|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Two archaeal tRNA methyltransferases belonging to the SPOUT superfamily and displaying unexpected activities are identified. These enzymes are orthologous to the yeast Trm10p methyltransferase, which catalyses the formation of 1-methylguanosine at position 9 of tRNA. In contrast, the Trm10p orthologue from the crenarchaeon Sulfolobus acidocaldarius forms 1-methyladenosine at the same position. Even more surprisingly, the Trm10p orthologue from the euryarchaeon Thermococcus kodakaraensis methylates the N1-atom of either adenosine or guanosine at position 9 in different tRNAs. This is to our knowledge the first example of a tRNA methyltransferase with a broadened nucleoside recognition capability. The evolution of tRNA methyltransferases methylating the N1 atom of a purine residue is discussed.
Cellular RNAs possess numerous chemically modified nucleosides, but the largest number and the greatest variety are found in transfer RNA (tRNA). These modifications are introduced by many different enzymes during the complex process of RNA maturation. The functions of these modified nucleosides are not well known, but it seems that modifications in the anticodon region play a direct role in increasing translational efficiency and fidelity, while modifications outside the anticodon region are typically involved in the maintenance of the structural integrity of tRNA. Among naturally occurring nucleoside modifications, base and ribose methylations are by far the most frequently encountered (1,2). These methylations are catalysed by tRNA methyltransferases (MTases) that use S-adenosyl-l-methionine (AdoMet) as the methyl donor, with a single exception of a recently identified enzyme, which uses a folate as the methyl donor (3).
AdoMet-dependent MTases belong to at least seven evolutionarily and structurally unrelated classes/superfamilies (4–6). Most of the known RNA MTases belong to class I. They possess a fold similar to the Rossmann fold, and are therefore called Rossmann fold MTases (RFM). The structure comprises a seven-stranded β sheet with a central topological switch-point and a characteristic reversed β hairpin at the carboxyl end of the sheet (6↑7↓5↑4↑1↑2↑3↑). This β sheet is flanked by α helices to form an αβα sandwich (4). RFM enzymes are typically monomeric although di-tri- or tetrameric structures have been reported. Class IV MTases, also named the SPOUT class MTases, a nomenclature coming from the first two members of this class, SpoU and TrmD, act also on RNA, but are structurally different from the class I MTases (7). They possess a five-stranded β sheet core (5↑3↑4↑1↑2↑) flanked by seven α helices. The most characteristic feature of these enzymes is the presence of a deep topological knot in the C-terminal part of the sheet. This knot is responsible for AdoMet binding. All known SPOUT MTases are dimers, with the catalytic site formed at the interface of two monomers (8).
There are only a few archaeal tRNA specific MTases functionally characterised to date. Those MTases can be very different in terms of structure, of target or in their mechanism. Some act as base MTases, while others are ribose MTases. Among the MTases acting on ribose, there exist two kinds of methylation pathways. In the first one, called ‘all-protein enzyme’, the MTase recognizes on its own the target nucleoside and catalyses the methyl transfer on the ribose. The second mechanism involves an MTase taking part of a ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complex, in which the recognition of the target nucleoside is carried out by a small guide RNA. In different organisms, the same modification can be accomplished by the two different mechanisms. This is the case of the Cm56 ribose methylation of tRNA in Archaea. In Pyrobaculum aerophilum, this modification is catalysed by a RNP complex, where the small RNA sR35 targets the C56 nucleoside for modification by a protein catalytic subunit, a member of the RFM superfamily (9). This case is an exception in Archaea, because all other archaeal genomes sequenced to date possess a SPOUT MTase homologous to aTrm56 from Pyrococcus abyssi, which catalyses non-guided methylation of C56 (9,10).
