to exponential cultures, intra-cellular levels of O2- detected by the fluorescent probe dihydroethidium (DHE), which can detect superoxide , initially declined during the few days of experiments but then gradually accumulated with time in stationary phase (Figure (Figure1A).1A). The chronological age-dependent accumulation of O2- occurred in parallel with loss of reproductive capacity as measured by colony-forming units (Figure (Figure1B;1B; “WT 2% glu”). As reported earlier , both the accumulation of O2- and loss of reproductive capacity in stationary phase cells were accompanied by an increase in cell death as measured by uptake of the membrane-impermeable DNA stain propidium iodide (PI) (Figure S1), which does not stain viable cells with intact membranes. The rate of cell death was accelerated in cells with visible buds that failed to exit the cell cycle in stationary phase compared to cells without visible buds (Figure S1). This is consistent with an earlier report that a subpopulation of stationary phase cells that includes all budded cells exhibits elevated levels of apoptosis .
Also similar to earlier reports [13,20], CR by reducing the initial concentration of glucose in growth medium from 2% to 0.5% extended the CLS of wild type cells (Figure (Figure1B).1B). Although CR initially increased O2- in exponential cultures at the start of CLS experiments (Figure (Figure1C),1C), it led to a reduction in O2- in stationary phase cultures three days later (Figure (Figure1D;1D; compare “WT 0.5% glu” with “WT 2% glu”). This decrease was detected in association with a decrease in the fraction of cells that failed to arrest in G0/G1 as indicated by visible buds (Figure (Figure1E).1E). In the absence of CR, CLS was lengthened to a similar extent (compared to CR) in a strain from which the SCH9 gene had been deleted, and CR extended the CLS of sch9Δ cells even further (Figure (Figure1B).1B). Similar to the effects of CR, the CLS-extending effects of inactivating Sch9p in 2% glucose medium were also accompanied by a decrease in O2-, and inactivation of Sch9p decreased levels of O2- in calorie-restricted cells even further (Figure (Figure1D).1D). A reduction in intracellular O2- in sch9Δ cells was recently reported by others as well  and is consistent with a previous report that expression of the superoxide dismutase Sod2p is elevated in sch9Δ cells . Inactivation of Sch9p also led to a decrease in the fraction of stationary phase cells that failed to arrest growth in G0/G1 as was reported earlier , and this fraction was reduced further by CR of sch9Δ cells (Figure (Figure1E).1E). Similar quantitative effects on efficiency of G0/G1 arrest in stationary phase in parallel with changes in CLS and O2- were observed in medium containing 2% glucose or 0.5% glucose in cells from which TOR1 had been deleted (Figure S2). Culturing cells in rich medium (YPD) rather than defined medium (SC), which also promotes more frequent growth arrest of stationary phase cells in G0/G1 , also reduced levels of O2- compared to cells cultured in SC (Figure S3).
Growth signaling pathways that depend on Sch9p, Tor1p and Ras2p converge on inhibition of Rim15p kinase activity that activates Sod2p and other stress responses, which are induced when these growth signaling pathways are genetically ablated or attenuated by CR . Sod1p and Sod2p activity are also induced by H2O2 that accumulates to higher levels in calorie-restricted cells or when catalases have been inactivated . Intracellular levels of H2O2 detected with the fluorescent probe dihydrorhodamine 123 were slightly reduced in stationary phase sch9Δ compared to wild type cells (Figure (Figure1F;1F; “DHR”). Therefore, unlike CR, inactivation of Sch9 does not reduce levels of O2- by inducing elevated levels of H2O2 that activate SODs. Moreover, CR increased H2O2 and reduced O2- levels in stationary phase rim15Δ cells (Figure (Figure1G),1G), similar to its effects in wild type cells . Thus, the reduction in O2- levels detected in calorie-restricted cells reflects both Rim15p-dependent effects downstream of reduced signaling by Sch9p, Tor1p and Ras2p that do not depend on increased H2O2, as well as Rim15p-independent effects related to H2O2 induction of SODs. Rim15p-independent effects of CR on levels of O2- are consistent with an earlier report of Rim15p-independent effects of CR on CLS . Together, these findings reveal the existence of a quantitative relationship between CLS extension, reduction in intracellular levels of O2- by Rim15p-dependent and -independent mechanisms and more efficient growth arrest of stationary phase cells in G0/G1 when growth signaling is inhibited.
