A small but growing literature suggests that
BRCA1/2 carriers may benefit from post-disclosure interventions over the short- to intermediate-term (
17,
29). The current randomized controlled trial evaluated the effects of post-disclosure psychosocial telephone counseling on psychological functioning in female
BRCA1/2 mutation carriers. Six months after result notification,
BRCA1/2 mutation carriers randomized to PTC reported significant decreases in depressive symptoms, were less likely to meet criteria for clinically significant anxiety, and reported significant decreases in genetic testing distress relative to those randomized to SGC. To our knowledge, this is the first study to report that post-disclosure telephone counseling reduces psychological distress among
BRCA1/2 mutation carriers.
Although the beneficial effects of the PTC intervention were seen at 6- but not at 12-months, there is reason to speculate that reducing distress in the immediate aftermath of receiving a positive test result could have important benefits. Considerable evidence documents the impact of affect on decision-making and risk comprehension (
10,
30,
31). Given the complexity of decision-making following
BRCA1/2 testing (
32), an intervention that reduces distress during this crucial decision making period could improve informed decision making, risk comprehension and family communication. Although PTC did not impact participants’ stress or confidence appraisals, future research should further explore the overall role of affect on
BRCA1/2 risk management decision making (
9–
11).
In addition to the potential benefits on risk-management decision making, our results and prior research suggest that adjunct interventions may provide benefits to subgroups of women who undergo
BRCA1/2 genetic counseling and testing (
9). Specifically, support programs like PTC may be most useful for women identified by genetic counselors as highly anxious or undecided about management options (
8). Future studies can explore the best methods for identifying such at-risk subgroups, investigate the theoretical mechanisms by which support programs produce change, and evaluate the most effective timing and delivery approaches for supportive adjunct interventions.
The beneficial effect of psychosocial telephone counseling on depressive symptoms, clinical levels of anxiety, and genetic testing distress should be interpreted in a larger context. First, it is noteworthy that a telephone counseling intervention can have a positive effect on psychological functioning within this specific population. This novel method of care delivery increases the portability of counseling services by overcoming transportation and geographic barriers (
33). Second, it is possible that reduced anxiety and distress may improve comprehension of genetic risk information and may facilitate decision-making about screening, managing risk, and communicating risk information (
31,
34). Third, it is important to note that although clinically-relevant levels of anxiety were reduced, the level of depressive symptoms reported by participants would not require psychiatric intervention (
24), findings consistent with prior research in this area (
2). Although psychiatric intervention is not indicated for the majority of
BRCA1/2 mutation carriers, interventions that provide short-term support may be beneficial for subgroups of carriers or women who self-select into these types of support interventions.
There are several limitations to this study. First, the small sample of 90
BRCA1/2 mutation carriers was homogenous; participants were Caucasian and reported high levels of education and income. Results need to be evaluated using larger and more diverse samples to improve power to detect intervention effects and extend generalizability of the results. Second, not all PTC participants completed the intervention and we did not assess the extent to which the women read or used the intervention materials. These concerns are mitigated by our use of intention-to-treat analyses, the fact that the majority (76%) of women randomized to PTC did complete the intervention, and similar rates of study retention between the PTC and SGC groups. Third, the impact of the intervention observed at 6 months was not sustained at 12-months. Future work can explore the best methods to maintain long-term effects. Despite these limitations, the present study is the first randomized clinical trial to demonstrate the beneficial effects of post-disclosure telephone counseling on psychological functioning among mutation carriers. Given the availability of direct-to-consumer genetic testing for a variety of health conditions including online testing for the three
BRCA1/2 founder mutations (
35), the value of adjunctive support services like psychosocial telephone counseling is likely to increase. Our findings add to the growing literature on adjunct interventions following genetic counseling by demonstrating that a post-disclosure telephone psychosocial intervention is feasible and provides short-to-intermediate term benefits for
BRCA1/2 carriers.