The six archaeal RFM MTases characterised to date act on the base of nucleosides. Trm-G10 from P. abyssi methylates or dimethylates guanosine 10 from tRNA to form m2G10 or G10 (11,12). The same modification can be found at position 26 of tRNA and is catalysed by Trm-G26 (also known as Trm1) (13,14). The MTase encoded by the open reading frame (ORF) PAB1947 from P. abyssi acts on several cytosines in tRNA to form m5C, with a preference for C49. The specificity of this MTase for C49 is increased by an archaease (15). Another important tRNA MTase identified in Archaea is Trm5, which methylates G37 in tRNA (16). Guanosine in position 37 is commonly methylated to form m1G37 in tRNA from organisms belonging to the three domains of life, and this modification prevents frame-shifting by assuring correct codon–anticodon pairing (17). The tRNA MTase TrmU54 catalyses the methylation of atom C5 in uridine to form ribothymidine in tRNA from P. abyssi (18). This modification is invariably found at position 54 in the TΨC loop of tRNAs of most organisms. And finally, the MTase TrmI from P. abyssi catalyses the methylation of position N1 of adenosine to form m1A. This enzyme displays region specificity, methylating A58 and A57 from TΨC loop of tRNA, m1A57 being the obligatory intermediate in the biosynthesis of 1-methylinosine (m1I) (19).
Until now, only one tRNA from hyperthermophilic archaea has been fully sequenced, the initiator methionine tRNA from the crenarchaeon Sulfolobus acidocaldarius (20). This tRNA contains 10 modified nucleosides, 9 of them bearing a methylation either on the base or on the ribose, or even both on base and ribose. However, the nature of the modified nucleoside at position 9 is unknown. In yeast, some tRNAs with a guanosine at this position are methylated by the Trm10p MTase, to form m1G9 (21). As a protein distantly related to the yeast enzyme is encoded by the Saci_1677 gene of S. acidocaldarius, it could be a potential candidate for the modification at position 9 of S. acidocaldarius tRN.
In this article, we show that the S. acidocaldarius Saci_1677p enzyme indeed acts at position 9 of tRNA, catalysing m1A formation. Furthermore, in Euryarchaeota, the homologous protein from Thermococcus kodakaraensis also acts at position 9 of tRNA, but catalyses both m1A and m1G formation. To our knowledge, this is the first MTase found to methylate the two purine bases at the same position.
Pwo DNA polymerase, T4 DNA ligase, T7 RNA polymerase, and T4 polynucleotide kinase were purchased from Roche. Ribonuclease A was from Fermentas. Genomic DNA from T. kodakaraensis was a gift from H. Grosjean (CNRS, France) and T.J. Santangelo (Ohio State University, USA). Genomic DNA from S. acidocaldarius was a gift from D. Charlier (VUB, Belgium). The S. cerevisiae Trm10-GST clone plasmid (pYCG_YOL93w) and S. cerevisiae Y16243 strain (BY4742; MATα; his3Δ1; leu2Δ0; lys2Δ0; ura3Δ0; yol093w::kanMX4) were purchased from Euroscarf.
The TK0422 ORF was amplified from T. kodakaraensis genomic DNA using Pwo polymerase (Roche) and the primers TKF (5′-CTAGCATATGAAGACCCTCGCAGATG-3′) and TKR (5′-CTAGCTCGAGTCAGCAGTTGTAGCAGAGC-3′) containing the NdeI and XhoI restriction sites, respectively. After cloning the PCR product in pCR-Blunt vector (Zero Blunt®, Invitrogen), the NdeI/XhoI fragment was extracted and cloned in pET-28b expression vector (Novagen), generating the pTK1 plasmid, allowing expression of an N-terminal His-tagged T. kodakaraensis protein in Escherichia coli. The Saci_1677 ORF was amplified from S. acidocaldarius genomic DNA using Pwo polymerase (Roche) and the primers SAF (5′-CTAGCATATGACACTTGCAAAGGTTTTTTCGC-3′) and SAR (5′-CTAGCTCGAGTCAATTTTTTCCCAGTCTAC-3′) containing the NdeI and XhoI restriction sites, respectively. After cloning the PCR product in pJET1.2/blunt cloning vector (CloneJETTM Fermentas), the NdeI/XhoI fragment was extracted and cloned in pET-28b expression vector, generating the pSA1 plasmid, allowing expression of an N-terminal His-tagged S. acidocaldarius protein in E. coli. The TRM10 ORF was amplified from the Trm10-GST clone using Pwo polymerase (Roche) and the primers SCF (5′-CTACATATGTCCAATGATGAGATAAACC-3′) and SCR (5′-CTACTCGAGTGTGTCCTTTGGAGCTGG-3′) containing the NdeI and XhoI restriction sites, respectively. After cloning the pCR product in pJET1.2/blunt cloning vector, the NdeI/XhoI fragment was extracted and cloned in pET-28b expression vector, generating the pSC1 plasmid, allowing expression of an N-terminal His-tagged S. cerevisiae protein in E. coli. The sequences of all clones were checked.
