The inverse relationship between HDL-cholesterol (HDL-C) and cardiovascular (CV) disease risk (
1) suggests that increasing HDL-C could potentially reduce CV risk (
2). This has been postulated to be related to the multiple CV benefits of HDL and, perhaps most importantly, the efflux of cholesterol from peripheral tissue. A variety of agents have been developed that increase HDL-C, including niacin and fibrates, and more recently, agents that decrease cholesteryl ester transfer protein (CETP) activity and are generically referred to as CETP inhibitors.
CETP inhibitors from two different chemical classes have been developed and have reached late clinical development. The first class are potent CETP inhibitors, which are 3,5-bis-trifluoromethyl-benzene derivatives such as torcetrapib (
3) and anacetrapib (
4) that have been shown to raise plasma HDL-C by up to 130% in humans (
4). The Phase III mortality/morbidity study of torcetrapib was terminated prematurely due to increased CV and non-CV deaths and events, most likely due to off-target effects (
5) unrelated to CETP inhibition (
6–
8); anacetrapib is currently undergoing Phase II/III investigations. The second chemical class represented by dalcetrapib (JTT-705/R1658/RO4607381), are benzenethiol derivatives (
9–
11). Dalcetrapib, which raises HDL-C by up to 36% in humans at a dose of 600 mg (
12), is currently being evaluated in a Phase III outcomes study (
13).
In addition to differences in potency, the mechanism of CETP inhibition by compounds derived from these two chemical classes is also likely to be different. The binding of torcetrapib to CETP increases its affinity for lipoproteins and induces the formation of an inactive high-affinity complex between CETP and lipoproteins such as HDL (
14). The CETP-lipoprotein complex, similar to the one induced by the CETP-inhibitory antibody TP2 (
15), cannot efficiently exchange neutral lipids between different lipoprotein particles. Although the exact mechanism by which dalcetrapib decreases CETP activity has not been elucidated, the mode of action has been suggested to involve the direct specific interaction between cysteine 13 (Cys13) of CETP and the benzenethiol moiety of dalcetrapib (
9). The thioester bond of dalcetrapib is cleaved by nonspecific esterases in the gastrointestinal tract and in plasma, generating reactive dalcetrapib-thiol and allowing formation of a disulfide bond with Cys13 (
9).
Qiu et al. (
16) suggested that CETP adopts a new conformation to enable binding to lipoproteins of larger size than HDL, such as VLDL. We therefore investigated potential differences in changes in CETP conformation induced by dalcetrapib or torcetrapib using monoclonal antibodies against CETP.
The significance of the different modes of interaction of various CETP inhibitors and the relative impact of decreased CETP activity on lipoprotein metabolism have not been compared previously. Synthetic CETP inhibitors were optimized for the inhibition of neutral lipid transfer between HDL and apolipoprotein B (apoB)-containing lipoproteins (heterotypic transfer), but their effect on transfer of cholesteryl ester (CE) among HDL subparticles (homotypic transfer) and CETP-dependent HDL remodeling have not been studied. CETP facilitates the extensive remodeling of plasma HDL particles by promoting the interconversion of apoA-I-containing α-HDL to small, lipid-poor, pre-β-HDL (
17,
18) and transfering CE among HDL subparticles (
19,
20). This dynamic remodeling of HDL is a key aspect of its function in reverse cholesterol transport (RCT), leading to the removal of excess cholesterol from tissue and its delivery to the liver (
21). CETP has been shown to impact these two processes by generating small lipid-poor pre-β-HDL particles, which are preferred acceptors of ABCA1-dependent cholesterol efflux (
22), and to facilitate HDL-CE uptake via the scavenger receptor class B type I (SR-BI) pathway (
23). In addition, CE transferred by CETP from HDL to LDL and subsequent uptake via the LDL receptor (LDLR) might be an important aspect of RCT (
24). Thus, the observation that CETP mediates HDL remodeling and cholesterol clearance via the LDLR raised concern that inhibition of CETP activity may adversely impact cholesterol efflux capacity and RCT (
21).
Indeed, torcetrapib treatment was not associated with an increase in fecal sterol excretion in clinical studies (
25), supporting the need for a relevant animal model to investigate the effects of compounds affecting CETP activity on macrophage RCT. A macrophage RCT model has been extensively characterized (albeit in mice naturally deficient in CETP) and confirmed as a valid model for assessing promotion of RCT (
26). In a recent study where torcetrapib was tested in a new hamster macrophage model, although treatment was associated with increased excretion of labeled cholesterol in feces, there was no correlation between fecal sterol excretion and torcetrapib dose. This raised the query as to whether marked inhibition of CETP activity was associated with an increase in HDL of normal composition and function (
27).
CETP inhibitors represent a valuable tool for investigating the mechanism by which changes in CETP activity affects HDL metabolism in vitro. We therefore compared the potent CETP inhibitors torcetrapib and anacetrapib with the structurally dissimilar benzenethiol derivative dalcetrapib (
10) in terms of respective modes of interaction with CETP, effect on transfer of CE from HDL to LDL versus from HDL3 to HDL2, binding sites, change in CETP conformation, and effect on CETP-induced formation of pre-β-HDL. In addition, the potential relevance of these differences was evaluated in vivo by assessing changes in macrophage RCT in CETP inhibitor-treated hamsters.