Changes in electrophysiological responses involving NMDA receptors
Some changes during aging in NMDA receptor expression are reflected in changes in the electrophysiological responses, but interpretations can be complicated by changes in other systems. Intracellular responses show a reduced sensitivity to applied NMDA in slices of the frontoparietal cortex from old Fischer 344 rats, as compared to young (Baskys et al.,
1990). There is also no evidence of LTP in this same region in old rats when using a protocol that produces LTP in the young, (Baskys et al.,
1990). NMDA responses from
Xenopus oocytes injected with mRNA isolated from aged frontal cortex show decreased maximal NMDA currents and increased sensitivity to magnesium, as compared to mRNA from young mice (Kuehl-Kovarik et al.,
2000). There was also a decrease in the low affinity and an increase in the high affinity ifenprodil components in oocytes injected with aged mRNA (Kuehl-Kovarik et al.,
2000), which is consistent with the findings of decreased GluN2B subunit mRNA in the frontal cortex of aged mice (Magnusson,
2000,
2001). Thus, there are changes in the function of the NMDA receptor in the frontoparietal cortex with age that are consistent with the changes in NMDA receptor expression.
The data from the hippocampus are more complicated. NMDA responses in both the dentate gyrus (Yang et al.,
2008) and in the CA1 region of the hippocampus show decreased excitatory post-synaptic potentials for a given presynaptic fiber volley in aged Fischer 344 rats (Barnes et al.,
1997). However, NMDA-induced inhibition of the extracellular field potential shows no age-related difference in dose in the CA1 regions of Sprague-Dawley rats (Billard et al.,
1997). The ratio of NMDA/AMPA responses also remains constant across age in the CA1 region of the hippocampus in Fischer 344 rats (Barnes et al.,
1997), but decreases in the dentate gyrus (Yang et al.,
2008). Certain aspects of LTP in the hippocampus are altered as rats age; the enhancement of LTP reaches maximum at a slower rate and the decay rate is faster in old rats, as compared to young (Barnes,
1979; Barnes and McNaughton,
1985). There is evidence that NMDA-dependent LTP induction is normal in the CA1 region of old rats when post-synaptic cells are depolarized by intracellular injection of current (Barnes et al.,
1996) or when high-frequency tetanization is used (Deupree et al.,
1991; Moore et al.,
1993; Billard et al.,
1997; Shankar et al.,
1998). However, a decline in both the magnitude of short-term potentiation (STP) and LTP in the CA1 region are seen with increasing age with peri-threshold stimulation protocols (Deupree et al.,
1991; Moore et al.,
1993; Barnes et al.,
1997). These results suggest that, although the aged hippocampus is still capable of producing NMDA-dependent LTP under maximal stimulation conditions, it is not as good as the young hippocampus at lower stimulation rates, which are likely to be more physiological. This could be due to changes in the NMDA receptor itself and/or due to alterations in other steps of the signaling pathways that are that are up- or down-stream from the NMDA receptors. In addition, the electrophysiological responses that are attributable to NMDA receptors in young animals can be more influenced by other signaling systems in the elderly. The maintenance of LTP in aged animals is characterized by a decrease in NMDA receptor-induced LTP and a compensatory increase in calcium channel-dependent LTP (Norris et al.,
1998; Shankar et al.,
1998). NMDA receptor-dependent LTD and reversal of LTP by low frequency stimulation are increased in the CA1 region of aged Fischer 344 rats (Norris et al.,
1996). The interpretation of these changes in NMDA receptor functions are complicated by alterations in the regulation of calcium and metabotropic glutamate receptor activity in the same region (Norris et al.,
1998; Kumar and Foster,
2004, 2007). There are, therefore, some electrophysiological differences in NMDA receptor responses that are evident between the dentate gyrus and CA1 regions of the hippocampus in aged rodents. However, other alterations in NMDA receptor function during aging may be influenced by changes in other systems.
