To investigate the specific neuronal population(s) mediating alterations in energy balance and glucose homeostasis in brain-specific PTP1B- and SHP2-deficient mice, we generated mice with POMC neuron disruption of PTP1B or SHP2. Our data highlight an important reciprocal role for PTP1B and SHP2 in POMC neuron control of HFD-induced weight gain, energy expenditure, leptin and insulin sensitivity, and hepatic steatosis.
Leptin acts through LRb, which is highly expressed in the ARC, and in other localized areas throughout the brain (
42–
44). Leptin binding to LRb causes autophosphorylation and activation of associated Jak2, which in turn phosphorylates critical tyrosine residues on the intracellular domain of the LRb, including Y
985 and Y
1138 (reviewed in refs.
45–
49). Phosphorylated tyrosine residues on the LRb provide docking sites for downstream signaling molecules, including Stat3 and suppressor of cytokine signaling (Socs3), a feedback inhibitor of leptin signaling. PTP1B acts as a negative regulator of leptin signaling by directly dephosphorylating Jak2 (
16–
18). In contrast, SHP2 is thought to promote leptin signaling. Tyrosine phosphorylation of Y
985 recruits SHP2, which competes for binding with Socs3 and mediates leptin activation of the growth factor receptor–bound protein 2 (Grb2)/ERK pathway (
25). In vivo studies have implicated both PTP1B and SHP2 in regulation of leptin signaling and whole body energy balance (
16,
17,
19,
27).
The expression of PTP1B is induced in the hypothalamus of mice in response to high-fat feeding, and PTP1B deficiency in the brain results in decreased body weight and improved leptin sensitivity (
16,
17,
19,
50,
51). However, the role(s) played by PTP1B in specific neurons that control energy balance remains unknown. We find that POMC-
Ptp1b–/– mice weigh less than wild-type controls on HFD due to decreased adiposity and increased energy expenditure, implicating POMC neurons as an important site of PTP1B action. Whether altered metabolism in POMC-
Ptp1b–/– mice is due to enhanced neuronal leptin signaling or other signaling pathways affected by PTP1B deletion is currently unknown. While our data demonstrate improved leptin sensitivity in the absence of PTP1B (including enhanced leptin-stimulated pStat3 within PTP1B-deficient POMC neurons themselves), PTP1B has been implicated in the regulation of other signaling pathways that may regulate energy balance, including insulin and cytokine signaling (
52,
53).
Insulin has been shown to have central effects on body weight, hepatic glucose production, and hepatic Stat3 activation (
54–
59). Genetic disruption of IR expression in the CNS leads to obesity and peripheral insulin resistance in mice (
57), and insulin injection directly in the mediobasal hypothalamus improves hepatic insulin sensitivity in rats (
55). Furthermore, insulin delivered to the third ventricle in rats causes upregulation of αMSH expression and a reduction in food intake that is blocked in the presence of a melanocortin antagonist (
60). Within the CNS, inhibitors of PI3K, a downstream mediator of multiple signaling pathways including insulin, have been shown to block the anorexigenic effects of insulin (
61). In POMC neurons, insulin potently activates PI3K activity (
62), but surprisingly, constitutive elevation of PIP3 within POMC neurons results in sex-specific hyperphagia and diet-induced obesity due to increased K
ATP channel conductance (
63). Notably, however, deletion of IR or IRS2 specifically in POMC neurons does not result in altered energy balance or glucose homeostasis on a chow diet or HFD (
64,
65), suggesting that PTP1B regulation of this pathway in POMC neurons is not likely to produce the observed phenotypes. PTP1B deficiency could in theory affect other cytokine-mediated signaling pathways, such as IL-6 (
66) or gp130 signaling (
67); however, there is no evidence currently implicating regulation of these pathways by PTP1B in hypothalamic neurons.
Previous reports demonstrated that mice with neuronal disruption of SHP2 are obese and leptin- and insulin-resistant (
27,
28), but the neurons mediating these effects are unknown. We found that POMC-
Shp2–/– mice weighed more than littermate controls not only on HFD, but also on a chow diet. The response to exogenous leptin was blunted in these animals, and energy expenditure was reduced, consistent with the development of leptin resistance. Examination of αMSH-containing fiber projections in 5- to 6-week-old POMC-
Shp2–/– mice revealed a significant reduction in αMSH immunolabeling in the PVN (Figure ) and DMH (data not shown), as well as an overall reduction in hypothalamic αMSH peptide content, raising the intriguing possibility that SHP2 may be important for the normal development of the hypothalamic melanocortin system. Since we stained for the αMSH peptide directly, we cannot determine whether POMC-
Shp2–/– mice have impaired development of neuronal projections and/or simply have reduced αMSH peptide content. It is interesting to note, however, that leptin has been shown to directly act on ARC neurons to stimulate axonal growth (
68,
69) and is a critical trophic factor particularly during neonatal development of the hypothalamus (
70). Orexigenic (NPY/AgRP) and anorexigenic (POMC) projections from the ARC to other hypothalamic nuclei, including PVN, DMH, and LHA, are severely impaired in
ob/ob mice, leptin receptor–deficient Zucker rats, and diet-induced obese rats (
68,
70,
71). Since reduced αMSH fiber staining is observed in young (5- to 6-week-old) POMC-
Shp2–/– mice, this is unlikely to be secondary to the development of chronic, long-term leptin resistance.
