Based upon the Human Genome Project, efforts were made over the last decade to better understand transcriptomes encoded in human erythroblasts. An erythroblast transcriptome project was initiated by first isolating human erythroblasts in real-time as they differentiate in
ex vivo cultures [
21]. mRNA from those cells was isolated and analyzed to provide a erythroid transcriptome map for further study. Due to the high-levels of erythroblast proliferation followed by incomplete maturation (without enucleation), the transcriptome generated using cultured cells was hypothesized to reflect ineffective erythropoiesis [
22]. High-levels of GDF15 gene expression were noted in culture among the more mature erythroblasts, and the cytokine was selected for further study [
23].
Along with studies in cultured erythroblasts, clinical studies of GDF15 expression
in vivo were begun. A summary of clinical reports is shown in . The levels of GDF15 in healthy individuals are generally measured in 200–1,150 pg/ml range by commercial ELISA assays [
23,
24]. There are no significant differences of GDF15 concentrations among citrated plasma, EDTA-treated plasma, and serum. GDF15 is stable at room temperature in serum, plasma, and whole blood for at least 48 hours. GDF15 is resistant to at least 4 freeze thaw cycles. Anticoagulants, albumin, bilirubin, or hemoglobin do not significantly influence the measurement of GDF15 concentrations [
25]. These features suggest GDF15 expression in the serum may eventually be utilized as a clinical marker of cell stress or apoptosis. Additional studies are needed to determine the sensitivity and specificity of GDF15 measurements in a broader range of disease settings.
Consistent with the high levels of GDF15 expressed
ex vivo in the culture model described above, serum GDF15 levels are highly-elevated in patients with ineffective erythropoiesis or other hematopoietic disorders (). The thalassemia syndromes (α-thalassemia and β-thalassemia) represent the most common causes of ineffective erythropoiesis. In the thalassemia syndromes, imbalances in the production of α- and β-globin chains result in increased apoptosis during erythroblast maturation [
26]. Serum GDF15 levels in patients with thalassemia were dramatically elevated compared with healthy volunteers or patients with the thalassemia trait. The median in beta-thalassemia patients (48,000 pg/ml) was particularly high with a detected range of 5,000–250,000 pg/ml [
23]. A second group of disorders associated with ineffective erythropoiesis and iron overloading is called dyserythropoietic anemias. Congenital dyserythropoietic anemia type I (CDAI) is caused by CDANI gene deficiency [
27]. Like α- and β-thalassemia, very high serum levels of GDF15 are expressed in patients with CDAI [
28]. In CDAI patients, serum GDF15 levels were correlated with the level of ineffective erythropoiesis, hepcidin-25, and ferritin. A third group of patients with ineffective erythropoiesis possess an erythroid defect that is characterized by accumulation of iron in mitochondria that “ring” the erythroblast nucleus during terminal maturation [
29]. Intramedullary apoptosis is a feature of acquired anemia with ringed sideroblasts [
30]. Significant elevations in GDF15 expression were also reported in this group (3,254 ± 1,400 pg/ml vs. 451 ± 87 pg/ml in healthy volunteers) [
31]. Finally, significant ineffective erythropoiesis has been reported among some patients with pyruvate kinase deficiency, but the erythroid phenotype is variable [
32,
33]. GDF15 expression in patients with pyruvate kinase deficiency is elevated, but the magnitude of elevation is considerably lower than measured in patients with thalassemia [
34].
Serum GDF15 levels from patients with other erythroid disorders have also been reported. Like thalassemia syndromes, sickle cell syndromes are characterized by increased levels of erythropoiesis, but the primary defect in sickle cell involves destruction of mature erythrocytes. In severe cases of sickle cell disease, some ineffective erythropoiesis may be found [
35]. Interestingly, the elevation in the serum level of GDF15 is mild in sickle cell disease compared to thalassemia [
23]. Studies of patients with effective erythropoiesis after bone marrow transplantation [
36] or after injection of erythropoietin [
37] failed to demonstrate major increases in serum GDF15. Indeed, preliminary studies at the National Institutes of Health suggest GDF15 expression is barely detectable in normal bone marrow, compared with the distinct staining in a subset of erythroid precursors in thalassemia bone marrow (). Since GDF15 is not expressed specifically in erythroblasts, elevations of this cytokine in patients with cancers and inflammatory disease should not be attributed to erythroblast expression. This point may be particularly important when considering the high-levels of GDF15 reported in patients with anemia of chronic disease [
38]. When combined, these data suggest GDF15 measurements may be helpful for predicting ineffective or apoptotic erythropoiesis.