|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Stability is a key issue in treating supination-external rotation ankle fractures, but we do not know how it affects functional outcome and subsequent development of radiographic osteoarthritis. With a systematic literature review, we identified 11 clinical studies (Level IV evidence) published in peer-reviewed journals reporting on at least 10 ankles. Followup was at least 1 year. Two authors independently scored the quality of the studies using the modified Coleman Methodology Score; the mean score was 58 of 100, with substantial agreement between the two examiners. Four studies used a general health assessment questionnaire. Several literature limitations (debatable fracture stability criteria, few cohort studies with heterogeneous methodology, small patient numbers and limited followup in some studies) do not allow definitive conclusions. Of 213 stable fractures treated nonoperatively, 2.8% of ankles had radiographic osteoarthritis develop (18 years’ mean followup) and 84% were free of symptoms. The incidence of radiographic osteoarthritis in 420 unstable fractures treated operatively was 20.9% at 5.5 years versus 65.5% at 6.8 years in 137 ankles treated nonoperatively. The complication rate in 355 operatively treated fractures was 10.4%. A medial malleolus fracture, female gender, older age, higher American Society of Anesthesiologists grade, smoking, and lower educational level negatively influenced general health outcome, physical function, and pain.
Level of Evidence: Level IV, therapeutic study. See Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.
Malleolar fractures range from an isolated distal fibular fracture with minimal displacement to a trimalleolar fracture with dislocation and vascular compromise [1, 24]. Three classification systems are most commonly used. The Lauge-Hansen system  classifies fracture patterns based on the mechanism of injury. The Danis-Weber classification [10, 43] is based on the level of the distal fibula fracture and the importance of damage to the lateral structures for ankle mortise stability . The Orthopaedic Trauma Association/American Orthopaedic Association classification [1, 24] combines elements of the Lauge-Hansen  and Danis-Weber [10, 43] classification systems, taking into account the level of the fibula fracture in relation to the syndesmosis, and the fact that insufficiency of the medial structures can lead to degeneration of the joint if biomechanical (dynamic) stability is not restored [27, 36, 42]. Stable injuries are those that cannot be displaced by physiologic forces, whereas unstable fractures easily displace when physiologic forces are applied . Based on this concept, manual [33, 47] and gravity stress radiographic tests [15, 29] have been introduced to identify unstable fractures. A medial clear joint space (space between the medial malleolus and the talus) greater than 4 mm is considered abnormal by many authors [7, 11, 12, 15, 19, 25, 33, 41].
The most common injury pattern occurs with axial loading of a supinated foot. Because of its complex axis of movement , the subtalar joint acts as an angled hinge, so calcaneus inversion causes the talus to rotate externally (supination-external rotation [SER] mechanism). If excessive, the external rotation causes damage to the anterior tibiofibular ligament, and a sequence of injuries can follow (Fig. 1). Completion of the sequence of traumatic events on the medial side characterizes an unstable fracture pattern (Fig. 2) [1, 24, 26]. Based on the stability concept, nonoperative treatment seems appropriate for stable injuries, whereas maintenance of reduction of unstable fractures without operative fixation is difficult to achieve [1, 41].
We raised several questions: (1) Does internal fixation of stable SER ankle fractures lead to reduced incidence of radiographic osteoarthritis compared with nonoperative treatment? (2) Does nonoperative treatment of unstable SER ankle fractures lead to occurrence of radiographic osteoarthritis and symptoms? (3) How common is radiographic osteoarthritis and the presence of symptoms after operative treatment of unstable SER ankle fractures? (4) Do other factors (eg, comorbidities, social factors) influence general health outcome, physical function, and pain? (5) How common are injuries to the syndesmosis requiring surgery in SER ankle fractures? (6) What is the complication rate after operative treatment?
We conducted a comprehensive literature search using MEDLINE®, EMBASE™, Cochrane, CINAHL®, and Google™ Scholar, with no restriction to time or language, on October 5, 2008. Database searches were performed using the following combinations of key words: (1) ankle and fractures and supination external rotation, (2) ankle and fractures and fixation, and (3) ankle and fractures and outcome. Abstracts were scanned by two of the authors (NG, AK) and articles relevant to the subject were retrieved and their bibliographies searched by hand to identify additional references. Articles reporting fractures in specific patient population groups (eg, elderly, diabetics) were excluded [17, 44], as comorbidities could have influenced the decision on fracture treatment method and its outcome. Included were original studies published in peer-reviewed journals, reporting on at least 10 closed SER ankle fractures in skeletally mature patients followed for more than 1 year. From a total of 697 references initially retrieved, 236 were identified as being relevant to the subject. Abstracts were scanned, and applying the exclusion criteria, 65 studies were processed for further evaluation. Full papers were examined, and 11 studies met the inclusion criteria. Pooling of data was possible to calculate followup periods and data regarding absence of symptoms and radiographic findings of posttraumatic osteoarthritis.