In mammals, sustained mitogenic signaling by RAS, AKT and other oncogenes increases levels of O2- and other forms of ROS  and induces replication stress in cells that growth arrest in S phase instead of G0/G1 during differentiation . Similar increases in O2-  and a reduced frequency of stationary phase growth arrest in G0/G1 phase [13,14] have been described for budding yeast cells expressing constitutively active Ras2p. As noted above, RAS- and AKT-related path-ways that signal growth in response to nutrients in budding yeast converge on inhibition of Rim15p kinase activity . In addition to exhibiting a shorter CLS, rim15Δ cells fail to arrest in G0/G1 when they enter stationary phase [13,24]. Stationary phase rim15Δ cells also exhibit higher levels of O2- compared to wild type cells (Figure (Figure2A2A).
The mammalian cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor p27 blocks entry into S phase when mitogenic growth signaling is downregulated in mammalian cells . Sic1p, the budding yeast homologue of p27, similarly inhibits entry of budding yeast cells into S phase when they enter into a nutrient depletion-induced stationary phase growth arrest . As reported earlier , inactivation of Sic1p shortens CLS (Figure (Figure2B).2B). Similar to the effects of the constitutively active Ras2 or deletion of RIM15, the shorter CLS of sic1Δ cells is accompanied by increased O2- (Figure (Figure2C).2C). Although in this strain background (W303), deletion of SIC1 did not increase the number of cells with visible buds (Figure (Figure2D),2D), budding is uncoupled from DNA replication in sic1Δ cells in some genetic backgrounds . Measurements of DNA content by flow cytometry confirmed that a large fraction of stationary phase W303 sic1Δ cells were growth-arrested in S phase, despite a low frequency of buds (Figure (Figure2E).2E). Uncoupling of budding from DNA replication was not observed, however, in sic1Δ cells in a different genetic background (CEN.PK). sic1Δ cells in this background arrested growth in stationary phase with a substantial increase in the fraction of cells with visible buds (Figure S4).
Snf1p is a conserved AMP kinase that regulates budding yeast metabolism in response to glucose . In mammals, AMPK inhibits mTOR signaling  and is required for a “metabolic checkpoint” that drives cells into G1 in response to reduced glucose concentrations , similar to the more frequent stationary phase growth arrest in G0/G1 imposed by CR during nutrient depletion of budding yeast cells . In addition to exhibiting a shorter CLS compared to wild type cells (Figure (Figure2F),2F), stationary phase snf1Δ cells also arrested in G0/G1 less frequently (Figure (Figure2G)2G) and exhibited elevated levels of O2- (Figure (Figure2H).2H). These findings establish a strong correlation between enhanced growth signaling, increased intracellular levels of O2- and less efficient G0/G1 arrest in stationary phase related to glucose metabolism.
High glucose accelerates aging in C. elegans  and hyperglycemia and/or excess calorie intake are risk factors for a number of age-related diseases. High glucose activates AKT in mammalian cells , and similar to enhanced mitogenic signaling by oncogenes [32,33], increased growth signaling by elevated levels of glucose promotes senescence in parallel with DNA damage and increased ROS [34,35]. To determine whether growth signaling by high glucose might trigger related events and accelerate chronological aging in budding yeast, we examined the effects of increasing the concentration of glucose in medium to 10% from the standard 2% (in these experiments, 2% glucose medium also contained 8% sorbitol, a non-metabolized sugar, in order to maintain equivalent osmolarity). Culturing cells in SC medium containing 10% glucose shortened CLS compared to CLS in medium containing 2% glucose (Figure (Figure3A).3A). The shorter CLS of 10% glucose SC cultures is likely accompanied by DNA damage and/or DNA replication stress, because loss of reproductive capacity was dramatically reduced in cells harboring mutations in the DNA damage/DNA replication stress response proteins Mec1p or Rad53p (Figure (Figure3B).3B). Cells cultured in 10% glucose SC medium also exhibited increased levels of intracellular O2- (Figure (Figure3C).3C). This increase occurred in parallel with a reduction in intracellular levels of H2O2 in 10% glucose compared to 2% glucose cultures (Figure (Figure3D).3D). Since levels of H2O2are also increased in 0.5% compared to 2% glucose cultures , this suggests that glucose inhibits the accumulation of H2O2 in stationary phase cells in a dose-dependent fashion. The shorter CLS and increased O2- detected in 10% compared to 2% glucose SC cultures was not related to increased medium acidity, because in the genetic background of the strains employed in these experiments (DBY746), the pH of stationary phase cultures established in 10% glucose was not significantly different from the pH of 2% glucose cultures (Table (Table1).1). Unexpectedly, the fraction of stationary phase cells with visible buds in 10% glucose SC cultures was reduced rather than increased compared to 2% glucose SC cultures (Figure (Figure3E).3E). This likely reflects the accelerated death of dividing cells in SC medium containing 10% glucose (see below).
