|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Amyloids are highly organized cross β-sheet-rich protein or peptide aggregates that are associated with pathological conditions including Alzheimer’s disease and type II diabetes. However, amyloids may also have a normal biological function as demonstrated by fungal prions, which are involved in prion replication, and the amyloid protein Pmel17, which is involved in mammalian skin pigmentation. Here, we show that peptide and protein hormones in secretory granules of the endocrine system are stored in an amyloid-like cross β-sheet-rich conformation. Thus, in contrast to the original association of amyloids with diseases, functional amyloids in the pituitary and other organs can contribute to normal cell and tissue physiology.
Cells transport newly synthesized secretory proteins and peptides in vesicles via the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and Golgi for release into the extracellular space (1, 2). Some secretory cells, such as neuroendocrine cells and exocrine cells, store secretory proteins and peptides for extended time periods in a highly concentrated form in membrane-enclosed electron-dense cores termed “secretory granules” (1, 3, 4), which are derived from the Golgi complex. The dense cores of these granules are made up of large, insoluble secretory protein and peptide aggregates that are formed by self-association (4–6). The granules are not amorphous, but possess a distinct molecular organization, possibly of crystalline structures (7) or large intermolecular aggregates (5, 8).
Amyloid fibrils are cross- β-sheet structures that are primarily associated with several neurodegenerative diseases including Alzheimer’s disease. However, amyloid fibril formation also provides biologically functional entities termed functional amyloids (9) and are present in Escherichia coli (10), silkworm (11), fungi (12), and mammalian skin (13). The cross-β-sheet motif is composed of intermolecular β-sheets along the fibril axis with the β-strands aligned perpendicularly to the fibril axis. An amyloid-like structure of peptide and protein hormones in secretory granules could explain most of their properties.
To address the question whether peptide and protein hormones are stored in secretory granules in an amyloid-like aggregation state, we first asked if a diverse set of peptide and protein hormones could form amyloids in vitro at granule-relevant pH 5.5. 42 peptide and protein hormones from multiple species and organs were selected randomly, some linear and some cyclic, with a variety of different three dimensional structures (Table S2). This set of hormones was assayed for a capacity to form amyloids by the amyloid-specific dyes thioflavin T (Thio T), congo red (CR), luminescent conjugated polyelectrolyte probes (LCP), by the conformational transition into β-sheet-rich structure measured by circular dichroism (CD), and by the presence of fibrils in electron microscopy (EM) images. Furthermore, x-ray fiber diffraction was measured for a subset of hormones (Table S1). Only 10 hormones out of the 42 showed significant formation of amyloids (figs. S1 and S2, Table S1).
Given that only one quarter of peptides spontaneously formed amyloid fibrils in vitro (Table S1) and the possible involvement of glycosaminoglycans (GAG)s in the formation of both secretory granules and amyloid fibrils (14–22), the amyloid formation of all 42 peptides and proteins was monitored in the presence of low molecular weight (LMW) heparin as a representative of GAGs. Indeed, after two weeks of incubation in the presence of heparin, most hormones formed amyloid fibrils (Table S1) based on EM (Fig. 1A and fig. S3), Thio T binding (fig. S1), CD (Table S1, fig. S4), CR binding (Table S1, figs. S5A and S5B), LCP binding (fig. S5C), and x-ray fiber diffraction (fig. S5D). In addition, the algorithm TANGO predicted 18 hormones to be aggregation-prone (fig. S6). Thus, out of the 42 hormones, 31 formed amyloid fibrils in the presence of heparin by all methods studied. Nonconclusive data was obtained for four hormones (see SOM) and the alpha-helical CRF served as a negative control (see SOM). Possible explanations for the lack of amyloid aggregation of the remaining six hormones may be that these hormones do not form amyloid-like aggregates when stored in secretory granules, that fibrilization conditions were not optimal, or/and that another substance might be required for aggregation. Indeed, human prolactin did not form amyloids in the presence of heparin, but did in the presence of chondroitin sulfate A, which is a GAG found in prolactin-specific granules (16) (Table S1, Fig. 1A and fig. S1).
