In the early 1970s, studies on fusion of human cells suggested that DNA in G1 nuclei was competent for initiation of DNA replication, but G1 cells lacked an activator(s) that was present in S phase cells
8. The competent state has been defined as licensing of replication origins prior to S phase
1, 5, 9, 10. The process occurs at the M-phase exit through G1 phase, when a pre-replicative complex (pre-RC) forms at each origin. Pre-RC assembly begins with the binding of the Origin Recognition Complex (ORC), which recruits more protein factors, and ultimately completes with the loading the minichromosome maintenance (MCM) complex. Subsequently S phase-specific kinases, S-CDKs and DDK, activate this competent state by promoting assembly of the Cdc45-MCM-GINS (CMG) complex, the active replicative helicase
11-13. The minimal set of S-CDK targets essential for initiation of replication has been identified
6, 7. S-CDKs phosphorylate Sld2 and Sld3, enabling them to bind to Dbp11
6, 7, 14. Genetic and biochemical evidence suggested the MCM complex as one DDK target
3, 4. In budding yeast, DDK phosphorylates several MCM subunits and a mutation in
MCM5,
mcm5-bob1, can survive without DDK
15-19.
DDK binds to Mcm4 via a kinase-docking domain, allowing processive phosphorylation of multiple sites within the adjacent 174 amino acid NSD
18. Since deletion of NSD does not prevent cells from initiating DNA replication, it is likely that the role of NSD is regulatory. One hypothesis is that the NSD of Mcm4 blocks the activation of licensed origins and phosphorylation of the NSD by DDK alleviates the inhibition. To test this idea, we replaced the chromosomal
MCM4 with
mcm4Δ2-174, which lacks the entire NSD, in the temperature sensitive (
ts) DDK mutants
cdc7-4 and
dbf4-1. Deletion of the Mcm4 NSD rescued the
ts defect of
cdc7-4 or
dbf4-1 (). Moreover,
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ2-174 cells were viable (
Fig. S1). The
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ2-174 cells, however, grow slowly, likely due to (1) residues 2-174 harbor a domain needed for optimal MCM functions, or (2) DDK has another function in addition to its essential role in regulating Mcm4. Nevertheless, removing the Mcm4 NSD allows cells to bypass the essential function of DDK.
The ability of
mcm4Δ2-174 to bypass DDK is recessive to
MCM4. Re-introducing a
MCM4 vector into
dbf4-1 mcm4Δ2-174 allows cells to grow better at the permissive temperature (22°C), but they did not grow at 37°C, in contrast to the empty vector (). Moreover, the
MCM4 plasmid, unlike the empty vector, failed to yield transformed colonies in
cdc7-4 mcm4Δ2-174 or
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ2-174 cells, while
CDC7 efficiently rescued
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ2-174 cells (
Fig. S2a and S2b). Together, these results suggest that the Mcm4 NSD contains an inhibitory activity that renders DDK essential for viability. Therefore, we used transformation of
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ2-174 cells as an assay to map the inhibitory activity. While transformation of the
mcm4Δ74-174 plasmid or empty vector yielded numerous colonies, transformation of plasmids carrying either
MCM4,
mcm4Δ2-73 or
mcm4Δ2-145 produced none (Fig. and
S2c). Thus, the inhibitory activity resides within 74-174 of Mcm4 and residues 146-174 are sufficient for inhibiting transformation of
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ2-174 cells. We have previously demonstrated DDK target sites within the 146-174 region
18. Here, we found that the phospho-mimetic mutation constructs (
mcm4Δ2-145, 5D+2D or
mcm4Δ2-145, 4D+2D) produced many transformed colonies whereas a construct that could not be phosphorylated by DDK (
mcm4Δ2-145, 5A+2A) failed to produce transformants in
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ2-174 cells (Fig. and
S2c). Thus, at least a portion of the Mcm4 NSD proximal to the DDK docking domain is inhibitory and phosphorylation of this region by DDK antagonizes the inhibitory effect.
We tested those
mcm4 alleles without the inhibitory activity for DDK bypass using a modified plasmid shuffle assay (; see legend). This assay is stringent and relies on a
CEN-based plasmid with a single replication origin to carry the tested allele. Thus, only those
mcm4 alleles that can both fulfill the function of Mcm4 and bypass the requirement for DDK efficiently would allow the tester strain to survive on 5-Fluoroorotic Acid (5-FOA) media. Plasmids carrying
mcm4Δ74-174,
mcm4Δ2-145, 5D+2D and
mcm4Δ2-145, 4D+2D allowed growth on 5-FOA media, indicating that these mutant alleles can cope with simultaneous loss of both
MCM4 and
CDC7 genes. In contrast, plasmids carrying
CDC7,
MCM4,
mcm4Δ2-174,
mcm4Δ2-73,
mcm4Δ2-145 and
mcm4Δ2-145,5A+2A scored negative in this assay. Although unphosphorylated
mcm4Δ2-145 appears to be sufficient for exerting the inhibitory effect (), the inhibitory domain extends beyond residues 146-174 because
mcm4Δ147-174,
mcm4Δ123-174 or
mcm4Δ98-174 also fail to support DDK-independent growth (
Fig. S3). Importantly, alanine substitution of 11 potential DDK phosphorylation sites within 74-174 in the full length NSD is lethal even in the presence of DDK (
Fig. S4). It is possible that, when unphosphorylated, the proximal portion of the NSD exerts its inhibitory effect by imposing on the MCM complex a conformation that is not permissive for recruitment of activating factors, such as Cdc45 and GINS, and phosphorylation by DDK or removal of this domain allows the complex to assume a permissive state. The NSD inhibitory domain may also alter the MCM hexamer oligomeric state. Alternatively, the domain may directly block the access of activating factors.
