|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Malignant hyperthermia (MH) is an inherited pharmacogenetic disorder of skeletal muscle, characterised by an elevated calcium release from the skeletal muscle sarcoplasmic reticulum. The dihydropyridine receptor (DHPR) plays an essential role in excitation-contraction coupling and calcium homeostasis in skeletal muscle. This study focuses on the gene CACNA1S which encodes the α1 subunit of the DHPR, in order to establish whether CACNA1S plays a major role in MH susceptibility in the UK.
We investigate the CACNA1S locus in detail in 50 independent MH patients, the largest study to date, to identify novel variants that may predispose to disease and also to characterise the haplotype structure across CACNA1S.
We present CACNA1S cDNA sequencing data from 50 MH patients in whom RYR1 mutations have been excluded, and subsequent mutation screening analysis. Furthermore we present haplotype analysis of unphased CACNA1S SNPs to (1) assess CACNA1S haplotype frequency differences between susceptible MH cases and a European control group and (2) analyse population-based association via clustering of CACNA1S haplotypes based on disease risk.
The study identified a single potentially pathogenic change in CACNA1S (p.Arg174Trp), and highlights that the haplotype structure across CACNA1S is diverse, with a high degree of variability.
Malignant hyperthermia (MH) is an inherited disorder of skeletal muscle, which predisposes to an increased release of calcium into the myoplasm under certain pharmacological conditions. Inhalational anaesthetics and the muscle relaxant suxamethonium can trigger an MH crisis and lead to acceleration of muscle metabolism and contractile activity generating heat and leading to hypoxaemia, metabolic acidosis, rhabdomyolysis and a rapid rise in body temperature. This condition is potentially fatal if not recognised and treated promptly.
Biochemical studies have shown that an MH crisis is due to an abnormal cellular calcium homeostasis within the skeletal muscle . Within skeletal muscle the sarcoplasmic reticulum (SR) controls the process of Ca2+ release, playing a major role in the process of excitation-contraction (E-C) coupling. During E-C coupling depolarisation of the sarcolemma initiates a conformational change in the voltage-gated Ca2+ channel (dihydropyridine receptor (DHPR)) subsequently activating the Ca2+ release channel (Ryanodine receptor (RyR1)) to release Ca2+ from the SR . During an MH crisis an elevated rate of cellular Ca2+ release from the SR is observed due, in part, to a reduced activation and increased deactivation threshold of the RyR1 , or from uncoupling of the DHPR-RyR1 interaction .
Genetic analyses have demonstrated that MH susceptibility exhibits locus heterogeneity, with significant observations for linkage to chromosome 1q [5,6] and 19q [7,8]. The locus on chromosome 19q has been identified as the gene encoding the skeletal muscle ryanodine receptor (RYR1) , and that on chromosome 1q as the gene encoding the α1 subunit of the DHPR (CACNA1S) . There is a finely balanced interaction between the gene products of RYR1 and CACNA1S, which are only beginning to be understood with alterations in both gene products affecting E-C coupling and modifying Ca2+ regulation [3,4].
Much research into MH susceptibility has been focused on the RYR1 locus and it is recognised that RYR1 plays a major role in susceptibility to MH. There are now over 178 mis-sense mutations described across RYR1 that co-segregate with MH susceptibility, 29 of which have been functionally characterised and are used diagnostically (reviewed in ). In the UK, RYR1 plays a part in MH susceptibility in over 70% (394/554) of UK pedigrees. Considerably less, however, is known about CACNA1S. Previous studies have demonstrated linkage to chromosome 1q within MH families that show RYR1 exclusion , but to date there is only a single mis-sense change (p.Arg1086His) described in CACNA1S in association with MH . This change was first detected in a single extended French family in 12 individuals all diagnosed as susceptible to MH, and absent from the 6 individuals diagnosed as normal . In a North American study of 98 independent MH samples this change was also identified in a single family , in 2 from the 5 MH diagnosed individuals. p.Arg1086His was not detected in 100 independent normal French chromosomes , nor in 150 unrelated North American normal samples . Interestingly, this change has further been described alongside an RYR1 alteration (p.Pro4973Leu) in a single individual , where the rest of the family diagnosed as MHS were accounted for by either the RYR1 change (three individuals) or the CACNA1S change (two individuals), suggesting a potentially more complex means of MH susceptibility involving multiple gene products.
