PMCCPMCCPMCC

Search tips
Search criteria 

Advanced

 
Logo of aemPermissionsJournals.ASM.orgJournalAEM ArticleJournal InfoAuthorsReviewers
 
Appl Environ Microbiol. 2010 April; 76(8): 2451–2460.
Published online 2010 February 26. doi:  10.1128/AEM.02667-09
PMCID: PMC2849203

Differential Effects of Rare Specific Flavonoids on Compatible and Incompatible Strains in the Myrica gale-Frankia Actinorhizal Symbiosis[down-pointing small open triangle]

Abstract

Plant secondary metabolites, and specifically phenolics, play important roles when plants interact with their environment and can act as weapons or positive signals during biotic interactions. One such interaction, the establishment of mutualistic nitrogen-fixing symbioses, typically involves phenolic-based recognition mechanisms between host plants and bacterial symbionts during the early stages of interaction. While these mechanisms are well studied in the rhizobia-legume symbiosis, little is known about the role of plant phenolics in the symbiosis between actinorhizal plants and Frankia genus strains. In this study, the responsiveness of Frankia strains to plant phenolics was correlated with their symbiotic compatibility. We used Myrica gale, a host species with narrow symbiont specificity, and a set of compatible and noncompatible Frankia strains. M. gale fruit exudate phenolics were extracted, and 8 dominant molecules were purified and identified as flavonoids by high-resolution spectroscopic techniques. Total fruit exudates, along with two purified dihydrochalcone molecules, induced modifications of bacterial growth and nitrogen fixation according to the symbiotic specificity of strains, enhancing compatible strains and inhibiting incompatible ones. Candidate genes involved in these effects were identified by a global transcriptomic approach using ACN14a strain whole-genome microarrays. Fruit exudates induced differential expression of 22 genes involved mostly in oxidative stress response and drug resistance, along with the overexpression of a whiB transcriptional regulator. This work provides evidence for the involvement of plant secondary metabolites in determining symbiotic specificity and expands our understanding of the mechanisms, leading to the establishment of actinorhizal symbioses.

Over the course of evolution, plants have developed many strategies to adapt to their environment and manage their biotic interactions. The production of secondary metabolites is an important tool in many of these strategies. In particular, secondary metabolites are involved in plant-microbe interactions both as weapons in plant defense mechanisms and as early signals in mutualistic as well as pathogenic relationships (22). For example, sesquiterpenes and flavonoids are involved in the early steps of arbuscular mycorrhizal symbiosis (1, 62). Similarly, in the early stages of the rhizobia-legume symbiosis, recognition of host flavonoids enhances rhizospheric competitiveness and root colonization and is the basic mechanism through which rhizobia induce the transcription of nod genes, leading to root hair deformation and nodulation in the plant tissues (13, 49, 55).

Actinorhizal symbiosis is a less well-known nitrogen-fixing interaction, resulting from the association between the actinobacterium Frankia and plants belonging to eight dicotyledonous families collectively called “actinorhizal”: Betulaceae, Myricaceae, Rosaceae, Datiscaceae, Elaeagnaceae, Coriariaceae, Casuarinaceae, and Rhamnaceae (8). Due to the nitrogen-fixing ability of their symbionts, actinorhizal plants, together with legumes, are a major source of bioavailable reduced nitrogen in ecosystems. The woody perennial characteristics of actinorhizal plants, the isolation of the symbiont in pure culture only in 1978, the lack of genetic tools to study Frankia, and the very low growth rate of the bacterial isolates have restricted progress in understanding the mechanisms involved in this symbiosis. Recently, however, the genome sequences of several Frankia strains have been released and show that there are no canonical nod genes in Frankia (45), suggesting a novel interaction mechanism may be acting in actinorhizal symbioses.

Despite this difference, legumes and actinorhizal plants belong to the same rosid I phylogenetic group (61), and their symbioses share several central features at the plant or the microbial level. For example, Frankia, like rhizobia, produces an extracellular root hair-deforming factor, and in both cases, plant secondary metabolites likely play a role in host recognition. Previous studies of actinorhizal symbioses have shown that nodulation in Alnus may be inhibited or enhanced by different seed flavonoids (7), and cell-specific flavan biosynthesis and accumulation occur in Casuarina glauca nodules (36). At the genetic level, expression of pal (phenylalanine ammonia lyase) and chs (chalcone synthase) genes, involved in flavonoid biosynthesis, is enhanced in Alnus glutinosa root systems after inoculation with a Frankia strain (24). These studies strongly suggest the involvement of plant phenolics in the first steps of the actinorhizal symbiosis.

Host specificity among Frankia strains has led to the description of the following three major host specificity groups (HSG) that correlate with strain 16S rRNA phylogeny: Alnus-Comptonia-infective strains (cluster 1a), Casuarinaceae-infective strains (cluster 1b), and Elaeagnaceae-infective strains (cluster 3) (44). Among actinorhizal plants, the family Myricaceae is a good experimental model to study the specificity of symbiotic interactions, as it includes species with either narrow or broad symbiont specificity. Most Myricaceae species are promiscuous (nonselective for Frankia strains), but Myrica gale exhibits a narrow symbiont specificity, being nodulated only by cluster 1a strains (5, 27). In addition, M. gale has the novel trait of exuding droplets of secondary metabolites at the fruit surface, and the phenolic contents of these metabolites are significantly different from those of other broad symbiont specificity Myricaceae species (our unpublished data).

In this study, we determined whether the responses of different Frankia strains to fruit exudates were correlated with symbiotic specificity. We hypothesize that the main parameters involved in symbiotic efficiency are (i) strain growth and competitiveness in the rhizosphere and (ii) nitrogen fixation activity. We thus purified and identified major M. gale fruit exudate constituents and evaluated their effects on growth and nitrogen fixation of compatible (cluster 1a) and noncompatible (cluster 1b and 3) Frankia strains. In addition, global transcriptional effects of total fruit exudates were assessed using Frankia whole-genome microarrays in order to identify the genes possibly involved in the molecular mechanisms of the Frankia-M. gale symbiosis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Plant material.

M. gale fruits were collected in December 2004 on the shore of Biscarosse Lake, Bordeaux, France. A voucher specimen was deposited at the herbarium of the Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1, Villeurbanne, France, under the name “Collection Piola” and collector number 3. Air-dried fruits (350 g) were sonicated (40 kHz; Branson 2510) twice in 2 liters of methanol and evaporated, producing 35 g of dried residue. This extract was then diluted in methanol for the further steps of the analyses.

Chromatographic analysis, purification, and structural elucidation of flavonoids.

