We demonstrate that filaggrin deficiency is associated with Th17-dominated skin inflammation, development of eczematous skin lesions with age, and permissiveness to EC sensitization with protein antigen.
Except for matted hair, there were no discernible skin lesions in
ft/ft mice until about 28 weeks of age. By 32 weeks of age,
ft/ft mice developed scaly eczematous skin lesions (). Skin lesions have not been previously described in
ft/ft mice
18, possibly because previous reports may not have investigated older mice. Alternatively, as in Nc/Nga mice
22, development of skin lesions in
ft/ft mice may be influenced by environmental factors, particularly microbial skin colonization, which may differ between animal facilities.
Normal appearing skin from 8-week-old
ft/ft mice revealed skin inflammation characterized by hyperkeratosis, acanthosis, dermal infiltration with CD4
+ cells and rare neutrophils, with notable absence of eosinophils, and increased expression of mRNA for IL-17, the IL-17 promoting cytokines IL-6 and IL-23, and the IL-17 inducible chemokine CXCL2 (). More severe, but qualitatively similar, skin inflammation was observed in skin lesions that had developed spontaneously in 32-week-old
ft/ft mice (). Keratinocytes, DCs, and macrophages are sources of IL-6 and IL-23, and release these cytokines in response to TLR ligands and IL-1
23-25. TLR2 ligands from
S. aureus and other bacteria, which colonize skin are particularly potent at driving IL-23 expression
26. We have found that mechanical skin injury by tape stripping causes rapid upregulation of IL-6 and IL-23 in the skin (MKO and RSG: unpublished observations). There was no significant elevation of IL-6 and IL-23 mRNA expression in the skin of 2-week-old
ft/ft mice (data not shown) suggesting that lack of filaggrin by itself does not drive increased expression of these cytokines. The trigger for this increase could be microbial antigens, absorbed via a disrupted skin barrier, and/or a mechanically damaged skin. Elevated IL-17 expression may explain the neutrophil infiltration in
ft/ft skin, as IL-17 induces expression of neutrophil chemotactic chemokines in epithelial cells, including CXCL2
27, which was upregulated in
ft/ft skin. In addition to T cells, neutrophils are a source of IL-17
19, and may contribute to increased IL-17 expression in
ft/ft skin. IL-6 drives keratinocyte proliferation
28, thus increased IL-6 expression in the skin may underlie epidermal thickening in ft/ft mice.
The skin of 8-week-old
ft/ft mice exhibited no detectable evidence of Th2-driven inflammation. There was no significant infiltration with eosinophils or upregulation of Th2 cytokine mRNA expression (). There was also no evidence of Th1-driven inflammation, as there was no increase in IFN-γ mRNA expression. Lack of evidence of Th2 inflammation in the skin of
ft/ft mice contrasts with elevation of their serum IgE and IgG1 levels, an indicator of a systemic Th2 response. High levels of IL-17 in the skin of
ft/ft mice may have inhibited local expression of Th2 cytokines and subsequent recruitment of eosinophils
29. Skin lesions in 32-week-old
ft/ft mice exhibited qualitatively similar, but more pronounced, changes in histology and cytokine expression, compared to skin from 8-week-old
ft/ft mice () The exception was IL-4 mRNA levels, which were elevated in lesional skin of 32-week-old, but not 8-week-old mice, consistent with an ongoing Th2 response to cutaneously absorbed antigens.
The skin of
ft/ft mice was permissive to EC sensitization of nonstripped skin with OVA, a protein antigen, normally excluded from penetrating the skin. Application of OVA to shaved, but non-tape stripped, skin elicited allergic skin inflammation and OVA specific systemic humoral and cellular immune responses in
ft/ft mice, but not C57BL6 or BALB/c mice ( and ). In previous studies, two additional strains, 129Sv and hr/hr hairless mice, failed to respond to OVA application to shaved skin (RSG: unpublished observations). Skin inflammation in EC sensitized
ft/ft mice was characterized by a significant increase in epidermal thickness, dermal infiltration with CD4
+ cells and expression of IL-4, IL-17 and IFN-γ, but not IL-13 or IL-5 mRNA. IL-13 plays an important in driving eotaxin expression in the skin
30. IL-5 is important not only for eosinophil mobilization, but also for their survival in tissues
31. Elevated IL-17 levels in
ft/ft skin before, and more so after EC sensitization, may have inhibited of IL-13 and IL-5 expression, resulting in lack of eosinophil infiltration. Genetic background could have contributed to lack of IL-5 and IL-13 mRNA expression in EC sensitized skin of
ft/ft mice.
EC sensitization of tape stripped skin of WT mice (BALB/c, C57BL6, 129Sv and BWF1) results in allergic skin inflammation and in OVA specific immune responses
16, 32, 33. Since tape stripping disrupts skin barrier and allows antigen entry
34, disrupted skin barrier function in
ft/ft mice likely underlies their permissiveness to EC sensitization of nonstripped skin by protein antigen. This permissiveness did not reflect a generalized enhanced immune response, because the humoral and immune responses of
ft/ft mice to
i.p. immunization with OVA were comparable or lower than those of C57BL6 and BALB/c mice (). This is consistent with the observation that
FLG is expressed exclusively in mouse skin, tongue, esophagus, and forestomach
35. With their eczematous skin lesions that developed with age and expressed IL-4 mRNA, elevated serum IgE and IgG1 levels and permissiveness to EC sensitization of nonstripped skin with protein antigen,
ft/ft mice share features with patients with extrinsic AD. However, while IL-17 expression is prominent in the skin of ft/ft mice and in psoriatic skin lesions, it is less prominent in AD skin lesions. There are two limitations to the interpretation of our results. Although mutation in
FLG likely underlies the skin abnormalities in
ft/ft mice, these mice are double homozygous of
flaky tail and
matted. Therefore, we cannot rule out a role for the
ma mutation in the skin inflammation and susceptibility to EC sensitization of nonstripped skin of
ft/ft mice. The other limitation is that the
ft/ft mice we studied, are not on a homogeneous background. Nevertheless, the skin inflammation and susceptibility to EC sensitization of nonstripped skin we observed in these mice was not observed in four other strains we have studied to date. Thus, it is unlikely that genes other than
FLG, or a closely linked gene, are implicated in the susceptibility of
ft/ft mice to develop skin inflammation to protein antigens normally excluded by the skin barrier and to develop eczema.
While this manuscript was being reviewed, the mutation in
FLG in
ft/ft mice was identified to be a 1-bp deletion (5303delA), and
ft/ft mice bred on C57BL6 background and lacking the ma mutation were demonstrated to be permissive to sensitization by cutaneous application of antigen, in agreement with our findings
36.
Clinical ImplicationsFilaggrin deficiency predisposes to skin inflammation, development of eczematous lesions and sensitization upon contact with protein antigens normally excluded by the skin barrier.