The aim of this study is to investigate the CACNA1S locus in detail and to determine whether CACNA1S may play a major role in MH susceptibility in the UK. As targeted sequencing for RYR1 has led to potential bias in mutation detection, we have sequenced the full cDNA transcript of CACNA1S for novel changes in 50 independent MH patients. We report here the findings of this sequencing and subsequent mutation screening. Furthermore, characterisation of the haplotype structure across CACNA1S is investigated. We present analysis using unphased CACNA1S SNP data directly to (1) assess CACNA1S haplotype frequency differences between MH susceptible cases and a population control group and (2) to analyse population-based association via clustering of CACNA1S haplotypes based on disease risk.
There is a well defined and standardised protocol for the laboratory confirmation of suspected MH cases and testing of family members. The in vitro contracture test (IVCT) involves exposure of skeletal muscle biopsy specimens to incremental concentrations of halothane or caffeine in an irrigated tissue bath and the subsequent measurement of muscle contracture in response to the applied stimulants. All individuals were phenotyped by the IVCT according to the European MH Group (EMHG) guidelines http://www.emhg.org at the MH Investigation Unit at St James's Hospital, Leeds, UK. The European protocol assigns the patient to one of three laboratory diagnostic categories, MHS, MHN or MHE according to whether their muscle displays increased sensitivity to both, none or only one of the stimulants respectively. Both MHS and MHE categories are deemed to represent clinical susceptibility to MH.
This study utilises the largest worldwide resource of genotyped MH samples from patients phenotyped in a single diagnostic centre. CACNA1S sequencing was performed on 50 independent UK MH susceptible samples, with approval by the Leeds East Local Research Ethics Committee and written informed consent from all patients. These samples comprise 30 MHS samples and 20 MHE (responding to halothane but not caffeine) samples; 14 of these MHE samples are from probands who suffered a clinical reaction. The remaining 6 MHE samples are the only available representative from these individual families. However, a recent study by our group, using transmission data, supports the classification of MHE samples as affecteds . All 50 of these samples have had the RYR1 cDNA transcript sequenced and have had no variants detected. There are 30 males and 20 females in the cohort and the ages range from 10-75 years, with a mean of 33 years. The IVCT data for the 50 patients show a median (range) contracture of 0.6 g (0.2 - 4.7 g) at 2% halothane and 0.2 g (0 - 3.6 g) at 2 mM caffeine.
Mutation screening was performed on an additional 410 independent UK MH patients to give a total of 460 independent MH patients represented. Of the 460 independent MH patients, 340 (74%) have an RYR1 mis-sense change assigned; of these, 298 (65%) co-segregate with disease, 226 (49%) have a functionally characterised RYR1 change and there are 8 instances of compound heterozygosity with two different RYR1 changes (one instance each of c.1021G>A/c.7025A>G, c.7063C>T/c.7025A>G, c.7036G>A/c.14817C>A, c.4024A>G/c.4088C>T, c.5441T>A/c.7528T>C and c.10616G>A/c.14210G>A and two instances of 7300G>A/7373G>A). 100 independent MHN samples were also screened.
CACNA1S haplotype analysis was performed on 460 independent UK MH patients, the same as used for mutation screening assays. Population control samples (480) for the haplotype analysis were obtained from a DNA panel of Human Random Controls manufactured by the European Collection of Cell Cultures (ECACC). The DNA is derived from peripheral blood lymphocytes of UK Caucasian donors with informed consent.
CACNA1S cDNA sequencing was performed on 50 independent MH susceptible individuals, who did not have an RYR1 mis-sense change after having previously been sequenced for the RYR1 cDNA transcript. cDNA prepared from total RNA isolated from muscle biopsy specimens was used to sequence the ~6.16 kb CACNA1S cDNA, using 12 overlapping fragments of approximately 700 bp in length, read in both the forward and reverse direction and analysed on an ABI3730.
A novel p.Arg174Trp/c.520C>T change in exon 4 causes a loss of an MspI site, thus further screening analysis was performed on genomic DNA using the forward primer 5'-CTC AAG CAT GGA CAG GAC AC-3' and reverse primer 5'-AGG AAG GGA GAG GAG AAA GG-3' to generated an amplicon of 279 bp. In the normal (c.520*C) this is cleaved to produce 3 fragments of 49 bp, 67 bp and 163 bp. Cleavage at one of the sites fails to occur in the presence of the mutated allele, c.520*T, thus generating 2 fragments of 116 bp and 163 bp in length.
The previously described CACNA1S mutation p.Arg1086His/c.3257G>A in exon 26 was screened for in the full cohort of independent UK MH patients using an assay developed in-house as follows: forward 5' ATG CAC CCT ACC CTA TCT CC-3' and reverse 5'-GGA GCA GGG AGC CTA GTT AC-3' primers generate an amplicon of 998 bp in length. In the normal (c.3257*G) this is cleaved by HhaI to produce 3 fragments of 362 bp, 316 bp and 313 bp. Cleavage at one of the sites fails to occur in the presence of the mutated allele, c.3257*A, generating 2 fragments of 629 bp and 362 bp in length.