The His-tagged TK0422p, Saci_1677p and Trm10p recombinant proteins were expressed in E. coli strain Rosetta (DE3) (Novagen) carrying extra copies of tRNA genes (argU, argW, ileX, glyT, leuW, proL, metT, thrT, tyrU and thrU) specific for rare E. coli codons, to aid this expression. Freshly transformed cells were grown to an OD660 of 0.5–0.6 at 37°C in 1 l of Luria broth with kanamycin (30 µg/ml). Isopropyl-β-d-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG) (Roche Diagnostics) was then added to a final concentration of 1 mM to induce recombinant protein expression. Cells were harvested after 3 h incubation at 37°C and resuspended in 100 ml of buffer A (Tris–HCl 50 mM pH 8, KCl 500 mM) complemented with protease inhibitors (Complete, EDTA-free protease inhibitor; Roche Diagnostics) prior to cell disruption by sonication. The lysate was cleared by centrifugation (20 000g for 30 min), and was applied to a Chelating-Sepharose fast flow column (GE Healthcare) charged with Ni2+ and equilibrated with buffer A. The column was washed with the same buffer, and the adsorbed material was eluted with a linear gradient (210 ml, from 0 to 1.0 M) of imidazole in buffer A. The fractions containing TK0422p, Saci_1677p and Trm10p were separately pooled. The purified proteins were then submitted to a gel filtration chromatography (Superdex G200; GE Healthcare), leading to almost completely pure TK0422p, Saci_1677p and Trm10p.
The general procedure for generating in vitro transcripts of tRNA genes is based on the method described previously (22). The sequence of the DNA product obtained after amplification of S. acidocaldarius genomic DNA with oligonucleotides MK1 (5′-TCTGCGTAATACGACTC ACTATAGGCGGCGTAGGGAAGCCTGGTATCCC-3′) and MK2 (5′-TCTGCGCTGCAGTGGTGGCGGCGCCTGGATTTGAACCAGGGACCTCAGGGTTA-3′) together with the sequence of this region of the genome in the database revealed differences with that of the sequence (20). The amplification product for in vitro transcription was therefore corrected in respect to the published tRNA sequence (D-loop in the published sequence was ACUGGGAGUA and the corrected sequence is AGCCUGGUA). The sequence coding for S. acidocaldarius was thus PCR amplified using the oligonucleotides MK1 (5′-TCTGCGTAATACGACTCACTATAGGCGGCGTAGGGAAGCCTGGTATCCC-3′) and MK2 (5′-TCTGCGCTGCAGTGGTGGCGGCGCCTGGATTTGAACCAGGGACCTCAGGGTTA-3′) as primers and oligonucleotides MK3 (5′-GGAAGCCTGGTATCCCGCAGGGCTCATAACCCTGAGGTCCCTGGTTC-3′) and MK4 (5′-GAACCAGGGACCTCAGGGTTATGAGCCCTGCGGGATACCAGGCTTCC-3′) as template DNA. The (A9G) was amplified as described for S. acidocaldarius but with oligonucleotide MK1′ (same as MK1 but introducing the A9G mutation) instead of MK1. The sequence coding for T. kodakaraensis tRNAAla was PCR amplified using oligonucleotides MK5 (5′-TCTGGAATTCTAATACG ACTCACTATAGGGCCGGTAGCTCAGCCTGGTAT G-3′) and MK6 (5′-TCTGGAATTCCTGCAGTGGTGGACCGGCCGGGATTTGAACCC-3′) as primers and oligonucleotides MK7 (5′-CAGCCTGGTATGAGCGCCGCCTTGGCAAGGCGGAGGCCCCGGGTTCAAATCC-3′) and MK8 (5′-GGATTTGAACCCGGGGCCTCCGCCTTGCCAAGGCGGCGCTCATACCAGGCTG-3′) as template DNA. T. kodakaraensis