Chromatographic analysis of the extracts was performed on an Agilent 1200 series high-performance liquid chromatograph (HPLC) equipped with a degasser (G132A), a quaternary pump module (G1311A), an automatic sampler (G1329A), and a diode array detector (DAD) (G1315B). Separations were carried out using a Kromasil reverse-phase C18 (RP18) column (250 by 4.6 mm, 5 μm, 100 Å), with a linear gradient of acetonitrile in water from 0% to 100% in 60 min supplemented with formic acid (0.4%). Chromatograms were recorded between 200 and 700 nm, and a specific channel settled at 280 nm was used to monitor chromatographic traces.

Gel filtration on Sephadex LH-20 and repeated chromatographic steps (medium-pressure liquid chromatography [MPLC] and HPLC) on RP18 and on silica of the fruit exudate extract led to the purification of 8 compounds (Fig. (Fig.1).1). The structural elucidation of the molecules was achieved by UV spectroscopy (Agilent 8453 UV spectrophotometer) recorded between 220 and 500 nm, HPLC-mass spectrometry (HPLC-MS), and by 1H and 13C mono- and bidimensional nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) (Bruker DRX 500). For HPLC-MS analysis, the HPLC system described above was interfaced with an HP MSD (mass-selective detector) 1100 series, allowing use of the same chromatographic conditions as those used for HPLC-DAD analysis. Mass spectrometry with an atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (APCI) interface had the following operating conditions: gas temperature of 330°C at a flow rate of 9.0 liters min−1, nebulizer pressure of 50 lb/in2, quadripole temperature of 30°C, capillary voltage of 4,000 V, and fragmentor voltage of 100 V. Full-scan spectra from m/z 100 to 900 in both positive and negative ion modes were recorded.

FIG. 1.
Purification strategy of Myrica gale fruit exudate compounds. Identified compounds are numbered from 1 to 8. 1, myrigalone A; 2, myrigalone E; 3, myrigalone B; 4, uvangoletin; 5, myrigalone P; 6, demethoxymatteucinol; 7, myrigalone D; 8, demethoxymatteucinol-7-methyl ...

Frankia strains and growth measurement.

Frankia strains used in this study belong to the three major HSG (Table (Table1).1). Five-day-old cultures (end of exponential growth phase) were used as inocula. Nitrogen-free basal medium with propinate (BAP medium) (42) was inoculated with a normalized number of cell equivalent to 75 mg liter−1 of bacterial lyophilized biomass. Homogenization of inocula was done by repeated forced passages through a 0.6-mm-diameter syringe. Total fruit exudate extract or purified compounds from M. gale were added to 20 ml BAP medium simultaneously with Frankia inoculation. Phenolic mixture or purified molecules were dissolved in 100 μl of methanol to final concentrations ranging from 10−4 to 10 mg liter−1. The same volume of methanol was added to the controls and was shown to have no effect on Frankia growth and nitrogen fixation.

TABLE 1.
Frankia strains tested

After 5 days, Frankia cells were sedimented by centrifugation at 5,000 × g for 15 min and washed three times with sterilized ultrapure water, and pellets were lyophilized. The effects of plant phenolic extracts on bacterial growth were tested by comparing the average weights of lyophilized Frankia cells for triplicates of each assay. Significant differences in means were assessed by Student's t test (P < 0.05). After bacterial growth in the presence or absence of the plant extracts, the resulting phenolic compounds present in the supernatants were extracted by solid-phase extraction (SPE; RP18) and eluted with methanol. Analyses of subsequent extracts were performed by HPLC in the same chromatographic system as that of the plant extracts described previously.

Nitrogen-fixing activity.

Nitrogen-fixing activity was assessed by measuring the reduction of acetylene to ethylene (acetylene reduction assay [ARA]). Frankia strains were grown in 50 ml of BAP medium for 1, 3, and 5 days in the presence of 1 mg liter−1 of M. gale fruit exudates. A total of 10 ml of acetylene corresponding to 10% in the atmosphere of the incubation flask was injected 24 h prior to the chromatographic analysis. Ethylene production was measured by injecting 0.4 ml of the culture atmosphere into a gas chromatograph equipped with a flame ionization detector (FID; Girdel). The injector temperature was 50°C, the oven temperature was maintained at 40°C, the vector gas used was nitrogen (2.5 bar), and the FID, functioning with pressurized air (1 bar) and hydrogen (2.3 bar), was heated to 150°C. The effect of M. gale fruit exudates on nitrogen-fixing activity was evaluated by comparing the average quantities of ethylene produced for triplicates of each assay. Quantifications were done by utilization of defined volumes of ethylene (Air Liquide). The amounts of ethylene produced for each assay were then normalized by the dry weight of the lyophilized bacterial cells. Significant differences in means were assessed by Student's t test (P < 0.05).

Frankia ACN14a gene expression. (i) Preparation of total RNA.

Assay and control cultures were performed in 250 ml of BAP medium inoculated with 0.4 g of cell pellets from a BAP medium mother culture. Assay cultures were grown in the presence of M. gale fruit exudates (1 mg liter−1 in 0.5% methanol). Two controls were made, a methanol control (BAP medium with 0.5% methanol) and a BAP control (with neither exudates nor methanol) in order to assess the effect of methanol itself on ACN14a transcriptome (see the supplemental material). Three biological replicates were performed for assay cultures and BAP controls, and two biological replicates were performed for methanol controls. After 5 days of culture, stirring was stopped in order to gently sediment cells during the night. Supernatants were carefully discarded, and cells were treated with RNAprotect bacterial reagent (Qiagen, Courtaboeuf, France) for stabilization of RNA. To purify RNA, stabilized cells were processed by using the RNeasy plant minikit (Qiagen) and on-column DNase digestion with the RNase-free DNase set (Qiagen). In order to avoid contamination with any remaining DNA, a second DNase treatment was performed with RQ1 RNase-free DNase (Promega, Charbonnières-les-Bains, France), followed by RNA cleanup using the RNeasy minikit. Purity, concentration, and quality of RNA samples were checked using a NanoDrop 1000 spectrophotometer (Thermo Fischer Scientific, Courtaboeuf, France) and agarose gel electrophoresis. A 0.24- to 9.5-kb RNA ladder (Invitrogen, Illkirch, France) was used as a standard.

(ii) Whole-genome expression microarray analysis.

