|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Although necessary in developing a rationale for vaccination, the burden of severe respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) disease in children in the resource poor setting remains poorly defined.
We conducted prospective surveillance of severe and very severe pneumonia in children aged less than 5 years admitted between 2002 and 2007 to Kilifi district hospital, coastal Kenya. Nasal specimens were screened for RSV antigen by immunofluorescence. Incidence rates were estimated for the well-defined user population.
Out of 25,149 admissions 7,359 (29%) had severe or very severe pneumonia, of whom 6,026 (82%) were enrolled. RSV prevalence was 15% (20% in infants) and 27% during epidemics (32% in infants). The proportion of cases >=3 months was 65% and >=6 months was 43%. Average annual hospitalization rates were 293 per 100,000 children under five years (95% CI 271-371) and 1,107 per 100,000 infants (1,012-1,211). Admission rates were double in the region close to the hospital. Few RSV cases had life-threatening clinical features or concurrent serious illnesses, and associated mortality was 2.2%.
In this low-income setting, rates of hospital admission with RSV-associated pneumonia are substantial, comparable to estimates from the US, yet considerably under-estimate the full community burden. An effective vaccine in children >2 months old, that is, outside the poor-responder age group, could prevent a large portion of RSV disease. Severity data suggest the basis for RSV vaccination will be the prevention of morbidity not mortality.
Six years surveillance of pediatric admissions to a rural Kenyan hospital provides well-defined incidence estimates and clinical characteristics of RSV pneumonia in a low-income setting. Data argue for vaccination based on morbidity, not mortality, targeted at age groups >2 months.
Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is a major cause of severe pneumonia and bronchiolitis in infants and children worldwide and is seen as an important target for a pediatric vaccine[1-3]. Much attention has focused on developing a live attenuated RSV vaccine targeting early infancy, with some encouraging results reported on the safety and immunogenicity of recent candidates [1, 4, 5]. In addition to research in vaccine design and development, a successful intervention program needs i) an accurate estimate of disease burden in the target population and ii) a comprehensive description of the epidemiology of infection and disease to optimise control strategies and estimate their potential impact. Both of these objectives can be reached through hospital-based surveillance for RSV disease within a well-defined user population. Furthermore, long-term disease monitoring establishes the necessary baseline of information by which to assess the impact and effectiveness of interventions. In the developing world hospital-based surveillance of RSV disease is infrequent, predominantly without an accurate population base and rarely sustained[6-8]. In this paper we present the results of prospective population-based surveillance for RSV disease spanning 6 years at a rural district hospital typical of tropical sub-Saharan Africa.
Surveillance was undertaken at Kilifi District Hospital (KDH) situated in the town of Kilifi, coastal Kenya, which serves as a primary care and referral facility for the predominantly rural farming population of around 500,000 of whom 18% are under 5 years of age . The District has one of the lowest average per capita incomes in Kenya, and under 5 and infant (age <1 year) mortality rates are high (85 and 141, respectively) although with considerable geographical variability. Malaria is transmitted throughout the year, with peaks in November-January and May-August following the rainy season but the incidence of malaria has declined sharply in recent years. HIV-1 prevalence in women attending KDH antenatal care in 2004 was ~5%. There are approximately 5,000 pediatric admissions (upper age of 12 years) each year. Each child is investigated with a standard computerized clinical history and examination and standard set of investigations on admission including a full haemogram, blood culture and, among febrile children, a Giemsa stained blood slide . In 2000, a demographic surveillance study was established in an area of 891 km2 close to KDH monitoring births, deaths and migration events in a population of approximately 240,000 through 4 monthly enumeration rounds. From 16th April 2002, the residency status of each child presenting to KDH was established on admission through linkage to the population register of the Kilifi Epidemiological and Demographic Surveillance Study (EpiDSS).
Surveillance for RSV was initiated on 1st January 2002. We report on all children aged 1 day to 59 months who presented with the clinical syndrome of pneumonia, either severe or very severe, excluding babies with neonatal tetanus. Clinical definitions, which follow, have been described previously[12, 13]. A history of cough or difficulty in breathing for less than 30 days, when accompanied by lower chest wall indrawing was defined as severe pneumonia, or when accompanied by any one of prostration, coma or hypoxemia was defined as very severe pneumonia. Prostration included the inability to feed or drink. Hypoxemia was defined by an oxygen saturation (pO2) of less than 90% determined by finger tip Oxymeter (Nelcor®). All children with hypoxaemia at admission are given supplemental oxygen. Malaria was defined by P. falciparum parasitemia on the blood slide. Severe malnutrition was defined as a small value (≤10th percentile by age group) for mid-upper arm circumference (MUAC), bipedal oedema or visible severe wasting, and shock by either a peripheral-central temperature gradient, a capillary refill time of >3sec or a weak peripheral pulse volume. A history of prematurity was elicited for all infant at admissions and heart disease established from diagnosis-on-discharge data. Bronchiolitis as a specific condition is not reported. In this setting it has little influence on patient management and, despite the long-term surveillance, remains poorly recognised by clinicians at admission (in the absence of laboratory confirmation). HIV diagnostic counseling and testing was not in place for most of the period of surveillance covered in this report and is not considered further here. Written informed consent was obtained for all eligible participants.