Focusing at the genomic DNA level there are >175 SNPs described across the 73 kb CACNA1S gene; predominantly listed in internet databases sources, in particular the CEPH population of the Hap-Map project http://www.hapmap.org, and a further 3 identified through in-house CACNA1S sequencing. When concentrating on SNPs with a minor allele frequency greater than 0.05 the total number of described SNPs spanning the gene is reduced to 115, 16 of which are located in exons. Using the Tagger software on Haploview we selected eight informative SNPs to span CACNA1S. The final list of SNPs chosen is detailed in Table Table11.
All SNPs were genotyped using Taqman® methodology. For all SNPs there is an ABI-assay-on-demand available (Table (Table1).1). All allelic discrimination assays were carried out on an ABI 7900 according to the manufacturer's instructions. Linkage disequilibrium between the SNPs was calculated using Haploview software .
The program PHASE (version 2) was used to reconstruct haplotypes from the unphased CACNA1S genotype data and to perform case control permutation tests between MHS samples and population control samples [15,16]. PHASE calculates the posterior probability distribution of haplotypes through a Bayesian statistical approach, combining a specified prior for a statistical model for population genetics and likelihood information. The program has a function for case control permutation testing. This tests the null hypothesis that haplotype frequencies are the same in cases and controls, versus the alternative hypothesis that haplotype frequencies are different between the two groups.
The program GENEBPM, a program designed for use with candidate genes, tests for association of disease with causal variants at an unseen functional polymorphism [17,18]. This program makes use of the expectation that a pair of haplotypes carrying the same disease mutation are more likely to share a more recent common ancestry than a random pair of haplotypes in the population and thus are more likely to be similar to each other in terms of their allelic make-up at flanking markers. Furthermore, output of the algorithm can be used to ascertain clusters of haplotypes that are associated with specific causative variants, and to estimate the odds of disease for these unobserved alleles.
Full cDNA sequencing identified non-synonymous changes in CACNA1S in 12 individuals, 24% of the MH cases. Sequence changes lead to modifications of amino acids at positions 69 (n = 4), 174 (n = 1), 258 (n = 4), 458 (n = 13), 606 (n = 1), 1541 (n = 4) and 1660 (n = 5) where the number in parentheses represents the total number of MH patients with each change. All are present as heterozygous changes, except the change at position 458 which was also observed in both homozygous forms. However, the changes at positions 1541 and 1660 are previously described polymorphisms (rs3850625 and rs13374149 respectively). The change at position 458 has also been described as polymorphic  and indeed was found to be highly variable in our cohort with a heterozygosity of 0.425. The other substitutions detected were in codons determining amino acids that are conserved in rabbit, cat, mouse and zebrafish (NCBI reference sequences NP_001095190, NP_001033694, NP_001074492.1 and NP_999891.1 respectively) and are therefore potentially deleterious mutations rather than infrequent polymorphisms. However, the first change p.Ala69Gly, whilst being detected in 4 MH susceptible individuals, was also detected in 7 from 100 MHN samples, and is therefore likely to be a polymorphism. Furthermore, the changes p.Gly258Asp and p.Ser606Asn, whilst not being detected in 100 MHN controls, were observed to be frequently discordant with MH status in families. Within the 4 p.Gly258Asp families there are a total of 24 individuals, comprising 5 MHS, 7 MHE and 12 MHN samples, and the p.Gly258Asp change was observed in a total of 3 MHN samples, 2 MHS and 3 MHE samples, whilst the p.Ser606Asn was detected in both the MHE and MHN siblings within a single family. There was no example of compound heterozygosity with these rare changes. These changes can be added to the growing number of non-synonymous changes reported across CACNA1S, over half (10) of which are likely to be polymorphisms (see Table Table22).
The final mis-sense variation that was detected, p.Arg174Trp, was found in an MHS sample, was concordant with disease within the family and also not detected in 100 MHN control samples. The mother of the proband was diagnosed MHS through the IVCT, and also had the p.Arg174Trp alteration. A sibling of the proband, diagnosed normal through the IVCT, did not have the p.Arg174Trp change. The MH proband, in whom the p.Arg174Trp was detected, developed intense masseter muscle spasm and generalised muscle rigidity lasting 8 minutes after administration of the inhalation anaesthetics propofol, fentanyl and halothane and the muscle relaxant suxamethonium (1.5 mg/kg). Post-operatively there was severe muscle stiffness that persisted for 2 weeks and a peak serum creatine kinase concentration of 14,500 IU/L (normal < 220 IU/L). The IVCT results for this individual were 0.35 g contracture at 2% halothane and 0.2 g contracture at 2 mM caffeine: laboratory classification (EMHG) MHS.
