|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Rhodoferax ferrireducens is a metabolically versatile, Fe(III)-reducing, subsurface microorganism that is likely to play an important role in the carbon and metal cycles in the subsurface. It also has the unique ability to convert sugars to electricity, oxidizing the sugars to carbon dioxide with quantitative electron transfer to graphite electrodes in microbial fuel cells. In order to expand our limited knowledge about R. ferrireducens, the complete genome sequence of this organism was further annotated and then the physiology of R. ferrireducens was investigated with a constraint-based, genome-scale in silico metabolic model and laboratory studies.
The iterative modeling and experimental approach unveiled exciting, previously unknown physiological features, including an expanded range of substrates that support growth, such as cellobiose and citrate, and provided additional insights into important features such as the stoichiometry of the electron transport chain and the ability to grow via fumarate dismutation. Further analysis explained why R. ferrireducens is unable to grow via photosynthesis or fermentation of sugars like other members of this genus and uncovered novel genes for benzoate metabolism. The genome also revealed that R. ferrireducens is well-adapted for growth in the subsurface because it appears to be capable of dealing with a number of environmental insults, including heavy metals, aromatic compounds, nutrient limitation and oxidative stress.
This study demonstrates that combining genome-scale modeling with the annotation of a new genome sequence can guide experimental studies and accelerate the understanding of the physiology of under-studied yet environmentally relevant microorganisms.
Rhodoferax ferrireducens is of interest because of its potentially important role in carbon and metal cycling in soils and sediments and its novel ability to convert sugars into electricity . R. ferrireducens, which was isolated from subsurface sediments in Oyster Bay, VA, is a facultative anaerobic microorganism in the Comamonadaceae family of the Betaproteobacteria . It is one of the few known facultative microorganisms that can grow anaerobically by oxidizing organic compounds to carbon dioxide with Fe(III) serving as the electron acceptor. This property, as well as its ability to grow at the low temperatures found in many subsurface environments, suggests that it could contribute to the oxidation of organic matter coupled to the reduction of Fe(III) in many soils and sediments. Microorganisms closely related to R. ferrireducens have been detected in a number of subsurface environments [3-7]. The novel ability of R. ferrireducens to oxidize sugars to carbon dioxide with quantitative electron transfer to electrodes in microbial fuel cells is of interest because of the possibility of using sugars as a renewable energy source for power production [1,8,9].
R. ferrireducens has a number of important physiological characteristics that distinguishes it from other members of the genus Rhodoferax. For example, it appears to be unable to grow phototrophically , a previous hallmark feature of the genus [10,11]. Furthermore, unlike other Rhodoferax species, R. ferrireducens cannot grow anaerobically via fructose fermentation. No other Rhodoferax species have been shown to grow via anaerobic respiration, whereas R. ferrireducens can grow by oxidizing a wide variety of organic electron donors, such as acetate, lactate, propionate, pyruvate, succinate, malate and benzoate, with Fe(III) serving as the electron acceptor . In addition to Fe(III), R. ferrireducens can utilize Mn(IV) oxide, fumarate, and nitrate as electron acceptors to support anaerobic growth .
The production of linear polyesters in the form of polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHAs)  is an interesting characteristic of R. ferrireducens with important biotechnological implications. PHAs are typically synthesized in bacteria from sugars or lipids and have industrial interest due to their properties as thermoplastics and elastomers .
In order to further elucidate the physiology of R. ferrireducens, the publicly available genome sequence http://www.jcvi.org/cms/research/projects/cmr was annotated in more detail and a genome-scale metabolic model was reconstructed using the constraint-based modeling approach [13-15]. Constraint-based modeling couples stoichiometric reconstructions of all known metabolic reactions in the organism with a set of constraints on the fluxes of each of these reactions in the system. This approach unveiled a variety of previously unknown physiological features of R. ferrireducens that contributed to a better understanding of its potential role in subsurface environments and converting organic compounds to electricity.