None of the adrenocorticotropic hormone’s (ACTHs) studied formed amyloid-like aggregates (Table S1). Because ACTH and β-endorphin are processed from the same prohormone (pro-opiomelanocortin) and secreted together in a regulated secretory pathway, we hypothesized that ACTH might need the amyloid-forming β-endorphin as an aggregation partner for storage in secretory granules. A 1:1 ACTH - β-endorphin mixture in the presence of heparin formed amyloid fibrils (fig. 1B) that comprise ACTH as measured by dot plot (Fig. 1C) and Trp fluorescence (Fig. 1D). The Trp/Tyr measurements also indicate that the ACTH – β-endorphin amyloid fibrils are composed of a 1:2 ratio of ACTH and β-endorphin present either in mixed or in individual fibrils (Fig. 1D). Since seeding experiments of ACTH with β-endorphin fibrils failed, we suggest that ACTH and β-endorphin form mixed fibrils. Since fibril-forming hypothalamic human CRF was not able to induce aggregation of the pituitary ACTH, the β-endorphin – ACTH aggregation appeared to be specific (figs. S8D and S8E, see also SOM and fig. S7). Coaggregation between β-endorphin and ACTH was further supported by a colocalization study of the two hormones in the tumor cell line AtT20 using double immunohistochemistry (Fig. 1E and fig. S7). A detailed analysis revealed that all the stained ACTH colocalized with β-endorphin, where as some β-endorphin did not colocalize with ACTH supporting the in vitro observation that ACTH aggregates only in the presence of β-endorphin. To show that the ACTH co-aggregation with β-endorphin was not an isolated case, coaggregation of Ghrelin with obestatin is documented in SOM (fig. S8).
The concept that peptide and protein hormones are stored in secretory granules in an amyloid-like aggregation state is challenged by the notion that amyloid fibrils are very stable and do not release monomers (but see (21)), a prerequisite upon granule secretion. To demonstrate that amyloid fibrils formed by hormones are able to release monomers, an amyloid release assay was performed (21) for a selection of hormone fibrils both at granule-relevant pH 6 and pH 7.4 at which the hormone aggregates are exposed upon secretion (Fig. 2 and fig. S9). The monomer release was monitored outside the membrane either by CD (Fig. 2B), UV or Trp fluorescence (fig. S9) and the remaining aggregates (inside the dialysis membrane) were monitored by Thio T binding (Fig. 2A, and fig. S9). All hormone fibrils studied appeared to release monomeric hormone upon dilution, because with time a drastic decrease of the Thio T binding was apparent and monomers were present outside the membrane. To show that the released monomers were functional, the monomer release of human CRF from its amyloid entity was investigated in more detail. The CD spectrum (Fig. 2B) indicated that the released human CRF comprises its functional helical structure. Furthermore, monomeric and aggregated human CRF activate cyclic AMP with similar efficacy in CHO cells expressing stably human type 1 CRF receptor (Fig. 2C) indicating that CRF amyloid fibrils release active monomer. The in vitro dialysis experiments with amyloid fibrils therefore resemble qualitatively the release abilities of isolated secretory granules (23).
Amyloid fibrils are thought to be toxic to neuronal cells (24). To test whether amyloids of hormones are toxic the 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-diphenyl tetrazolium bromide-formazan assay (MTT assay) with the neuronal cell line B12 was employed (24). Upon addition of 20 µM of Aβ(1–40) fibrils, the MTT reduction was decreased by 40% (fig. S10A). In contrast, many of the hormone amyloids formed in the presence of LMW heparin and all hormones that do not aggregate into amyloids induced no significant decrease in MTT reduction at 20 µM concentration. However, in contrast to monomers amyloids of ovine CRF, mUcnIII, hUcnIII, human GRF, and GLP-2 showed a similar response as Aβ(1–40), whereas glucagon amyloids interfered with the reduction of MTT almost twice as much (25). To further support the observation that some amyloids from hormones are moderately toxic, the neuronal cell survival of E18 rat hippocampal neurons was measured following the addition of amyloid fibrils of Aβ(1–42) and human CRF, which showed a moderate effect in the MTT assay (figs. S10B and S10C). Although Aβ(1–42) fibrils appeared to be one order of magnitude more toxic than human CRF fibrils, human CRF amyloids also influenced the survival of neurons with an IC50 of approximately ~20 µM. Although some hormone amyloids appear to be moderately toxic, their actual toxicity might be substantially diminished in vivo by their membrane-encapsulated state in the granules.