Given the role SHP2 plays in multiple signal transduction pathways, it is difficult to attribute the observed phenotypes of POMC-
Shp2–/– mice to a particular signaling pathway. Multiple studies both in vitro and in vivo support a role for SHP2 as a positive mediator of leptin signaling at the cellular level, likely stemming from the Y
985 site on the leptin receptor (
25–
28). It is plausible that impairments in leptin signaling in POMC-
Shp2–/– mice could lead to the phenotypes of these animals. However, it should be noted that mice with a homozygous mutation in Y
985 (
l/l mice) are not obese. In fact, female animals harboring this mutation are leaner than controls (
72). The differences between POMC-
Shp2–/– mice and
l/l mice could be due to the fact that in POMC-
Shp2–/– mice, the Y
985 site remains intact and available for Socs3 to bind without competition, thereby promoting negative regulation of leptin signaling. Alternatively, SHP2 may be regulating additional, unidentified signaling pathways in these neurons.
In addition to its regulation of leptin signaling, SHP2 is required for transduction of signals stemming from many other cell surface receptors, including the receptor tyrosine kinases EGF, FGF, PDGF, insulin, and nerve growth factor (NGF). SHP2 also promotes integrin signaling and Src family kinase activation (
23,
52,
73–
75). The Src family kinases Src and Fyn are highly expressed in the developing nervous system and localize to growth cones (
76,
77). Mice lacking these tyrosine kinases have defects in axon outgrowth and guidance (
78), raising the possibility that defects in an Src kinase–dependent pathway could alter efferent projections in POMC-
Shp2–/– mice. SHP2 also mediates signaling by the c-Ret receptor tyrosine kinase (
79,
80), which has been shown to be important for normal axon growth and guidance in developing sympathetic neurons (
81). Furthermore, NGF-stimulated axonal growth is mediated via an SHP2-dependent mechanism in mouse sympathetic neurons (
82). Collectively these studies highlight the potential complexity of SHP2 function in mediating neuronal development. More studies are needed to determine whether the observed phenotypes of the POMC-
Shp2–/– mice are due to impaired neuropeptide expression, development of neural projections, and/or defects in cellular signaling.
POMC-
Ptp1b–/– mice have improved leptin sensitivity, whereas POMC-
Shp2–/– mice have impaired leptin sensitivity. Interestingly, while energy expenditure was altered in both lines of mice, food intake was not significantly affected by POMC deficiency of either PTP1B or SHP2. Mice with widespread neuronal SHP2 deficiency also showed altered energy expenditure, with no significant effect on food intake (
27), whereas mice with neuronal deficiency of PTP1B displayed both increased energy expenditure and suppression of food intake (
19). These data collectively suggest that PTP1B has an important role in POMC neuron regulation of energy expenditure, whereas non-POMC neurons likely mediate the intake-suppressive effects seen in brain-specific
Ptp1b–/– mice. This idea is supported by an increasing number of studies showing that leptin acts at distributed sites across the CNS (
42,
44,
83,
84). Consistent with their increased energy expenditure as measured by indirect calorimetry, POMC-
Ptp1b–/– mice had elevated body temperature. However, POMC-
Ptp1b–/– mice did not display altered locomotor activity. This finding is in contrast to the increased locomotor activity seen in whole-brain
Ptp1b–/– mice, suggesting that this also may be due to deletion of PTP1B in non-POMC neurons.
Mice with PTP1B deficiency in brain, muscle, and liver all show improvements in peripheral insulin sensitivity (
19–
21). Here we found that POMC-
Ptp1b–/– mice had improved insulin sensitivity on a low-fat chow diet in the absence of a weight difference (and similar adiposity compared with controls). These data suggest that PTP1B may regulate a neural pathway that can directly influence peripheral insulin sensitivity under physiological conditions. Other studies are consistent with the idea that CNS pathways can regulate glucose homeostasis (reviewed in refs.
