|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Hsp90 is an ATP-dependent molecular chaperone that regulates key signaling proteins and thereby impacts cell growth and development. Chaperone cycle of Hsp90 is regulated by ATP binding and hydrolysis through its intrinsic ATPase activities, which is in turn modulated by interaction with its co-chaperones. Hsp90 ATPase activity varies in different organisms and is known to be increased in tumor cells. In this study we have quantitatively analyzed the impact of increasing Hsp90 ATPase activity on the activities of its clients through a virtual prototyping technology, which comprises a dynamic model of Hsp90 interaction with clients involved in proliferation pathways. Our studies highlight the importance of increased ATPase activity of Hsp90 in cancer cells as the key modulator for increased proliferation and survival. A tenfold increase in ATPase activity of Hsp90 often seen in cancer cells increases the levels of active client proteins such as Akt-1, Raf-1 and Cyclin D1 amongst others to about 12-, 8- and 186-folds respectively. Additionally we studied the effect of a competitive inhibitor of Hsp90 activity on the reduction in the client protein levels. Virtual prototyping experiments corroborate with findings that the drug has almost 10- to 100-fold higher affinity as indicated by a lower IC50 value (30–100 nM) in tumor cells with higher ATPase activity. The results also indicate a 15- to 25-fold higher efficacy of the inhibitor in reducing client levels in tumor cells. This analysis provides mechanistic insights into the links between increased Hsp90 ATPase activity, tumor phenotype and the hypersensitivity of tumor Hsp90 to inhibition by ATP analogs.
The online version of this article (doi:10.1007/s11693-009-9046-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.
Hsp90 (Heat shock protein 90) is one of the most abundant protein of eukaryotic cells, comprising 1–2% of the total protein under non-stress conditions (Pratt and Toft 2003). It is mainly an ATP-dependent molecular chaperone which performs house-keeping functions controlling the activity, turnover, and trafficking of a variety of proteins (Pratt and Toft 2003). It plays an important role in the folding of at least 100 specific proteins of various signaling pathways that have crucial role in growth control, cell survival and development processes and in the refolding of denatured proteins during proteotoxic stress including heat, oxidative stress and acidosis (Whitesell and Lindquist 2005). A unique ATP-binding site, the Bergerat fold, exists in the N-terminal domain of Hsp90 which is the characteristic of only some bacterial gyrases, topoisomerases and histidine-kinases besides Hsp90. This unique N-terminal ATP-binding pocket allowed for the development of specific Hsp90 inhibitors (Marcu et al.2000; Garnier et al.2002; Sõti et al.2002).
The chaperone function of Hsp90 requires the formation of a multi-chaperone complex, consisting of Hsp70, Hop, p23, and Hsp40 and is dependent on ATP-binding and hydrolysis (Fig. 1; Pratt and Toft 2003; McLaughlin et al. 2002; Siligardi et al.2004; Panaretou et al. 1998). This complex binds to key signaling proteins in the metabolic states and regulates their activities in response to appropriate stimuli. It is the inherent ATPase activity of Hsp90 which drives a conformational cycle involving transient association and dissociation of the N-terminal nucleotide-binding domains within the Hsp90 dimer (Siligardi et al. 2004). This suggests that binding of ATP to Hsp90 plays an essential role in the functioning of the Hsp90 chaperone machinery.
Human Hsp90 in its isolated form has a very weak ATPase activity (McLaughlin et al. 2002; Richter et al. 2001). The interaction of Hsp90 with its co-chaperones results in an increase in the inherent ATPase activity for Hsp90. In fact, the co-chaperones Cdc37, Aha-1, Hop and p23 modulate Hsp90 ATPase activity significantly (Siligardi et al. 2004; Kamal et al. 2004; Siligardi et al. 2002). An increased ATPase activity correlates with an increase in the Hsp90 chaperone cycle and increased processing, folding and release of the active client proteins (Pratt and Toft 2003).
Hsp90 plays a key role in the conformational maturation of many signaling proteins and protein kinases like Akt-1 (protein kinase B), Raf-1, Cdk4 (cyclin-dependent kinase 4), which are important regulators of cell proliferation and survival (Whitesell and Lindquist 2005; Kamal et al. 2004). All these protein kinases form novel complexes with Hsp90 and are stabilized and activated by the Hsp90 ATP-dependent chaperone cycle (Sato et al. 2000; Lawlor and Alessi 2004; Schulte et al. 1995).