Similar to the effects of elevated glucose in SC medium, wild type cells cultured in 10% glucose YPD medium exhibited a shorter CLS and increased O2-levels compared to cells cultured in 2% glucose YPD (Figure 3F-G). However, in contrast to the reduced fraction of cells with visible buds detected in 10% glucose SC (Figure (Figure3E),3E), a substantial increase in the fraction of visibly budded cells was detected in YPD cultures established in 10% glucose (Figure (Figure3H).3H). As was the case for 10% glucose SC medium, the effects of 10% glucose in YPD medium were unrelated to changes in medium acidity, because the pH of these cultures did not differ significantly from the pH of YPD cultures established in 2% glucose (Table (Table1).1). Similar to the effects of inactivating Sch9p in cells cultured in 2% glucose SC (Figure 1B-D), Sch9p inactivation extended CLS, reduced O2- and lowered the fraction of budded cells detected in wild type cells cultured in 10% glucose YPD (Figure 3F-H). Since the CLS-shortening effects of 10% compared to 2% glucose are not related to acetic acid, we conclude that inactivation of Sch9p reduces O2- levels, enhances stationary phase G0/G1 arrest and extends CLS in 10% glucose medium by inhibiting glucose-dependent growth signaling, and not by causing resistance to acetic acid.
Wild type cells cultured in 2% glucose YPD medium also exhibited reduced levels of O2- compared to 2% glucose SC cultures (Figure S3; also compare “WT 2% glu” in Figure Figure3C3C with “WT 2% glu” in Figure Figure3G).3G). This likely reflects a reduced amount of acetic acid in stationary phase YPD cultures compared to SC cultures, because the pH of stationary phase YPD medium is substantially higher than the pH of SC medium (Table (Table1).1). Furthermore, unlike in 2% glucose SC cultures (Figure 1B-C), in 2% glucose YPD cultures sch9Δ cells did not exhibit a longer CLS or reduced levels of O2- compared to wild type cells (Figure 3F-G). This suggests that in 2% glucose SC cultures, inactivation of SCH9 extends CLS by inhibiting acetic acid induction of O2-.
The findings described in previous sections indicate that both glucose and acetic acid shorten CLS in concert with elevated levels of O2- and less efficient growth arrest of stationary phase cells in G0/G1. However, the reduced fraction of budded cells detected in 10% glucose compared to 2% glucose SC cultures (Figure (Figure3E)3E) is not consistent with a general relationship between enhanced growth signaling, increased O2- and less efficient G0/G1 arrest. Budding yeast cells die in stationary phase by an apoptosis-like mechanism [36,37]. The substantial increase in the fraction of stationary phase wild type cells with visible buds in 10% glucose YPD (Figure (Figure3H)3H) raised the possibility that the reduced fraction of budded cells in 10% glucose SC might be related to the very short CLS observed in these cultures and frequent apoptotic elimination of budded cells. Consistent with this possibility, PI staining of cells in 10% glucose SC stationary phase cultures revealed a 6-fold increase in the fraction of visibly budded cells that were dying compared to cells that did not have visible buds (Figure (Figure4A).4A). This is substantially larger than the ~2-fold increase in budded compared to unbudded cells that stain with PI in 2% glucose SC cultures (Figure S1).