85,
86). For example, insulin action in AgRP neurons is required for the insulin-induced suppression of hepatic glucose production (
64), and hypothalamic lipid sensing can modulate glucose metabolism in the liver via a direct brain-liver circuit (
87). Furthermore, mice expressing a mutant Kir6.2 subunit in POMC neurons have disrupted glucose sensing and impaired systemic glucose tolerance (
29). Central leptin administration (directly into the mediobasal hypothalamus of rats) can suppress lipogenesis in white adipose tissue via a PI3K-dependent mechanism (
88). Expression of functional leptin receptors in leptin receptor–deficient mice resulted in dramatically improved insulin and glucose levels (
34,
89). Similarly, expression of leptin receptors in the ARC of obese leptin receptor–deficient Koletsky rats resulted in markedly improved peripheral insulin sensitivity (
90). Genetic manipulations in POMC neurons implicate these specific cells as important regulators of glucose tolerance. For example, deletion of the LRb in POMC neurons (POMC-Cre:
Leprflox/flox mice) results in elevated fasting glucose levels and impaired glucose tolerance when mice are maintained on a chow diet, as well as impaired insulin sensitivity compared with control mice maintained on HFD (
33). In contrast, leptin-hypersensitive POMC-
Socs3–/– mice display improved glucose homeostasis (
35). Collectively, these studies demonstrate that central leptin and/or insulin sensitivity may have direct effects on peripheral fat metabolism and glucose homeostasis.
Consistent with the known expression pattern of POMC cells, we detected recombination of the
Ptpn1 and
Ptpn11 floxed alleles in pituitary, hypothalamus, and the hindbrain, making it difficult to attribute the observed phenotypes to one specific population of POMC-expressing neurons. However, serum corticosterone levels were normal in both POMC-
Ptp1b–/– and POMC-
Shp2–/– mice, suggesting that pituitary-mediated hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) function is intact. Furthermore, mice with anterior pituitary–specific deletion of PTP1B (Cga-
Ptp1b–/–) show similar body weights and glucose levels on HFD compared with
Ptp1b+/+ controls (Supplemental Figure 4), which argues against a primary role for PTP1B in pituitary POMC cells in mediating the observed phenotypes. Although the most extensive and well-characterized population of POMC neurons is localized to the ARC, leptin-responsive POMC neurons are also present in the NTS (
91–
93), and we therefore cannot rule out a possible contribution of this population to the observed phenotypes.
POMC-
Ptp1b–/– mice were protected against HFD-induced hepatic steatosis, whereas hepatic TG content was elevated in HFD-fed POMC-
Shp2–/– mice, consistent with previous studies implicating the melanocortin pathway in regulation of hepatic lipogenesis (
54,
94). Expression of
Scd1 and
Pparg2 mRNA was reduced in livers of POMC-
Ptp1b–/– mice and increased in steatotic livers of POMC-
Shp2–/– mice. SCD-1 catalyzes the synthesis of monounsaturated fatty acids from saturated fatty acids and is therefore a major regulator of lipid synthesis (
95). SCD-1 deficiency promotes β-oxidation and decreases lipogenesis in liver and muscle; thus, mice deficient in SCD-1 have increased energy expenditure, reduced adiposity, and improved insulin sensitivity (
96–
98). PPARγ2 promotes adipogenesis; selective deletion of PPARγ2 in mice results in reduced adipose tissue mass and decreased adipogenesis (
99). Although PPARγ2 is expressed mainly in adipose tissue,
Pparg2 gene expression has recently been shown to be markedly upregulated in livers of human patients with nonalcoholic fatty liver (
100).
The reduction in liver TG and
Scd1 gene expression in POMC-
Ptp1b–/– mice is consistent with enhanced leptin signaling in POMC neurons. Leptin has previously been shown to have antisteatotic effects on the liver via CNS-mediated suppression of
Scd1 gene expression (
41,
96). Mice lacking Socs3 expression in POMC neurons also display enhanced leptin sensitivity, reduced fatty liver, and decreased hepatic SCD-1 expression (
35). In contrast, elevated liver TG and increased hepatic lipogenic gene expression in POMC-
Shp2–/– mice are consistent with leptin resistance. Interestingly, neuronal
Shp2–/– mice showed similar increases in hepatic lipid content and hepatic lipogenic gene expression as early as postnatal day 28, suggesting that these changes in gene expression precede the development of obesity (
27).
Taken together, our results identify PTP1B and SHP2 as essential contributors to POMC neuron regulation of energy balance. PTP1B deficiency in POMC neurons results in protection from weight gain on HFD and in improved insulin sensitivity independent of body weight and adiposity on a low-fat chow diet. We also present evidence that SHP2 deficiency in POMC neurons leads to obesity on either a chow diet or HFD, likely due to impaired functioning of the melanocortin system at a young age. In addition, these studies define what we believe to be a novel role for these PTPs in CNS control of diet-induced hepatic steatosis, which may have important therapeutic implications for diet-induced fatty liver disease.