Based on the sequence and annotation data for the Frankia alni ACN14a genome (45), a whole-genome high-density microarray was designed and manufactured by Roche NimbleGen, Inc. (Madison, WI). Due to the high GC content (72.8%) of the F. alni genome, a 60-mer oligo length was chosen for probe design. NimbleGen design rules and analysis algorithms found probes for 6,607 out of 6,786 genes. For 6,340 genes, 18 probes per gene were obtained, and for 267 genes, 1 to 17 probes per gene were obtained. Probes were duplicated on the array. RNA quality analysis using the Agilent 2100 Bioanalyzer, double-stranded cDNA synthesis, and labeling by random priming with Cy3 dye-labeled 9-mers, hybridization at 42°C, array scanning, and data extraction were performed by the NimbleGen expression service lab (Reykjavik, Iceland), according to its standard protocol. Array normalization was performed using the quantile normalization method (10). Normalized gene expression values were generated using the robust multichip average (RMA) algorithm (28). Data were further analyzed using the GeneSpring gene expression analysis software version 7.3 (Agilent Technologies, Massy, France). Genes were considered differentially expressed between the two biological conditions if the increase/decrease was >80% in all pairwise comparisons yielded by biological replicates. Hence, six pairwise comparisons were generated when comparing cells in Bap medium with methanol (2 replicates) with exudates (3 replicates).

RESULTS

Characterization of the major compounds of M. gale fruit exudates.

Ultrasound-assisted washing of 350 g of M. gale fruits in methanol led to 35 g of dry extract. HPLC-DAD-MS chromatograms indicated a majority of flavonoids along with terpenes among detectable compounds. After fractionation of the extract, eight compounds were purified, and their absolute structures were obtained by NMR analysis and by comparing NMR experimental data with the literature for the known molecules (Fig. (Fig.2).2). All structures are also in accordance with UV and MS spectra (data not shown). Seven of these compounds have previously been isolated from various plants and described in the literature, and one is a new natural product.

FIG. 2.
Structures of compounds purified from M. gale fruit exudates. Compounds 1 to 5, dihydrochalcones; compound 7, chalcone; compounds 6 and 8, flavanones.

The known compounds were identified as myrigalone A (MyA) (37), myrigalone E (MyE) (3), myrigalone B (MyB) (37), uvangoletin (26), demethoxymatteucinol (64), myrigalone D (MyD) (37), and demethoxymatteucinol-7-methyl ether (31), on the basis of a comparison of their 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopic data with those reported previously.

The fifth compound was obtained as a white powder. Its APCI-negative and positive MS spectra gave a molecular weight of 286. Its 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopic data are given in Table Table2.2. All assignments are based on bidimensional heteronuclear multiple-quantum coherence (HMQC) and heteronuclear multiple-bond coherence (HMBC) experiments. This compound is described here for the first time as a natural product, and the name myrigalone P (MyP) was assigned to this molecule. Three major compounds represented 80% of the total extract, MyA, MyB, and uvangoletin, with 40%, 20%, and 20%, respectively. The others are minor molecules (<1% to 3%).

TABLE 2.
Myrigalone P 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopic dataa

Effect of total fruit exudates on Frankia growth.

A total of 14 Frankia strains belonging to the three major HSG were tested for their responsiveness to M. gale fruit exudates. All but two strains (assigned to group C) were significantly affected, six strains (assigned to group A) showed inhibited growth, and six other strains (assigned to group B) showed enhanced growth compared with that of controls (Fig. (Fig.33).

FIG. 3.
Biomass of Frankia strains in the presence of M. gale fruit exudates. (A) Growth inhibition; (B) growth enhancement; (C) growth unaffected. Methanolic exudate solutions were added at 1 and 10 mg liter−1 to Frankia cultures, and exudate-free controls ...

All the affected strains (inhibited or enhanced) respond at 1 mg liter−1 total exudates. In order to determine the minimal active concentration of total fruit exudates, further experiments using concentrations from 0.1 μg liter−1 to 1 mg liter−1 were conducted on the following four strains, representative of the two affected groups: Ea112 and Cg704 (inhibited strains) and ACN14a and M16467 (enhanced strains) (Table (Table3).3). The lowest concentration at which growth of Ea112 and Cg704 was inhibited was 100 μg liter−1, whereas the lowest concentration at which growth of ACN14a and M16467 was enhanced was 1 μg liter−1.

TABLE 3.
Biomass of Frankia strains grown in the presence of M. gale fruit exudates

In order to determine whether these effects were due to trophic utilization of fruit exudates or response to a signal produced by exudates, phenolic compounds in the culture supernatants of the four strains were analyzed after bacterial growth. The HPLC chromatograms showed no quantitative or qualitative differences between Frankia culture supernatants and controls (culture media plus fruit exudates without bacterium) (data not shown), indicating that no metabolization, chemical transformation, or degradation of exudates via exoenzymes occurred. Besides, measures performed on fruit exudates showed very small amounts of total nitrogen, indicating that those exudates are not a significant source of nitrogen for Frankia (our unpublished data). These results suggest signal processes and not trophic functions of fruit exudates on growth enhancement of compatible strains.

Effect of purified compounds on Frankia growth.

In order to identify compounds responsible for the activity of total fruit exudates, the three major molecules and the new natural product (MyA, MyB, MyP, and uvangoletin) were evaluated for their effect on the growth of four Frankia strains, Ea112, Cg704, ACN14a, and M16467 (Table (Table44).

TABLE 4.
Biomass of Frankia strains grown in the presence of purified compounds from M. gale fruit exudates

Whereas MyA and uvangoletin had no significant effect on Frankia growth, MyB and MyP affected Frankia growth similarly to total exudate extract: inhibition of Ea112 and Cg704 and enhancement of ACN14a and M16467. In order to determine the lowest active concentration, those two molecules were also tested at 1, 10, and 100 μg liter−1. None were active below 1 mg liter−1.

Effect of M. gale fruit exudates on nitrogen fixation activity.

Fruit exudates at 1 mg liter−1 were tested for their effect on the nitrogen fixation activity of the four representative Frankia strains by ARA. At 24 h after inoculation, ARA of incompatible strains (Ea112 and Cg704) was significantly inhibited, whereas ARA of compatible strains (ACN14a and M16467) was significantly enhanced (Fig. (Fig.4).4). However, whichever the strain, these differences were no longer significant at 3 and 5 days after induction by plant extracts.

FIG. 4.
Effect of M. gale fruit exudates on nitrogen fixation activity of four Frankia strains. Nitrogen fixation activity was assessed by the acetylene reduction assay (10% volume). Ethylene production in nmol of ethylene per mg of lyophilized cell produced ...

Frankia ACN14a gene expression.