Furthermore, at day 2 of medium depletion, cells in 10% glucose SC cultures were more frequently undergoing apoptosis compared to cells in 2% glucose SC indicated by increased apoptotic degradation of DNA. In fact almost all the cells in 10% glucose cultures harbored substantially less than the complete G1 complement of DNA required for continued viability (Figure (Figure4B).4B). Electron microscopic visualization of stationary phase cells cultured in 2% glucose YPD medium revealed that some cells exhibited fragmented nuclei indicative of apoptosis as well as an irregular cell shape indicating deterioration of the cell wall structure (Figure 4C and D). This contrasted with the appearance of intact nuclei and cell walls in non-apoptosing cells (Figure (Figure4E).4E). In some cases, disruption of the cell wall structure was detected at specific sites in apoptosing cells (Figure (Figure4D;4D; arrow) that may correspond to the location of a bud that broke off in cells undergoing apoptosis. A decline in numbers of cells in 10% glucose SC stationary phase cultures from day 1 to day 3 measured by counting particles (Figure (Figure4F)4F) confirmed that similar to mammalian cells, budding yeast cells undergoing apoptosis eventually are completely destroyed. We conclude that high glucose reduces the efficiency of G0/G1 arrest in stationary phase and preferentially kills dividing cells, and that the reduced number of cells with visible buds in 10% glucose SC cultures is caused by the specific and rapid apoptotic destruction of cells that failed to arrest growth in G0/G1.
The inverse relationship between levels of O2- and the frequency with which cells arrest in G0/G1 when they enter stationary phase under a variety of experimental conditions (summarized in Table Table2)2) suggests that O2- inhibits G0/G1 arrest. To test this hypothesis, we examined the effects of experimental manipulations that directly alter levels of O2- independently of changes in growth signaling pathways. sod2Δ cells exhibited a significantly shorter CLS (Figure (Figure5A;5A; ) accompanied by increased O2- (Figure (Figure5B)5B) and less efficient G0/G1 arrest (Figure (Figure5C)5C) in stationary phase. Sod2p expression is elevated in sch9Δ cells, and deletion of SOD2 from sch9Δ cells partially suppresses their longevity phenotype (; Figure Figure5D).5D). sch9Δ sod2Δ double mutant cells also exhibited an intermediate level of O2- compared to wild type or sch9Δ cells (Figure (Figure5E)5E) accompanied by a stationary phase G0/G1 arrest that was intermediate between that of wild type and sch9Δ cells (Figure (Figure5F).5F). Thus, a quantitative relationship exists between levels of O2- and frequency of G0/G1 arrest in sod2D, sch9D sod2Δ and wild type cells.
We also asked whether treatment of cells with the antioxidant N-acetylcysteine (NAC) would extend CLS and increase the efficiency of stationary phase G0/G1 arrest in association with reduced levels of superoxide. Surprisingly, NAC shortened CLS in a dose-dependent fashion in wild type, but not sch9Δ cells (Figure (Figure5G).5G). The shorter CLS conferred by NAC in wild type cells occurred in concert with dose-dependent increases rather than decreases in levels of O2- (Figure (Figure5H).5H). Similar pro-oxidant effects of the antioxidants α-tocopherol and coenzyme Q10 were recently reported in budding yeast , and induction of O2- by NAC has been reported in mammalian cells as well . Increased O2- in wild type cells exposed to NAC was accompanied by a parallel dose-dependent increase in the fraction of cells with visible buds (Figure (Figure5I).5I). NAC-induced increases in O2- and frequency of G0/G1 arrest in stationary phase were absent in sch9Δ cells (Figure 5H and I; “sch9Δ”). The absence of NAC effects in sch9Δ cells expressing elevated levels of Sod2p  suggests that in wild type cells, the effects of NAC are related to increased amounts of O2- and not to unrelated toxic effects of this compound. In contrast, cells in which the catalases Cta1p or Ctt1p had been inactivated, which exhibit reduced levels of O2- in stationary phase and a longer CLS , also exhibited fewer visible buds (Figure (Figure5J).5J). Similarly, cells treated with the antioxidant glutathione (GSH) also exhibited fewer visible buds (Figure (Figure5K)5K) in concert with reduced levels of O2- (Figure (Figure5L).5L). We conclude that O2- inhibits growth arrest of stationary phase cells in G0/G1.