tRNAAsp was PCR amplified using oligonucleotides MK9 (5′-TCTGGAATTCTAATACGACTCACTATAGCCCGGGTGGTGTAGCCCGGCCCATC-3′) and MK10 (5′-TCTGGAATTCCCTGGCGCCCGGGCCGGGATTTGAACCCGG-3′) as primers and oligonucleotides MK11 (5′-GTAGCCCGGCCCATCATACGGGACTGTCACTCCCGTGACCCGGGTTCAAATC-3′) and MK12 (5′-GATTTGAACCCGGGTCACGGGAGTGACAGTCCCGTATGATGGGCCGGGCTAC-3′) as template DNA. The DNA sequences encoding and A9G were cloned in the SmaI site of the pUC18 vector, giving plasmids pUC18- and pUC18- A9G. The DNA sequences encoding tRNAAla and tRNAAsp were cloned in the EcoRI site of pUC18, giving plasmids pUC18-tRNAAla and pUC18-tRNAAsp. The sequences of all the clones were checked. These plasmids allow T7 transcription of S. acidocaldarius and (A9G) and T. kodakaraensis tRNAAla and tRNAAsp, respectively. Radioactive (32P) in vitro transcripts were obtained using PstI (for S. acidocaldarius tRNA) or MvaI-digested plasmids (for T. kodakaraensis tRNA). [α32P]ATP and [α32P]GTP were purchased from Perkin Elmer. Radioactive transcripts were purified by 10% polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis.
The two types of tRNA MTase assays used in this work were described in (23). The first method consisted of measuring the amount of 14C transferred to total yeast tRNA (Y16243 strain), or total E. coli tRNA using [methyl-14C]AdoMet as the methyl donor. The reaction mixture (300 µl) consisted of 50 mM Tris–HCl pH 8, 10 mM MgCl2, 100 µg total tRNA, 25 nCi [methyl-14C]AdoMet (50 mCi/mmol; GE Healthcare) and enzyme. The effect of TK0422p concentration on the MTase reaction was carried out using 80 µg total E. coli tRNA, and variable amount of TK0422p (5, 2.5, 1, 0.5 and 0.01 µg). The effect of pH on MTase reaction was measured using 50 µg E. coli tRNA as substrate and 5 µg enzyme. The buffers were: acetate buffer pH 4.8, MES buffer pH 5.5, phosphate buffer pH 7, HEPES buffer pH 7, CHES buffer pH 9 and CAPS buffer pH 9.75. All buffers concentrations were 50 mM. The second type of tRNA MTase assay involved in vitro transcribed, 32P-labelled tRNA as substrates. Modified nucleotides were analysed by 2D thin layer chromatography (2D–TLC) on cellulose plates (Merck). First dimension was with solvent A (isobutyric acid/concentrated NH4OH/water; 66/1/33; v/v/v); second dimension was with solvent B [0.1 M sodium phosphate pH 6.8/solid (NH4)2SO4/n-propanol; 100/60/2; v/w/v)] . The nucleotides were identified using a reference map (24).
Prior to tRNA extraction, the E. coli strain overexpressing TK0422p and the control strain (no expression of TK0422p) were incubated for 2 h at 50°C. Then, total tRNA was extracted. An amount of 200 µg of totally hydrolysed tRNA was injected on a Supelco Discovery C18 (250 × 4.6) mm HPLC column equilibrated with ammonium acetate 0.25 M, pH 6.5. The column was eluted with a linear gradient of acetonitrile/water (40/60; v/v) at a flow rate of 1.2 ml/min. The nucleosides were detected by measuring UV absorbance at 254 nm. The standard HPLC curve was obtained by injecting 20 µl of 1 mM canonical nucleosides together with m1A and m1G modified nucleosides.