In this study, through a dynamic and mathematical in silico model of Hsp90 interaction with its client proteins such as Akt and Raf-1 that are involved in cell survival, proliferation and apoptosis signaling pathways, we quantitatively analyze the effects of modulation of Hsp90 ATPase activity on cell survival and proliferation endpoints (Fig. 2). Through this virtual ‘what-if’ analysis, we get an insight into the quantitative outcome of increasing ATPase activity of Hsp90 by different folds and the consequential fold variations in the activities of its various client proteins. Additionally, we have performed virtual experiments with an inhibitor of Hsp90. We analyzed the efficacy of the inhibitor with increasing ATPase activity and also efficacy of a range of IC50’s of the inhibitor and its impact on the system with varying Hsp90 activity. Predictive studies through such virtual prototyping experiments are insightful in obtaining mechanistic understanding for known experimental observations such as increased Hsp90 ATPase activity in tumor cells (Kamal et al. 2003); getting semi-quantitative information on biomarker profiles; and also streamlining inhibitor kinetics.
The platform consists of the Hsp90 interactome associated with cell proliferation, survival and apoptosis processes. The reactions related to binding of Hsp90 with its client proteins and the stabilization and activation of these clients in the above cellular processes are detailed. This includes the ATP-dependent chaperoning cycle of Hsp90 and its ubiquitous role in the regulation of cellular processes. Figure 2 is the actual snapshot of the virtual system in which are highlighted different cellular processes regulated by Hsp90 that are included in this study. It is a dynamic model with each reaction represented through an ordinary differential equation and it predicts the quantitative effects on the levels of each of the Hsp90 clients, with an increase in binding affinity for ATP and Hsp90 ATPase activity. The key sections of the model are qualitatively described in Supplementary information S1, with the equations and mechanisms for each node tabulated in Supplementary information S2.
The model is a dynamic representation of Hsp90 ATP-dependent chaperone cycle and includes kinetic details for the regulation of Hsp90 client proteins. The time dependent client protein binding to Hsp90 multi-chaperone complex and release of the active client following ATP-hydrolysis has been done utilizing modified ordinary differential equations (ODE) and mass action kinetics. The ODEs are solved by Radau method (Raichur et al. 2006). The Cellworks proprietary technology, iC-PHYS™ has been used to create and simulate the platform.
The model is a generic Hsp90 centric system and not specific to a cell type. The binding affinity of all protein kinases to Hsp90_cdc37 complex has been assumed to be the same. The ATP concentration is maintained at 5,000 μM and ADP at 2,000 μM in the model to maintain a physiological ratio. The phosphate source has not been explicitly modeled in the system. It has been assumed that Hsp90 has a very weak ATPase activity in normal cells, with a Kf = 1.5E−1 s−1 (McLaughlin et al. 2002; Richter et al. 2001). It has been assumed that ATP-hydrolysis results in release of active client proteins from Hsp90 chaperone complex. ATP-binding displaces cdc37 from Hsp90-chaperone complex and only then p23 binds to Hsp90 in the ATP form. The protein degradation process is mediated by ubiquitination, but in the system, all degradation processes are shown as irreversible and spontaneous reactions. A constant source for EGFL6, EGFR, IGF-1R, PDGFR, PDGF, Her2, Her3 has been assumed in the system to account for their constitutive expression due to gain of function mutations during cancer (Fredrick et al. 2000; O’Rourke et al. 1997; Puputti et al. 2006; Joensuu et al. 2005).
At initial conditions the model represents normal ATPase activity for Hsp90 with a Kf of 1.5E−1 s−1 (optimized from the original value of 1.5E−3 s−1 mentioned (McLaughlin et al. 2002; Kamal et al. 2003). The client proteins remain bound to the Hsp90 chaperone complex and ATP hydrolysis drives the release of the active client proteins. Hsp90 and its co-chaperone cdc37 were maintained at a concentration of 10 μM (Carrello et al. 2004) in the system.
‘What-if’ analysis or hypothesis testing has been done to see the effects of increased ATPase activity on the cell proliferation, survival and apoptosis processes. The ATPase activity of Hsp90 has been hypothetically increased by 10-, 30- and 50-folds. Increased ATP-binding and ATPase activity of Hsp90 has been shown to occur in tumor cells (Kamal et al. 2003). The levels of the client proteins namely Akt-1, Raf-1, Casp9, Bad and Cyclin D1 have been analyzed with the variation in the ATPase activity.