Our findings reveal that under a variety of experimental conditions, an inverse relationship exists between budding yeast CLS and intracellular levels of O2- (summarized in Table Table2)2) that points to O2- accumulating downstream of growth signaling as a primary cause of chronological aging. A role for growth signaling-induced O2- in chronological aging is consistent with earlier reports that CR extends CLS in part by downregulating Tor1p-, Ras2p- and Sch9p-dependent growth signaling pathways that inhibit the Rim15p kinase and its induction of oxidative stress defenses (; Figure Figure6).6). Our findings also indicate that the Rim15p-independent extension of CLS by CR reported earlier  is related to the induction of H2O2 that reduces O2- (Figure (Figure1G)1G) by activating SODs  independently of Rim15p (Figure (Figure66).
Burtner et al.  recently proposed that the primary cause of chronological aging in budding yeast is toxic effects of acetic acid that are not caused by oxidative stress, and that inactivation of Sch9 or Ras2 protect against acetic acid toxicity through unknown mechanisms rather than reduced growth signaling. Our data are consistent with a role for acetic acid toxicity as a determinant of CLS in 2% glucose medium. However, acetic acid causes O2- to accumulate in stationary phase cells, because buffering SC medium to a higher pH, which extends CLS, reduces levels of O2- . O2- levels are similarly reduced in cells in YPD (Figure S3), which in addition to maintaining a higher medium pH (Table (Table1)1) exhibit a longer CLS (Figure (Figure3;3; ). O2- accumulating in stationary phase cells is toxic, because experimental manipulations that directly elevate O2- levels (inactivation of Sod2p or exposure to NAC) shorten CLS (Figure (Figure55).
Acetic acid  and/or intracellular acidification  induce the same TOR- and RAS-dependent growth signaling pathways induced by glucose, and the induction of O2- by acetic acid is likely a consequence of acetic acid-induced growth signaling. A role for RAS-dependent growth signaling in acetic acid toxicity is consistent with an earlier report that the enhanced stationary phase viability of ras1Δ and/or ras2Δ cells cultured in SC medium is absent in YPD cultures or in SC cultures buffered to a higher pH . Our finding that CLS extension in sch9Δ compared to wild type cells cultured in 2% glucose SC (Figure (Figure1B;1B; ) is similarly absent when these cells are cultured in 2% glucose YPD, (Figure (Figure3F),3F), which also maintains a higher pH, suggests that acetic acid also triggers Sch9p-dependent growth signaling pathways. Therefore, the protective effects against acetic acid toxicity in unbuffered 2% glucose medium associated with inactivating Ras1p, Ras2p and Sch9p are likely due to downregulation of growth signaling by acetic acid and consequent upregulation of SODs and other oxidative stress defenses by Rim15p (Figure (Figure66).
Burtner et al. also proposed that the effects of acetic acid on CLS are specific for this form of acid . However, deletion of RAS1 and RAS2 also protects against acid stress induced by hydrochloric acid . Furthermore, Ras2p-dependent growth signaling is triggered by the acidifying protonophore 2,4-dinitrophenol . Low pH also induces AKT activity in human cells [44,45], and as we noted earlier , growth signaling by low pH that depends on RAS, AKT and other oncogenes underlies a number of pathological states in humans, including cancer. Thus, acetic acid toxicity in budding yeast corresponds to a conserved mitogen-like response to low pH, and not just acetic acid, that mimics the sustained activation of oncogenes in complex eukaryotes.
In mammalian cell cultures, high levels of glucose that mimic the effects of hyperglycemia induce DNA damage, AKT-dependent growth signaling, increased O2- and senescence [31,34,35,46]. Each of these effects has been implicated in aging and age-related diseases linked to hyperglycemia and/or excess calorie intake, including cancer, diabetes and cardiovascular disease. High glucose also promotes aging in C. elegans in association with increased O2- . The induction of elevated O2- and a shorter CLS by glucose signaling has been implicated in aging in the fission yeast S. pombe as well . The increased levels of O2- (Figure 3C and G) and shorter CLS (Figure 3A and F) induced by 10% glucose in either SC or YPD medium establish budding yeast as an additional model for investigating the effects of elevated glucose on aging and age-related diseases. These effects are mediated in part by Sch9p-dependent signaling by glucose because in 10% glucose YPD cultures, sch9Δ cells exhibit a longer CLS and less O2- compared to wild type cells (Figure (Figure3)3) in the absence of changes in pH compared to 2% glucose YPD cultures.