M. gale exudates at 1 mg liter−1 induced differential modification of the growth and nitrogen fixation of Frankia, depending on the compatibility statuses of strains. We have previously shown (4) that this concentration also induced substantial modifications of bacterial protein expression. To investigate the effects of these exudates at the transcriptional level, we performed whole-genome microarrays on Frankia ACN14a cells growing in the presence of the extract of fruit exudates. Fruit exudates induced differential expression of 22 genes compared to that induced by controls (Table (Table5).5). Most were downregulated. Eight genes had an annotated function: a cytochrome c oxidase (FRAAL6078), a putative membrane-bound O-acyltransferase (FRAAL6221), a putative lyase (FRAAL6071), and a putative multicopper oxidase-encoding gene (FRAAL4284) were downregulated, whereas genes coding for rubrerythrin (FRAAL5116), a putative Fur family peroxide operon regulator (FRAAL5117), a putative WhiB family transcriptional regulator (FRAAL2286), and a putative multidrug export protein (FRAAL1973) were upregulated.

TABLE 5.
Differentially expressed Frankia ACN14a genes in the presence of M. gale fruit exudatea

DISCUSSION

Phytochemical characterization of M. gale fruit exudates.

In this work, fruit exudates were studied for their involvement in the Frankia-M. gale symbiosis. We chose fruit extracts instead of root exudates because of the difficulty of obtaining sufficient quantity and reproducibility with root exudates. Moreover, the flavonoids that are active in Rhizobium nod gene induction have been identified from seeds and seed coats of alfalfa (25), and flavonoid-like compounds from Alnus rubra seeds have been shown to influence nodulation of that host by Frankia (7). Finally, those fruit exudates are the first compounds released in the soil when the germination of the seeds occurs and thus might be involved in the first steps of the interactions between the root plantlets and the rhizospheric environment, in particular with Frankia strains, as M. gale is rapidly nodulated by its symbiont after germination.

The quantity and chemical diversity of M. gale fruit exudates were such as to represent 10% of fruit dry weight and more than 30 different HPLC signals. These results imply a strong investment of plant photosynthates into exudate production and suggest that fruit exudates may impact deeply the rhizospheric environment. However, in spite of the great quantity of secondary metabolites present on the fruits, the degree to which they permeate the soil remains unclear, as it is affected by many parameters, such as the water solubility of each molecule and the nature of the soil matrix. Phenolic bioavailability in soil is poorly documented, and more data are needed concerning spatial and temporal distribution of flavonoids in soils and their effects on rhizospheric microorganisms (57, 58).

The compounds identified in this study are flavonoids. Among the 8 identified, 5 are dihydrochalcones (Fig. (Fig.2).2). This class of flavonoids is quite rare in the plant kingdom. Interestingly, dihydrochalcones have previously been identified in a few Fabaceae species, but no nod-inducing activity has been reported for those compounds, whereas several chalcones are known to be nod inducers (2, 41, 50, 54).

Among the compounds described here, four were previously identified in other Myricaceae species as follows: demethoxymatteucinol in Morella pensylvanica, a species with broad symbiont specificity, MyB, MyE, and MyD in Morella serrata, and MyB in Comptonia peregrina (both hosts with unknown symbiotic specificity) (19, 64). The other compounds (MyA, MyP, uvangoletin, and demethoxymatteucinol-7-methyl ether) have been described only in M. gale among actinorhizal plants. The presence of these four metabolites in the global phenolic content of M. gale (a narrow-specificity species) and their absence in Morella pensylvanica and Morella cerifera (two broad-specificity Myricaceae spp.) suggest that these compounds are good candidates for an involvement in the restricted symbiont range of M. gale.

Several biological activities have been reported for those dihydrochalcones, and among them, antioxidant and radical scavenging properties were described (38, 40). The highest radical scavenger, MyB, and MyA have also been reported to perturb the oxidative electron transfers in the respiratory chain of rat mitochondria and to inhibit ATP synthesis, indicating a high effect of those flavonoids on the membrane redox environment (39).

The effect of M. gale fruit exudates on Frankia growth and nitrogen fixation is related to strain symbiotic compatibility.

The symbiotic specificity of M. gale has been previously studied using cross-inoculation experiments as well as in field studies (27), and only cluster 1a strains have ever been reported to establish a symbiosis with M. gale. All but two of the strains studied here have their growth either inhibited or enhanced by M. gale fruit exudates (Fig. (Fig.3).3). All the growth-enhanced strains belong to the Alnus-Comptonia HSG (cluster 1a), which includes all the strains nodulating M. gale, whereas all the growth-inhibited strains belong to clusters 1b and 3. The minimal active concentration for which there is still a growth enhancement of the compatible strains is 1 μg liter−1. Considering the structures of the purified compounds and an average molecular mass of 300 g mol−1 for a flavonoid, the molar concentration is approximately 10−9 M, which is a typical active-signal concentration, as observed for example in the rhizobial symbiosis. It is worthwhile to note that the minimal active concentration for which there is still a growth inhibition is about 100 μg liter−1, corresponding to 10−7 M. This 100-fold difference between these two minimally active concentrations suggests either different targets or different signal molecules involved in the process.

Similarly, aqueous extracts of Casuarina cunninghamiana tissues stimulate the growth of several Frankia strains (66). Flavonoids released from host plants have been also described as involved in the microbial growth modulation in other symbiosis. Indeed, daidzein and luteolin not only are nod inducers but also increase Bradyrhizobium japonicum and Sinorhizobium meliloti growth, respectively (15, 25). Flavonoids released from host plants have also been described as hyphal growth inductors in the mycorrhizal symbiosis (6). On the contrary, depending on concentration, rhizobial growth inhibition by flavonoids has been reported with various selective effects. For example, medicarpin, a phytoalexin produced by Trifolium species and Medicago sativa, inhibits growth of incompatible strains (Bradyrhizobium japonicum) but has no effect on compatible rhizobia, thus participating in the selection of rhizospheric bacterial populations (46). Besides, glyceollin from Glycine max inhibits its own symbionts, indicating the complexity of regulation between symbiosis induction and plant defense (47).

Among the four tested flavonoids, MyB and MyP show similar patterns of biological activity on compatible and incompatible Frankia strains as the total extract. This strongly suggests the involvement of dihydrochalcones in the molecular mechanisms of the symbiosis. However, these pure compounds are not active below 1,000 μg liter−1, whereas total extract remains active at 1 μg liter−1. This difference between thresholds suggests that single compounds are not individually responsible for the effect observed with the total extract. A synergistic effect between different compounds could be at the root of growth modulation of Frankia strains. In the rhizobial symbiosis, such a synergy has previously been described. Combinations of inducers like eriodictyol and naringenin together with genistein and liquiritigenin on pea rhizobia generate higher nod gene expression than each compound alone (13). However, no synergistic effect was observed in our experiments with any combination of flavonoids tested, even with MyB and MyP together (data not shown). Other plant compounds might be involved in the activity of M. gale total fruit exudate extract. Furthermore, the activity of the total extract could be due to two groups of compounds: on the one hand, molecules specifically responsible for the growth induction of compatible strains and, on the other hand, other molecules involved only in growth inhibition of incompatible strains. A bioguided fractionation of the fruit exudates based on the monitoring of growth modulation would be an efficient way to determine exactly which molecules are responsible for those effects.