A generic competitive inhibitor has been tested on the system to observe the effects of reduced Hsp90 ATPase activity on the processes of cell proliferation, survival and apoptosis. The kinetics used were for Hsp90 inhibitor 17-AAG (17-(Allylamino)-17-demethoxygeldanamycin) with a Ki of 4.9E−2 μM (Kamal et al. 2003). The drug concentrations used for the study were in the range of 0.1, 0.5, 1, 5 and 10 μM of the drug. It is explicitly assumed that the concentration of the drug is present at the site of action post ADME (absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion). Efficacy of the inhibitor with varying Hsp90 ATPase activity has been tested. Additionally, to test the sensitivity of binding of the inhibitor to systems with varying Hsp90 ATPase activity, we have tested a wide range of IC50 values in the range of 30–3,000 nM.
Control state is defined as one in which the ATPase activity is basal at 0.15 s−1. A disease state is where the ATPase activity is 50-fold higher at 7.5 s−1. The drug was tested in the disease state at the Ki and concentration mentioned in “Inhibitor of Hsp90 ATPase activity”
Phospho Akt-1, (pAkt-1) a significant marker for cell survival, is a known interactor and a substrate for Hsp90. Cancer cells that have increased Hsp90 ATPase activity have been shown to exhibit increased active Akt-1 levels (Lawlor and Alessi 2004; Kamal et al. 2003).This observation has been analyzed using a virtual Hsp90 platform where the ATPase activity of Hsp90 has been increased by 10-, 30- and 50-folds and its effect on the active Akt-1 levels were observed (Supplementary Information S1, Sect. 1.2.1). Active Akt-1 initially shows a stoichiometric increase in levels with an increasing ATPase activity upto tenfolds, but beyond a 30-fold rise in ATPase activity the fold increase in the pAkt-1 levels increases significantly (for a 50-fold increase in the Hsp90 ATPase activity, pAkt-1 increases by 120-folds; Fig. 3a). This is due to the existing feed-forward loop from IRS1 present in the system (Supplimentay Information, Sect. 1.2.2 B). When the feed-forward loop is switched off, the increase in pAkt-1 levels remains stoichiometric even with a 50-folds increase in Hsp90 ATPase activity (Fig. 3b). A comparison between the two effects has been done in Fig. 3c. As a result of increased Akt-1 activation with increase in Hsp90 activity, the downstream targets of Akt-1 in the survival, proliferation and apoptosis signaling pathways are also increased. An example of the downstream effects of Akt-1 is the inactivation due to increased phosphorylation of pro-apoptotic proteins such as Caspase 9 and BAD, as shown in Fig. 3d. This shows that with an increase in Hsp90 ATPase activity there is a simultaneous increase in the anti-apoptotic effect.
Raf-1P is another major Hsp90 client and an important player in the cell proliferation pathway. Raf-1 is stabilized and activated by Hsp90. Activated Raf-1, further activates many downstream transcription factors like ELK-1, ATF-2, NFkB, B-catenin and AP-1, resulting in the expression of Cyclin D1. Cyclin D1 forms an active complex with the cell-cycle kinase Cdk4 and helps in the G1-S phase transition (Kamal et al. 2004; Goetz et al. 2003), acting as a key biomarker for cell proliferation. With a 50-folds increase in the Hsp90 ATPase activity, Raf-1P level was found to be increased by 35-fold. However, a dramatic increase in the levels of Cyclin D1 (180-folds) is seen even with a tenfold increase in the ATPase activity, thereby indicating an increase in cell proliferation. This dramatic increase in Cyclin D1 levels can be attributed to an increase in all the transcription factors responsible for its synthesis. All the above transcription factors are known to transcribe Cyclin D1 and a reasonable increase in each of these levels occurs with the increasing Hsp90 ATPase activity. Figure 4 highlights the effect of increasing ATPase activity on Raf-1P and Cyclin D1 levels, respectively obtained through virtual prototyping studies.
As indicated by the trends seen an increase in the ATPase activity of Hsp90 results in an increase in the levels of active Hsp90 client proteins that are key players in cell proliferation and survival. We have analyzed how an inhibitor of Hsp90 ATPase activity would affect these endpoints (Methods in “Inhibitor of Hsp90 ATPase Activity”). The inhibitor was represented to competitively inhibit the ATP binding to Hsp90 and thereby interfere with the normal ATPase cycle of Hsp90 (Goetz et al. 2003; Banerji et al. 2005; Richter et al. 2001).
