In this report, we confirm and extend our previous partial characterizations of the Brd2 multiprotein complex,
8,11,13 with MS and immunoaffinity analysis of its components. We have reported that the Brd2 complex in fibroblasts contains E2F proteins and histone H4-directed HAT activity. These results supports a model of dual control of
cyclin A transcription through (a) direct transcription factor recruitment and (b) histone acetylation/deacetylation.
11,13,31,33 Furthermore, chromatin immunoprecipitation has established, in synchronized cells, that Brd2 is associated with the
cyclin A promoter at both G
1 and S phase of the cell cycle,11 suggesting that Brd2 functions as a scaffold that mediates access of transcriptional control proteins to chromatin.
20 These observations imply that the Brd2 complex, at least when physically associated with
cyclin A promoter chromatin, has dynamic, time-ordered functions of transcriptional repression, then activation, then repression again, as the cell progresses through the stages of the cell cycle. It is reasonable to hypothesize, therefore, that the complex also has dynamic composition, with shifting alliances between transcriptionally repressing and activating sub-complexes.
1 In this report, we studied asynchronously cycling 293T cells as an established model system in order first to develop our methods and then to obtain a time-averaged, “global” picture of Brd2 complex composition.
Brd2 complexes are likely to provide a functional link between mitogenic signal transduction pathways and mechanisms of cell cycle progression, particularly
cyclin A transcriptional control.
11 In a Tg mouse model wherein Brd2 constitutive expression is B cell-restricted, Brd2 upregulates
cyclin A transcription, destabilizes the cell cycle and leads to B cell malignancy.
10 Furthermore, constitutive expression of
BRD2 in the lymphoid compartment increases
cyclin A transcription, “priming” pre-malignant, Tg B cells for over-proliferation. Thus, the identities of Brd2-associated proteins in the constitutively expressed state are likely to be informative of lymphoid carcinogenesis. In the case of Adenovirus delivery to 293T cells, we have controlled for Brd2 expression with “empty vector” Adenovirus constructs, which gives us confidence that Brd2 overexpression is sufficient to increase
cyclin A transcription, although any interpretation of cell cycle “destabilization” in 293T cells must be made with caution because of the already highly transformed nature of these cells. Nevertheless, having worked out our MS methods in this system, we are poised to explore Brd2 complex composition and function in normal systems with endogenous Brd2 levels, such as activated human primary B cells; in nonmalignant Tg B cells and Tg B cell lymphomas;
10 and in an important control case, murine brd2
(−/
−) null B cells, which we are currently generating with Cre-Lox technology. We expect these experiments will illuminate the role of Brd2 complexes in the control mechanisms of normal B cell mitogenesis and deregulated proliferation in malignancy.
The presence of components of the SWI/SNF nucleosome remodeling complex in association with Brd2 is consistent with the long-established mechanism whereby histone acetylation and nucleosome remodeling work together in transcriptional activation.
1,2,30,33 The SWI/SNF complex is the best-characterized nucleosome remodeling complex
2,4,21 and is composed of 11 subunits, two of which (Baf155 and Brg-1) we have so far identified. Brg-1 and the related protein brahma (Brm) are catalytic components of SWI/SNF complex. They do not bind to specific DNA sequences, but they form separate, related SWI/SNF complexes that are recruited to promoters and that are essential for growth and development.
34 Apart from histones and histone modifying enzymes, SWI/SNF components are also known to interact with E2F proteins,
35 a property that underscores the functional links between Brd2 and proliferation, as well as with the general transcription machinery, TAFs, Mediator and RNA Polymerase II.
36,37 Definition of a Brd2-dependent structural assembly that requires ATP to associate offers in vitro support for the idea that these sub-complexes actually do physically associate in a single “supercomplex”, whereas earlier discussion has tended to use transitive logic: E2F proteins are associated with basal transcription machinery at promoter DNA and SWI/SNF is associated with promoter chromatin, therefore E2Fs must be associated with SWI/SNF and TAFs at promoter chromatin.
We summarize our findings of the aggregate Brd2 complex in the scheme presented in . We have used anti-HA- Brd2 immunoaffinity chromatography to isolate components of the DNA/chromatin-directed subcomplexes shown. The major subcomplexes represented include: (a) the core promoter and TATA binding factor (TBP)-associated factors (TAFs) TBP, TAF
II250, TAF
II55, TAF
II170, and RNA Polymerase II; (b) activated transcription factors E2F and DP-1; (c) Mediator/scaffold proteins Brd2 and MED6; (d) chromatin/histone modification enzymes HDAC11, CBP, and p300; and (e) SWI/SNF remodeling complex components Brg-1/Snf2
β, p270, and Baf155. Interestingly, all of these complexes are represented, but none in its entirety. For example, several of the RNA Polymerase holoenzyme components and general transcription factors have not been detected. Also not detected were some of the TAFs, such as TAF
II130 and TAF
II150; many of the Mediator elements, such as MED1–5, 7–31, CDK8, or CycC; and some of the Swi/Snf proteins, such as Brm/Snf2α and Swi2/Snf2. Neither did we detect representative elements of other nucleosome remodeling machines such as RSC, ISWI, SAGA, or ADA. The presence of the basal transcription factor TAF
II250 (and its inhibitor38 TAF
II55) is significant because the double bromodomain structure of Brd2 is very closely related to TAF
II250.7 Histone acetylation of
cyclin A promoter chromatin, probably in part through HAT activity that is intrinsic or associated with TAF
II250, is essential for
cyclin A transcription and cell cycle progression.
