This study provides a detailed assessment of acute HCV infection outcomes in a large cohort of young IDU with a high incidence of HCV and a significant number of acute infections. Analyses using interval censored techniques showed that an estimated 20% of infected individuals resolved infection, and that 86% of those followed cleared within six months of infection. Females were over three times more likely to resolve HCV than males, and female clearers showed a significantly steeper decline in HCV viral load during early infection compared to male clearers. Finally, reinfection and re-clearance was common.
Numerous studies have shown that women are more likely to resolve HCV infection compared to men [
5,
8,
27]. Almost half (45%) of women who received HCV contaminated Rh immune globulin cleared infection [
28,
29]. Other studies have not shown gender differences including among IDU [
18], or in cross-sectional population samples [
30]. In cross-sectional studies, a temporal effect might be attributed to a loss of detectable antibody in women who resolved early [
8] resulting in underestimation clearance among women [
31]. A recent systematic review of prospective studies of HCV infection supports that clearance is significantly more likely in women compared to men[
2]. Nevertheless, most studies investigating HCV clearance merely control for gender and therefore this factor remains understudied. Sex differences are also not well understood with respect to treatment outcomes [
32], and progression to liver disease[
33,
34], and sex hormones have been hypothesized to be involved [
35]. The higher rate of clearance among women raises a number of important areas to be examined, not only with respect to controlling infection, but also to potential differences in susceptibility to infection.
For the majority of HCV infected young IDU, infection outcome was determined within six months, the period generally considered to be the defining threshold for infection outcome. However, a measureable number of clearance events occurred outside this window, as others have documented [
6,
8,
16]. In the first two years after infection we show that the probability of clearing infection levels off nine months after infection. We acknowledge, however that these results could be underestimates of the true clearance rates due to the relatively short follow up period [
36]. In a retrospective study of transfusion recipients with an overall 35% clearance rate, 27% cleared within two years, and 8% between 2–10 years later [
8]. We also acknowledge that if participants with aviremia were misclassified as clearers when they were actually experiencing temporary viral suppression followed by viral rebound, we could be overestimating rates of viral clearance. Viral interclations, however are relatively brief and we expect that with the frequent testing in our cohort, we reduced the chances of misclassification[
8].
Patterns of viral load in early infection [
16,
37] and clearance [
38] are usually examined on an individual basis, and are often limited by testing frequency. Our analyses assess patterns in aggregate and present a population perspective of viremia in early infection. Unlike Hofer et al, [
39] we observed neither differences in peak viremia between clearers and non-clearers, nor in the rate of intermittent viremia prior to ramp-up [
40]. Like others we saw steep declines in viremia [
18,
38,
39], and also show significant differences among clearers by sex. These data suggest that monitoring changes in viral load in acute infection may help discriminate cases which should be considered for early HCV treatment from those who might wait for spontaneous resolution, potentially avoiding unnecessary exposure to HCV chemotherapy. HCV RNA values obtained at a single time point were not useful in discriminating between resolvers and non-resolvers, however, and the analyses limit individual inference regarding prediction of infection outcome. Nevertheless, the data are meaningful on a population level and demonstrate the need for more research on the predictive value of early viral kinetics in acute infection.
Frequent HCV viremia testing after initial infection allowed us to demonstrate that the HCV reinfection incidence was high in our young IDU sample, consistent with others [
23,
41–
43]. Re-clearance of HCV after reinfection is not well studied. Mehta et al, [
42] showed that previously infected IDU were 12 times less likely to develop chronic infection with reinfection, and that they had lower peak viral loads and a shorter duration of subsequent viremia compared to initial infection. Gerlach showed viremia generally lasted less than 12 weeks among reinfected IDU who re-cleared [
44]. These and other studies of recurring infection and clearance in animals demonstrate that host genetic and/or immune responses exist that protect from chronic infection [
45,
46]. It is also unknown unclear whether persons who clear one viral strain have reduced infection susceptibility to the same or different HCV genotypes, as has been seen in animals [
47]. Our results and others show that there is greater genetic heterogeneity in HCV among active IDU [
23] than in clinical and other populations [
30,
48]. Reinfections were confirmed in two of the seven cases by a switch in HCV genotypes. The remaining five cases failed to yield genotype information and will require direct viral sequencing to confirm that reinfection occurred. The use of serotyping may have limitations: if it reflects the first infection, subsequent reinfections could be misclassified. Some had very short HCV negative intervals, which could indicate rapid clearance after reinfection as others have shown[
42,
44]. Further studies of reinfection and re-clearance are needed to shed more light mechanisms that may protect against persistent infection [
47].
Despite the relatively large number of new infections and systematic follow up, we were nonetheless limited by the small number of clearance and reinfection events, indicating the need to combine data from multiple acute infection HCV cohorts to refine estimates for rates and kinetics HCV infection outcomes. The significant differences found by sex show the need for further studies of biological and immunological differences between females and males in HCV infection control. Finally, incidence of HCV remains very high in IDU, and more work is urgently needed to prepare for and develop vaccines which will offer the most important opportunity to prevent and control this common bloodborne viral infection [
49,
50].