Though insulin is well known to stimulate
de novo lipogenesis in liver, the precise mechanism by which this is accomplished is not well understood. SREBP1c is clearly an important intermediate in the transcriptional control of lipogenesis, but the pathway by which insulin activates both processing and expression of SREBP1c remains uncertain (
Raghow et al., 2008). To some extent, the difficulty in investigating this problem relates to the low rates of
de novo lipogenesis in the normal postabsorptive liver, which have been estimated to contribute as little as 5% of total triglyceride fatty acids in humans (
Diraison et al., 2003). For this reason, it has proven instructive to manipulate the metabolic state of experimental organisms in order to increase fat accumulation in the liver. In the present study, we have done so employing both genetic and dietary strategies and found a strong dependency on the presence of hepatic Akt2 for the development of steatosis and an absolute requirement for the increase in lipogenesis. Though these data are derived from mouse models of human disease, there is much to support the notion that the obligatory role for Akt2 in lipid synthesis is not unique to the insulin-resistant, steatotic condition. We often see a trend towards lower hepatic triglycerides, fatty acid synthesis and lipogenic gene expression in livers from normal mice on a chow diet and in several cohorts these changes have reached statistical significance (, ). Thus, we can conclude that Akt2 is required definitively for full accretion of hepatic triglyceride during pathological states and it is likely that this is an extension of a requirement for the kinase in normal anabolic lipid metabolism.
One surprising result of these studies is that even though the necessity of Akt2 for steatosis applies to multiple models, in at least one, i.e. obesity induced by high fat and sucrose feeding, hepatic triglyceride content is reduced but lipogenesis and lipogenic gene expression are unchanged (). This contrasts with development of NAFLD in the
Lepob/ob mouse, in which the protection from steatosis is mediated, at least in part, through preventing the stimulation of
de novo lipogenesis (). Thus, Akt2 likely mediates insulin’s induction of triglyceride accumulation by stimulating fatty acid synthesis as well as processes other than
de novo lipogenesis (). One obvious candidate mechanism it that loss of Akt2 abrogates the normal suppression of β-oxidation produced by insulin. For example, insulin suppresses the PGC-1α-dependent stimulation of fatty acid oxidation, both by reducing hepatocyte cyclic AMP and by promoting the Akt-dependent inhibition of PGC-1α activity (
Li et al., 2007). However, by several criteria, an increase in β-oxidation is unlikely to explain the protection from steatosis in our studies. First, though
PGC-1α mRNA increased in
Lepob/ob AFP;Akt2lox/lox livers, expression of the critical targets
MCAD and
CPT1 were not elevated in parallel () (
Schreiber et al., 2003;
Song et al., 2004). Second, there were no differences in expression of hepatic oxidative genes comparing
Akt2lox/lox to
AFP;Akt2lox/lox mice placed on a Surwit HFD (). Lastly, RER and serum ketones bodies were largely indistinguishable in wildtype versus
AFP;Akt2lox/lox mice on either an
Lepob/ob background or Surwit HFD (
Suppl. Figures 2 and 3, Suppl. Tables 2 and 4). Another possible mechanism through which Akt2 could be decreasing hepatic lipid accumulation is increased VLDL export, as serum triglycerides were elevated in
Lepob/ob Akt2−/− mice (
Suppl. Table 1). However, neither
Lepob/ob AFP;Akt2lox/lox nor
AFP;Akt2lox/lox mice on Surwit HFD exhibited increased serum triglyceride levels under fasted or fed conditions and direct measurement of triglyceride export failed to reveal a requirement for Akt2 (
Suppl. Tables 2 and 4 and not shown). Thus, the necessity for Akt2 in the development of hepatic steatosis relates to its role in mediating induction of SREBP1c and
de novo lipogenesis as well as other presently unidentified anabolic processes.