Changes in levels of acetic acid also do not play a role in the CLS-extending effects of increased H2O2 induced by CR . The longer CLS in 2% compared to 10% glucose SC or YPD cultures in the absence of a change in medium pH reveals an additional mechanism by which CR extends CLS in budding yeast related to reduced growth signaling by glucose rather than acetic acid. CR is most often defined in yeast experiments as a decrease in the glucose content of medium below 2%. However, in their natural environment yeasts are likely exposed to higher concentrations of glucose and other sugars that trigger growth signaling. For example, the glucose and fructose content of grapes can exceed 13%  and the sugar content of overripe plantains approaches 27% . Thus, culturing cells in 2% compared to 10% glucose medium can be considered a physiologically relevant form of CR that depends on reduced growth signaling by glucose rather than acetic acid. This form of CR is broadly relevant to CR in complex eukaryotes.
The longstanding free radical theory of aging predicts that the pro-aging effects of O2- are caused by oxidative damage to macromolecules. However, the reduced levels of O2- and extended CLS produced by inactivation of catalases are accompanied by increased, rather than decreased oxidative damage . Conversely, the shorter CLS detected in sod2Δ and other cells harboring defective oxidative stress defenses is not accompanied by general increases in oxidative damage to macromolecules [50,51] A similar disconnect between oxidative damage and longevity is observed in naked mole rats, which exhibit a ~10-fold longer lifespan compared to mice despite the presence of high levels of oxidative damage . This suggests that the pro-aging effects of oxidative stress are not always a direct consequence of oxidative damage.
The inverse relationship between CLS and levels of O2- we detected under a variety of experimental conditions is accompanied by a similar inverse relationship between levels of O2- and frequency of G0/G1 arrest in stationary phase (Table (Table2).2). This points to an alternative, but not mutually exclusive possibility - that the age-promoting effects of O2- are related in part to inhibition by O2- of growth arrest of stationary phase cells in G0/G1, leading to more frequent growth arrest in S phase instead, where cells suffer replication stress. The inhibitory effects on G0/G1 arrest in stationary phase of experimental manipulations that more directly impact levels of O2- compared to alterations in growth signaling pathways (Figure (Figure5)5) are consistent with this model.
Based on measurements of the fraction of stationary phase cells with visible buds, Madia et al. proposed that the effects on chronological aging related to replication stress are minor compared to other pro-aging factors . In fact, the magnitude of inhibitory effects on G0/G1 arrest in stationary phase related to O2- is larger than suggested by counting cells with visible buds in stationary phase, for several reasons. First, cells die in stationary phase cultures via an apoptosis-like mechanism (; Figure 4B-D) that eventually destroys cells (Figure (Figure4F).4F). The preferential death of cells that failed to arrest in G0/G1 (Figures. S1 and and4A)4A) leads to underestimates of the fraction of these cells. Second, our data suggest that as the budding yeast cell wall deteriorates during apoptosis, buds break off of mother cells (Figure (Figure4D),4D), which would lead to additional underestimates of the fraction of cells with visible buds. Third, cells in early S phase with small buds are difficult to distinguish microscopically from unbudded cells that have truly arrested in G0/G1. Consequently, at least some of the dying cells that do not have visible buds in stationary phase in our experiments have not arrested in G0/G1.
According to a recent study, treatment of cells with low levels of hydroxyurea, which inhibits a protein essential for DNA replication (ribonucleotide reductase) shortens CLS by 20 - 27% . Furthermore, increased apoptosis of stationary phase cells harboring a mutation in the replication stress protein Mec1 is suppressed by ectopic expression of the RNR1 gene encoding ribonucleotide reductase . Therefore, in principle, replication stress caused by reduced dNTP pools can substantially shorten CLS. Replication stress as a determinant of CLS is consistent with the observation that stationary phase cells that fail to arrest in G0/G1 die faster than unbudded cells (Figures S1;). The rate at which dividing cells die in stationary phase is accelerated further when growth signaling and levels of O2- are enhanced by high glucose (Figure (Figure4A),4A), which also triggers DNA damage responses (Figure (Figure3B).3B). These findings suggest that the toxic effects of O2- in stationary phase cells are caused in part by DNA damage specifically in cells that failed to growth arrest in G0/G1.
