Biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters requires a coordinated delivery of iron and sulphide. While sulphide in iron-sulfur clusters is derived from L-cysteine by cysteine desulfurases [
45,
46], iron donor for the iron-sulfur cluster assembly largely remains elusive. Previously, we reported that
E. coli IscA is a novel iron binding protein that can provide the iron for the iron-sulfur cluster assembly in a scaffold protein IscU
in vitro [
22–
24]. In the present study, we report that the human IscA homologue, hIscA1, has the similar iron binding activity as
E. coli IscA (), and that the iron binding in hIscA1 expressed in
E. coli cells can be modulated by the accessible iron in the cell growth medium (). We further show that the iron-bound hIscA1 can provide the iron for the iron-sulfur cluster assembly in
E. coli IscU
in vitro () and partially substitute for IscA in restoring the cell growth of
E. coli in the M9 minimal medium under aerobic conditions (). Collectively, our results suggest that human hIscA1, like
E. coli IscA, is an iron binding protein that may act as an iron chaperone for biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters.
It has been postulated that frataxin, a mitochondrial protein linked to the human neurodegenerative disease Friedreich ataxia [
35], may also act as an iron chaperone for biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters [
36,
37]. Like IscA, frataxin is highly conserved from bacteria to humans. While mature form of human frataxin purified from
E. coli cells contained little or no iron (), frataxin was able to bind approx. 10 atoms of iron per frataxin monomer
in vitro under aerobic conditions [
38]. In addition, the iron-bound frataxin [
36] or its bacterial homologue CyaY [
37] can provide the iron for the iron-sulfur cluster assembly in proteins
in vitro. Furthermore, frataxin has been shown to specifically interact with the iron-sulfur proteins such as aconitase [
47] and mitochondrial electron transfer components [
48], and with the iron-sulfur cluster assembly proteins IscS [
49] and IscU [
50]. All these studies suggested that frataxin/CyaY could be directly involved in the iron-sulfur cluster assembly and/or repair. However, other studies indicated that deletion of frataxin/CyaY has little or no effect on biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters in
S. cerevisiae [
51],
Salmonella enterica [
52], and
E. coli [
53], and that expression of frataxin in cytosol [
54] or addition of manganese [
55] in cultured mammalian cells is sufficient to substitute for frataxin in protecting iron-sulfur enzymes in mitochondria. In addition, it has been shown that frataxin/CyaY has a fairly weak iron binding activity under physiologically relevant conditions
in vitro [
56,
57]. Here we find that unlike human hIscA1, human frataxin fails to bind any accessible iron in
E. coli cells grown in the M9 minimal medium (), further indicating that frataxin has a weak iron binding activity
in vivo under normal physiological conditions. Without a strong iron binding activity in cells, it is arguable whether frataxin/CyaY could act as an iron donor for biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters.
It should be emphasized that the physiological function of IscA in biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters still remains controversial. Our results presented here and previously [
6,
7,
22–
27] could not exclude the possibility that IscA may act as an alternative scaffold protein for biogenesis of iron-sulfur clusters as proposed by others [
11–
19]. Recent purification of the native iron-sulfur cluster-bound SufA from
E. coli cells by co-expressing SufA with the entire gene cluster
sufABCDSE clearly indicated that SufA is able to bind an iron-sulfur cluster
in vivo [
18]. On the other hand, since the iron-sulfur cluster assembly will require a concert delivery of stoichiometric amounts of iron and sulphide, it is conceivable that if cells have more available iron than sulphide, an excess of iron must be transiently stored. Under this scenario, IscA may act as an iron chaperone to scavenge excess iron and deliver the iron for the subsequent iron-sulfur cluster assembly. In this context, we propose that IscA could be a dual functional protein that is capable of binding either a mononuclear iron or an iron-sulfur cluster depending on accessible iron and sulphide contents in cells. The dual functional model for IscA is consistent with the x-ray crystal structures of
E. coli IscA [
58,
59] and its paralog SufA [
60] which reveal that the conserved “cysteine pocket” in IscA/SufA can readily accommodate a mononuclear iron or an iron-sulfur cluster without significant re-arrangements of protein structure. The dynamic alteration between the mononuclear iron binding mode and the iron-sulfur cluster binding mode in IscA is currently under investigation.