In this study, we show that nitrogen fixation activity is affected by M. gale fruit exudates in the same manner as bacterial growth: induction of nitrogen fixation in compatible strains and inhibition in incompatible ones. Growth induction or inhibition could thus be at least partly the consequence of modifications in nitrogen supply for the bacteria in the early perception of plant chemicals. Indeed, after 3 days of induction, nitrogen fixation of both compatible and incompatible Frankia cells is no longer affected by the flavonoid mixture. These transitory effects on nitrogen fixation could result from the oxidative stress generated by M. gale flavonoids, as we have previously described (4). In this previous work, we have shown deep modifications of the hydrosoluble intracellular proteomic content of several Frankia strains induced by M. gale fruit exudates. Among the proteins differentially affected, many involved in the oxidative stress response (e.g., superoxide dismutase, peroxidases, and tellurium resistance proteins) were also detected in Frankia after induction by Alnus glutinosa extracts (23). As nitrogenase is highly sensitive to the cellular oxygen level, a bacterial redox environment perturbation could affect its functioning. Due to the previously described antioxidant and radical scavenging properties of dihydrochalcones, such compounds might interfere with the redox environment of Frankia cells, and a specific management of those compounds by compatible strains could be part of the molecular mechanisms of host specificity. The possibility for Frankia strains to efficiently protect their nitrogenase could lead to a successful infection. This hypothesis is supported by our microarray experiments (discussed below). We note that in plant-microorganism interactions, oxidative stress commonly occurs, for example, in rhizobial symbiosis (56) and also in phytopathogenic infections (35). More generally, it could be a common and fundamental mechanism occurring widely in many prokaryote-eukaryote interactions, as it has been described recently in the Aedes albopictus-Wolbachia symbiosis (11).

Effects of M. gale fruit exudates on ACN14a Frankia gene expression.

In order to identify bacterial genes possibly involved in the physiological changes induced by M. gale fruit exudates as part of the very early mechanisms of the Frankia-M. gale interaction, transcriptomic analysis of the compatible strain ACN14a was performed. Surprisingly, only 22 genes were differentially expressed between cells induced with M. gale fruit exudates and methanol controls. Considering the large phenotypic effects of M. gale fruit exudates that we saw on growth and proteomic expression (4), we expected to observe correspondingly deep modifications of the bacterial transcriptome. However, the slight effect on gene expression could be explained by a different time-dependent response at the transcriptional and physiological levels. Frankia ACN14a RNA extraction was performed after 5 days of growth in the presence of plant compounds, in order to be under the same conditions that we used for biomass and proteomic analyses (4). It is possible that the transcriptional reaction of the bacteria to exudates occurred earlier and then decreased to a lower level over 5 days, when stationary growth phase is achieved. Similarly, the nitrogen fixation capacity of strains is affected by fruit exudates 24 h after induction but not after 5 days. Moreover, methanol cell toxicity could mask a few differentially transcribed genes, even though a 0.5% (vol/vol) concentration is classically used for biological cellular assays. Fruit exudates induce a downregulation of most of the 22 differentially regulated genes. Only eight affected genes have an annotated function. The highest overexpression (19-fold change) was observed for a multidrug resistance (MDR) protein (FRAAL1973), which is an efflux pump with high homology to the Nocardia lactamdurans cephamycin export protein CmcT (14). Mutations of genes encoding multidrug efflux pumps of Rhizobium etli CFN42 lead to the reduction of 40% of the numbers of nodules on its host plant Phaseolus vulgaris (21). MDR efflux pumps are also implicated in the virulence of phytopathogens such as Erwinia amylovora, Botrytis cinerea, or Fusarium graminearum (12). The synthesis of such a transporter could explain the resistance of ACN14a and compatible strains to the antibacterial activity of M. gale fruit exudates (51). However, MDR homolog genes, and all the other differentially transcribed genes, are also present in EaN1pec and CcI3 Frankia genomes, which are both considered to be incompatible with M. gale. Differential activity of MDR pumps between compatible and incompatible strains could thus result either from a specific molecular interaction between flavonoids and MDR proteins or from genetic regulation of related encoding genes rather than from the presence/absence of the latter in the genomes of Frankia strains.

Three differentially expressed genes are involved either in oxidative stress response or in oxidative process in respiratory chains, metabolic pathways that were shown to be affected by plant extracts (4). FRAAL6078 is a cytochrome c AA3 subunit-encoding gene whose transcription is reduced by M. gale compounds. A significant effect of dihydrochalcones such as MyA and MyB on electron transfers in rat mitochondria inhibiting ATP synthesis has been reported in the literature (39). Respiratory phosphorylation effects of flavonoids could partly explain the toxicity observed on bacterial strains and the modification of electron transfers, resulting probably in reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation. The two sequences encoding rubrerythrin (FRAAL5116) and a Fur family transcriptional repressor (FRAAL5117) are colocalized in the ACN14a genome and are involved in peroxide regulation and in iron metabolism. Oxidative stress and iron metabolism are often coregulated, particularly during the Fenton reaction, which produces hydroxyl radicals (33). Moreover, flavonoids are known as iron chelators, and their presence in Frankia medium could thus modify siderophore production and iron availability and consequently alter the redox environment of the bacterial cell generating ROS. Consequently, these two proteins could be involved in the management of such ROS to avoid toxic effects. Besides, ROS generated by the oxidative stress induced by the flavonoid mixture could also play a role in signal mechanisms. ROS and RNS (reactive nitrogen species) usually associated with biotic and abiotic stress were first regarded as damaging for cells but appear more and more as ubiquitous signaling molecules. In legumes, those reactive species are considered to play a key role in the symbiosis (48). ROS production in Frankia cells induced by plant flavonoids could thus be involved as a signal in the interaction with the host plant, while the bacteria would manage the plant's oxidative burst (63).

