In a study published in this issue of
Critical Care, Gogos and colleagues [
1] investigated the influence of the type of bacterial infection, the compartment where it occurs, its origin (community or nosocomial), and its severity (sepsis versus severe sepsis or septic shock) on lymphopenia, on the respective number of mononuclear cell subsets, on apoptosis of circulating mononuclear cells, and on HLA-DR expression on monocytes. The same group had already reported that tumor necrosis factor (TNF) and interleukin (IL)-6 production by lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-stimulated monocytes was lower in sepsis patients with ventilator-associated pneumonia than in patients with sepsis due to other types of infections [
2]. These analyses permit clinicians to monitor sepsis patients' immune status, which undergoes numerous modifications gathered under the term 'compensatory anti-inflammatory response syndrome' [
3].
Lymphopenia is a hallmark of sepsis. It affects most lymphocyte subsets, although some divergent observations for B lymphocytes exist [
4-
6]. Importantly, lymphopenia is accompanied by modifications of the CD4
+/CD8
+ ratio and the relative percentage of cellular subsets. For example, among lymphocytes, the percentages of Treg (regulatory T) [
7] and of natural killer (NK) [
8] cells are enhanced. Lymphopenia already has been associated with bacteremia [
9], has been found to be more severe in patients with Gram-positive infection than in those with Gram-negative infection [
4], and has been found to inversely correlate with outcome [
10]. It can be mimicked by injections of live bacteria, LPS, IL-1, or TNF in animal models. The mechanisms that lead to lymphopenia are mainly a redistribution of activated cells that leave the blood compartment to migrate toward the tissues, particularly toward lymphatic tissues, and the occurrence of apoptosis. Apoptosis of lymphocytes during human sepsis was revealed by the Hotchkiss group [
11] when studying the spleens of patients who died of sepsis. Le Tulzo and colleagues [
12] showed that apoptosis of circulating lymphocytes was significantly lower in patients with sepsis than in those with septic shock. Hotchkiss and colleagues [
13] showed that apoptosis was affecting circulating NK cells, B lymphocytes, and CD4
+ and CD8
+ T lymphocytes. The reduced HLA-DR expression on CD14
+ monocytes is another hallmark of sepsis and systemic inflammatory response syndrome. It is a useful prognosis marker of intensive care patients and correlates with the occurrence of sepsis [
14]. Measurements performed a few days after the onset of sepsis appear as a prognosis marker, and low expression correlates with poor outcome [
15]. IL-10 and glucocorticoids are the main mediators that lower HLA-DR expression, although they act differently on CD14
HIGHCD16
NEG and CD14
LOWCD16
POS monocyte subsets [
16].
The present study illustrates the importance of being careful when comparing different reports, which often include different types of patients with sepsis. The heterogeneity of the patients gathered under the term 'sepsis' is a nightmare for anyone who wishes to submit grant applications or articles, since reviewers can easily argue that the studied group is ill defined and too heterogeneous! This study further emphasizes the difficulty of reaching definite conclusions on patients with sepsis when considered as a global group. The conclusions drawn for sepsis patients with pyelonephritis may not be true for sepsis patients with community-acquired pneumonia or intra-abdominal infection. However, although the authors report differences, these differences were minimal. Only community-acquired pneumonia was associated with a higher number of NK cells as compared with the other groups, and only intra-abdominal infection was associated with an enhanced number of CD8+ cells. The latter group was the only one with a significantly enhanced number of apoptotic CD8+ cells. Reduced expression of HLA-DR on CD14+ cells was seen mainly in patients infected with Klebsiella pneumoniae or Acinetobacter baumanii. Surprisingly, when patients with sepsis were compared with those with severe sepsis and septic shock, the number of significant differences in terms of the number of circulating NK cells, CD4+ T lymphocytes, CD8+ T lymphocytes, and B lymphocytes was limited to community-acquired pneumonia and intra-abdominal infection. Such a difference was not seen in patients with nosocomial pneumonia, pyelonephritis, or bacteremia. Enhanced apoptosis of NK and NKT cells was seen mainly in severe sepsis or septic shock caused by nosocomial pneumonia. Finally, HLA-DR expression was particularly reduced in patients with severe sepsis or septic shock due to pyelonephritis or intra-abdominal infection. Altogether, it is heartening to note that there were fewer differences than similarities between the different sepsis subgroups. Who else but Hippocrates can offer us a conclusion for this study from Greece: 'It is more important to know what sort of person has a disease than to know what sort of disease a person has'.
1 and Minou Adib-Conquy1
