Rtt109 is a novel HAT (KAT) that lacks sequence similarity to other well-characterized CoA-dependent acetyltransferases and requires association with a histone chaperone for efficient catalysis. In this study, we sought to understand the catalytic mechanism for this unique high affinity histone chaperone-HAT complex and performed detailed kinetic and binding analyses that support a random sequential (direct-attack) mechanism (). We propose that AcCoA and H3 (or H3-H4) bind to the Rtt109-Vps75 complex without obligate order, forming a ternary complex (enzyme•AcCoA•H3), whereby the ε-amino group of lysine directly attacks the acetyl group of bound AcCoA (). After acetyl-group transfer to the substrate lysine, acetylated H3 and CoA are released either in ordered or random fashion (). Using rapid-quenching techniques, we provided evidence consistent with chemical catalysis as the rate-limiting step in turnover. From pH-rate analyses, we propose that the ionizable group which must be unprotonated for catalysis reflects the lysine ε-amine of bound substrate.
Several lines of evidence support the conclusion in which Vps75 and Rtt109 form a reversible, high-affinity interaction that represents the catalytically maximized complex. First, direct binding measurements yielded nanomolar
Kd values (~ 10 nM) of the complex. Furthermore, similar
kcat values were attained whether micromolar (i.e. RQF) or sub-micromolar proteins concentrations were utilized (i.e. steady-state analysis), consistent with low nanomolar
Kd values and a Rtt109-Vps75 complex that was maximally activated. We also observed that co-expression of Rtt109-Vps75, followed by resolution over nickel-affinity, anion exchange and gel filtration maintained the complex, and that only a strong hydrophobic interaction column (phenyl-sepharose) could disrupt their interaction. After separating Rtt109 and Vps75 by hydrophobic interaction chromatography, recombining the two proteins produced fully-activated complex, demonstrating the reversibility of binding. Consistent with a high affinity complex, endogenous Rtt109 co-purifies with Vps75 in yeast (
5,
27,
40,
41). Previously, two other labs reported a lower affinity interaction between Vps75 and Rtt109 (
Kd·=2.7 to ~5 μM) (
20,
42). While it is unclear what this low affinity interaction represents, here, we observed no significant changes in catalytic efficiency at higher protein concentrations (~1 μM), suggesting that this binding event does not markedly alter catalysis. Alternatively, this discrepancy may be the result of different methods, protein constructs or binding conditions used by others. For example, we find that Rtt109 alone is an unstable protein and is highly prone to aggregation, and inclusion of AcCoA during the binding assays stabilized Rtt109 and prevented aggregation.
Unlike other HAT enzymes that require obligate-ordered substrate binding (AcCoA followed by histone substrates) (
25,
36,
37), a unique feature of Rtt109-Vps75 is the random binding of substrates (). In such a mechanism, it is predicted that one substrate should be able to bind independently of the other, and the binding of substrate will not significantly enhance the binding of the second. From product inhibition studies, CoA exhibited competitive inhibition against AcCoA, indicating AcCoA and CoA can bind to the same enzyme form, yielding an Rtt109-Vps75•AcCoA or Rtt109-Vps75•CoA complex (). Equilibrium binding studies revealed both AcCoA and CoA bind to Rtt109-Vps75, and no increase in binding affinity is observed when CoA binding is measured in the presence of H3 peptide. Additionally, H3-H4 formed a tight-binding complex with Rtt109-Vps75 in the absence of AcCoA, as demonstrated by gel filtration analysis. Also consistent with a random substrate-binding model, the H3 peptide is able to bind Rtt109-Vps75 in the absence of AcCoA. Interestingly, p300, the likely mammalian structural ortholog of Rtt109, requires binding of AcCoA prior to binding histone substrates, revealing that although Rtt109 and p300 share roles in acetylating lysine 56 of H3, their kinetic mechanisms differ (
25,
43). Other key differences between Rtt109 and p300 are highlighted by the fact that p300 has efficient HAT activity in the absence of histone chaperones and likely displays wider substrate specificity, including both histone and non-histone substrates(
43,
44).
The pre-steady state kinetic analysis provides strong support for acetyl group transfer as the rate-limiting step in catalysis at pH 7.5. The observed rates in both multiple- and single-turnover experiments are in agreement with the steady-state kcat value. The lack of a discernable lag or burst phase during multiple-turnover conditions argues against substrate binding or product release as rate-limiting steps in catalysis. Given that the kcat reflects the chemical step of catalysis, the effect of pH on the kcat reveals information on how chemical catalysis is accomplished by the Rtt109-Vps75 complex.