Finally, the last upregulated gene (FRAAL2286) induced by M. gale fruit exudates is homologous to whiB, a transcriptional regulator-encoding gene present in Actinomycetales. Regulators of the Whi family are involved in Streptomyces cell differentiation, sporulation, or antibiotic production and are highly suspected to be involved in Mycobacterium smegmatis virulence (32, 53). A conserved role in biotic interactions can thus be suspected for Whi family regulators in the Actinomycetales. WhiB could be at the origin of growth enhancement observed for compatible strains in the presence of M. gale fruit exudates. The presence of four cysteine residues suggests that these WhiB proteins may be sensitive to redox changes perhaps through a metal atom bound or through direct sensitivity to oxidation via disulfide-bound formation. It has been shown that Streptomyces WhiD, a member of the WhiB family, binds a [4Fe-4S] cluster and that all four cysteine residues are essential for its activity (29). Corynebacterium glutamicum WhcE, also a member of the WhiB family, is important for survival following heat and oxidative stress (34). These observations support the hypothesis that the members of this protein family are likely to be associated with intracellular redox-sensing pathways. Frankia ACN14a WhiB could thus be induced by ROS signals generated after induction by flavonoids and causing a specific cell multiplication related to the symbiotic process.

The work presented in this paper demonstrates for the first time, to our knowledge, a role for plant secondary metabolites in the specificity of actinorhizal symbioses. Phytochemical characterization of fruit exudates of M. gale revealed the occurrence of many flavonoids, particularly from the rare class of dihydrochalcones. They induce phenotypic (growth and nitrogen fixation) and transcriptional effects in Frankia strains congruent with the symbiotic compatibility statuses of the strains, supporting the involvement of these molecules in the symbiotic interaction. The physiological effects of M. gale fruit exudates on Frankia strains indicate the bivalent role of plant phenolic compounds, acting as positive chemical signals on compatible strains and as chemical weapons on incompatible ones. Whole-genome microarrays allowed the identification of several ACN14a genes that could be involved in the molecular mechanisms of the interaction. The Myricaceae-Frankia symbiosis is a model of interest for the study of the interactions occurring between actinorhizal partners. More generally, the Frankia/actinorhizal plant symbiosis is an original and crucial model for progress in the understanding of the evolution of nitrogen-fixing symbioses.

Supplementary Material

[Supplemental material]

Acknowledgments

Jean Popovici was supported by a Ph.D. fellowship from the French Ministère de l'Education Nationale et de la Recherche. This work was partly supported by the Cluster Qualité de Plantes (Rhône-Alpes Region).

We thank Frédéric Blanchard (National Botanic Conservatory, Bordeaux, France) for harvesting the fruits, Frank Poly (University of Lyon, France) for performing the ARA experiments, Anne Wierinckx and Joël Lachuer from ProfileXpert (Lyon, France) for GeneSpring analysis of NimbleGen array data, and Meg Woolfit (University of Queensland, Australia) for helpful comments on the manuscript.

Footnotes

[down-pointing small open triangle]Published ahead of print on 26 February 2010.

Supplemental material for this article may be found at http://aem.asm.org/.