Virtual experimental studies reveal that Akt-1 which increases by 120-folds when ATPase activity is 50-fold higher than baseline (representative of a cancer condition), is reduced by almost 24-folds with 1 μM concentration of the generic inhibitor. Similarly, Raf-1P shows an 18-fold reduction in levels after having increased to 35-folds in the high ATPase condition (Fig. 5).
Inhibiting Hsp90 ATPase activity does seem to have a significant impact on the key tumor survival and proliferation markers such as pAkt-1 and Raf-1P, as supported by successful outcomes of clinical trials of Hsp90 inhibitors such as 17-AAG, 17-DMAG, IPI-504, SNX-7081, Novobiocin (Banerji et al. 2005; Abramson et al. 2008; Sydor et al. 2006; Rice et al. 2008). Hsp90 has been widely accepted as a potential cancer therapeutic target (Goetz et al. 2003; Radanyi et al. 2008; Messaoudi et al. 2008).
We analyzed the inhibitor binding affinity and efficacy of reducing the cell survival endpoints through monitoring reduction in activated Akt-1 levels. It was observed that with 1 μM concentration of the inhibitor with Ki of 4.9E−2, active Akt-1 levels were reduced by almost 24-folds when the ATPase activity was 7.5 s−1 (50-fold) as compared to only 12-folds with an ATPase activity of 1.5 s−1 (30-fold; Fig. 6a). This data clearly indicates that the inhibitor would be more efficacious when ATPase activity for Hsp90 is higher, as is seen in cancer cells (Kamal et al. 2003) as compared to cells with a lower ATPase activity (normal cells). Virtual prototyping studies reveal that the inhibitor will be more effective or sensitive in a cancer condition marked by a sequential increase in the ATPase activity for Hsp90 (Fig. 6a).
We also analyzed the drug efficacy by increasing IC50 values for the inhibitor (range between 30 and 3,000 nM) at a constant drug concentration of 1 μM. A higher IC50 value would essentially mean a lower binding affinity for the drug and vice versa. It was seen that tumor cells generally have a lower IC50 value (Kamal et al. 2003). As shown in Fig. 6b, the drug effectiveness in reducing pAkt-1 levels at 1 μM concentration is decreasing with an increase in IC50 values. The drug is effective upto an IC50 of 100 nM beyond which negligible reduction of pAkt-1 is seen. It shows the highest reduction of pAkt-1 by 35-folds at an IC50 of 30 nM. The impact of this inhibition on a normal cell with high IC50 value (in the range of μM) will be less as compared to tumor cell with low IC50 value (in the range of nM). This analysis indicates that not only the inhibition of Hsp90 ATPase activity is more effective in conditions where the system has higher ATPase activity such as a tumor cell but also it would have higher binding affinity to this state over a normal state. This study suggests that inhibition of Hsp90 ATPase activity with a drug having a low IC50 value less than 100 nM would be beneficial in impacting the key tumor endpoints of proliferation and survival without much perturbation to the normal system.
Hsp90 is an ATP-dependent molecular chaperone which performs house-keeping functions controlling the activity, turnover, and trafficking of a variety of proteins (Pratt and Toft 2003). It serves as a key convergent node in the cell signaling circuit not just for the human cell types but for other organisms as well, based on the concept of common circuitry and design across varied life forms. The Hsp90 molecular machinery is dependent on ATP-binding and hydrolysis and operates as a multi-chaperone complex. Recent evidence suggests an intricate link between Hsp90 ATPase activity and structural dynamics accompanying its chaperoning cycle and the universality of this across different organisms (Southworth and Agard 2008).
There has been experimental evidence of different states of a system (i.e., normal vs. tumor states) having varying Hsp90 ATPase activity (Kamal et al. 2003). Furthermore, the Hsp90 activity characterized from different organisms exhibit widely different ATPase activities (Owen et al. 2002). While the reason underlying varying ATPase activities of Hsp90 from different systems remain unknown, this study makes an effort to quantitatively study the consequence of this variation in its catalytic efficiency on maturation of its client proteins and its overall impact on organism growth. Virtual analysis shown here has also revealed that variation in catalytic activities of Hsp90 from different systems may confer differential sensitivities to small molecule inhibitors of Hsp90. This dynamic, computational, quantitative analysis of Hsp90 networks shown here provides a theoretical framework to analyze the impact of varying its ATPase activity on maturation of its clients, progression through signaling pathways and organism growth. In addition, it provides a basis to predict the extent of growth inhibition conferred by generic Hsp90 inhibitors on organisms with differing Hsp90 ATPase acitivities.