The fact that
mcm4Δ2-174 scored negative in the stringent assay for DDK-independent cell proliferation is consistent with our previous finding that it executes the function of
MCM4 poorly
18. In contrast,
mcm4Δ74-174 exhibited the best growth on 5-FOA media in the same experiment (), suggesting that the distal part of the Mcm4 NSD (residues 2-73) plays a positive role in supporting DDK-independent growth. A shorter version (residues 2-37) could function similarly (
Fig. S3). The distal NSD of Mcm4 is serine/threonine (S/T) rich and contains four CDK target (S/T-P) sites
20, all of which are preceded by additional S/Ts (), which would become favorable phospho-acceptors for DDK upon priming phosphorylation
21, 22. Converting all four CDK sites to alanines within
mcm4Δ74-174 (i.e.
mcm4Δ74-174, 4(SP→AP)) had little effect on its ability to rescue
mcm4Δ (Fig. and
S5). However, this mutant failed to bypass DDK. In contrast, phospho-mimetic substitution of these sites (i.e.
mcm4Δ74-174, 4(SP→DP)) allowed DDK-independent growth and additional phospho-mimetic substitutions of all the preceding S/Ts further improved the growth (). One caveat is that constitutive phosphorylation or phospho-mimetic substitution may compromise other aspects of Mcm4 function in DNA replication (see
Fig. S10). As a result, the phospho-mimetic derivatives of
mcm4Δ74-174 do not support growth better than
mcm4Δ74-174 which is regulated by phosphorylation. Nevertheless, the positive function within the distal NSD may depend on phospho-regulation by CDK, and possibly by DDK. In the absence of DDK, CDK control of this region becomes essential. It remains to be addressed whether additional kinases also contribute to regulation of the Mcm4 NSD, which also contains multiple potential ATM/ATR target (S/T-Q) sites and many of these are also preceded by stretches of S/Ts.
Other MCM subunits such as Mcm2 and Mcm6 also have extended unstructured amino-terminal domains (NTDs) harboring DDK target sites (
Fig. S6a). However, none of the N-terminal deletion mutants of
MCM2 or
MCM6 tested supported DDK-independent cell growth using analogous plasmid shuffle assays (
Fig. S6 b and c). Thus, the inhibitory activity may be a unique feature of Mcm4. Yet, we have previously demonstrated that the NTD of Mcm2 can functionally replace the Mcm4 NSD in supporting normal cell proliferation and timely S phase progression
18. The
mcm21-200-mcm4Δ2-174 fusion can function as an
mcm4 allele that supports DDK-independent cell proliferation to the extent that surpasses
mcm4Δ74-174 (Fig. and
S7a). Therefore, the Mcm2 NTD has a positive role in activating DNA replication. This region contains >30 % negatively charged aspartic acid (D) and glutamic acid (E) residues, reminiscent of phosphorylated S/Ts. Thus the Mcm2 NTD may act like a phosphorylated distal NSD of Mcm4.
DDK-bypass alleles of
MCM4 were introduced into the endogenous locus in subsequent experiments.
mcm4Δ74-174,
mcm21-200-mcm4Δ2-174 and
mcm5-bob1 cells grew at the same rate as the
WT cells (
Fig. S7a and S7b). The proliferation rates of
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ74-174 and
cdc7Δ mcm5-bob1 were comparable. Consistent with earlier observations (),
cdc7Δ mcm21-200-mcm4Δ2-174 cells proliferated faster than
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ74-174 cells while
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ2-174 cells proliferated more slowly (
Fig. S7b). Cells without DDK grew slowly, entered S phase later and progressed through S phase at slower rates than their DDK positive counterparts (). These results suggest that DDK has other non-essential roles in regulating S phase progression in addition to alleviating the inhibitory activity within the proximal NSD. For example, DDK may phosphorylate the distal NSD of Mcm4 or other substrates for efficient S phase progression.