REFERENCES

1. Akiyama, K., K. Matsuzaki, and H. Hayashi. 2005. Plant sesquiterpenes induce hyphal branching in arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi. Nature 435:824-827. [PubMed]
2. Alvarez, L., and G. Delgado. 1999. C- and O-glycosyl-α-hydroxydihydrochalcones from Eysenhardtia polystachya. Phytochemistry 50:681-687.
3. Anthonsen, T., I. Falkeberg, M. Laake, A. Midelfart, and T. Mortensen. 1971. Unusual flavonoids from Myrica gale. Acta Chem. Scand. 25:1929-1930. [PubMed]
4. Bagnarol, E., J. Popovici, N. Alloisio, J. Maréchal, P. Pujic, P. Normand, and M. P. Fernandez. 2007. Differential Frankia protein patterns induced by phenolic extracts from Myricaceae seeds. Physiol. Plant. 130:380-390.
5. Baker, D. D. 1987. Relationships among pure cultured strains of Frankia based on host specificity. Physiol. Plant. 70:245-248.
6. Bécard, G., D. D. Douds, and P. E. Pfeffer. 1992. Extensive hyphal growth of vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi in the presence of CO2 and flavonols. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 58:821-825. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
7. Benoit, L. F., and A. M. Berry. 1997. Flavonoid-like compounds from seeds of red alder (Alnus rubra) influence host nodulation by Frankia (Actinomycetales). Physiol. Plant. 99:588-593.
8. Benson, D. R., and W. B. Silvester. 1993. Biology of Frankia strains, actinomycete symbionts of actinorhizal plants. Microbiol. Rev. 57:293-319. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
9. Berry, A., and J. G. Torrey. 1979. Isolation and characterization in vivo and in vitro of an actinomycetous endophyte from Alnus rubra bong, p. 69-83. In J. C. Gordon, C. T. Wheeler, and D. A. Perry (ed.), Symbiotic nitrogen fixation in the management of temperate forests. Forest Research Laboratory, Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR.
10. Bolstad, B. M., R. A. Irizarry, M. Astrand, and T. P. Speed. 2003. A comparison of normalization methods for high density oligonucleotide array data based on variance and bias. Bioinformatics 19:185-193. [PubMed]
11. Brennan, L. J., B. A. Keddie, H. R. Braig, and H. L. Harris. 2008. The endosymbiont Wolbachia pipientis induces the expression of host antioxidant proteins in an Aedes albopictus cell line. PLoS One 3:e2083. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
12. Burse, A., H. Weingart, and M. S. Ullrich. 2004. The phytoalexin-inducible multidrug efflux pump AcrAB contributes to virulence in the fire blight pathogen Erwinia amylovora. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact. 17:43-54. [PubMed]
13. Cooper, J. E. 2004. Multiple responses of rhizobia to flavonoids during legume root infection. Adv. Bot. Res. 41:1-62.
14. Coque, J. J., P. Liras, and J. F. Martin. 1993. Genes for a β-lactamase, a penicillin-binding protein and a transmembrane protein are clustered with the cephamycin biosynthetic genes in Nocardia lactamdurans. EMBO J. 12:631-639. [PubMed]
15. D'Arcy-Lameta, A., and M. Jay. 1987. Study of soybean and lentil root exudates. III. Influence of soybean isoflavonoids on the growth of rhizobia and some rhizospheric microorganisms. Plant Soil 101:267-272.
16. Diem, H. G., and Y. R. Dommergues. 1983. The isolation of Frankia from nodules of Casuarina. Can. J. Bot. 61:2822-2825.
17. Diem, H. D., D. Gauthier, and Y. Dommergues. 1983. An effective strain of Frankia from Casuarina sp. Can. J. Bot. 61:2815-2821.
18. Fernandez, M. P., H. Meugnier, P. A. D. Grimont, and R. Bardin. 1989. Deoxyribonucleic acid relatedness among members of the genus Frankia. Int. J. Syst. Bacteriol. 39:424-429.
19. Gafner, S., J. L. Wolfender, S. Mavi, and K. Hostettmann. 1996. Antifungal and antibacterial chalcones from Myrica serrata. Planta Med. 62:67-69. [PubMed]
20. Gauthier, D., H. G. Diem, and Y. Dommergues. 1981. In vitro nitrogen fixation by two actinomycete strains isolated from Casuarina nodules. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 41:306-308. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
21. González-Pasayo, R., and E. Martinez-Romero. 2000. Multiresistance genes of Rhizobium etli CFN42. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact. 13:572-577. [PubMed]
22. Gould, K. S., and C. Lister. 2006. Flavonoid functions in plants, p. 397-441. In O. M. Andersen and K. R. Markham (ed.), Flavonoids: chemistry, biochemistry and applications. Taylor and Francis Group, Boca Raton, FL.
23. Hammad, Y., J. Maréchal, B. Cournoyer, P. Normand, and A. M. Domenach. 2001. Modification of the protein expression pattern induced in the nitrogen-fixing actinomycete Frankia sp. strain ACN14a-tsr by root exudates of its symbiotic host Alnus glutinosa and cloning of the sodF gene. Can. J. Microbiol. 47:541-547. [PubMed]
24. Hammad, Y., R. Nalin, J. Maréchal, K. Fiasson, R. Pepin, A. M. Berry, P. Normand, and A. M. Domenach. 2003. A possible role for phenylacetic acid (PAA) in Alnus glutinosa nodulation by Frankia. Plant Soil 254:193-205.
25. Hartwig, U. A., C. M. Joseph, and D. A. Phillips. 1991. Flavonoids released naturally from alfalfa seeds enhance growth rate of Rhizobium meliloti. Plant Physiol. 95:797-803. [PubMed]
26. Hufford, C. D., and B. O. Oguntimein. 1980. Dihydrochalcones from Uvaria angolensis. Phytochemistry 19:2036-2038.
27. Huguet, V., M. Gouy, P. Normand, J. F. Zimpfer, and M. P. Fernandez. 2005. Molecular phylogeny of Myricaceae: a reexamination of host-symbiont specificity. Mol. Phylogenet. Evol. 34:557-568. [PubMed]
28. Irizarry, R. A., B. Hobbs, F. Collin, Y. D. Beazer-Barclay, K. J. Antonellis, U. Scherf, and T. P. Speed. 2003. Exploration, normalization, and summaries of high density oligonucleotide array probe level data. Biostatistics 4:249-264. [PubMed]
29. Jakimowicz, P., M. R. Cheesman, W. R. Bishai, K. F. Chater, A. J. Thomson, and M. J. Buttner. 2005. Evidence that the Streptomyces developmental protein WhiD, a member of the WhiB family, binds a [4Fe-4S] cluster. J. Biol. Chem. 280:8309-8315. [PubMed]
30. Jamann, S., M. P. Fernandez, and P. Normand. 1993. Typing method for N2-fixing bacteria based on PCR-RFLP: application to the characterisation of Frankia strains. Mol. Ecol. 2:17-26. [PubMed]
31. Joshi, B. S., and D. H. Gawad. 1974. Flavanones from the stem of Unona lawii. Isolation of lawinal, desmethoxymatteucinol, desmethoxymatteucinol-7-methyl ether, and a synthesis of lawinal. Indian J. Chem. 12:1033-1037.
32. Kang, S. H., J. Huang, H. N. Lee, Y. A. Hur, S. N. Cohen, and E. S. Kim. 2007. Interspecies DNA microarray analysis identifies WblA as a pleiotropic down-regulator of antibiotic biosynthesis in Streptomyces. J. Bacteriol. 189:4315-4319. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
33. Keyer, K., and J. A. Imlay. 1996. Superoxide accelerates DNA damage by elevating free-iron levels. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 93:13635-13640. [PubMed]
34. Kim, T. H., J. S. Park, H. J. Kim, Y. Kim, P. Kim, and H. S. Lee. 2005. The whcE gene of Corynebacterium glutamicum is important for survival following heat and oxidative stress. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 337:757-764. [PubMed]
35. Lamb, C., and R. A. Dixon. 1997. The oxidative burst in plant disease resistance. Annu. Rev. Plant Physiol. Plant Mol. Biol. 48:251-275. [PubMed]