The above biophysical analysis of hormones supports the hypothesis that hormones are stored as amyloids in secretory granules. In this paragraph, direct evidence is provided that secretory granules of the mouse pituitary tumor neuroendocrine cell line AtT20 are composed of amyloids. The AtT20 cell line synthesizes precursors to corticotropin (i.e. ACTH and β-endorphin), and correctly glycosylates, cleaves, and stores them in secretory granules (26). Secretory granules of AtT20 cells with and without membrane were purified (fig. S11) and showed typical ACTH-containing electron-dense granules with a diameter of 200–600 nm surrounded by membrane (figs. S11B, S11C, and S11D). The purified granules from AtT20 cells were amyloid-like in nature as determined by amyloid-specific antibody (Fig. 3A), Thio T binding (Fig. 3B), CR binding (fig. S12), and CR birefringence (Fig. 3C). Finally, x-ray fiber diffraction was measured of purified membrane-less secretory granules (fig. S11B). A near membrane-free preparation of granules was used because membrane lipids attribute a very strong reflection at 4.1 Å close to the 4.7 Å reflection expected for a cross-β-sheet structure. The major reflections observed were at 4.7 Å interpreted as the spacing between strands in a β-sheet and a diffuse reflection at ~10 Å interpreted as the spacing between β-sheets (Fig. 3D). These reflections are typically observed for amyloid-like fibrils. The circular profiles of these reflections, rather than the normal orthogonal positions for the two reflections, show that the amyloid-like entities in granules are not strongly aligned.
Similarly, secretory granules of type light (L) and heavy (H) purified from rat pituitary (fig. S13) also contained amyloid-like material as evidenced by amyloid-specific antibody binding (Fig. 3E), Thio T binding (Fig. 3F), CR binding (figs. S12C and S12D) and birefringence (Figs. 3G, see also SOM). Furthermore, the x-ray diffraction pattern with membrane-less granules of type light show the typical cross β-sheet reflections at 4.7 Å and at ~10 Å in addition to a 4.1 Å reflection attributed to remaining membrane (Figs. 3H and 3J). The circular profiles for these reflections indicate that the amyloid-like entities in granules are not strongly aligned.
Immunohistochemical studies were performed with mouse pituitary tissue to probe whether secretory granules in neuroendocrine tissues are amyloid-like in nature. The positive binding of the amyloid-specific dye Thio-S both in the interior and posterior lobes of the pituitary was indicative of the abundant presence of amyloids in the pituitary of mouse (Fig. 4). To examine if the Thio-S detected amyloids were composed of endocrine hormones colocalization of Thio-S with hormone-specific antibodies was measured. There was almost complete colocalization between Thio-S and the hormones ACTH, β-endorphin, prolactin, and growth hormone (GH) in the interior lobe, ACTH in the intermediate lobe and oxytocin and vasopressin in the posterior lobe of the pituitary, respectively (Fig. 4), strongly supporting their storage in the secretory granules to be extensively amyloid-like. Similar results were obtained for a colocalization study between the fibril-specific antibody OC and the corresponding hormone antibodies.