The transcript of or (A9G) from S. acidocaldarius was used as substrate for the MTases TK0422p or Saci_1677p. An amount of 2 µg of tRNA was incubated in presence of 4 µg of enzyme and 0.3 mM AdoMet (Sigma) for 1 h at 50°C. As a control, transcripts were incubated in the MTase assay conditions, but without enzyme. Then the reaction was stopped by phenol extraction, transcripts were ethanol precipitated and the pellet was resuspended in 30 µl of RNase A buffer (Tris–Cl 10 mM pH 7.5, 15 mM NaCl). The resuspended solution was heated at 85°C for 5 min and then slowly cooled down to 37°C. Then 10 µg of RNAse A was added and the digestion was carried out for 1 h at 70°C. Half of the RNase A digestion was 5′-end radiolabelled with 50 µCi of [γ32P] ATP and 20 units of T4 polynucleotide kinase. The radiolabelled fragments were then separated by 20 or 30% polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and revealed by autoradiography. The 8-nt long fragments (A9 or G9 at 5′-end), and 5-nt long fragments (control) were identified by their position and their intensities on the autoradiogram, excised from the gel and eluted overnight at 45°C in 200 µl water. Subsequently, they were digested by P1 nuclease and mononucleotides were separated by 2D–TLC as described in the MTase assay. The radiolabelled nucleotides present at the 5′-end of the fragments were revealed by autoradiography.
Searches of the current version of non-redundant sequence database (nr) were carried out using a local version of PSI-BLAST (25) with E-value threshold of 1e – 5, until convergence. This threshold ensured identification of members of the Trm10 family, without paralogous members of other, more distantly related families of the SPOUT superfamily. All sequences were extracted and a multiple sequence alignment was calculated using MUSCLE (26). Structure prediction was carried out via the GeneSilico metaserver (27).
The from S. acidocaldarius is the only tRNA from an hyperthermophilic archaeon sequenced to date (20). It bears an unknown modification at position 9. In yeast, the enzyme Trm10p catalyses m1G formation at this position (21). By iterative Psi-Blast analysis, the authors identified proteins from S. solfataricus and P. furiosus which are distantly related to S. cerevisiae Trm10p. We used these two archaeal sequences as query for a Psi-Blast analysis of archaeal proteomes, and identified the proteins Saci_1677p from S. acidocaldarius (phylum Crenarchaeota) and TK0422p from T. kodakaraensis (phylum Euryarchaeota). These two enzymes are orthologues of S. cerevisiae Trm10p.
Since Saci_1677p and TK0422p are distantly related to S. cerevisiae Trm10p, the activities of these enzymes were tested in vitro using unfractionated (bulk) tRNA from the S. cerevisiae Y16243 strain (in which the TRM10 gene is inactivated) as substrate. The purified recombinant proteins (see ‘Materials and Methods’ section) were incubated at 30°C for the yeast enzyme, and at 50°C for the archaeal enzymes for an hour with [methyl-14C]AdoMet and tRNA. The choice of a reaction temperature of 50°C was based on a compromise between hyperthermophilic enzyme activity and mesophilic tRNA stability. After incubation, the tRNA was recovered by phenol extraction and ethanol precipitation and further completely hydrolysed into 5′-phosphate nucleosides by nuclease P1. The resulting hydrolysates were then analysed by 2D–TLC followed by autoradiography. The results presented in Figure 1 confirm that S. cerevisiae Trm10p catalyses formation of one single radioactive compound with migration characteristics identical to 1-methylguanosine (m1G) 5′-phosphate according to reference maps (24). Interestingly, the S. acidocaldarius enzyme catalyses the formation of one single radioactive compound, but it corresponds to 1-methyladenosine (m1A) 5′-phosphate. Surprisingly, the T. kodakaraensis TK0422p enzyme catalyses formation of two radioactive compounds, m1A and m1G in tRNA. The enzyme TK0422p forms approximately the same amount of m1A and m1G when the tRNA of the yeast strain Y16243 is used as substrate. Given that occurrence of A9 and G9 in this tRNA population is almost equal (~50% each) this result indicates that the enzyme TK0422p does not show any preference for one of these two nucleosides.