Two authors (NG, AK) independently scored the quality of the studies using the Coleman Methodology Score (CMS) [8, 39]. The CMS allows analysis of the quality of the studies reviewed, is accurate and reproducible in systematic reviews, and has been used for several years. The CMS was adapted (Table 1) to evaluate studies reporting on ankle fractures. A score approaching 100 indicates the study has a robust design and largely avoids chance, various biases, or confounding factors. The subsections that compose the CMS are based on the subsections of the CONSORT statement (for randomized, controlled trials)  but are modified to allow for other trial designs. Each investigator scored the quality of the studies twice with an interval of 3 weeks between scoring sessions. Intraobserver and interobserver reliability were examined. Where differences were encountered, agreement was achieved by consensus. The presented scores are those set by agreement of both examiners. We collected data for year of publication, type of study, patient numbers, gender, mechanism of injury, followup, type of fracture, interventions, complications, and outcome.
From 11 clinical studies fulfilling our criteria, four were retrospective and seven were prospective investigations (all Level IV evidence) . The mean CMS was 57.8 of a possible total of 100 (standard deviation [SD], 14; range, 34–81) (Fig. 3). The intraobserver Spearman-Brown coefficient was 0.92 for Examiner A and 0.89 for Examiner B (substantial agreement) . The values of the second assessment for each examiner were included for further evaluation. The mean CMS was similar (p = 0.73) between the two examiners (57.8 versus 57.4). The intraclass correlation was 0.95, indicative of substantial agreement . Five studies were performed in institutions in the United States, three in Denmark, two in Sweden, and one in Ireland. No randomized, controlled trials were found. There were no studies investigating different forms of nonoperative treatment (eg, cast versus functional brace).
Three prospective long-term outcome studies from Scandinavia [2, 20, 46] reported on 213 SER-II (stable) ankle fractures treated from 1950 to 1976. Although anatomic reduction was not always achieved after nonoperative treatment after a mean followup of 17.9 years, similar percentages (p = 0.53) of patients/ankles treated nonoperatively and operatively were symptom free: 148 of 178 (83.1%) and 30 of 34 (88.2%), respectively (Table 2). Posttraumatic osteoarthritis seen on followup radiographic examination occurred in a similar (p = 0.21) percentage of patients undergoing nonoperative and operative treatment (five of 178, or 2.8%, versus one of 34, or 2.9%, respectively).
Two studies [2, 47], both published in the 1980s, showed, after nonoperative treatment of 67 SER-IV (unstable) ankle fractures, 42 (62.7%) were asymptomatic and 33 (49.3%) had some degree of osteoarthritis after a mean followup of 19.4 years.
In two studies, posttraumatic osteoarthritis was observed radiographically after operative treatment of unstable SER ankle fractures in 18 of 86 ankles (20.9%) after a mean followup of 5.5 years [13, 47]. Clinical evaluation showed 64 of 96 ankles (66.7%) were asymptomatic at a mean of 4.4 years after operative fixation of SER-IV ankle fractures [34, 47]. Correlation of clinical and radiographic findings was not reported in the original studies.
Three studies [3, 19, 34] used a general health assessment questionnaire (Table 2). A fracture of the medial malleolus, female gender, older age, higher American Society of Anesthesiologists grade, smoking, and lower educational level negatively influenced general health outcome, physical function, and pain.
Injury of the syndesmosis was recorded in only two studies. Bhandari et al.  suggested none of the 30 ankles required transsyndesmotic fixation after intraoperative stressing. Koval et al.  used MRI and reported two of 19 ankles had a syndesmosis injury.
Five studies [3, 13, 26, 34, 40] on operative treatment recorded 37 complications in 355 ankles (10.4%), including thromboembolic events, hardware failure, nonunions, and infections. One patient died of fatal pulmonary embolism.
SER injuries, the most common pattern of ankle fractures, are treated either with closed reduction and cast immobilization or with operative fixation [1, 24, 27, 41]. We investigated which SER ankle fractures would benefit from operative treatment, regarding clinical outcome and development of osteoarthritis. Orthopaedic surgeons seem to advocate operative treatment for unstable SER ankle fractures.
While addressing our questions, we noted substantial limitations in the literature. First, there is no consensus regarding the definition of stability and descriptions of clinical outcome evaluation methodologies were heterogeneous. These are major limitations in comparing and combining data from different publications and extrapolating their results reliably. Second, the lack of randomized, controlled trials, or high-quality prospective studies, and the heterogeneity in the design and mode of outcome presentation do not provide strong evidence regarding the outcome of SER ankle fractures. Future studies should consider reporting results according to fracture type to enhance comparability across publications. Third, although some cohort studies have reported the incidence of radiographic osteoarthritis, it is unclear whether this was related to patients’ symptoms. Fourth, length of followup in some studies probably is inadequate to assess osteoarthritis, particularly clinically evident osteoarthritis, which typically takes decades to develop. Fifth, loss to followup in trauma populations (which probably is inevitable) may underestimate complications and unfavorable results of treatment. Finally, the small sample sizes in some studies limit the validity of their findings.