The pH
kcat analysis of Rtt109-Vps75 revealed an ionizable group (p
Ka=8.5) that must be unprotonated for efficient catalysis. Due to the proximity of two conserved aspartic acid residues (D287, D288) near the putative active site, we investigated whether these residues have a role in deprotonating the ε-amino group of lysine () (
22-
24). The mutational analysis revealed there were substantial effects on catalysis, which were reflected by the large ~50-100-fold decrease in the
kcat of the D288N and D287A/D288A variants. However, pH
kcat analysis of D287A/D288A did not eliminate nor cause an upward shift in the p
Ka value as would be expected for the loss of a general base catalyst and the unassisted deprotonation of the lysine. In fact, the apparent p
Ka value for the D287A/D288A mutant was shifted downward by ~1 pH unit. These results are in contrast to other previously characterized HATs that utilize a general base mechanism, where the
pKa value of ~8 represents the hydrogen-bonded ion pair between the N-ε-lysine and the general base glutamate/aspartate (
35,
36,
39).
Since D287 or D288 are not likely responsible for the ionization in the
kcat pH profiles, we propose that the pH-dependent ionization reflects the enzyme-bound lysine of H3 substrate, which is perturbed when bound in the hydrophobic active site. The crystal structures of Rtt109 reveal a hydrophobic active site that creates an environment favoring the neutralized, unprotonated state of the substrate lysine (). Residues that line the hydrophobic “tunnel” include F84, V85, and the aliphatic side chain of K87 on β sheet 4, as well as L191, F192, and the aliphatic side chain of R194 on β sheet 5 of Rtt109 (). Rtt109 may increase the nucleophilicity of the substrate lysine by perturbing the p
Ka of lysine downwards to ~8.5 within the hydrophobic tunnel of the enzyme•AcCoA•H3 complex. Perturbation of the p
Ka values of ionizable groups arise from the energetically unfavorable process of transferring a charged group from a high dielectric constant environment (i.e. water) into a less polar environment, such as the burial of the charged group into the interior of a protein environment. For example, a V66K mutant in staphylococcal nuclease displayed a
pKa value of 10.2 in the denatured state compared to the
pKa value of 6.4 in the native state (
45,
46). This downward shift of
pKa is suggested to favor the uncharged form of lysine 66 within the context of the hydrophobic interior of the folded protein. Interestingly, p300, the closest structural homolog of Rtt109 in mammals also appears to lack a putative general base (
25). Like Rtt109, catalysis by p300 revealed the requirement of an ionizable group (p
Ka = 8.4) and the x-ray structure revealed a very hydrophobic active site(
25).
Our steady-state analysis revealed a critical role for aspartate 288 of Rtt109, as mutation resulted in both
kcat/
Km and
kcat defects. An ~16-fold increase in
Km for AcCoA and a ~50 fold decrease in
kcat was observed for the D288N mutant compared to wild type enzyme. Thus, the
kcat/
Km for AcCoA was decreased by ~3-orders of magnitude. This large
kcat/
Km effect may reflect a role for D288 in AcCoA binding. Surprisingly, D288 of Rtt109 lies ~ 8 Å from AcCoA in the active site, suggesting that direct interaction between AcCoA and D288 is unlikely(
22-
24).
One potential role for D288 may be linked to its interaction with acetylated K290 of Rtt109. As shown by mass spectrometric analysis, previous studies demonstrated that K290 is nearly completely acetylated in both affinity purified TAP-tagged Rtt109 from yeast, and Rtt109 (Rtt109 Δ130-179) expressed in bacteria () (
22). Three independently solved crystal structures of Rtt109 revealed electron density at lysine 290 consistent with an acetyl group, while genetic analysis indicated that mutation of this residue produced defective Rtt109 in vivo (
22-
24). Additionally, wildtype Rtt109 used in our analyses is fully acetylated at K290, while the D287A/D288A mutant is mostly unacetylated at K290 (BNA and JMD unpublished data). Together, these studies suggest a role for D288 in autoacetylation. The structures of Rtt109 show D288 and K290 residing on α-helix 6, forming a “lid” domain that interacts with the hydrophobic core domain of Rtt109, including β-sheet 5 which partially houses the acetyl group of AcCoA () (
22-
24). The interaction of α-helix 6 with the core domain results in the burial of acetylated K290 within the hydrophobic core and formation of a hydrogen bond interaction between D288 and acetylated K290 (
22-
24). D288 might properly position acetylated K290 or facilitate the chemistry of autoacetylation (i.e. general base), whereupon mutation of this residue prevents K290 acetylation. An unfavorable interaction of positively charged K290 with the core interior could perturb a local rearrangement of the acetyl binding pocket of AcCoA, as reflected by the large
kcat/
Km defect. Interestingly, Rtt109-Vps75 displays a 30-fold higher binding affinity for AcCoA over CoA, indicating that the acetyl group significantly contributes to overall AcCoA binding, and this acetyl-specific interaction might be disrupted in the D288N Rtt109 mutant. A multi-faceted layer of regulation for Rtt109 exists, governed by interactions with histone chaperones and autoacetylation of K290. Current efforts are directed at providing a detailed understanding of the functional role of K290 autoacetylation and the involvement of D288 in this modification, as well as the potentially distinct mechanisms of activation mediated by histone chaperones Asf1 and Vps75.