Relationships of NMDA receptor changes to cognitive aging
Aged humans show declines in performance (30–80% decreases from young performance) in problems involving spatial memory (Evans et al.,
1984; Moore et al.,
1984; Sharps and Gollin,
1987; Kirasic and Bernicki,
1990; Cherry and Park,
1993). The role of NMDA receptors in spatial learning and memory in the young, behaving animal has been predominantly studied by Morris and his associates with the use of the Morris water maze and a reference spatial memory task (Morris et al.,
1986; Morris,
1989; Morris and Davis,
1994; Bannerman et al.,
1995). This task (Gage et al.,
1984; Rapp et al.,
1987; Gallagher et al.,
1993; Magnusson,
1997a) and others, including the Barnes circular platform maze and Olton radial arm maze (Barnes et al.,
1980), also have been used extensively in aging research to demonstrate and characterize the age-related declines that occur in spatial memory performance in rodents and the relationship between changes in NMDA receptor binding during aging to memory dysfunctions. Several studies show that lower binding of agonist or antagonist to the NMDA binding site in the frontal cortex and/or hippocampus of aged animals is associated with poorer performance in spatial memory tasks utilizing the water maze (Pelleymounter et al.,
1990; Davis et al.,
1993; Magnusson,
1998a,
2001). There is also evidence for a role for NMDA receptors in passive avoidance retention memory (Mondadori and Weiskrantz,
1993) and there is a significant correlation between [
3H]MK801
Bmax and passive avoidance latency during aging; high binding was associated with better retention (Scheuer et al.,
1995).
Changes in specific subunits of the NMDA receptor have also shown relationships with memory declines during aging. Age-related decreases in the protein expression of the GluN1 subunit within crude synaptosomes of the frontal cortex of C57BL/6 mice show a relationship to the declines in performance in a spatial reference memory task across age groups (Magnusson et al.,
2007). Lower expression of the GluN1 subunit within the synaptic membrane of the hippocampus of middle-aged mice is also associated with poorer performance in the same task, though this relationship is reversed in the old mice (see “Not Your Young Adult's NMDA Receptor” below) (Zhao et al.,
2009b). Lower protein expression of the GluN1 subunit was also found in the CA3 region of aged Long-Evans rats that performed the worst in a spatial reference memory task (Adams et al.,
2001b). High mRNA expression of GluN1
0XX (1-a) splice variants in the ventral orbital cortex of old C57BL/6 mice is associated with good spatial working memory performance and showed a trend for a similar relationship to spatial reference memory (Das and Magnusson,
2008). Interestingly, this splice form was negatively associated with performance in the cued association task (Das and Magnusson,
2008). The reason for this is unclear. This finding represents another example of the variability among the GluN1 splice forms, since other splice variants that were affected by aging, GluN1
X11 (1-1) and GluN1
X10 (1-3), did not show a relationship with the learning declines (Das and Magnusson,
2008).
Although there is less of an affect of aging on the GluN2A subunit than the other subunits, the expression of the GluN2A subunit in aged mice does appear to influence spatial learning. A high ratio of mRNA for GluN2A subunits to either GluN1 or GluN2B subunits in parietal cortex and/or hippocampus within aged mice is associated with good performance in a spatial reference memory task (Magnusson,
2001). This suggests that enhancing the expression of the NR2A subunit in aged individuals may be beneficial in light of the declines seen in the other subunits with age.
In aging, the decline seen in expression of the GluN2B subunit in both frontal cortex and hippocampus is significantly correlated with impaired memory function in old or middle-aged mice and rats (Clayton and Browning,
2001; Magnusson et al.,
2007; Zhao et al.,
2009b). A study by Clayton et al. (
2002b) investigated whether or not the deficit of the GluN2B subunit seen in aged rats was sufficient to account for the spatial memory deficit that had been previously observed (Clayton and Browning,
2001). They found that GluN2B subunit antisense treatment in the hippocampus diminished NMDA-dependent LTP and spatial learning (Clayton et al.,
2002b). Significant reductions in GluN2B subunit expression have also been observed in the susceptible regions of brains with AD (Sze et al.,
2001; Hynd et al.,
2004). These studies suggest that age-related reductions in the levels of the GluN2B subunit are likely to contribute to memory impairment in aged individuals.
The relationships observed between NMDA receptor expression and cognitive declines during aging suggest that aging interventions aimed at retaining or improving NMDA receptor function could be beneficial to relieving some age-related memory dysfunctions.
Interventions that enhance NMDA receptor expression
Many different interventions have been used successfully
in vivo to attenuate the effect of aging on the NMDA receptor complex, as shown by improvements in receptor binding and/or subunit expression. Acetyl-L-carnitine (ALCAR), a compound that demonstrates multiple anti-aging effects in the brain when administered systemically to an aged animal (see review, Castorina et al.,
1994), improves antagonist binding to the NMDA binding site, slightly in the hippocampus and frontal cortex and significantly in the striatum (Castorina et al.,
1994). ALCAR also decreases the age-related difference in NMDA-displaceable [
3H]glutamate binding, slightly in the hippocampus (Fiore and Rampello,
1989) and significantly in the anterior cortex (Davis et al.,
1993). In the latter study, there was a slight improvement in spatial memory performance associated with the aged animals that received ALCAR treatment (Davis et al.,
1993). Other cognitive enhancing and free radical scavenging drugs, such as memantine (Bresink et al.,
1995), phosphatidylserine (Cohen and Muller,
1992), piracetam (Cohen and Muller,
1993), pyrintol (Hartmann et al.,
1993), vitamin E (Martinez-Villayandre et al.,
2006) and alpha-lipoic acid (Stoll et al.,
1993), all produce significant increases in the binding of [
3H]MK801 in aged rodents. Bifemalane hydrochloride, a drug used for cerebrovascular diseases, increases CPP binding in most cortical, hippocampal and thalamic regions studied in aged rats (Ogawa et al.,
1992). D-cycloserine, a partial glycine agonist, improves the NMDA-stimulated norepinephrine release in older treated rats over non-treated, age-matched controls (Pittaluga et al.,
1993).