The cDNA sequencing further identified 3 novel silent changes in the CACNA1S gene. These were located in 2 different exons; p.Leu766/c.2296C>T minor allele frequency of 0.01 and a heterozygosity of 0.02, and p.Ile781/c.2343C>T, with a minor allele frequency of 0.031 and a heterozygosity of 0.06 were located in exon 17 and p.Pro1622/c.4866C>T with a minor allele frequency of 0.208 and a heterozygosity of 0.33 was located in exon 40. There is no significant linkage disequilibrium detected between the markers, with r2 = 0 between 4866*C and both 2296*C and 2343*C, and r2 = 0.32 between the neighbouring markers 2296*C and 2343*C. Linkage disequilibrium was also not detected between these markers and their adjacent markers across CACNA1S, i.e. between 4866*C with either rs3850625*C or rs13374149*G and nor between 2296*C and 2343*C with rs7415038*T or rs1684767*C.
The p.Arg174Trp change was identified in a single family showing full concordance with disease status and not identified in 100 normal controls. Accordingly we screened for the presence of this site in the full UK cohort of 410 independent MH families. The p.Arg174Trp change was not detected in any other UK family.
The previously described CACNA1S mutation p.Arg1086His in exon 26 was screened for in the 460 independent UK MH patients. This change was not detected in any UK MH family, nor the 100 MHN controls.
A total of 460 independent UK MH patients and 480 Caucasian population controls were typed for all eight CACNA1S SNP markers. These 8 SNPs were used to reconstruct haplotypes from the unphased data using PHASE and GENEBPM. From GENEBPM there were a total of 23 haplotypes with an estimated population frequency ≥0.01 (1%), and these are detailed in Table Table3,3, along with a breakdown of the haplotype frequencies for each study group (MHS, PC and also the subset of 50 samples that were sequenced for CACNA1S) calculated using PHASE. The single SNPs were tested for association with disease using a Spearman rank correlation between MHS samples and PC. There was no evidence for significant associations with any of the markers except p.Ile199, where p = 0.014.
Case control permutation testing was performed between MHS samples and the population control samples to test for differences in CACNA1S haplotype frequencies using the program PHASE. There was a small but significant difference observed with this comparison (p = 0.02), providing evidence for association between MH and CACNA1S. However, for the same comparison using the GENEBPM program to analysis haplotype relative risk of disease, there was no categorical evidence of CACNA1S haplotype association with MH (posterior probability = 0.46).
To illustrate the posterior similarities between haplotypes in terms of their risk of carrying causal variants and allelic make-up, a dendrogram can be constructed. Figure Figure11 presents a dendrogram of the 23 CACNA1S haplotypes with estimated relative frequency ≥1% from the analysis of MHS cases versus population controls. These 23 haplotypes are coded according to their relative frequency, where 1 represents the most frequent haplotype and 23 the least frequent. The dendrogram shows considerable posterior similarity between haplotypes and demonstrates no apparent clustering of haplotypes, suggesting that there is no clear high risk disease variant. Additionally, the haplotype analysis reveals that there are numerous relatively rare haplotypes (there are only three haplotypes with a frequency >5% in population controls), suggestive of an elevated degree of haplotype diversity potentially resulting from a high rate of recombination across the locus and a low level of linkage disequilibrium.
To exclude any influence of RYR1 on the analysis, a case control permutation test in PHASE was also performed between the 480 population control samples and the 50 samples that have been cDNA sequenced for CACNA1S. There was no overall significant difference in CACNA1S haplotype frequency observed between these groups. The haplotypes H5 and H14 were observed at a noticeably higher frequency in the 50 sequenced samples (0.099 and 0.058 respectively) than the population controls (0.043 and 0.029 respectively) (see Table Table3),3), however given that the haplotype frequencies are relatively small these observations are unlikely to be significant. Further analysis with GENEBPM also provided no categorical evidence of CACNA1S haplotype association with MH (posterior probability = 0.415), suggesting that CACNA1S does not play a major role in MH susceptibility, however due to the small number in the cDNA sequenced group this comparison may lack power.
Furthermore, to investigate whether there were any differences in CACNA1S haplotype frequencies between MH phenotypes, an additional case control permutation test was performed on the subset of 50 samples that underwent cDNA sequencing between the MHS (n = 30) and MHE (n = 20) samples using all 8 SNPs. There was no significant difference in CACNA1S haplotype frequency observed between the MHS and MHE samples (p = 0.27); however, again due to the small numbers in each group this comparison may lack power.