Nasal specimens were collected as soon as possible after admission by nasal washing; in children who were too unwell to undergo nasal washing a nasaopharyngeal aspirate was performed . Sample collection was postponed to the following Monday for children admitted over the weekend (beginning Friday at 5pm). Specimens were processed as described previously and screened for RSV antigen by using a Direct Immunofluorescent Antibody Test (Light Diagnostics RSV screen, Chemicon, Temecula, CA) following the manufacturer’s protocol.
Admission and demographic data were entered onto FileMaker 5.5, and cleaned and analysed using STATA 10.1 (StataCorp, Texas). Throughout, the term pneumonia refers to all cases with clinically severe or very severe pneumonia. The pattern of admissions to hospital with RSV-associated pneumonia was determined from January 2002 to December 2007 and the incidence of admission to hospital with RSV-associated pneumonia was determined between May 2002 and April 2007. The incidence and 95% confidence intervals were calculated as the mean annual number of resident children admitted with each case definition divided by the resident population size at the mid-point of the study period (29th October 2004), and adjusted for the estimated proportion of these cases with detectable RSV in their nasal specimens. This assumes that the proportion of children with pneumonia who had RSV in their nasal specimens was the same in both the tested and untested groups. Annual period incidence estimates (e.g. year May 2002 to April 2003) were calculated using the resident population denominator for the mid-point of each period (e.g. October 30th 2002). Incidence rate 95% confidence intervals were estimated using a normal approximation of the likelihood profile.
Geographical variation in the incidence of RSV-associated admissions was calculated for each administrative sub-location (of which there are 40 in Kilifi EpiDSS), and presented as a categorical variable using ArcView (ESRI ArcMap v9.2) and Adobe Illustrator (CS2 v12.1). The incidence was calculated separately for sub-locations close to the hospital meaning that at least part of the sub-location fell within a radius of 5km of KDH . RSV epidemic periods were empirically defined to begin when at least 10% of tested samples were RSV positive or with the observation of at least two RSV cases per week in each of two consecutive weeks, and to continue while these conditions were satisfied, with the requirement that an epidemic must last for four or more weeks. Proportions were compared using Fisher exact or Chi-Squared tests (2 tailed) and equality of distributions evaluated using the Wilcoxon rank-sum test. Adjusted risk ratios were determined using binomial regression.
Between 1st January 2002 and 31st December 2007, 25,149 children aged <5 years, 11,829 infants, were admitted to KDH (Fig.1). Of the 7,359 eligible children 82% (6,026) were enrolled, of whom 15% (884) tested RSV positive (there was no difference by sex). The reasons for nonenrollment were early discharge, refusal and death in an approximate ratio of 2:1:1. Comparing children who were and were not enrolled, there was no difference in the median age (9m), or in the percentage male (56%), and the proportion of infants was higher in the enrolled group (59% versus 56%, P=0.037). Nonenrolment was higher outside of RSV epidemics than during (20% versus 16%, exact P<0.001). Among the enrolled 4.4% died in-hospital compared with 9.9% in all eligible children. Furthermore, for those enrolled, relative to the non-enrolled, at admission there was a lower proportion with malaria parasitemia (16% versus 21%, P <0.001), a pathogenic bacterial isolate (5.4% versus 11%, exact P <0.001), and very severe pneumonia (22% versus 46%, exact P<0.001), but there was no difference in the proportion with severe malnutrition (14% versus 16%, exact P=0.058).
Epidemics of RSV positive cases were periodic with a starting date between November and February, a peak month between January and May and an average duration of 18 weeks (range 13-27 weeks). Epidemics appear not to have a simple annual pattern, but rather the interepidemic period (from peak month to peak month) alternates between 9m and 15m (Fig.S1). Of all RSV-associated pneumonia admissions 815 (92%) occurred during an epidemic period. The number of RSV cases occurring in each epidemic ranged from 68 (17% of samples tested) in the epidemic of 2002/3 to 202 (30% of samples tested) in 2005/6, with an overall proportion of 27%. Seasonal variation in RSV admissions was roughly coincident with total pneumonia admissions. No temporal association with any meteorological measure or other disease syndrome was observed (Fig.S1).
