|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Urinary incontinence is a highly prevalent condition in aging women that results in significant morbidity. Less than half of women who suffer from urinary incontinence seek treatment resulting in a significant proportion of clinically relevant urinary incontinence remaining undiagnosed. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to quantify the prevalence of urinary incontinence in undiagnosed women in a managed care population.
136,457 women ages 25−80 enrolled in the Kaiser Permanente Northwest (KPNW) who were free of genitourinary diagnoses including urinary incontinence were included in this study. 875 of the 2,118 women who were mailed questionnaires ascertaining information on demographic and urinary incontinence characteristics completed the survey. A chart review of the 234 women who reported moderate to severe urinary incontinence was performed.
The prevalence of undiagnosed urinary incontinence was 53% in the preceding year, and 39% in the preceding week. The prevalence of undiagnosed stress, mixed and urge incontinence were found to be 18.7%, 12.0% and 6.8%. Quality of life was found to significantly decrease with increasing urinary incontinence severity. 5% of the 234 chart reviewed women were found to have physician documented urinary incontinence.
These results suggest that a significant proportion of women in this managed care population are suffering from urinary incontinence that remains undiagnosed. Efforts should be made to encourage women and physicians to initiate conversations about urinary incontinence symptoms in order to decrease the unnecessary burden of this disease.
Urinary incontinence, defined as the involuntary leakage of urine, affects 15−50% of women in the community, and results in annual direct costs of over $12 billion in the United States1, 2 While urinary incontinence is effectively treatable with medical, surgical and behavioral therapies, less than half of the women who suffer from urinary incontinence receive treatment.3 Barriers to incontinence care among women include the misconception that it is not a legitimate medical problem, the embarrassment surrounding the resulting symptoms,4 and the perception that it is a normal part of the aging process5 or the natural result of childbirth.6 These beliefs are compounded by a lack of knowledge about treatment options and fear of invasive medical interventions.3, 7 As a result, women are less likely to initiate a conversation with their primary care physician about their urinary incontinence and thus, a significant portion of clinically relevant urinary incontinence among women goes undiagnosed and untreated in the United States.
In order to better characterize the burden of undiagnosed incontinence among US women, this study sought to determine the prevalence and severity of undiagnosed urinary incontinence in women aged 25−80, from the Kaiser Permanente Northwest (KPNW) managed care population.
The managed care population utilized for this study, Kaiser Permanente Northwest (KPNW), is a mostly Caucasian population of 436,000 enrollees representing the metropolitan Portland, Oregon area. KPNW has an 85% retention rate yearly and is unique in that EpicCare clinical information system, a comprehensive electronic medical record (EMR), was implemented beginning in 1998, which allows for population based research of physician diagnosed disorders. Women ages 25 to 80 who were members of KPNW for greater than 2 months, had at least 12 months of eligibility between January 1998 through May 2002, and who consented to be contacted for research purposes were included in this study. The initial inclusion criteria identified 136,457 women.
Women who had diagnoses of genitourinary cancer, neurologic disease, radiation cystitis or urethral diverticula in the EMR were excluded from the questionnaire mailing. Women with previously diagnosed urinary incontinence were also excluded. After applying these criteria, 115,117 women were identified as eligible for this study.
A questionnaire ascertaining demographic and urinary incontinence information was mailed to random sample of 2,118 eligible women. Of these, 875 completed the questionnaire, yielding a 41% response rate. Questions regarding incontinence type and frequency of urinary leakage were included in the questionnaire. A comprehensive list of the incontinence specific questions is provided in Appendix 1.
Urinary incontinence was defined in two ways: 1) leakage of any amount of urine during the past 12 months; and 2) leakage of any amount of urine during the past 7 days. In those with urinary incontinence in the past 7 days, the type of incontinence was categorized as stress, urge, or mixed. Stress incontinence was defined as accidentally leaking urine with physical activity such as coughing, sneezing, lifting or exercising. Urge incontinence was defined as accidental urine leakage that was associated with a strong urge to empty the bladder. Mixed incontinence was defined as having both stress and urge incontinence.