To further confirm the activities of the archaeal enzymes, the MTase activity assay was carried out as described above on unfractionated E. coli tRNA. The rationale behind using bulk E. coli tRNA arises from the fact that position 9 of E. coli tRNA is never modified. The results shown in Figure 2 confirm those obtained using tRNA from the yeast Y16243 (trm10::kan) strain. Indeed, the Saci_1677p from S. acidocaldarius catalyses the formation of m1A, while the TK0422p from T. kodakaraensis catalyses the formation of two radioactive compounds, m1A and m1G. The ratio m1A/m1G is higher than what we observed using tRNA from the yeast Y16243 strain. This is consistent with the fact that there are about two times more tRNAs with A9 than with G9 in E. coli. Again, this confirms the absence of preference of TK0422p for one of these two nucleosides. To our knowledge this is the first description of a tRNA MTase with a broadened substrate recognition capability.
The activity of Saci_1677p from S. acidocaldarius was confirmed under identical experimental conditions as above, but using [α32P]ATP-labelled tRNA substrates obtained after in vitro transcription by T7 RNA polymerase of synthetic S. acidocaldarius gene or A9G gene. After incubation, the formation of N1-methyladenosine was analysed as above, and the 32P phosphate is only present in AMP (5′P) and AMP (5′P) derivatives. Figure 3 demonstrates unambiguously the presence of m1A in the WT from S. acidocaldarius, showing that the enzyme is indeed a tRNA m1A MTase. Interestingly, no m1A was formed in a mutant of the where position 9 is occupied by a guanosine ( A9G), suggesting that S. acidocaldarius Saci_1677p acts at position 9 of tRNA, as its yeast orthologue does. Quantification of the relative amount of 32P in the different radioactive spots on TLC plates revealed that about 1 mole of m1A was formed per mole of tRNA after 1 h incubation at 50°C.
Similarly, the activity of T. kodakaraensis TK0422p was also confirmed using in vitro [α32P]ATP- and [α32P]GTP-labelled transcripts of T. kodakaraensis tRNAAla and tRNAAsp genes. The tRNAAla contains an adenosine at position 9, while tRNAAsp contains a guanosine at this position. Figure 4 shows that TK0422p catalyses formation of m1A in the [α32P]ATP-tRNAAla (A in position 9), but not in the [α32P]ATP-tRNAAsp that possesses G in position 9. Similarly, there was only formation of m1G in the GTP-labelled tRNAAsp (G9), but not in the tRNAAla (A9). Quantification of the relative amount of 32P in the different radioactive spots on TLC plates revealed that about 1 mol of m1A or 1 mol of m1G was formed per mole of tRNA after 1 h incubation at 50°C. Taken together, these results confirm that TK0422p is capable of methylating the two purine bases, and they suggest that the T. kodakaraensis enzyme acts also at position 9 of tRNA.
The MTase Trm10p from S. cerevisiae modifies guanosine at position 9 of tRNA (21). The results described above suggest that the archaeal enzymes also target this position. To precisely identify the localisation of nucleosides methylated by the archaeal enzymes, modified and unmodified S. acidocaldarius or S. acidocaldarius A9G were digested by RNase A and the products of this reaction were 32P-labelled at the 5′ extremity (see ‘Materials and Methods’ section). The resulting 8-nt long fragments bearing A9 or G9, and 5-nt long fragments (controls) were hydrolysed by nuclease P1 and the 5′-phosphate mononucleosides were separated by 2D–TLC. The nature of the nucleotide present at the 5′-end of each fragment was revealed by autoradiography. Figure 5 shows that m1A or m1G is only present at the 5′-end of the 8-nt long fragment from the modified transcript, confirming that both archaeal enzymes act at position 9 of tRNA. Furthermore, it underlines the dual tRNA m1A9-m1G9 specificity of the T. kodakaraensis TK0422p.
To determine whether the formation of m1A and m1G resulted from the use of a too high enzyme/tRNA ratio, various concentrations of the enzyme were incubated with the same amount of E. coli tRNA and [methyl-14C]AdoMet (see ‘Materials and Methods’ section). Both m1A and m1G are formed in E. coli tRNA incubated in presence of TK0422p, and the intensity of the spots are related to the concentration of TK0422p. Furthermore, the ratio between m1A and m1G is conserved throughout the dilutions (results not shown).