Caloric restriction is an aging intervention that has been shown to improve memory performance (Witte et al.,
2009), especially in spatial tasks (Algeri et al.,
1991; Pitsikas and Algeri,
1992; Magnusson,
2001). Restricting the dietary intake of calories to 60% of
ad-libitum fed animals, beginning from 3

months of age, resulted in the maintenance of slighter higher levels of [
3H]glutamate binding to the NMDA site in older C57Bl/6 mice (Magnusson,
1997a,
2001) and this effect is correlated with improved spatial memory performance in the water maze (Magnusson,
1998a,
2001). Caloric restriction also results in an increase in mRNA expression of the GluN1 subunit in frontal cortical regions of middle-aged and old mice, as compared to the
ad-libitum fed animals, (Magnusson,
2001). Fischer 344 rats also show a positive effect of caloric restriction on GluN1 subunit protein expression in the aged hippocampus (Eckles-Smith et al.,
2000). The F344XBN rats exhibit a reduction in the age-related differences seen in the GluN1 and GluN2A subunits in the hippocampus, but this appears to be due to a reduction in the expression of the subunits in the calorically-restricted young rats, as compared to young rats fed
ad-libitum (Newton et al.,
2007; Shi et al.,
2007). There was no reversal of the age-related declines in GluN2B subunit mRNA expression with these calorie restriction protocols (Magnusson,
2001; Newton et al.,
2007). In the dentate gyrus, the aged animals on the restricted diets actually show the greatest decreases in GluN2B subunit mRNA densities (Magnusson,
2001; Newton et al.,
2007). However, a recent study by Fontan-Lozano et al. (
2007) employed the long-term intermittent fasting diet (L-IFD), a variant of caloric restriction. The L-IFD resulted in an increase in protein expression of the GluN2B subunit in both the hippocampus and perirhinal cortex (Fontan-Lozano et al.,
2007). There was also a significant increase in GluN1 in the perirhinal cortex, but no effect on GluN2A subunit expression in any region examined (Fontan-Lozano et al.,
2007). The enhanced memory in aged L-IFD mice appeared to be due to the enhanced expression of the GluN2B subunit in the hippocampus, as demonstrated by region-specific antagonism (Fontan-Lozano et al.,
2007).
Other dietary interventions, such as dietary supplementation, also show promise for ameliorating the cognitive declines associated with aging. Aging is associated with oxidative stress and declines in omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (
n-3 PUFA) in the brain (Butterfield et al.,
1999; Ulmann et al.,
2001). This deficit in
n-3 PUFA is associated with memory impairment (Greiner et al.,
1999; Ulmann et al.,
2001). A study by Calon et al. (
2005) showed that in a mouse model of AD with
n-3 PUFA deficiency, the expression levels of GluN1, GluN2A and GluN2B subunits are significantly decreased compared to non-transgenic mice. This change can be partially rescued by dietary supplementation with docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), a key component of
n-3 PUFA (Calon et al.,
2005). Likewise, in aged rats, dietary supplementation with
n-3 PUFA reversed deficits in the expression of the GluN2B subunit (Dyall et al.,
2007). Recently, Chytrova et al. (
2009) showed that both the actions of exercise and dietary supplementation of DHA in young adult rats enhances spatial memory and increases expression of the GluN2B subunit.
Other dietary interventions have also shown promise. Dietary supplementation with blueberry extract in aged rats rescues NMDA receptor-dependent LTP in the hippocampus, but did not prevent aged related declines in the protein expression of the GluN1 or GluN2B subunits (Coultrap et al.,
2008). However, an increase in phosphorylation of a key tyrosine residue on the GluN2B subunit in aged animals is associated with improved LTP in these animals (Coultrap et al.,
2008). Dietary supplementation with ginsenoside, the effective ingredient in ginseng, improves memory in aged C57BL/6 mice and enhances the expression of phosphorylated GluN1 subunits back to the levels seen in young adults (Zhao et al.,
2009a).