In women who reported incontinence in the preceding week, the Sandvik Severity Index (SSI) was used to characterize the incontinence severity10. The SSI is a validated measurement of incontinence severity which has been shown to correlate with the objective measurement of incontinence using a 24-hour pad test11. The SSI is comprised of an index score calculated by multiplying the frequency of incontinence by the amount of urine leaked, yielding four categories of severity: slight (1−2), moderate (3−6), severe (8−9) and very severe (12). Quality of life
Quality of life was assessed by asking survey participants the question, “If you had to spend the rest of your life with your urinary symptoms just the way they have been during the past month, how would you feel about that?” Response options include ‘delighted’, ‘pleased’, ‘mostly satisfied’, ‘about equally satisfied and dissatisfied’, ‘mostly dissatisfied’, ‘unhappy’, and ‘terrible’. For analytic purposes, responses were categorized as Satisfied (‘delighted’, ‘pleased’, or ‘mostly satisfied’), Mixed (‘about equally satisfied and dissatisfied’), and Dissatisfied (‘mostly dissatisfied’, ‘unhappy’, and ‘terrible’).
Electronic medical records were reviewed in all women characterized by the SSI as having moderate or severe incontinence in the preceding week. Progress notes for the 12 months prior to the survey completion date (May-June 2000) were manually reviewed to determine whether there was documented evidence of urinary incontinence at the time of each contact with a healthcare provider. Number of contacts, type of contact (telephone vs. office visit), and provider specialty for each contact were recorded.
Descriptive statistics were used to characterize the demographics and incontinence of the population Age-adjusted prevalence estimates were calculated for all types of incontinence and severity based on 5-year age distributions and standardized to the general KPNW female population. Associations with age were tested using Pearson chi-square test of associations and Cochran-Armitage tests for trend. To better quantify the magnitude of the relationship between severity and quality of life, odds ratios were estimated. An alpha level of 0.05 was used to determine statistical significance. All analyses were performed using SPSS (Version 14.0, SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL).
Among the 875 participants in this study, 461 (52.6%) reported having urinary incontinence in the past 12 months, and 340 (38.9%) reported having urinary incontinence in the past 7 days. The age-adjusted prevalence of undiagnosed urinary incontinence was 51% in the past 12 months, and 38% in the past 7 days. The age-adjusted rates of stress urinary incontinence, urge urinary incontinence and mixed urinary incontinence were 18.7%, 6.8% and 12.0%, respectively. While the rates of urge urinary incontinence and mixed urinary incontinence were found to significantly increase with age (p-value trend: <0.001, 0.003), stress urinary incontinence was not found to be significantly associated with age in this cohort (p-value: 0.056). (TABLE 1)
The majority of women reported moderate (53.6%) or slight urinary incontinence (34.5%) symptoms as classified by their SSI score. (TABLE 2) The median number of any type of weekly incontinence episodes was 1 (range 1−35). (TABLE 2). The amount of leakage per incontinence episode tended to be small, with 63% of women reporting that they leak only “drops”. The majority of women (68%) reported using sanitary napkins or pads at least occasionally, and 46% reported occasionally having wet clothing as a result of their urinary leakage. (TABLE 2)
The severity of incontinence by age group and urinary incontinence type is displayed in Table 3. Within each of the three types of incontinence, no statistically significant association was seen between age and reported severity, with the majority of women across all age groups and all urinary incontinence types reporting either moderate or slight degree of symptoms. (TABLE 3)
Incontinence severity was found to be significantly associated with quality of life, with women of all three types of urinary incontinence reporting lower quality of life as urinary incontinence severity increased. (p-values <0.05) (FIGURE 1) None of the women reporting very severe urge or mixed urinary incontinence also reported being satisfied with her quality of life. The associations between increasing severity and decreasing quality of life for all three subtypes of urinary incontinence were found to be moderately strong in magnitude. (ORs: 2.5−8.6) (FIGURE 1)
A total of 234 women had moderate or severe incontinence based on the SSI. The median age of this group was 54 years (range 25−80), and 53 (22.6%) were 65 years or older. 43% of these women reported stress urinary incontinence, 32% reported urge urinary incontinence and 24% had mixed urinary incontinence. (TABLE 4) Review of the medical records of these patients was performed. For the 12 months prior to the questionnaire completion date, the median number of office visits was 4 (range 0−19), and the median number of telephone contacts was 2 (range 0−21) (Table 4). Only 11 (4.7%) of these women had urinary incontinence symptoms documented in the medical record.