As more is being understood about the nature of susceptibility to MH it is becoming increasingly apparent that it is complex and cannot always be simply described as autosomal dominant. There is evidence for variation in clinical severity and IVCT phenotype, resulting from the same mis-sense change in RYR1 [19,20]. There are also reports of compound heterozygotes in RYR1 [[12,21], unpublished UK observations] and an individual with mutations in both RYR1 and CACNA1S . Furthermore, we have previously demonstrated, using transmission disequilibrium testing, that multiple interacting gene products affect susceptibility to MH [10,22]. Even within families that showed linkage to RYR1 evidence has been provided for linkage to other loci elsewhere in the genome .
This study focused on CACNA1S encoding the α1 subunit of the DHPR. In the largest study to date, of 50 MH patients, we identified a single, potentially pathogenic, variant p.Arg174Trp. The p.Arg174Trp change is situated at a site that is conserved in rabbit, cat, mouse, and zebrafish and causes a change in the charge of the amino acid from basic to non-polar. The amino acid in question lies in the S4 segment domain of the DHPR thought to function as a voltage sensor, thus a change in charge may alter the voltage sensor mechanism and consequently disrupt the cellular calcium homoeostasis. Further functional work to support these observations would be valuable.
This work also identified two other variants (p.Gly258Asp, p.Ser606Asn) thought to be polymorphic as they do not show disease concordancy, but which were not present in control chromosomes. Whilst it is likely that they are indeed polymorphisms, the fact that they lie in conserved regions of the protein and cause a change in the polarity of the amino acid substituted suggests otherwise and there is the potential that they could play a minor role in, or have a modifier effect on, disease phenotype. Since there is evidence that MH may not necessarily be a simple single gene disorder, there is the possibility that both of these changes are present together with an additional major change and in some instances account for discordancy with disease; i.e. these mutations may be necessary, but not sufficient, to cause MH susceptibility in particular individuals.
Comparison of CACNA1S haplotype frequencies between susceptible cases and UK Caucasian population controls identified no significant haplotype frequency differences. Even given that this is the largest standardised and genotyped MH database worldwide, there are a limited number of MH patients, which could reduce the power to detect a significant association between CACNA1S haplotype with MH. However, the haplotype analysis does provide some evidence for an elevated haplotype diversity, potentially resulting from the high rate of recombination observed across the locus and a low level of linkage disequilibrium detected, as seen in the present study and consistent with that observed in the HapMap project. Coupling this observation with the now growing number of reported non-pathogenic non-synonymous changes described across CACNA1S, it is possible that this locus can tolerate a high degree of variability. This variability could affect the conformation of the DHPR protein, which has implications not only in the E-C coupling of skeletal muscle but also in that of cardiac muscle.
Our data suggest that, whilst CACNA1S may play a role in MH manifestation in the UK, it is not a major locus, thereby suggesting that there are other loci with importance in MH susceptibility. As well as the reported linkage to chromosome 1q and 19q there are alternative loci proposed on chromosomes 7q  and 17q , however no contributory mutations have been identified in these regions. It is highly probable that any novel genes for MH susceptibility will play a minor role. An alternative method to identify genes responsible for MH could be to take a candidate gene approach and focus on genes whose products are directly involved with E-C coupling and Ca2+ regulation, for example the other subunits of the DHPR, calmodulin and JP-45 .
We have previously proposed that several independent genes can influence the MH phenotype [10,22]. Here we have presented evidence for a novel variant in CACNA1S which could have the potential to directly influence MH susceptibility. There was also a possible indirect or modifier effect of CACNA1S in a small number of families, likely to cause MH in combination with another, as yet unknown, locus. The evidence for the existence of multiple independent loci that influence MH susceptibility is now increasing and the disorder appears to be more complex than previously thought. To fully comprehend MH and all the gene product interactions we need to identify and characterise all the multiple loci involved.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
DC participated in the design of the study, carried out the Taqman® genotyping, haplotype analysis and drafted the manuscript. CR and VL carried out the sequencing, screened for the changes Arg1086His and Arg174Trp and performed family studies. AM provided assistance with haplotype analysis. RLR participated in the design of the study. PJH and PMH carried out and determined the IVCT phenotypes. PMH and MAS designed the study, coordinated the study, and participated in the analysis and manuscript preparation. All authors approved the manuscript.
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:
Financial support for this project was provided by a grant through the Department of Health Pharmacogenetics Research Programme Grant, and the Big Lottery Fund.