The proposed amyloid-like conformation of peptide/protein hormones in secretory granules may explain the processes of granule formation including hormone selection, membrane surrounding as well as the inert hormone storage, and subsequently the release of hormones from the granules (fig. S14): It is proposed that in the Golgi, amyloid aggregation of the (pro)hormone is initiated spontaneously above a critical (pro)hormone concentration or/and in presence of helper molecules such as GAGs in parallel to a possible prohormone processing. Alternatively, since the prohormone may aggregate less into an amyloid entity than its hormone counterpart (27), the prohormone processing at critical hormone concentrations may initiate the aggregation. Since the formation of amyloid fibrils is amino acid sequence-specific, the initiated amyloid aggregation of the (pro)hormone is selective yielding granule cores composed of specific hormones only. Specific coaggregation of some hormones may be possible since some amyloid proteins are able to cross-seed (28, Fig. 1). The amyloid aggregation sorts thereby the protein/peptide hormones into secretory granule cores, concentrates them to the highest density possible and excludes non-aggregation-prone constitutively secreted proteins. During the aggregation process the hormone amyloids get surrounded by membrane, separate from the golgi and form mature granules. The membrane attraction may be spontaneous since membrane binding seems to be an inherent property of amyloid aggregates (29). Alternatively, since the cross-β sheet represents a single structural epitope it may serve as a possible recognition motive of an unknown granule-recruiting membrane protein. Once the secretory granules are formed they can be stored for long durations since the amyloid entity provides a very stable depot. Upon signaling, secretory granules are secreted and the cross-β sheet structure of the amyloid enables a controlled release of monomeric, functional hormone (21), which might be supported by chaperones.
The functional amyloid-state of many endocrine hormones in secretory granules of the pituitary (fig. 4) and possibly hypothalamus (i.e. CRF) and pancreas (for example somatostatin) contrasts directly the historical disease-association of amyloids both in the brain (such as tau, α-synuclein, Aβ, and prion protein) and in the pancreas (such as insulin and amylin). On the one hand, this challenges once more the “amyloid hypothesis” that amyloids are the most toxic culprit in amyloid diseases (30). On the other hand, hormone amyloids may not be (very) toxic since the hormone amyloids are stored inside the granules and the amyloid aggregation of hormones for secretory granule formation may be highly regulated. This regulation may include the processing of prohormones that aggregate slower than the hormone counterpart (27) or the required presence of helper molecules to induce aggregation as demonstrated for prolactin (note: prolactin lacks a prohormone). Furthermore, the hormone amyloids are stored in an “inert” membrane container and the amyloid fibrils dissociate upon secretion. Such regulations require a functional protein homeostasis. If the protein homeostasis is altered under certain conditions such as diet, stress and age, hormone aggregation may be out of control and disease-associated amyloid aggregation of hormones may occur (see below). Whether such aggregations cause disease, or are an indirect effect of the protein homeostasis altered by disease, remains to be determined.
There are many associations between amyloid processing and function of secretory granules: (i) Aggregation of hormones into secretory granules is an intracellular process, and upon secretion not all of the aggregates dissolve completely (31). Similarly, Aβ may be present in granules (32) and Aβ aggregation may be initiated intracellularly and ends up as a pathological hallmark in the extracellular space (30). (ii) The malaria drug chloroquine both interferes with the formation of secretory granules as well as prion infectivity (33, 34). (iii) The natural compound curcumin both interferes with the progression of Alzheimer’s disease (35) and the release of endocrine hormones (36). (iv) Several endocrine hormones that may be stored in secretory granules in an amyloid-like state are present as amyloids in amyloid diseases. These include amylin associated with diabetes type II, calcitonin associated with medullary carcinoma of the thyroid, and atrial natriuretic factor with artial amyloidosis (37). Hence, the presence of many functional amyloids in the body together with the apparent tight link between functional and disease-associated amyloids in their processing, biophysical and biochemical properties require a rethinking of the relationship between aggregation and function of polypeptides, and the correlation between amyloid aggregation and toxicity.
We thank S. Maji for the cartoon drawing in fig. S14; S. Pisani and C. Peto for technical assistance; C.R. Grace and C. Tzitzilonis for valuable suggestions; P.S. Dannies and M.E. Hodsdon for valuable suggestions and the plasmid of human prolactin; and C. Glabe for the OC antibody. Supported by the Swiss National Foundation, Clayton Medical Research Foundation Inc., and National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (NIDDK) grant P01 DK026741-29. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of NIDDK or NIH. W.V. is a cofounder, consultant, equity holder, and member of the Board of Directors and Scientific Advisory Board of Neurocrine Biosciences Inc. and Acceleron Pharma Inc. J.R. is founder and owner of Sentia Medical Sciences Inc. and is coinventor in several patents covering CRF receptor ligands.
One-sentence summary: Peptide and protein hormones are stored in secretory granules in an amyloid conformation