36. Laplaze, L., H. Gherbi, T. Frutz, K. Pawlowski, C. Franche, J. J. Macheix, F. Auguy, D. Bogusz, and E. Duhoux. 1999. Flavan-containing cells delimit Frankia-infected compartments in Casuarina glauca nodules. Plant Physiol. 121:113-122. [PubMed]
37. Malterud, K. E., T. Anthonsen, and G. B. Lorentzen. 1977. Chemistry of Myrica gale L. Part 4. Two new C-methylated flavonoids from Myrica gale. Phytochemistry 16:1805-1809.
38. Malterud, K. E., O. H. Diep, and R. B. Sund. 1996. C-methylated dihydrochalcones from Myrica gale L.: effects as antioxidants and as scavengers of 1,1-diphenyl-2-picrylhydrazyl. Pharmacol. Toxicol. 78:111-116. [PubMed]
39. Mathiesen, L., K. E. Malterud, and R. B. Sund. 1996. Uncoupling of respiration and inhibition of ATP synthesis in mitochondria by C-methylated flavonoids from Myrica gale L. Eur. J. Pharm. Sci. 4:373-379.
40. Mathiesen, L., K. E. Malterud, and R. B. Sund. 1997. Hydrogen bond formation as basis for radical scavenging activity: a structure-activity study of C-methylated dihydrochalcones from Myrica gale and structurally related acetophenones. Free Radic. Biol. Med. 22:307-311. [PubMed]
41. Maxwell, C. A., U. A. Hartwig, C. M. Joseph, and D. A. Phillips. 1989. A chalcone and two related flavonoids released from alfalfa roots induce nod genes of Rhizobium meliloti. Plant Physiol. 91:842-847. [PubMed]
42. Murry, M., M. Fontaine, and J. Torrey. 1984. Growth kinetics and nitrogenase induction in Frankia sp. HFPArI3 grown in batch culture. Plant Soil 78:61-78.
43. Normand, P., and M. Lalonde. 1982. Evaluation of Frankia strains isolated from provenances of two Alnus species. Can. J. Microbiol. 28:1133-1142.
44. Normand, P., S. Orso, B. Cournoyer, P. Jeannin, C. Chapelon, J. Dawson, L. Evtushenko, and A. K. Misra. 1996. Molecular phylogeny of the genus Frankia and related genera and emendation of the family Frankiaceae. Int. J. Syst. Bacteriol. 46:1-9. [PubMed]
45. Normand, P., P. Lapierre, L. S. Tisa, J. P. Gogarten, N. Alloisio, E. Bagnarol, C. A. Bassi, A. M. Berry, D. M. Bickhart, N. Choisne, A. Couloux, B. Cournoyer, S. Cruveiller, V. Daubin, N. Demange, M. Pilar Francino, E. Goltsman, Y. Huang, O. R. Kopp, L. Labarre, A. Lapidus, C. Lavire, J. Marechal, M. Martinez, J. E. Mastronunzio, B. C. Mullin, J. Niemann, P. Pujic, T. Rawnsley, Z. Rouy, C. Schenowitz, A. Sellstedt, F. Tavares, J. P. Tomkins, D. Vallenet, C. Valverde, L. G. Wall, Y. Wang, C. Medigue, and D. R. Benson. 2007. Genome characteristics of facultatively symbiotic Frankia sp. strains reflect host range and host plant biogeography. Genome Res. 17:7-15. [PubMed]
46. Pankhurst, C. E., and D. R. Biggs. 1980. Sensitivity of Rhizobium to selected isoflavonoids. Can. J. Microbiol. 26:542-545. [PubMed]
47. Parniske, M., B. Ahlborn, and D. Werner. 1991. Isoflavonoid-inducible resistance to the phytoalexin glyceollin in soybean rhizobia. J. Bacteriol. 173:3432-3439. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
48. Pauly, N., C. Pucciariello, K. Mandon, G. Innocenti, A. Jamet, E. Baudoin, D. Herouart, P. Frendo, and A. Puppo. 2006. Reactive oxygen and nitrogen species and glutathione: key players in the legume-Rhizobium symbiosis. J. Exp. Bot. 57:1769-1776. [PubMed]
49. Peters, N. K., J. W. Frost, and S. R. Long. 1986. A plant flavone, luteolin, induces expression of Rhizobium meliloti nodulation genes. Science 233:977-980. [PubMed]
50. Phrutivorapongkul, A., V. Lipipun, N. Ruangrungsi, K. Kirtikara, K. Nishikawa, S. Maruyama, T. Watanabe, and T. Ishikawa. 2003. Studies on the chemical constituents of stem bark of Millettia leucantha: isolation of new chalcones with cytotoxic, anti-herpes simplex virus and anti-inflammatory activities. Chem. Pharm. Bull. 51:187-190. [PubMed]
51. Popovici, J., E. Bagnarol, C. Lenepveu, C. Bertrand, M. P. Fernandez, and G. Comte. 2006. Nature and role of phenolic compounds of Myrica gale fruit exudates on growth of representative strains of the rhizospheric bacterial ecosystem, p. 79-80. In F. Daayf, A. El Hadrami, L. Adam, and G. M. Balance (ed.), Polyphenols communications. Groupe Polyphénols, Winnipeg, Canada.
52. Prin, Y., L. Maggia, B. Picard, H. G. Diem, and P. Goullet. 1991. Electrophoretic comparison of enzymes from 22 single-spore cultures obtained from Frankia strain ORS140102. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 69:91-96.
53. Raghunand, T. R., and W. R. Bishai. 2006. Mapping essential domains of Mycobacterium smegmatis WhmD: insights into WhiB structure and function. J. Bacteriol. 188:6966-6976. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
54. Recourt, K., J. Schripsema, J. W. Kijne, A. A. Van Brussel, and B. J. Lugtenberg. 1991. Inoculation of Vicia sativa subsp. nigra roots with Rhizobium leguminosarum biovar viciae results in release of nod gene activating flavanones and chalcones. Plant Mol. Biol. 16:841-852. [PubMed]
55. Redmond, J. W., M. Batley, M. A. Djordjevic, R. W. Innes, P. L. Kuempel, and B. G. Rolfe. 1986. Flavones induce expression of nodulation genes in Rhizobium. Nature 323:632-635.
56. Santos, R., D. Herouart, S. Sigaud, D. Touati, and A. Puppo. 2001. Oxidative burst in alfalfa-Sinorhizobium meliloti symbiotic interaction. Mol. Plant Microbe Interact. 14:86-89. [PubMed]
57. Shaw, L. J., P. Morris, and J. E. Hooker. 2006. Perception and modification of plant flavonoid signals by rhizosphere microorganisms. Environ. Microbiol. 8:1867-1880. [PubMed]
58. Shaw, L. J., and J. E. Hooker. 2008. The fate and toxicity of the flavonoids naringenin and formononetin in soil. Soil Biol. Biochem. 40:528-536.
59. Simonet, P., A. Capellano, E. Navarro, R. Bardin, and A. Moiroud. 1984. An improved method for lysis of Frankia with achromopeptidase allows detection of new plasmids. Can. J. Microbiol. 30:1292-1295.
60. Simonet, P., N. Thi Le, A. Moiroud, and R. Bardin. 1989. Diversity of Frankia strains isolated from a single alder stand. Plant Soil 118:13-22.
61. Soltis, D. E., P. S. Soltis, D. R. Morgan, S. M. Swensen, B. C. Mullin, J. M. Dowd, and P. G. Martin. 1995. Chloroplast gene sequence data suggest a single origin of the predisposition for symbiotic nitrogen fixation in angiosperms. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 92:2647-2651. [PubMed]
62. Steinkellner, S., V. Lendzemo, I. Langer, P. Schweiger, T. Khaosaad, J. P. Toussaint, and H. Vierheilig. 2007. Flavonoids and strigolactones in root exudates as signals in symbiotic and pathogenic plant-fungus interactions. Molecules 12:1290-1306. [PubMed]
63. Tavares, F., C. L. Santos, and A. Sellstedt. 2007. Reactive oxygen species in legume and actinorhizal nitrogen-fixing symbioses: the microsymbiont's responses to an unfriendly reception. Physiol. Plant. 130:344-356.
64. Wollenweber, E., G. Kohorst, K. Mann, and J. M. Bell. 1985. Leaf gland flavonoids in Comptonia peregrina and Myrica pensylvanica (Myricaceae). J. Plant Physiol. 117:423-430. [PubMed]
65. Zhang, Z., M. F. Lopez, and J. G. Torrey. 1984. A comparison of cultural characteristics and infectivity of Frankia isolates from root nodules of Casuarina species. Plant Soil 8:79-90.
66. Zimpfer, J. F., J. M. Igual, B. McCarty, C. Smyth, and J. O. Dawson. 2004. Casuarina cunninghamiana tissue extracts stimulate the growth of Frankia and differentially alter the growth of other soil microorganisms. J. Chem. Ecol. 30:439-452. [PubMed]

Articles from Applied and Environmental Microbiology are provided here courtesy of American Society for Microbiology (ASM)