Given the literature limitations, we found nonoperative treatment of stable SER ankle fractures resulted in a similarly low (< 3%) incidence of radiographic osteoarthritis, compared with operative treatment, whereas greater than 80% of patients were asymptomatic regardless of the treatment received. Surgery for unstable SER ankle fractures, however, resulted in reduced incidence of radiographic osteoarthritis and better clinical outcomes according to the Cedell criteria , compared with nonoperative treatment (Table 2). The distinction between stable and unstable SER ankle fractures is an issue of controversy, and to our knowledge, there are no pathognomonic clinical or radiographic signs. Clinical signs (medial tenderness, swelling, bruising) are not reliable predictors of instability  and do not predict widening of the medial clear space on stress radiographs . Bruising and tenderness could result from superficial deltoid ligament injury, whereas the deep deltoid remains intact providing stability . Furthermore, radiographic criteria (talar tilt and medial clear space) probably are not well defined. In fact, osseous injury and radiographs did not predict the patterns of ligamentous injuries in 53% of ankles examined with MRI . A dynamic examination (stress radiographs) could be of value. Stress radiographs [12, 25, 34] and the gravity stress test [15, 29] are methods proposed to distinguish between stable and unstable fracture patterns (Fig. 4). A medial clear joint space greater than 5 mm probably is predictive of instability [7, 33, 42]. The value of MRI  and ultrasound  in the diagnosis of complete deltoid ligament ruptures has been investigated and preliminary results are indicative of their accuracy. Additional research and long-term clinical followup are needed to establish criteria for instability of isolated distal fibular fractures and guide treatment.
Lauge-Hansen  suggested, more than 60 years ago, (stable) SER-II ankle fractures (approximately 30% of all ankle fractures ) do not require anatomic reduction, and optimal function can be expected. Long-term outcome studies [2, 46] have confirmed this. Clinical trials comparing operative with nonoperative treatment should consider including nonoperative treatment with a functional brace versus cast.
Nonoperative treatment of (unstable) SER-IV ankle fractures, however, has been associated with inferior results compared with operative treatment . Our review suggests the incidence of radiographic changes of posttraumatic osteoarthritis in unstable SER ankle fractures treated nonoperatively approaches 50% at an average of 19 years’ followup (range, 3–34 years) [2, 47]. Individual studies [2, 20, 46, 47] did not clarify, however, whether radiographic evidence of osteoarthritis correlated with clinical outcome.
Anatomic reduction is essential for good outcomes of unstable SER ankle fractures . The data we found in the literature suggest an incidence of 20% of radiographic joint degeneration at 5.5 years and presence of symptoms in 33% of ankles at 4.4 years in ankles treated operatively. However, the lack of rigorous validated outcome measures does not allow definite conclusions regarding the longer-term outcomes of these injuries. Furthermore, although trauma is the most common cause of ankle arthritis , the ankle has distinctive mechanical, biochemical, and anatomic characteristics making it resilient to aging and trauma . Therefore, radiographic findings may correlate poorly with clinical symptoms .
Some studies [3, 19, 26, 34] reported outcomes of operative treatment of ankle fractures classified as Orthopaedic Trauma Association/American Orthopaedic Association B [1, 24], without clarifying whether these were unstable. Possibly, the inclusion of the B1 subgroup of stable fractures, which are associated with better outcomes , has influenced results. Additional research needs to confirm whether the results of operative treatment of isolated distal fibula fractures are better because of inclusion of some stable injuries.
Other factors (eg, social and educational status, smoking, alcohol consumption, medical comorbidities, age, gender) also are important [3, 35, 40], and their influence on outcome should be investigated further. Interpretation of outcome studies should take into account factors other than the fracture pattern.
The incidence of syndesmotic injuries, which can be as much as 39%  in unstable SER ankle fractures, and how it affects outcome did not receive adequate attention in the included studies. This should be an objective of future research.
Although surgery for ankle fractures is considered a routine procedure, it carries a remarkable risk of complications (10.4% in the studies reviewed). Therefore, it is important to accurately identify stable injuries and avoid unnecessary operations. Additional studies comparing operative with nonoperative treatment should be conducted with particular attention to methodology to avoid bias.
There is adequate evidence that nonoperative treatment is appropriate for stable SER ankle fractures. Unstable fractures appear best treated surgically but still are associated with symptoms and osteoarthritis. The current literature does not allow one to identify the responsible factors (eg, patient demographics, social factors, fracture characteristics, treatment methods, adequacy of fracture reduction). Multicenter prospective studies to evaluate factors influencing general health outcomes are needed.
Each author certifies that he or she has no commercial associations (eg, consultancies, stock ownership, equity interest, patent/licensing arrangements, etc) that might pose a conflict of interest in connection with the submitted article.
This work was performed at Centre for Sports and Exercise Medicine and Frimley Park Hospital.