To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report of connectivity between brain areas in preterm children and term controls at school age. Significantly different patterns of functional connectivity from Wernicke’s reference region were demonstrated in the preterm children compared to term controls with increased connectivity to right-sided regions seen in the preterm group. Wernicke’s region has been demonstrated to subserve language processing in numerous fMRI studies in both children and adults. (
Brauer, 2007;
Ment et al., 2006a) Independent of handedness of the study subjects, significantly greater correlations in activity were noted across hemispheres between the reference region and the SMG component of the inferior parietal lobule as well as the homologue of Broca’s area in the right inferior frontal gyrus, in the preterm group than in the term controls. A significantly increased ipsilateral connection between Wernicke’s and left SMG was also seen in preterm subjects. The left SMG, has traditionally been thought responsible for phonologic processing, (
Ment et al., 2006a) and recent evidence has demonstrated the role of Broca’s area homologue in the right hemisphere in the auditory processing of language in young children. (
Karunanayaka et al., 2007) Taken together, these data suggest the engagement of a broader network of neural systems for auditory phonologic processing of language in the prematurely born.
Although critical to our understanding of the developing brain, there are few reports of connectivity in the pediatric population. Recent studies of connectivity in typically developing subjects ranging in age from infancy to early adulthood have revealed emerging patterns of cortical maturation. Using connectivity analysis, investigators have described the differences that exist in the resting state networks of children, adolescents (
Fair et al., 2008;
Fair et al., 2007) and adults (
Hampson et al., 2006a;
Hampson et al., 2006b). Some resting state networks are present in infancy, (
Fransson et al., 2007) and maturation of neural networks occurs during adolescence. (
Fair et al., 2008;
Fair et al., 2007) Over time, the developing brain increases the strength of connections that exist in spatially remote regions in an anterior-posterior direction, weaving distal brain areas into highly cohesive and connected circuits, while reducing the strength of connections between anatomically proximal regions and contralateral homologues. (
Fair et al., 2008;
Fair et al., 2007) Connectivity analysis in our study revealed an increase in cross-hemispheric connections in the preterm group with remarkable engagement of right-sided circuits such as Broca’s homologue and the SMG portion of the inferior parietal lobule. Given the developmental trajectories suggested by prior studies, it is possible that preterm children exhibit developmental delays in the maturation of their neural circuitry just as they appear to lag in the pruning of the initial overabundance of synapses in gray matter. (
Kesler et al., 2004; Ment et al., 2008)
Alternatively, the engagement of right-sided regions in the connectivity circuit that includes Wernicke’s region in our preterm cohort may represent a compensatory strategy to overcome difficulties in language processing. Studies of dyslexic children have described similar findings and investigators hypothesized that disruption in the normal reading pathway results in the engagement of alternate systems to compensate for conventional circuit failure. (
Shaywitz et al., 2002;
Shaywitz, 2005) Recruitment of right hemispheric sites may allow children with reading difficulty to utilize other “perceptual processes to compensate for his or her poor phonologic skills.” (
Shaywitz et al., 2002)
Although preterm children are at high risk for developmental disabilities, numerous recent studies have revealed a pattern of improvement in behavioral and neuropsychologic measures over time in the prematurely born. (
Hack et al., 2005;
Hack et al., 2002;
Ment et al., 2003) In contrast, multiple MRI investigations have documented both volumetric and microstructural changes in the brains of preterm children during school age and adolescence. (
Constable et al., 2008;
Gimenez et al., 2006a;
Kesler et al., 2004;
Kesler et al., 2008;
Nosarti et al., 2002;
Reiss et al., 2004) Furthermore, recent evidence suggests that birth at early gestation has a long lasting influence on corticogenesis in preterm subjects compared to term controls during school age and early adolescence. (
Kesler et al., 2004;
Peterson et al., 2000;
Reiss et al., 2004) Contradictions between the differences in cortical development and the recovery of cognitive function may be partially accounted for by our studies of connectivity. As has been reported for prematurely born teens and children with congenital focal brain lesions, neural plasticity may permit the recruitment of alternate pathways for language processing. (
Chilosi et al., 2005;
Rushe et al., 2004)
These data extend our previous work documenting the patterns of neural recovery and plasticity in the developing preterm brain. In the past, we have reported improved language scores over time in this cohort of prematurely born children compared to term controls. Earlier fMRI studies have shown that preterm children recruit alternate cortical regions in response to a passive listening task. (
Ment et al., 2006b;
Peterson et al., 2002) Furthermore, we have reported microstructural differences in the white matter tracts between those regions of the brain that sub-serve language processing. (
Constable et al., 2008) The differences in functional connectivity reported in this paper represent the results of an important emerging modality available to investigate the alterations in language processing in preterm children.
The children who participated in this study are part of a well-studied cohort with neuroimaging available from the earliest postnatal hours. Sequential evaluation with a variety of imaging modalities has documented their progress in terms of cognitive performance, volumetric differences, cortical activation and microstructural alterations in normal cortical development over time. Although recent data in adult subjects suggest a correlation between structure and function, we had neither complete volumetric data nor diffusion tensor imaging in this cohort of children. (
Olesen et al., 2003;
Saur et al., 2008)
The limitations of this study include the small sample size. In addition, the use of fMRI to evaluate functional connectivity in this group is an emerging technology with little known about technical limitations. To the best of our knowledge this is the first study using functional connectivity to evaluate prematurely born children at school age. Longitudinal assessment of a large cohort of preterm and term controls is necessary to fully evaluate brain maturational changes and their effects on cognitive and language development.
In conclusion, these data demonstrate that preterm birth results in the engagement of alternate neural systems for language processing in the developing brain with increased recruitment of brain regions in the right hemisphere. These alterations may represent either a developmental lag in the stabilization of neural networks of prematurely born children, or the recruitment of alternate circuits for language in the developing preterm brain.