Secoisolariciresinol diglycoside (SDG) is a polyphenolic plant lignan which when administered orally is hydrolyzed to secoisolariciresinol (SECO) and further metabolized by intestinal bacteria to the biologically active mammalian lignans, enterodiol (END) and enterolactone (ENL) [
1–
4]. In a high estrogen environment these lignans act as partial estrogen antagonists in a tissue specific manner [
5–
9]. SDG is found in highest concentration in flaxseed but is also present in other oil rich seeds, nuts, whole grains, legumes, and certain fruits, and vegetables [
1,
10,
11]. The typical western diet provides < 10 mg/day of lignans [
11,
12,
13]., Administration of flaxseed or SDG is associated with reduced ER- and ER+ mammary cancers in preclinical studies [
14–
17].
Some human studies show an inverse correlation between lignan intake or blood levels and breast cancer incidence, but others do not [
18–
32]. This inconsistency is not surprising given the inherent limitations of dietary recall, early use of intake questionnaires with incomplete validation for lignans, variation in lignan metabolism, single point blood collections, and different populations studied [
33–
37]. However, for premenopausal women, the preponderance of evidence suggests there is a reduced cancer incidence with higher lignan intakes or plasma ENL levels [
19–
22,
24–
26,
30]. This is particularly in women with CYP17 A2 alleles that may result in higher endogenous estrogen levels [
24,
38,
39]. Correlative studies indicate reduction in risk of ER- as well as ER+ breast cancer, including ER- cancer in premenopausal women [
23,
25,
27–
29].
Given the likelihood that lignans act as partial estrogen antagonists we undertook a pilot study of the plant lignan secoisolariciresinol diglycoside (SDG) in premenopausal women at increased risk for breast cancer. Our primary endpoint was change in the proliferation marker Ki-67 in hyperplastic benign breast tissue obtained by random periareolar fine needle aspiration (RPFNA). Proliferation plays a fundamental role in carcinogenesis [
40] and higher proliferation (Ki-67) in hyperplastic and atypical hyperplastic specimens is associated with cancer development [
41,
42]. Reduction in Ki-67 is also associated with response in early cancer treatment trials [
43,
44]. We had previously demonstrated that cytomorphologic evidence of atypia in tissue obtained by RPFNA from high risk women is associated with a 5-fold increased risk of developing DCIS or invasive cancer [
45] and that Ki-67 in cytology specimens obtained by RPFNA is positively associated [
46] with evidence of cytologic atypia [
47,
48]. Secondary endpoints measured included cytomorphology, percent mammographic density, serum bioavailable estradiol and testosterone, and IGF-I and IGFBP-3 (Reviewed in [
49]). We chose a commercial preparation (BrevailR) to avoid the marked variability in SDG content and bioavailability observed with different batches of raw or ground flaxseed [
50]. Pharmacologic studies had shown that daily dosing with this formulation, which contains 50 mg of SDG, produced ENL levels (median 63 nmol/L) similar to those found in the highest quintiles associated with reduction in cancer incidence in case control studies [
18,
51].