The role of Akt as the primary mediator of insulin’s action to increase SREBP1c and promote lipogenesis has been a point of some controversy. Hepatic overexpression of constitutively active Akt increases hepatic neutral lipid dramatically by a pathway only partially dependent on SREBP1c (
Ono et al., 2003). Similarly, forced activation of endogenous Akt by liver-specific deletion of the lipid phosphatase
Pten produces substantial accumulation of hepatic triglyceride and increased lipogenic gene expression, though this model is complicated by the concomitant activation of other PI3K-dependent kinases (
Stiles et al., 2004). On the other hand, a dominant inhibitory Akt does not block insulin’s induction of SREBP1c in tissue culture cells and
Lepob/ob mice have markedly increased
SREBP1c mRNA in spite of significantly reduced levels of phospho-Akt (
Matsumoto et al., 2002;
Shimomura et al., 2000). Atypical PKC (PKCλ/ζ) proteins have received considerable attention as obligate mediators of the effects of insulin and PI3K on anabolic lipid metabolism, and have specifically been advanced as an alternative to Akt (
Matsumoto et al., 2003;
Taniguchi et al., 2006). Matsumoto et al. showed that mice with liver-specific deletion of PKCλ have decreased
SREBP1c expression and triglyceride content, though reduced serum insulin levels complicated the interpretation of the
in vivo findings in the study (
Matsumoto et al., 2003). Kahn and colleagues undertook a different approach, eliminating both aPKC and Akt activity by ablation of all PI3K in the liver, and then selectively introducing constitutively activate versions of the two kinases by adenovirus-mediated delivery (
Taniguchi et al., 2006). They found that aPKC, but not Akt, restored
SREBP1c mRNA, but the effects on hepatic lipids were not reported. The current studies do not address a potential role for aPKC and thus are compatible with a requirement for this kinase. However, in contrast to Taniguchi et al., they strongly support a critical role for Akt2. Importantly,
Lepob/ob mice heterozygous for
Akt2 displayed a reduction in liver triglyceride content and
de novo lipogenesis intermediate between that of mice wildtype and null for
Akt2 (). This indicates that Akt2 is not only permissive for anabolic lipid metabolism, but is actually rate-determining. Moreover,
Lepob/ob Akt2+/− mice did not display the increase in serum glucose compared to
Lepob/ob mice evident in the
Akt2 null mice, so the protection in hepatic steatosis cannot be attributed to a worsening of the diabetes. Thus, these data support a obligate role for Akt2 in the development of the steatosis of obesity and insulin resistance, most likely reflecting the function of Akt2 in normal insulin signaling to lipid metabolism.
As shown in , deletion of both Akt2 and leptin resulted in fasting hyperglycemia considerably more severe than that in mice lacking either of the two proteins alone. This is associated with glycosuria, which likely contributes to caloric loss and reduction in body size in these mice (). In a recent paper, Chen and colleagues attribute the severe diabetes observed in compound
Akt1+/− Akt2−/− mice to leptin deficiency secondary to lipodystrophy (
Chen et al., 2009). Our findings cannot be explained by this model as Akt2 deficiency enhances the diabetes and presumably insulin resistance in spite of the complete absence of leptin in either mouse line. Rather, these data suggest that Akt and leptin control glucose metabolism in parallel pathways.
A recent study examining lipid abnormalities in humans with genetic syndromes of insulin resistance reported increased liver fat content, lipogenesis and serum triglycerides in several individuals with a dominant-negative mutation in
Akt2 (
Semple et al., 2009). However, as pointed out by Semple et al., the one patient studied in most detail might have had other, confounding metabolic abnormalities. Of note, like patients with an
Akt2 mutation,
Lepob/ob mice null for
Akt2 had elevated serum triglyceride levels, whereas
Lepob/ob mice with liver-specific deletion of Akt2 exhibit normal or reduced circulating triglyceride (
Suppl. Tables 1 and 2). This emphasizes the role of non-hepatic tissues in determining lipid levels and the difficulties in interpreting metabolic data. Nonetheless, additional translational experiments will be required to establish whether the requirement for Akt in NAFLD is unique to rodents or does indeed recapitulate the pathophysiology in humans.
A longstanding paradox has been that people with T2DM and the metabolic syndrome or rodents with equivalent metabolic disorders have systemic insulin resistance in the face of increased hepatic lipogenesis, a classical insulin response (
Petersen et al., 2007). Though a number of models could explain this, the concept of selective or partial insulin resistance has received increasing recent attention (
Brown and Goldstein, 2008). Both humans with insulin resistance due to inherited mutations in the insulin receptor and mice with liver-specific deletion of the insulin receptor exhibit hyperglycemia and hyperinsulinemia but are protected against steatosis and hypertriglyceridemia (
Biddinger et al., 2008;
Semple et al., 2009). This finding is consistent with the idea that in classical “insulin-resistant” states, not all signaling is blunted, but rather some is preserved, in particular that to lipid synthesis. While it is likely that the pathways regulating glucose and lipid metabolism diverge somewhere downstream of the IRS proteins but upstream of FoxO1 and SREBP1c, respectively, the precise biochemical site is unknown (
Dong et al., 2008;
Kubota et al., 2008;
Matsumoto et al., 2007). In a recent consideration of selective insulin resistance, Brown and Goldstein wrote that the “Identification of the branch point is a central question for future research” (
Brown and Goldstein, 2008). In the studies presented in this paper, we have demonstrated that the point of selective insulin resistance lies downstream of Akt. A major unresolved question is the nature of those pathways responsible for divergent signaling to glucose output and lipogenesis.