The distribution of RSV-associated pneumonia admissions by age and severity is presented in Table 1. The proportion RSV positive within an age class was highest in children 0-5 months (around 21%), declined with increasing age, and was higher in children with severe compared with very severe pneumonia (16.5% versus 8.3%, P<0.001). The proportion of cases aged less than 3, 6, and 12 months were 35%, 57% and 79%, respectively. The age distribution of cases differed significantly by clinical category (P<0.001). In particular, the proportion of RSV-associated admissions that were aged 0-2 months was higher (51%) among the sub-set of children with very severe pneumonia.
Over the 5 year period 1st May 2002 to 30th April 2007 the mean annual number of admissions from the community of Kilifi EpiDSS residents was 2,661 aged <5 years, and 1,188 aged <1 year. The rate of hospital admissions with severe or very severe pneumonia was 1,912 for children aged <5 years and 5,528 for infants. The incidence of admission with RSV-associated severe or very severe pneumonia was 293 (range between years 202-373) for children aged <5 years and 1,107 (range 692-1587) for infants (Table 2). Incidence estimates by year of study and finely stratified by age are provided as supplementary material (Table S1).
The geographical distribution of RSV associated severe and very severe pneumonia incidence in children under 5 years of age, presented in Fig.2, reveals considerable variation between administrative sub-locations, with incidence apparently declining with distance from the District hospital. For the population of children under 5 years of age living within the region defined as close to KDH, the hospitalization rate for severe or very severe pneumonia was 3,169 per 100,000 (95% CI 3,023-3,323) and for RSV-associated severe or very severe pneumonia 574 per 100,000 (95% CI 507-650). Among infants in the sub-locations closest to the hospital the incidence of severe or very severe pneumonia and RSV-associated severe or very severe pneumonia were 8,828 per 100,000 (8,297-9,393) and 2,112 per 100,000 (1,835-2,431), respectively.
Among cases of severe or very severe pneumonia the clinical signs crackles, wheezing, nasal flaring and lower chest-wall indrawing were all associated with RSV whereas shock, hypoxemia, prostration and coma were inversely associated with RSV (Table 3). Concurrent malaria parasitemia, severe malnutrition and bacteraemia were all significantly less common among RSV-positive children with pneumonia. Furthermore, a history of premature birth in infants and a discharge diagnosis including heart disease were marginally less frequent in RSV-positive children. Cases of RSV-associated pneumonia had a significantly shorter in-patient stay and lower case fatality rate than cases of RSV-negative pneumonia. RSV positive cases were significantly younger than RSV negative cases (median age 4.9 vs 19.1 months, respectively; Wilcoxon rank-sum z=11.34, P<0.001). Adjusting the relative risk of each feature in Table 3 for age did not alter the pattern above. The proportion of RSV pneumonia cases in children under 5 years of age that were very severe did not differ by distance from KDH (near 11.2% versus far 13.5%, exact P=0.501).
Bacterial pathogens were identified from the blood of 20/864 (2%) RSV-positive cases of pneumonia. Isolates cultured were Group A β-haemolytic streptococci (5), Streptococcus pneumoniae (5), Acinetobacter sp (5), Haemophilus influenzae (4), Pseudomonas sp (1), and Escherischia coli (1). In one instance there was a dual co-infection with S. pneumoniae and H. influenzae. Three of the children with confirmed bacterial co-infection, subsequently died, two with H. influenzae and one with Acinetobacter sp. In comparison, 6% (302) of RSV negative cases were blood culture positive, with similar mortality (15%) and species distribution relative to RSV positive cases.
Our surveillance at a district hospital in coastal Kenya spanning 6 years provides a highly detailed description of the burden of RSV severe disease in young children in a typical rural developing country setting. Over the period 2002 to 2007 we identified clinically severe or very severe pneumonia in roughly one third of under 5 year olds and 38% of infants admitted to KDH, of which an estimated 15% and 19%, respectively, were associated with RSV infection. The rate of hospital admissions with RSV-associated pneumonia within the demographically well-defined user population was 293 cases per 1000,000 per annum in children under 5 years and 1,107 cases per 100,000 per annum in infants. These data are similar in magnitude to those reported for an intensively monitored birth cohort within the same population (1,300 infant cases of RSV-associated severe pneumonia admitted to KDH per 100,000 child years of observation) , and for the small number of other denominator-based studies of hospital admissions in resource-poor countries[6, 7]. Furthermore, our reported rates mirror closely population-based hospitalization rates recently described for various locations in the US.