Interestingly, T. kodakaraensis TK0422p methylates atom N1 of both adenosine and guanosine, whose protonation states are different at physiological pH. Indeed, position N1 of adenosine is unprotonated at physiological pH, whereas position N1 of guanosine is protonated. To get some insight into the catalysis by TK0422p, influence of the pH on the methylation reaction was analysed (Table 1). At pH 4.8, the T. kodakaraensis TK0422p is not active. The MTase is active in a pH range going from pH 5.5 to 9.75, but the intensity of m1A and m1G spots vary greatly as a function of the pH. At pH 5.5, m1A MTase activity of TK0422p is predominant over m1G. At pH 7 or higher, both m1A and m1G were detected, m1G intensity growing with increasing pH.
To get some insight into the in vivo activity of T. kodakaraensis TK0422p, total tRNA was extracted from the E. coli strains expressing or not TK0422p. The tRNA preparations were then hydrolysed by P1 nuclease, snake venom phosphodiesterase and alkaline phosphatase and the resulting mononucleosides were analysed by HPLC (Figure 6). As E. coli does not naturally possess any tRNA (m1A) MTase, no m1A could be detected in tRNA from the control strain. On the other hand, a small amount of m1G could be detected, consistent with the presence of a tRNA m1G37 activity in E. coli. When we then analysed the HPLC profile of the tRNA from the recombinant strain overexpressing TK0422p, m1A could clearly be identified (Figure 6), and more m1G was present in this tRNA preparation compared to the control strain. This result shows that TK0422p can act as a tRNA m1A and m1G MTase in E. coli.
In this work, we have identified and characterised two archaeal orthologues of Trm10p from S. cerevisiae. We have shown that the protein Saci_1677p from the crenarchaeon S. acidocaldarius catalyses N1 methylation of an adenosine to form m1A at position 9 of tRNA. Our data also show that Saci_1677p is specific for A9 of tRNA substrates. Interestingly, we have shown that the orthologous protein TK0422p from the euryarchaeon T. kodakaraensis catalyses both m1A and m1G formation in tRNA. We have demonstrated that both m1A and m1G are formed at position 9 of tRNA. To our knowledge, this is the first description of an MTase with a broadened nucleoside recognition capability. It is interesting to point out that the protonation state of position N1 of both adenosine and guanosine differs at physiological pH. Indeed, the N1 atom of adenosine is not protonated at this pH, while the same position of guanosine bears a proton. This difference of protonation state raises questions about the enzymatic mechanism of TK0422p. In this article, we have shown that the pH of the methylation reaction has an influence on the efficacy of m1A or m1G formation. Indeed, the relative efficiency of m1G formation by TK0422p increases with increasing pH, especially at pH values above 9.5 which corresponds to the pKa of N1 of G (28). This could reflect the need of this enzyme to deprotonate G to be able to catalyse the methyl transfer, although other possibilities are not excluded, such as an influence of pH on tRNA or enzyme structure.
Figure 7 illustrates sequence conservation between Trm10p from yeast and the two archaeal proteins analysed in this work. According to structure prediction methods, the catalytic core of the SPOUT domain spans residues 100–260 of TK0422p (and the corresponding positions in the homologous sequences), and includes five β-strands and six α-helices. The N-terminus is conserved only between the archaeal proteins, but not with the eukaryotic protein. Due to uncertain alignments with known SPOUT structures we were unable to generate a confident 3D model of the catalytic domain, nonetheless the mapping of clusters of conserved residues on predicted secondary structures suggests that the active site is composed of nearly invariant (on the level of the whole family) residues D104, Q122 and D206 (numbering for TK0422p). Interestingly, there appears to be no equivalent catalytic residues between the Trm10p family and the bacterial TrmD family of m1G MTases, also members of the SPOUT superfamily that act on the position G37 in tRNA (29). This suggests that the N1 purine methylation activity has evolved independently at least two times in the SPOUT superfamily. Independent origin of the N1 purine methylation activity has been also postulated for MTases of the RFM superfamily, i.e. tRNA:m1A58 MTase TrmI, tRNA:m1A22 MTase TrmK, and 16S rRNA:m1A1408 MTase KamB, which also present different active sites despite the common fold of the catalytic domain (30,31). This variety of protein folds and active sites available to carry out the same type of reaction suggests that N1 purine methylation is probably relatively easy for an enzyme to evolve (e.g. from an MTase of a different specificity).