The Rhodoferax ferrireducens genome as sequenced and assembled by the Joint Genome Institute (JGI)  consists of a circular chromosome of 4,712,337 base pairs (bp) and a plasmid with 257,447 bp. Manual curation of this sequence predicted a total of 4451 coding sequences (CDSs) from the chromosome and 319 CDSs from the plasmid (Figure (Figure1,1, Table Table1).1). Of the chromosomally located CDSs, BLAST searches matched 3,830 to a database of Proteobacterial proteins, by selecting for alignments with a 70% length requirement, 35% identity and an e-value less than 1 e-5. Analysis of the best BLAST match for each CDS against the database of Proteobacterial proteins established the taxonomic breakdown as follows: Betaproteobacteria (3,253 genes), Gammaproteobacteria (258), Alphaproteobacteria (185), Delta/Epsilonproteobacteria (121), and unclassified Proteobacteria (13). Beyond examining best BLAST matches, the "BLAST Curves" analysis was also employed. BLAST Curves (Figure (Figure2)2) visually display the number of genes in each percent identity bin, and each color-coded curve corresponds to matches to a particular genome in the BLAST database. By comparing the profiles of all the curves in the graph, relative rankings of completely sequenced Proteobacterial genomes in the BLAST database can be elucidated for R. ferrireducens. For example, a curve having a profile with a peak on the right side of the graph, which indicates high percent identity matches to R. ferrireducens, is ranked higher than a curve displaying a peak on the left side of the graph. An important note concerning BLAST Curves is that a database genome with a lower absolute number of matches can have a more significant ranking if it has a high percent identity profile compared to another genome with a higher absolute number of low percent identity matches. As shown in Figure Figure2,2, the genomes in the BLAST database, which are most closely related to R. ferrireducens, are Polaromonas sp. JS666 and Polaromonas napthtalenivorans CJ2 species with 2508 and 2417 matches respectively [17-20]. The next several closely ranked organisms include Acidovorax sp. JS42 and Acidovorax avenae subsp citrulli AAC00-1 (both with 2203 matches), Delftia acidovorans SPH-1 (2308 matches), and Verminephrobacter eiseniae EF01-2 (2029 matches). Compared to these examples of Comamonadaceae, the unclassified Burkholderiales, Methylibium petroleiphylum PM1 (2116 matches) and Ralstonia eutropha H16 (2303 matches) have a lower profile in the BLAST Curves output. R. ferrireducens is also a better match to the Gammaproteobacterium Escherichia coli K12 (1259 matches) than to the Deltaproteobacteria Geobacter metallireducens GS 15 and G. sulfurreducens PCA (825 and 811 matches, respectively).
Of the 319 predicted CDSs in the plasmid, BLAST searches matched only 69 to a database of Proteobacterial proteins, using the same criteria used for the chromosome (see above). These include possible conjugation proteins, 3 integrases separated by large spans of hypothetical proteins, a helicase, a DNA methylase, a gene for DNA repair protein RadA, a copy of polymerase DnaN (different from the chromosome copy), at least 6 CRISPR cas genes, a DNA ligase, a thymidine kinase, 3 secretion proteins, 2 sensor histidine kinases, and possible type 4 pilin proteins. An unusual finding was a copy of a tRNA-Ile, which is different in sequence from the identical copies in the chromosome but shares the same anticodon.
Of the 4770 genes in the R. ferrireducens genome used for developing the in silico model, 744 genes were included in the reconstructed genome-scale network. The R. ferrireducens metabolic model contains 762 reactions and 790 metabolites, including 69 extracellular metabolites (Table (Table2).2). A detailed list of genes, reactions, metabolites, and gene-protein-reaction (GPR) associations in the metabolic model are available in Additional file 1. The functional characterization of the 762 reactions in the model is summarized in Figure Figure3.3. Among different functional groups, reactions for biosynthesis of amino acids, lipids and cell wall components, cofactors, and nucleic acids are the most abundant, accounting for 65% of all the reactions. Currently, there are 77 reactions associated with transporting metabolites, including redundant transporters for the extracellular metabolites.
The model incorporates two types of maintenance energy parameters: the growth-associated maintenance (GAM), which reflects the energy cost during division (e.g. protein polymerization); and the non-growth associated maintenance (NGAM), which reflects the basal energy requirement of the cell regardless of growth. Based on the similarity in biomass composition between R. ferrireducens and E. coli, the GAM was set at 59.81 mmol ATP/gdw h, the same as the E. coli model . Three independent sets of physiological and growth data were used to determine the NGAM and the stoichiometry of the electron transport chain of the genome-scale model of R. ferrireducens: 1) acetate and fumarate, 2) acetate and Fe(III)  and 3) citrate and Fe(III) (see Methods for growth conditions). In order to determine the most consistent values with experimentally determined growth yields, an optimization algorithm (Figure (Figure4A)4A) iterated the H+/2e- ratio of NADH dehydrogenase from 1 to 4, the H+/2e- ratio of cytochrome reductase from 1 to 4, and the NGAM from 0 to 2.5 mmol ATP/gdw h. This process identified optimal energy parameters of an H+/2e- ratio of 2 for both NADH dehydrogenase and cytochrome reductase, and an NGAM of 0.45 mmol ATP/gdw h (Figure (Figure4B).4B). This set of energy parameters was applied to the metabolic model in simulations to compare between in silico predictions and experimentally determined yields. A fourth set of experimental data, obtained from a batch culture grown on fumarate as the electron donor and acceptor, was used to validate the model. The biomass yield of fumarate was calculated by constraining fumarate, succinate, and acetate fluxes to simulate the experimental conditions, and the yields obtained through the simulation closely matched the actual experimental results (Figure (Figure4C).4C). The use of fumarate as electron donor and acceptor by R. ferrireducens is further described in the fumarate dismutation section.