A role for replication stress in chronological aging is also consistent with an earlier report by Allen et al. that non-quiescent stationary phase cells separated from denser quiescent cells by density gradients more frequently undergo apoptosis and exhibit elevated expression of genes encoding proteins that respond to replication stress . It is not consistent with the results of a recent genetic screen that identified budding yeast deletion mutants that exhibit an extended CLS in the absence of more frequent stationary phase growth arrest in G0/G1 . However, this screen also failed to identify the numerous deletion strains with inactivated growth signaling pathways, including sch9Δ, that were previously reported to have an extended CLS. In fact, in this recently published study, ras2Δ cells that earlier studies indicated are long-lived in the CLS model exhibited a substantially shorter CLS compared to wild type cells.
Replication stress as a determinant of CLS also is not consistent with the recent claim by Madia et al.  that the denser fraction of stationary phase cells, which according to Allen et al.  are quiescent and exhibit fewer signs of genome instability-promoting replication stress, paradoxically exhibit an elevated mutation frequency compared to “non-quiescent” cells . We note that the experiments of Allen et al. employed YPD medium, which prolongs CLS compared to CLS in SC medium (Figure (Figure3;3; ) and maintains a fraction of quiescent cells exhibiting a higher density for weeks . In contrast, Madia et al. employed SC medium in their experiments. Close inspection of the data in Figure Figure22 of Madia et al. indicates that although a denser fraction of cells initially accumulated at day 1 of stationary phase in their experiments, unlike the experiments of Allen et al., this fraction declined and the fraction of less dense non-quiescent cells increased during the next several days of stationary phase. Furthermore, the number of stationary phase cells in S phase increased during this same period of time (Madia et al., Figure S1A). Although the fraction of budded cells in both “quiescent” and “non-quiescent fractions continues to decline with increasing time in stationary phase despite an overall increase in cells in S phase, this likely reflects the specific apoptotic destruction of budded cells. In fact, flow cytometry measurements by Madia et al. of the DNA content of “quiescent” and “non-quiescent” wild type cells clearly indicate that at the three and five day stationary phase time points they employed to measure mutation frequency in their experiments, most of the wild type cells they defined as “quiescent” that exhibited a higher mutation frequency also harbored significantly more DNA compared to “non-quiescent” wild type cells, and thus were more frequently in S phase (Figure S1B of Madia et al.; compare “Lower Fraction” (quiescent) histograms with “Upper Fraction” (non-quiescent) histograms at each time point). Thus, in contrast to the experiments of Allen et al., the initially denser cells Madia et al. refer to as “quiescent” do not remain quiescent for more than a few days, most likely due to increased growth signaling by the larger amounts of acetic acid accumulating in SC medium compared to the YPD medium employed in the experiments of Allen et al. In the absence of nutrients required for efficient DNA replication in stationary phase cultures, entry of these cells into S phase is a recipe for replication stress and mutations.
The induction of insulin/IGF-1-like growth signaling pathways that depend on RAS, AKT, mTOR and other oncogenic proteins has been implicated in aging and a number of age-related diseases in humans, including many for which hyperglycemia and/or excess calorie intact are risk factors. In addition to elevated levels of ROS, DNA replication stress has been implicated in some of these diseases as well. For example, sustained oncogenic signaling that leads to growth arrest in S phase has been implicated in the senescent state of preneoplastic cells . Similarly, inappropriate activation of growth signaling pathways in tauopathies and other neurodegenerative disorders promotes unscheduled entry of postmitotic neurons into S phase , where these cells also likely undergo replication stress. Thus, as in budding yeast, growth signaling may impact aging in more complex organisms, including humans, by inducing replication stress, in addition to oxidative stress.