In this managed-care population of women aged 25−80, the prevalence of undiagnosed urinary incontinence was 53% in the preceding year, and 39% in the preceding week. Of these women, greater than 65% reported moderate to severe incontinence severity. While barriers in care have been suggested to result in a proportion of cases of urinary incontinence going undiagnosed in women, the magnitude of this problem is not well characterized. To date the majority of research estimates the prevalence of urinary incontinence based on self-report in a community setting and it is not well established whether or not these cases are physician diagnosed. Previous studies have estimated the prevalence of urinary incontinence in women to range anywhere from 18% to 69%. 8-11 The overall prevalence of incontinence tends to increase in young adulthood, with a steady increase seen among elderly women.12 Our results support this trend, in that with increasing age, the prevalence of undiagnosed urinary incontinence significantly increases. Stress incontinence is the primary type of urinary incontinence reported among younger women, with approximately 50% of urinary incontinence being stress.13 Urge incontinence becomes more prevalent with age, with urge and mixed incontinence explaining the majority of urinary incontinence in older women.14 In this study, the rates of undiagnosed stress, mixed and urge incontinence were found to be 18.7%, 12.0% and 6.8%, respectively.
Our results suggest that undiagnosed incontinence is a nontrivial problem, with substantial impact on quality of life. The majority of women in this sample reported moderate severity of symptoms regardless of subtype. 70% of women with undiagnosed incontinence had symptoms for greater than one year, and approximately 50% reported wet clothes due to urine leakage. These results suggest that undiagnosed incontinence is equally common as diagnosed incontinence in women, and that the incontinence tends to be frequent, lasting, and bothersome.
The chart reviews of women with moderate to severe incontinence symptoms revealed that the vast majority of these women do not simply lack billing codes for urinary incontinence. Rather, the incontinence is apparently unrecognized by caretakers. The majority of the women (74%) had at least one health maintenance examination in the preceding year. Therefore, it appears that physician-patient communication about urinary incontinence is poor. One might expect the burden of undiagnosed incontinence to be more severe in non-managed care populations, where access to care is more limited. Although the present study did not address the reasons for this poor communication, previous studies have shown that many factors are involved such as patient embarrassment about the condition, presence of more acute or severe medical conditions which take precedence during the office visit, and limited understanding of the condition by patients and physicians.3, 7, 15
While this study is one of the first to quantify the magnitude of undiagnosed urinary incontinence in women, there are limitations to consider. The questionnaire response rate of 41% was suboptimal, and it is possible that this influenced the results. Although the ICD-9 diagnoses of non-respondents were found to only slightly differ from the respondents, women with incontinence symptoms may be more likely to respond than those without symptoms resulting in an overestimate of the urinary incontinence prevalence in this population. However, it is somewhat reassuring that our incontinence prevalence estimates are similar to those from prior questionnaire studies with higher response rates.13, 16, 17 Second, while the question ascertaining urinary incontinence in the past 12 months may overestimate the prevalence of urinary incontinence in the past year, the majority of our results are focused on the prevalence of urinary incontinence in the past 7 days, thus limiting the effects of this bias. Finally, the chart reviews were limited to the year preceding questionnaire administration, and therefore discussions about incontinence symptoms that occurred prior to this interval would be unrecognized. Finally, the majority of study participants were Caucasian and of similar demographics, thus limiting the generalizability of our results to other ethnicities and demographic groups.
In conclusion, among women aged 25−80 in a managed care population, the prevalence of undiagnosed urinary incontinence was found to be 53% in the past year and 39% in the past week, with 65% reporting moderate to severe symptoms. These results suggest that a significant proportion of women are suffering from clinically relevant urinary incontinence that remains undiagnosed. Because urinary incontinence is largely treatable in women, efforts need to be made to encourage women as well as their physicians to identify and discuss their incontinence symptoms in order to decrease the unnecessary burden of this disease.
J. Quentin Clemens acknowledges that he had full access to all of the data in the study and takes responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis
|Many people complain that they leak urine (wet themselves) or have accidents. In the past 12 months, have you leaked even a small amount of urine?||Yes/No|
|If “Yes” about how long have you had urine leakage?||Less than 3 months|
|3 to less than 6 months|
|6 to less than 12 months|
|1 year to less than 5 years|
|5 years or more|
|During the past 7 days, how many times did you accidentally leak urine:||Free response answer for each sub-question: _____ Times|
|- When you were performing some physical activity such as coughing, sneezing, lifting, or exercise?|
|- When you had the strong feeling that you needed to empty your bladder but couldn't get to the toilet fast enough?|
| - Without any particular physical activity or warning?|
|When you leak urine, about how much is it?||Drops or a little|
|Would you say:||Small splashes|
|How often do you wear pads or sanitary napkins, or change your underwear due to urine loss? Would you say:||Never|
|Sometimes people have wet clothes due to urine loss. By wet, we mean wet through their underwear to the next layer of clothing (or sheets, couch, etc). How often do you have wet clothes due to urine loss? Would you say:||Never|
Publisher's Disclaimer: This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final citable form. Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.