We conducted an initial GWA study of both 25[OH]D and 1,25[OH]
2D in a subset of 229 Hispanics from San Antonio, Texas and performed replication genotyping and analysis of 50 SNPs in the entire sample of 1,190 Hispanics. Of the 50 SNPs selected for replication genotyping, five for 25[OH]D (rs2806508, rs10141935, rs4778359, rs1507023, and rs9937918) and eight for 1,25[OH]
2D (rs6680429, rs1348864, rs4559029, rs12667374, rs7781309, rs10505337, rs2486443, and rs2154175) were replicated in the entire sample of Hispanics (
P <0.01; ). Although three GWA studies of 25[OH]D have been reported, no GWA studies of the more active vitamin D metabolite, 1,25[OH]
2D, have been reported thus far [
4;
5;
7]. Moreover, GWA publications thus far have been centered on populations of European descent [
20]; this GWA study in Hispanic Americans helps fill a void in the existing GWA literature.
The five SNPs that were associated with 25[OH]D were independent from the eight SNPs that were associated with 1,25[OH]
2D. One would expect a SNP to be associated with both metabolites if the SNP is involved in a process that is common to both metabolites, for example, the transport of the vitamin D metabolites, as was seen with a SNP in the vitamin D binding protein gene in a previous publication by this group [
1]. However, if a SNP is involved in a process that is specific to one of the metabolites, for example, the hydroxylation of a particular metabolite to another metabolite, the SNP may only be associated with the metabolites involved in that hydroxylation step. For example, a SNP that enhances the expression of
CYP24A1, which produces 24-hydroxylase that degrades excess 1,25[OH]
2D to 24,25-dihydroxyvitamin D, would not necessarily be strongly associated with the concentration of the upstream metabolite, 25[OH]D.
In the stage 1 GWA analysis in 229 Hispanics from San Antonio, no SNPs met the Bonferroni corrected
P-value cut-off (
P <1.62 × 10
−7) for 25[OH]D (); however, three SNPs (rs6680429, rs9970802, and rs10889028) in high LD were significantly associated with 1,25[OH]
2D (
P <1.62 × 10
−7; ). All three SNPs are intronic and reside on the short arm of chromosome 1 (1p32-p31; NCBI Mapviewer) within the disabled homolog 1 (
DAB1) gene.
DAB1 is a very large gene, spanning more than 1.2 Mb, which encodes a protein that is thought to be a signal transducer that interacts with protein kinase pathways to regulate neuronal positioning in the developing brain (GeneID: 1600; NCBI Entrez Gene). Of note, two other intronic SNPs in
DAB1 ranked in the top 25 associations based on the additive
P-values (rs155288 and rs1831870). Since these SNPs were in LD, only the SNP with the lowest
P-value (rs6680429;
P = 6.6 × 10
−9), was genotyped in the entire IRASFS Hispanic cohort, where the association was replicated (
P = 1.4 × 10
−3). However, this region was not among the three regions that reached genome-wide significance in the two recent GWA studies [
5;
7].
Twelve SNPs were selected for replication because they were under a linkage peak for 1,25[OH]2D, were in the top 3,000 SNPs in the stage 1 GWA analysis, and were functional SNPs. However, none of these SNPs were significant (P <0.01) in the entire Hispanic cohort. There are at least two potential explanations for this lack of replication. First, the linkage peaks could have been due to chance and, therefore, false positives. Second, one or both of the linkage peaks may have been true positives, but we did not select a SNP for replication genotyping that was in strong enough LD with the causative variant to show an association with 1,25[OH]2D. If this was the case, it may be that the twelve SNPs that were under a linkage peak and in the top 3,000 SNPs in the stage 1 GWA analysis (with additive P-values ranging from 9.9 × 10−5 to 7.6 × 10−3) were false positives and the HumanHap 300 BeadChip that we used did not contain a SNP that was in strong LD with the causative variant.
Of the three regions identified by both of the two recent large GWA studies of 25[OH]D,
GC,
DHCR7/NADSYN1, and
CYP2R1, only one of the regions showed marginal significance in our stage 1 GWA analysis: rs7041 in the
GC gene (
P <0.10) [
5;
7]. Two SNPs in the
DHCR7/NADSYN1 gene and two in the
CYP2R1 gene were included in the HumanHap 300 BeadChip used for our stage 1 GWA analysis, but none of these showed even a marginally significant association with 25[OH]D. This lack of association could be explained by the small sample size of our stage 1 GWA sample (
N = 229). Alternately, the lack of association could be explained by differences in LD and/or allele frequencies between the non-Hispanic white populations included in the two recent GWA studies and the Hispanic population included in the current GWA study.
To carry out this study we chose a research design in which a pilot GWA study was performed on 229 Hispanic subjects from one clinical center (San Antonio). From the analysis results, 50 SNPs were selected for genotyping and analysis in the entire IRASFS Hispanic cohort. While we ideally would have carried out the GWA study on the entire cohort, this was not financially possible. Our purpose was to identify some potential polymorphisms, and was motivated by the success of a number of small GWA studies. For example, the complement factor H gene association with age-related macular degeneration (224 cases and 134 controls) [
21], the
NOS1AP gene association with cardiac repolarization (200 subjects) [
22], the
TNFSF15 gene conferring susceptibility to Crohn’s disease (94 subjects) [
23], and the recent report of a region near the
CDKN2A and
CDKN2B genes on chromosome 9 associated with coronary heart disease, which was based initially on results from a GWA study of 322 cases and 312 controls [
24].
A limitation to this study is that, due to financial constraints, we were only able to select 50 SNPs for replication genotyping, but it is likely that additional SNPs contribute to the variation in vitamin D metabolite concentrations. For example, a SNP in the
GC gene, rs7041, has been previously shown to be associated with 25[OH]D in the entire San Antonio Hispanic cohort of 504 individuals (
P = 0.003), as well as in Hispanics from the San Luis Valley and African Americans from Los Angeles, and in the two recent large GWA studies [
1;
5;
7]. However, in the stage 1 GWA analysis in a subset of 229 Hispanics from the San Antonio cohort, rs7041, which was included in the HumanHap 300 BeadChip, was only marginally associated with 25[OH]D (
P <0.10), although the association with the T risk allele was in the same direction and of similar magnitude. Following up an expanded list of SNPs will be the focus of future research.