As in budding yeast, replication stress in mammalian cells may be related to O2- inhibition of quiescence. Consistent with this possibility, MnSOD-defective mouse cells driven into a non-dividing state by contact inhibition exhibit elevated levels of O2-, a higher fraction of S phase cells and increased apoptosis . Furthermore, O2-induced by hyperglycemia  or by a metabolite of polychlorinated biphenyls that cause cancer  inhibit DNA replication. These findings have important implications for understanding aging and age-related diseases. For example, although DNA replication stress now is generally accepted as a factor that contributes to tumorigenesis downstream of oncogene activation, it is not considered to be an initiating event . However, high glucose inhibits progression of endothelial cells through S phase , and as in our yeast experiments, also induces DNA damage in human mesothelial cells . It is possible, therefore, that hyperglycemia and other factors can initiate tumorigenesis by inducing replication stress that leads to mutational activation of oncogenes.
This model does not explain all facets of aging, which is multifactorial and exceedingly complex. A compelling argument can be made, for example, that autophagy is in an important component of lifespan regulation in all eukaryotes . Even here, however, our model may be relevant - in budding yeast, CLS extension by spermidine, which activates autophagy, is accompanied by reduced levels of O2- and more frequent arrest of stationary phase cells in G0/G1 . Overall, our results provide a framework for investigating the role of growth signaling and oxidative stress in aging that accommodates recent evidence pointing to pro-aging factors other than oxidative damage. They also suggest a novel mechanism by which normal aging can be impacted by diet and other environmental factors.
Strains employed in these studies are listed in Table S1. To assess CLS 50 ml cultures were inoculated with 1% (v/v) of a fresh overnight culture in either SC or YPD. SC was supplemented as described . In experiments that employed media that initially contained 10% glucose, control 2% glucose cultures also contained 8% sorbitol to maintain equivalent osmolarity. Deter-mination of chronological life span, fraction of budded cells, flow cytometry measurements of DNA content and measurements of dihydroethidium (DHE) and dihydrorhodamine 123 (DHR) were as described previously [8,13]. N-acetylcysteine (NAC) and glutathione (GSH) were dissolved in growth medium, filter sterilized and added to cultures from 100mM (NAC) or 250mM (GSH) stocks at the start of experiments. Propidium iodide (PI) was used to assess viability of cells by mixing a 2μl of cells with an equal volume of 1mM PI on a microscope slide and examining the slide with a fluorescence microscope equipped with a Texas Red filter. Non-fluorescent cells were scored as intact (live) and fluorescent cells were scored as dead. The total number of cells in cultures was determined by particle counts using a Petroff Hauser counting chamber.
Samples for transmission electron microscopy were prepared according to . Briefly, cells cultured at 30°C in YPD medium for 3 to 5 days were harvested by gentle centrifugation, washed in phosphate buffered saline (PBS) (pH=7.2), resuspended in 2.5%(v/v) glutaraldehyde in PBS and fixed for 40 min at room temperature. Cells were further fixed by 2% freshly prepared potassium permanganate in water for 1 hour at room temperature. Fixed cells were dehydrated with 30%, 50%, 75%, 85%, 95%, and 100% ethanol. Cells were transitioned with propylene oxide, infiltrated in Spurr resin (Electron Microscopy Sciences, PA). Resin was polymerized at 65°C overnight in the oven. 60 nm ultrathin sections were cut with a diamond knife, stained with 2% uranyl acetate and lead citrate and examined using a Hitachi H-7000 electron microscope, equipped with a 4K × 4K cooled CCD digital camera (Gatan, Inc., CA).
Values presented in graphs that contain error bars represent means and standard deviations from three or more independent experiments. Other results are representative of at least three independent experiments. Statistical analyses were performed using Student's t-test. P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Identification of dead or dying cells in stationary phase by staining with the membraneimpermeable dye propidium iodide.
Effect of inactivation of TOR1 and/or caloric restriction on CLS (A), levels of superoxide anions detected by DHE (B) and fraction of cells that fail to arrest in G0/G0 stationary phase (C).
Inactivation of Sic1 inhibits growth arrest of stationary phase in in G0/G1 in the CEN.PK background.
This research was supported by a National Cancer Institute Cancer Center Support Grant (P30 CA016056) to Roswell Park Cancer Institute and a fellowship to A.M. from Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia (SFRH/BD/32464/2006). We are grateful to Molly Burhans for preparation of Figure Figure66.
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.