Drug related interventions have shown promise for reversing age-related cognitive deficits. Nicotine reversed the effects of aging on the GluN2B subunit in the hippocampus, but showed no influence on expression of the GluN2A subunit in aged Sprague-Dawley rats (Delibas et al.,
2005). Likewise, sulindac, a non-steriodal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID), attenuated age-related deficits in memory by decreasing inflammation, while increasing expression levels of the NMDA receptor subunits, GluN1 and GluN2B (Mesches et al.,
2004).
Hormone treatments have also been used successfully as aging interventions for the NMDA receptor complex. Insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) alleviates the decline in both GluN2A and GluN2B subunits seen in older F344XBN rats (Sonntag et al.,
2000). Growth hormone enhances the mRNA expressions of the GluN1 and GluN2A subunits in the hippocampus (Le Greves et al.,
2002). Estradiol can increase the protein expression of the GluN1 subunit, but not the mRNA, in the hippocampus of female Sprague-Dawley rats (Gazzaley et al.,
1996b).
Many of these interventions have selective effects on certain subunits, which further supports the idea that there are different mechanisms of aging acting on the NMDA receptor subunits. These interventions do offer some hope for correcting the effects of aging on the NMDA receptor complex. However, a more in depth examination of how these improvements in the NMDA receptor relate to improvements in receptor function and memory processing is needed before deciding which of these represent the optimal treatment.
“Not your young adult's NMDA receptor”
Although there is evidence that declines in NMDA receptor binding densities and subunit expression are associated with the declines in memory during aging, there is also mounting evidence that the NMDA receptors that remain in aged animals are less associated with good learning and memory than the receptors of young animals. Middle-aged mice showed that good spatial memory was associated with higher expressions of the NMDA receptor subunits, GluN1 and GluN2B, in the synaptic membrane of the hippocampus (Zhao et al.,
2009b). This would be expected given the importance of hippocampal NMDA receptors in acquisition of spatial memory in younger animals (Morris,
1989; Heale and Harley,
1990; Steele and Morris,
1999). In contrast, the highest levels of expression of both GluN1 and GluN2B subunits in the hippocampal synaptic membrane were found in the aged mice with the poorest spatial memory (Zhao et al.,
2009b). The negative relationship with memory in the old mice was not simply due to the subunit expression falling below a certain threshold (Zhao et al.,
2009b). This suggests that a change occurred in the functioning of NMDA receptors in the synaptic membrane between 11 and 26

months of age in C57BL/6 mice. This change could be due to compensatory changes, induced by the decline in NMDA receptor expression, that did not occur until later ages, and/or aging changes that affect other molecules that interact with NMDA receptors.
There is other evidence of a change in the role of NMDA receptors in aged animals. High densities of NMDA receptor binding within old rats in subregions of the hippocampus have been shown to be associated with poor long-term memory retention in the water maze (Topic et al.,
2007) and a non-spatial complex maze task (Ingram et al.,
1992) and in the striatum are related to poor set shifting (Nicolle and Baxter,
2003) and poor spatial learning (Nicolle et al.,
1996). Aged rats that were unimpaired in a spatial memory task showed greater age-related declines in MK801 binding in the cortex and hippocampus than those that were impaired (Le Jeune et al.,
1996). NMDA receptor antagonists, including mementine, a therapeutic used for AD, improve memory (Norris and Foster,
1999; Danysz and Parsons,
2003; Pieta Dias et al.,
2007; Beracochea et al.,
2008) and increase neurogenesis (Nacher et al.,
2003) in aged individuals. Cholinesterase inhibitors used to treat AD are also believed to act by inhibiting NMDA receptors (Chen et al.,
2008). Some evidence suggests that the blockade of the NMDA receptor may be protecting against excitotoxicity and oxidative damage (Pieta Dias et al.,
2007). There is an increased responsiveness in aged animals to NMDA receptor-dependent low frequency stimulations leading to LTD or paired pulse stimulation that is inversely correlated with memory ability, as compared to young (Norris et al.,
1996; Huang and Kandel,
2006). Non-NMDA receptor-dependent LTP and LTD are more associated with good memory in aged rats than NMDA receptor-dependent (Lee et al.,
2005; Boric et al.,
2008). It has been suggested that the decline in NMDA receptor contribution to plasticity in aged animals may be beneficial by reducing the overwriting of old information (Yang et al.,
2008). All of these studies suggest that the NMDA receptors present in aged animals function differently from those in young. Potentially this could be due to changes in subunit composition or the environment in which the receptor functions. It remains to be seen whether this could or should be reversed or prevented.