14 Indeed, TAF
II250 was originally named
CCG1, for Cell Cycle Gene 1.
7 On the basis of these similarities, we have suggested
11 that certain Brd2 functions may be redundant with TAF
II250.
The presence in a supposed transcriptional activation complex of HDAC11, a protein with transcriptional repression activity, was initially a paradox, but upon consideration of the dual nature of Swi/Snf complexes,
1 which include the repressor Brg-1, its detection here is not so surprising. Specifically, the transcriptional control of E2F-regulated cell cycle genes is essential to proper progression through each stage of the cell cycle. The
cyclin A locus, for example, is transcriptionally repressed in G
1 phase, then activated in S phase, then repressed again as the cell exits S phase, a mechanism that clearly requires coordinated regulation,
11,31,33,35 as we have discussed elsewhere.
1 The dual nature of chromatin remodeling was first observed in yeast, wherein Swi/Snf complexes, which were initially associated with transcriptional activation,
39 were later linked to repression as well:
swi/snf mutations transcriptionally activate more yeast genes than they repress.
40Swi/Snf complexes can perform different functions, depending on the promoter context, and sometimes work in collaboration with HAT/HDAC exchange.
33 Ectopic expression of Brg-1 is known to repress
E2F1 and
cyclin A promoters through interaction with the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor protein (RB) to enhance RB-mediated transcription repression during G
1 phase.31,41,42 These considerations led to a hypothesis that the Brd2 complex is present at the
cyclin A promoter not only during S phase, when it acts as part of a transcriptional activating machine, but during G
1 phase as well, when transcriptional repression is required. We have recently confirmed this hypothesis in fibroblasts.
11 The complex analyzed above was purified from asynchronous, cycling cells, and is therefore a time-average of complex composition, with every stage of the cell cycle represented. Our results do not imply that all the elements illustrated () are simultaneously present in association with each Brd2 molecule. Cell cycle-specific changes in complex composition may alter the functions of the complex. We suspect that this mechanism underlies
cyclin A transcriptional deregulation in Tg mice.
10We demonstrate herein the first biochemical purification of endogenous histones in association with a double bromo-domain protein. Previous reports employed nonphysiological methods, such as glutathione-S-transferase pull-downs
6 or yeast two-hybrid analysis.
17 The presence on mitotic chromosomes of the double bromodomain proteins Brd2
15 and Brd4
12,16 probably reflects a high association constant, exploitable in this kind of affinity purification. However, this constant may be too low in single bromodomain protein–histone interactions to permit biochemical isolation. In further stages of these investigations, we will use the methods employed here to map specific amino acid modifications, such as acetylation of histones in the complex, which may also influence complex recruitment.
19,39 Comprehensive analysis of lysine acetylation requires MS methods because modifications are spread throughout each histone molecule, and are not exclusively localized to the amino terminal tails, for which commercial Ab reagents exist.
43 Of particular interest is our identification of components of the mammalian Swi/Snf complex in association with Brd2. Previous MS analyses of the yeast Swi/Snf complex
44,45 or Mediator
23 identified a partially overlapping set of proteins; several chromatin remodeling complexes contain the DNA-dependent ATPases Snf2/Swi2p, Sth1p, Brg-1, Brm, and Iswi. We speculate that this Brd2-associated set of Swi/Snf components defines a specific Brd2-dependent chromatin remodeling complex. Intriguingly, MS and immunoblot studies of the human trithorax “supercomplex”
46 also identify SWI/SNF components (Brm and Baf155), HDACs, TAF
II250, and TBP in association with methylation of lysine 4 of histone H3 and acetylation of histone H4. Human trithorax, named ALL-1 for Acute Lymphocytic Leukemia or MLL for Mixed Lineage Leukemia, is also a bromodomain protein and a homologue of
Drosophila trithorax. Its disruption by chromosomal translocation at 11q23 underlies many of these human leukemias. Because
fsh genetically activates
trithorax during fly development,
47 we originally proposed
8 that the relationship between Brd2 and ALL-1/MLL is conserved in humans. Thus, these complexes may serve important and specific functions in proliferation and cancer.
We will use isotopic labeling methods and two-dimensional SDS-PAGE with Ab immunoblot to define the relative stoichiometry of Brd2 complex components in further stage-specific experiments. Alternatively, the Brd2 complex may share subunits of nucleosome remodeling complexes but not the complexes in their entirety, inasmuch as many complexes share the histone-like TAFs. These subunits might be important to target Brd2 to sequence specific activators, after which Brd2 might act as a docking platform for other coactivators. We expect that chromatin immunoprecipitation of the MS-identified components in synchronized cells at different stages of the cell cycle or under different regimens of mitogenic stimulation will help resolve these questions for the
cyclin A promoter. There is sufficient evidence to hypothesize that increased levels of the Brd2 scaffold are oncogenic in any normal cell because of increased
cyclin A transcriptional activation. Finally, proteomics and bioinformatics approaches will allow us to define the characteristic molecular events of the Brd2-driven Tg lymphoma and to define potential biomarkers for diagnosis and therapeutic intervention, such have been validated recently for cancer-specific expression of endothelial cell proteomes.
48 Taken as a whole, this research illuminates the regulation of transcription through the coordinated action of large complexes that recruit specific transcription factor proteins, nucleosome remodeling machines, and histone modification enzymes to promoter chromatin.