Thus our data indicate that an effective pediatric RSV vaccine could prevent a sizeable proportion of hospital pneumonia admissions. A useful reference point is afforded by comparison with severe rotavirus diarrhoea, targeted for vaccination, which exhibited an annual rate of hospitalization at KDH for the period 2002-04 of 478 per100,000 in the under 5 year olds and 1431 per 100,000 in infants. Furthermore, the ‘distance decay’ in rates of hospitalization (Fig.2), previously reported in The Gambia , indicates a large (~two fold) additional burden of severe RSV present in the community but not recorded through in-patient surveillance. If we assume the estimates close to the hospital are more realistic of the community burden and representative of Kenya as a whole, the annual number of RSV-associated severe or very severe pneumonia cases in children under 5 and infants throughout the country are estimated at 37,000 and 29,500, respectively (based on population estimates for children <5 years and births in 2008 of 6.5m and 1.4m, respectively.)
We further point out an additional burden of RSV severe pneumonia in the community, missed by hospital surveillance, in the form of cases presenting to out-patient health facilities and not admitted, as was shown in our previous report of a birth cohort in the same setting as the present study. A potential further source of under-estimation of RSV disease in our study arises from the immunofluorescence assay used to detect the virus, which has been shown to be less sensitive than molecular based detection methods [20, 21].
A clear impediment to vaccine intervention is the absence of an effective candidate for use in the key target age group of 0-2m [4, 22]. Nevertheless, studies consistently show good safety and immunogenicity of live attenuated RSV vaccines in older infants and young children[5, 23]. Data from the present study show that around 2/3 of hospitalised RSV-associated pneumonia occurs in children 3 months and over, and hence delayed vaccine delivery has the potential to prevent a significant fraction of RSV disease. Reduced transmission from older vaccinated infants to the vulnerable early infants may enhance the benefit of delayed vaccination.
Our data show that the incidence of RSV disease varies considerably year-by-year, particularly in infants, which varied by a factor in excess of two between the lowest and highest years, suggesting that short-term studies may present a biased picture of RSV disease burden. Interestingly the distribution of disease by age was roughly constant over time (in contrast to observations from The Gambia).
In relation to pneumonia severity our study shows that non-life-threatening clinical features were more strongly associated with being RSV positive than negative, whereas the risks of very severe conditions, risk factors and concurrent illness were significantly higher in RSV negative cases. A similar clinical pattern was reported from an in-patient study in Mozambique. The low case fatality rate of 2.2% for RSV positives (in line with most other reports[6, 26, 27]), compared with 4.7% in RSV negative cases, is therefore not surprising. These data support the rationale for a RSV vaccine based on prevention of morbidity rather than mortality. Nevertheless, as in previous studies there is some concern over bias in sampling of less severe cases, since 18% of eligible children were not tested, and the case fatality in the enrolled was less that half that found in all eligible children (4.4% versus 9.9%). In our setting, faced with a child undergoing emergency management, it was not a clear priority of the clinician to collect a nasal sample. Hence, it is possible that the true case fatality rate associated with RSV is significantly higher than observed, and consideration should be given to collecting a specimen post-mortem to address this unknown.
The prospect of widespread use of vaccines against H. influenza type b and S. pneumoniae across the developing world is set to alter substantially the landscape of pneumonia aetiology. Surveillance for a broad aetiology of the remaining significant burden of childhood pneumonia is of increasing importance. Arguably, the most important remaining cause of childhood pneumonia potentially preventable by vaccine intervention is RSV. The present study reports a substantial burden of RSV associated severe pneumonia in a low-income setting that is equivalent to that identified in the high-income setting. This argues a need to investigate the potential use of vaccines for both developed and developing countries. This study also demonstrates the power of long-term surveillance in understanding the role of RSV in morbidity and mortality patterns in children in a low resource setting, and the requirement for population evidence in developing a rational strategy for future RSV vaccine intervention.
We would like to thank the participants involved in the study and their caregivers, and the staff of the RSV team (in the ward and the laboratory), pediatric wards, hospital administration and Kilifi EpiDSS team. The study is published with permission of the Director of KEMRI.
Funding: Financial support was provided by the Wellcome Trust (061584 and 076278). The funding agencies had no role in study design, data collection or preparation of this manuscript. The authors declare there to be no conflict of interest in relation to the publication of this work.
Ethical approval: The Kenyan National Research Ethical Committee and the Coventry Research Ethics Committee, UK, granted ethical approval for the study.