Hsp90 is a molecular target for cancer therapeutics and Hsp90 inhibitors are now widely being tested in clinical trials for depletion of clients including several oncogenic kinases (Kamal et al. 2004; Goetz et al. 2003; Issacs et al. 2002; Stepanova et al. 1996; Smith et al. 2008). More than being just a cancer therapeutic target, Hsp90 inhibitors are now extensively being tested for treatment of other diseases including neurodegenerative disorders (Waza et al. 2005; Dickey et al. 2007), rheumatoid arthritis (Rice et al. 2008), diabetes (Yang et al. 2009), malaria as well as other infectious diseases of fungal and viral origin (Banumathy et al. 2003; Wider et al. 2009; Nicola et al. 2008; Chase et al. 2008). The regulation of various client proteins by Hsp90 highlights its ubiquitous role in various organisms like Plasmodium falciparum (Banumathy et al. 2003; Acharya et al. 2007), Candida albicans (Solit and Chiosis, 2008), Aspergillus fumigates, Cryptococcus neoformans (Cardenas et al. 1999) and Vaccinia virus (Hu and Seeger 1996).
In light of the key role of Hsp90 in many organisms and disease processes, we analyzed the effect of a generic Hsp90 competitive inhibitor on the system and could substantially conclude from the results that the sensitivity (binding affinity) towards inhibition would increase with the increasing ATPase activity for Hsp90. For instance, a tenfold increase in ATPase activity has shown 12% increase (Fig. 6a) in inhibition by an Hsp90 inhibitor like geldanamycin. The analysis has also shown that inhibition of ATPase activity of Hsp90 is efficacious in reducing the cell survival and proliferation endpoints.
The results support the notion that an increased ATPase activity for Hsp90 during cancer (Kamal et al. 2003) would also increase its sensitivity to a particular inhibitor targeting inhibition of its ATPase activity. Hence, a specific Hsp90 inhibitor would be more effective against a cancer cell with higher ATPase activity in preference to a normal cell. Our studies indicate that an inhibitor to Hsp90 such as 17-AAG, 17-dimethylaminoethylamino-17-demethoxy-geldanamycin (17-DMAG) would be 15- to 25-fold more effective against a cancer cell with a higher ATPase activity as compared to the normal cell with a very weak ATPase activity for Hsp90. Reducing survival and proliferation specifically of the tumor cells is the need of an hour in order to overcome the toxic side effects of chemotherapeutic drugs.
Hsp90 inhibitors presently under clinical trials include 17-AAG (NC1, Kosan Biosciences), KOS-953 (Kosan Biosciences), CNF-1010 and CNF-2024 (Biogen Idec), IPI-504 (Infinity Pharmaceuticals) and SNX-5422 (Serenex; Solit and Chiosis 2008). Most of these are now under Phase II and Phase III clinical trials. These inhibitors induce depletion of the clients by blocking the binding of ATP to Hsp90 and hence inhibiting the ATPase chaperone cycle. Other inhibitors that target co-chaperone proteins like Cdc37 (Smith et al. 2008) and Hop (Yi and Regan 2008) are also being studied as an alternative approach to inhibit Hsp90 mediated activation of various client proteins.
This dynamic virtual system can also be used to study the role of Hsp90 activity on other phenotypes that are affected in cancer such as increased angiogenesis, metastasis, and increased expression of drug resistance proteins. Through this study we present a novel approach for target validation and understanding the efficacy of manipulating a target in normal versus abnormal cell systems. The study strongly supports the role of Hsp90 as a “Master switch” for cell survival and proliferation and a therapeutic target (Goetz et al. 2003; Banerji et al. 2005; Beliakoff and Whitesell 2004).
Authors sincerely thank Dr. Fred Gorin for reviewing the manuscript and giving his valuable feedback. R. P acknowledges Junior Research Fellowship from the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, New Delhi, India. UT acknowledges DBT, DST, New Delhi, India and Malsig for their financial support.
Statement of conflicts of interest None.
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.
Shireen Vali and Rani Pallavi have contributed equally to the article.