As evidenced in the sections above, the CLOCK system and HPA axis influence the activity and function of the CNS and peripheral tissues, while the master CLOCK system clearly dictates the circadian activity of the HPA axis. In the following sections, we discuss these mutual interactions and their implications in the development of pathologic conditions, with metabolic and immune disorders as illustrative examples.
Intermediary metabolism handles the turnover of carbohydrates, proteins and lipids, as well as energy production/storage, all functions essential for survival. Expression of a substantial number (~10%) of the energy-controlling genes, including those encoding nuclear hormone receptors and enzymes for glucose and lipid metabolism, are under circadian regulation, in a tissue-specific fashion
38–41. One nuclear receptor, Rev-erbα, which is also a negative regulator of the circadian CLOCK transcription circuit, suppresses gluconeogenesis and lipid metabolism in the liver, inhibits adipocyte differentiation and represses the transcriptional activity of several other nuclear receptors, including PPARγ and RORα
42, 43. Mice defective in the
Clock or
Bmal1 gene demonstrate disturbances in gluconeogenesis and defective diurnal variation of circulating glucose and triglycerides, and develop obesity, hyperlipidemia and diabetes mellitus
44, 45, as well as elevated expression of the plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 (PAI-1), all known risk factors for obesity, diabetes and cardiovascular disease
46–48. Another CLOCK protein, Per2, represses PAI-1 expression in a Clock/Bmal1-dependent manner, indicating that Per2 is also an interface for the development of these metabolic diseases upon dysregulation of the CLOCK system
48. In humans, rotating shift workers whose circadian system is continuously reset by night-time activity/day-time sleep show a higher risk of obesity, hypertension, high triglycerides, insulin resistance and subsequent development of ischemic heart disease
49, 50. Furthermore, specific single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) within the
Clock gene have been associated with development of obesity
51, 52, while mRNA expression of
Bmal1,
Per2 and
Cry1 in visceral fat are associated with increased waist circumference, an indicator of visceral adiposity and the metabolic syndrome
53.
Persistent stimulation of the HPA axis by various stressors or administration of high doses of glucocorticoids strongly shift intermediary metabolism toward catabolism and visceral fat accumulation
19, 22. Elevated circulating glucocorticoids stimulate gluconeogenesis, glycogenolysis, lipolysis and degradation of proteins into amino acids, and over time cause central obesity and insulin resistance/overt diabetes mellitus, hyper(dys)lipidemia and muscle loss and thinning of the skin, all of which are typically observed in patients with Cushing’s syndrome
19, 22, 54.
Interestingly, most of the metabolic phenotypes associated with dysregulation of the CLOCK system and the HPA axis overlap with each other (). Whether disruption of the former system leads to metabolic problems through modulation of the HPA axis, or these distinct systems influence the same metabolic pathways independently is not known. We hypothesize that both mechanisms are functional in the development of the metabolic syndrome upon dysregulation of the CLOCK system. Indeed, several molecules, such as PPARγ, PAI-I and PGC1α, which play key roles in intermediary metabolism, respond to both the CLOCK system and glucocorticoids; furthermore, mice defective in the clock genes, such as
Per1−/− and
Per2−/− mice, have defective glucose metabolism and obesity with an impaired HPA axis and altered diurnal glucocorticoid rhythm
26, 27. Furthermore, Clock/Bmal1-mediated modulation of GR-induced transcriptional activity may also participate in the development of metabolic abnormalities, as these transcription factors suppress glucocorticoid-induced mRNA expression of glucose-6 phosphatase, a rate-limiting enzyme in the process of glycogenolysis
36.
| Table 3Metabolic Disturbances Associated with Loss of Circadian Rhythm or Glucocorticoid Excess. |
The circadian activity in the sensitivity of glucocorticoid target tissues to cortisol may explain the development of central obesity and the metabolic syndrome in chronically stressed individuals, whose HPA axis circadian rhythm is characterized by blunting of the evening decreases of circulating glucocorticoids, as a result of enhanced input of higher centers upon the hypothalamic PVN secretion of CRH and AVP (). Similarly disrupted coupling of the secretion of cortisol and target tissue sensitivity to glucocorticoids may explain the increased cardiometabolic risk of persons who are exposed to frequent jet lag because of traveling across time zones
55, 56.
Similar interactions between the CLOCK system and the HPA axis are also observed in the regulation of immune function. In both humans and rodents, the CLOCK system produces a circadian fluctuation of several cytokines, including interferon (IFN) γ, interleukin-1 (IL-1)β, IL-6, and TNFα in T- and B-lymphocytes and natural killer cells
57, 58. Indeed, knockout mice defective in components of the CLOCK system demonstrate various immune dysfunctions, such as a blunted and/or absent circadian rhythm in circulating leukocytes and cytokine secretion, an impaired response to lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-induced endotoxic shock and defective B-lymphocyte development
57, 58. Activation of the HPA axis and subsequent release of glucocorticoids, in turn, strongly influence immune activity and the inflammatory reaction
4, 19, 22. Physiologic concentrations of glucocorticoids are crucial for proper function of the immune system, whereas pharmacologic doses and/or high concentrations observed under stress strongly suppress its activity primarily by repressing the activity of transcription factors/other molecules crucial for the regulation of immune function/inflammation, such as activator protein-1 (AP-1), NF-κB and STAT5, through protein-protein interaction with GR
20, 21, 59. Since many immune cells are in the circulation, with decreased access to the CNS, their peripheral CLOCK system seems to be mainly regulated through humoral factors, including glucocorticoids, that are under the control of the central CLOCK
58. The CLOCK system may also regulate immune function and lead to development of immunologic defects in part through modulation of endogenously secreted glucocorticoid actions on numerous components of the immune system via mutual interaction between transcription factors Clock/Bmal1 and GR.