In this large cohort of older men, higher estrone levels were strongly associated with an increased risk of incident prostate cancer. Few studies have explored the role of estrone in prostate cancer pathogenesis because of the difficulty in measuring low circulating levels in men using older assays. Estrone sulfate has been shown to be a prognostic marker for tumor aggressiveness in prostate cancer [
18]. Estrone sulfate is converted to estrone by the enzyme steroid sulfatase (STS). STS is important in the formation, regulation, and conversion of inactive sex steroids into biologically active sex steroids, which are known to stimulate tumor growth in breast cancer, as well as prostate cancers [
19]. Research into STS inhibitors has shown promise, similar to aromatase inhibitors for breast cancer, and these inhibitors may become increasingly important in future prostate cancer management [
20].
Although androgens are known to stimulate prostate cell proliferation, results of previous studies examining increased androgen levels as a risk factor for prostate cancer have been inconclusive. Most of the case-control studies have found no association between sex hormones and prostate cancer [
4–
6]. A meta-analysis in 1998, which systematically reviewed 8 quantitative studies, also found no association between sex hormones and prostate cancer, except for androstanediol-glucoronide (A-diol g) which had an overall odds ratio (OR) of 1.05; 95% CI 1.00–1.11) for all of the studies combined [
7]. However, a more recent meta-analysis, published in 2000, found approximately a 2-fold increased risk of prostate cancer in men with either serum total testosterone and insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) in the upper quartile of the study population [
21]. Furthermore, the most significant recent analyses of this relationship was reported by the Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging (2005), which showed a positive relationship between elevated serum testosterone and an increased risk of prostate cancer [
22]. In a European prospective study of Scandinavian men, high levels of circulating androgens were not associated with an increased prostate cancer risk [
6,
23]. Our study results extend previous findings and are concordant with those from systematic reviews and other published data, which have found no association between endogenous androgens and prostate cancer risk [
5,
7–
8]. From mouse and human studies, including
in vivo and
in vitro studies, it is clear that androgens positively influence prostate gland growth; however, little is unknown how hormone levels interact with each other and whether or how they influence malignant growth in humans [
24]. On the other hand, we also know clinically that androgen deprivation, often used as a form of prostate cancer treatment, can induce prostate cancer remission or retardation.
Our study has several limitations. Our follow-up was approximately 5 years and it is unclear whether extended follow-up would change the association. In the Massachusetts Male Aging Study (MMAS), which had 8 years of follow-up, researchers found no association between sex hormones measured by radioimmunoassay, including estrone, and prostate cancer risk [
5]. Our study, in contrast to the MMAS, had a larger number of prostate cancer (MrOS=275 prostate cancer cases vs. MMAS=70 prostate cancer cases) which may have increased our ability to detect differences between cases and subcohort [
5,
25–
26]. Furthermore, in the MrOS study, we centrally adjudicated all prostate cancer diagnoses, while the MMAS identified prostate cancer cases through the Massachusetts cancer registry, medical records, self-report (confirmed by registry and/or medical records), death certificates, and medical records. We measured hormone levels in a single serum sample at one point in time, with a median of 2.4 years prior to prostate cancer diagnosis. Whether serial measurements of sex hormones over time are a better index of hormone status is unknown. In the Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging study, which evaluated serial hormone level measurements over nearly 40 years (median follow-up of 18.5 years for all study participants), higher levels of calculated serum free testosterone were associated with increased risk of prostate cancer [
22]. Unfortunately, this study used less reliable sex hormone concentration measurements by using mass action equations for estimating free testosterone in serum [
22,
27].
Our study also had several important strengths, including its sample size, volunteer participants from the general community, all study participants were closely followed, all prostate cancer cases were centrally adjudicated, and sex hormones were assayed by gas chromatography combined with mass spectrometry.