Unfortunately, we were unable to identify a negatively charged residue conserved between TK0422p (m1G and m1A MTase) and Trm10p (m1G MTase) but absent from Saci_1677p (m1A MTase) that could explain the inability of the latter protein to deprotonate and methylate guanosine. Therefore, the molecular basis of the different specificities in the Trm10p family remains a mystery. This problem may be approached in the future by experimental determination of a high-resolution structure for one of the family members, characterisation of specificities of numerous additional members of the family, or by mutagenesis of individual members. In particular the availability of a crystal structure for a Trm10p family member would enable its comparison with the known structures of evolutionarily related TrmD MTases and would help to evaluate the hypothesis of convergent evolution of their active sites for an analogous reaction, upon homologous protein scaffold.
Interestingly, the distribution of Trm10p orthologues in Archaea is restricted to hyperthermophiles. We found single representatives of this family in Crenarchaeota (S. acidocaldarius, S. tokodaii, S. solfataricus, S. islandicus, Hyperthermus butylicus, Ignicoccus hospitalis, Aeropyrum pernix, Pyrobaculum aerophilum, P. arsenaticum, P. calidifontis, P. islandicum, Thermoproteus neutrophilus, Caldivirga maquilingensis, Metallosphaera sedula) and in Euryarchaeota (T. kodakaraensis, T. gammatolerans, T. onnurineus, T. barophilus, T. sibiricus, T. sp. AM4, Archaeoglobus fulgidus, Methanopyrus kandleri, Pyrococcus furiosus, P. abyssi and P. horikoshii), as well as in Nanoarchaeum equitans. On the other hand, Trm10p is absent from the mesophilic archaeon Halobacterium volcanii, which is known to lack m1A or m1G at position 9 (32). This suggests that m1G or m1A modification may contribute to the thermostability of archaeal tRNAs.
A stabilizing function of base methylation has been recently identified for the m7G46 modification in a thermophilic bacterium T. thermophilus (33). In tRNA crystal structures the base A9 is stacked between bases 45 and 46. Modelling of the S. acidocaldarius tRNA with and without modifications (data not shown) suggests that the methyl group of m7G46 would be located only about 5–6 Å from the methyl group of m1A9. However, G46 is not methylated in Archaea due to the absence of the TrmB family MTase responsible for this activity in Bacteria and Eukaryota (34). The methyl group on residue A9 may fill a cavity between bases 45 and 46 and the backbone of residue 22. This could increase the surface of interaction between this residue and G46, which may contribute to the increased stability of the tRNA molecule. Furthermore, the positive charge on m1A may have a stabilisatory function due to electrostatic interactions with the neighbouring phosphate groups of residues 22 and 23. Thus, it is tempting to speculate that m1A9 may fulfil a similar stabilisatory role in thermophilic Archaea as m7G46 does in thermophilic bacteria.
Fonds pour le Recherche Fondamentale Collective [grant number 2.4.520.05F] and by the Fonds D. et A. Van Buuren; Fonds pour la Formation à la Recherche dans l’Industrie et dans l’Agriculture fellowship (to M.K.); EURASNET Network of Excellence grant in the 6th Framework Program of the European Commission and by the Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education [grant number 301 2396 33] (to J.M.B.); Polish Ministry of Science and Higher Education [grant number 301 105 32/3599] and by the START fellowship from the Foundation for Polish Science (to K.L.T.). Funding for open access charge: Fonds pour la Recherche Fondamentale Collective.
Conflict of interest statement. None declared.
The authors warmly acknowledge D. Gigot (ULB, Belgium) for help and advice during protein purifications and HPLC analyses. We are grateful to D. Charlier (VUB, Belgium), H. Grosjean (CNRS, France) and T.J. Santangelo (Ohio State University, USA) for the gift of archaeal genomic DNAs. J.M.B. thanks Tomasz Puton (Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznan, Poland) and Irina Tuszynska (IIMCB, Warsaw, Poland) for their help with tRNA modelling and structural analysis.