One important consequence of DDK action during S phase is formation of a stable complex between Cdc45 and MCM at each origin as it is activated
18, 23-25. To determine if
mcm4Δ74-174 can bypass the requirement of DDK for Cdc45-MCM complex formation, co-immunoprecipitation of Cdc45 with Mcm2 antibodies in
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ74-174 cells,
mcm4Δ74-174 and
WT cells was examined. Cells were synchronized to allow progression through the cell cycle from G1 at 25°C (). The Cdc45-MCM complex was detected at similar intensity and kinetics in WT and
mcm4Δ74-174 cells, with a peak at ~40 minutes after G1 release (). In the
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ74-174 cells, the complex appeared at a later time (at ~60 minutes, peak at ~80 minutes) and at reduced levels. Nevertheless, these results demonstrated that eliminating the inhibitory domain in the Mcm4 NSD allows the Cdc45-MCM complex to form in the absence of DDK but DDK is still needed for timely Cdc45-MCM association under this bypass condition.
Recent studies reported conditions that allow yeast cells to replicate DNA in the absence of S-CDKs
6, 7. For example, the requirement for S-CDK for DNA synthesis can be bypassed by combining an
sld3-dpb11 fusion (
SD fusion) and over-expression of a phospho-mimetic
sld2-T84D mutation
7. Under this S-CDK bypass condition, DDK is limiting for DNA replication and over-expression of
DBF4 is necessary for extensive DNA synthesis in α-factor arrested, G1 cells. Instead of Dbf4 over-production, replacing the chromosomal
MCM4 with
mcm4Δ74-174 in this S-CDK bypass system allowed a similar extent of DNA replication in G1 (Fig. and
S8). We also observed a modest but consistent DDK-independent increase of DNA content in G1 by introducing
mcm4Δ74-174 to a different S-CDK bypass condition
6 (
Fig. S9). Furthermore, unlike another DDK bypass mutation
mcm5-bob1,
mcm4Δ74-174 does not exhibit synthetic lethality with the
SD fusion. Thus, DDK bypass is not necessarily synthetic lethal with
SD fusion as previously suggested
7. This result suggests DDK bypass by
mcm4Δ74-174 is different from DDK bypass by
mcm5-bob1. Moreover, accumulating biochemical evidence suggest that Mcm4, Mcm2 and Mcm6, but not Mcm5, are substrates of DDK
15, 17-19, 21, 22, 24, 26. Since
MCM4 does not cause lethality in
mcm5-bob1 cells lacking DDK,
mcm5-bob1 is epistatic to
MCM4 in this condition. Thus, DDK bypass by
mcm5-bob1 is likely downstream of the inhibitory function of the Mcm4 NSD.
In the presence of DDK,
mcm4Δ2-174 cells, but not
mcm4Δ74-174 or
mcm21-200-mcm4Δ2-174 cells, were sensitive to the ribonucleotide reductase inhibitor hydroxyurea (HU) (), suggesting that the distal Mcm4 NSD or its functional equivalent (e.g. NTD of Mcm2) is required under DNA damaging conditions. Like
cdc7Δ mcm5-bob1 cells
19,
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ2-174,
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ74-174 and
cdc7Δ mcm21-200-mcm4Δ2-174 cells were not viable in HU (). Thus,
mcm4Δ74-174 and
mcm21-200-mcm4Δ2-174 do not bypass the requirement of DDK for growth in the presence of HU. We examined checkpoint activation under synchronous G1 to HU release by monitoring Rad53 hyper-phosphorylation (). While checkpoint activation in
MCM4 and
mcm4Δ74-174 cells was efficient, Rad53 hyper-phosphorylation was not detectable in
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ74-174 cells over the course of 3 hours in 200 mM HU. A similar defect in checkpoint activation in S phase was also found in
cdc7Δ mcm5-bob1 cells
27. Although it is conceivable that insufficient initiation in
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ74-174 cells would evade checkpoint
28, HU treatment of the asynchronous
cdc7Δ mcm4Δ74-174 culture, which accumulates a large population of S phase cells, still failed to elicit robust Rad53 phosphorylation, unlike the response of the asynchronous
mcm4Δ74-174 culture (). Thus, it remains possible that DDK is required for the checkpoint response through Rad53 under replication stress (
Fig. S11 and S12). Overall, our results demonstrate that
mcm4Δ74-174 can bypass the requirement for DDK in an unperturbed S phase, but it cannot bypass the requirement for DDK in proper intra-S-phase checkpoint response.
Cell fusion experiments suggested that “certain substances which are present in the S component probably migrate into G1 nucleus and cause initiation of DNA synthesis”
8. The results presented here for DDK and elsewhere for CDK
6, 7, 14 have uncovered essential targets for such activators that must act on the competent pre-RC. One surprising finding is that the essential DDK activity is to inhibit an intrinsic inhibitor of initiation of DNA replication. Our study reveals that the unstructured Mcm4 NSD is a multi-function domain that may serve to integrate various signals to regulate eukaryotic DNA replication.