Early microdissection studies of ADPKD kidneys indicated that cysts initially appear as focal lesions in kidney tubules that otherwise appear to be normal along most of their length (
38). A molecular explanation for the focal nature of cyst formation in the setting of heterozygous germline mutations came with the discovery that cyst lining cells from human ADPKD cysts have loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in the chromosomal regions of the respective
PKD genes in both the kidney (
39–
42) and liver (
43). These findings implicated a cellular recessive mechanism for cyst formation in ADPKD and suggested the possibility that the observed intrafamilial variation in disease severity may at least in part be determined by variation in the timing and number of somatic `second hit' mutations in individual family members (
44). The causal relationship between `second hit' mutations and cyst formation in adult kidneys was validated in a mouse model expressing a modified
Pkd2 allele (
Pkd2WS25) that expresses functional PC2 but is prone to genomic rearrangement leading to somatic loss of PC2 (
45).
Alternative mechanisms of cyst formation also exist and the relative importance of these in human clinical disease remains to be determined. Cyst formation resulting from trans-heterozygous somatic mutations involving
PKD1 and
PKD2 have also been proposed (
46;
47). However, trans-heterozygous mutations alone are unlikely to be sufficient for cyst formation. Individuals with bilineal inheritance of
PKD1 and
PKD2 mutations (
16) and trans-heterozygous mice (
48) show more severe polycystic kidney disease, but the overall severity is within the range consistent with additive effects of single gene mutations. Recent evidence indicates that significant reduction of functional PC1 expression below a critical threshold level is sufficient to result in cyst formation in some situations () (
18;
49;
50). A unique chimeric animal model produced by mosaic embryos combining
Pkd1−/− cells with wild type cells formed kidney cysts with severity proportionate to the degree of
Pkd1−/− contribution to the mosaic animal (
51). Interestingly, the cysts were mosaic with both
Pkd1−/− and wild type cells in the early stages, but over time, the
Pkd1−/− cells replaced the wild type cells by inducing apoptosis. These data suggest the possibility that cellular loss of PC1 produces cyst formation both by expansion of the null cell mass and by induction of programmed cell death in surrounding normal cells.
More recently the conditional Cre-lox system has been used to bypass the embryonic lethality of null mice and inactivate genes of interest in a tissue selective or temporally controlled manner (
49;
50;
52;
53). Temporally controlled inactivation of
Pkd1 has shown that the timing of gene inactivation impacts the rate of cyst growth (
54;
55) Inactivation of
Pkd1 in the developing kidney results in rapid cyst growth while inactivation in the adult kidney results in markedly slower cyst growth () (
54;
55). A developmentally regulated change in the gene expression profile of the kidney coincides with the differential effect of
Pkd1 loss on cyst formation (
55). The underlying proliferative potential of the cells as a function of developmental stage may account for part of the difference in the rate of cyst formation (
53). This is supported by the finding that regenerating tubules after ischemia reperfusion injury have an increased rate of cyst formation (
56–
58). Factors such as the timing of gene inactivation, the degree of inactivation of the protein product and the presence of other forms of renal injury are likely to contribute to the severity of ADPKD in individuals.