It is interesting to point out that the obtained NGAM for the R. ferrireducens genome-scale model is similar to that of G. sulfurreducens, another acetate-oxidizing Fe(III) reducer  often found in the same microbial niche [3-7]. Both R. ferrireducens and G. sulfurreducens in silico models have an H+/2e- ratio of 2 for the NADH dehydrogenase of the electron transfer chains. However, the H+/2e-ratio for cytochrome reductase is 2 in R. ferrireducens as opposed to 1 in G. sulfurreducens . Such a difference between the two models implies that the electron transfer chain of R. ferrireducens is more efficient than that of G. sulfurreducens. The evolution of electron transport chains with different efficiencies suggests that microorganisms could adapt to different lifestyles within the same community. Additional modeling studies on microbial community competition have shown that G. sulfurreducens is better adapted to acetate-rich environments, whereas R. ferrireducens thrives in nutrient-depleted environments (K. Zhuang, personal communication). Understanding these survival strategies is crucial for modeling complex microbial communities.
R. ferrireducens possesses a full tricarboxylic acids (TCA) cycle and pentose phosphate pathway. Oxaloacetate is likely replenished by the combined action of PEP carboxylase (Rfer_1714) and pyruvate phosphate dikinase (Rfer_0088). Genes coding for the enzymes of the glyoxylate cycle and a glyoxylate oxidase (Rfer_0480-81) are present, which allow this organism to utilize glycolate as the sole electron and carbon source (data not shown).
The versatility in donor utilization is reflected by the existence of several pathways and their associated enzymes by which the key intermediate pyruvate can be produced. These include the enzymes of the glycolytic pathway, L-lactate dehydrogenase (cytochrome) [Rfer_2351, EC 126.96.36.199], and the pyruvate-oxidoreductase (POR) complex. Likewise, the genome provides multiple alternatives for generating acetyl-CoA: pyruvate dehydrogenase, aldehyde dehydrogenase/acetaldehyde dehydrogenase, acetate-CoA ligase and acetate kinase/phosphate acetyltransferase. Notably, of these enzymes only the pyruvate dehydrogenase and acetate kinase/phosphate acetyltransferase are shared by G. sulfurreducens.
No fermentative growth with sugars was observed in R. ferrireducens, which contrasts with other Rhodoferax species [2,10,11]. Fermentative growth on glucose was simulated with the in silico model and the result confirmed the experimental observation. Detailed analysis of the metabolic network suggested that the lack of fermentative growth of R. ferrireducens with glucose is likely due to its inability to recycle reduced NADH generated from glycolysis for redox balance without an electron acceptor. Compared to the E. coli metabolic model, the R. ferrireducens model lacks several reactions, including the reversible lactate dehydrogenase (LdhA), the pyruvate formate lyase (PflA), and the acetaldehyde CoA dehydrogenase/alcohol dehydrogenase (AdhE). These reactions are important to the E. coli fermentative growth that produces acetate, ethanol, lactate, and formate to allow the balance of the reducing equivalents generated during glycolysis . Simulations with the R. ferrireducens model predicted that introducing any one of these enzymes into R. ferrireducens should support the fermentation of glucose (data not shown).
R. ferrireducens differs from most other acetate-oxidizing Fe(III) reducers in its ability to completely oxidize sugars to carbon dioxide with electron transfer to Fe(III) and electrodes . The genome contains genes coding for the Entner-Doudoroff glycolytic pathway, typical of Pseudomonads and Comamonas. Sugars are likely to be imported into the bacterial cells by a homolog of a general hexose phosphotransferase system (Rfer_0601-03). In addition, several ABC transporters might be related to sugar transport. For instance, Rfer_0952-55 have weak similarity to ABC-type sugar transporters and are surrounded by genes related to carbohydrate metabolism (see Additional file 2). A larger cluster comprising CDSs Rfer_1094 to Rfer_1113 contains at least two putative sugar ABC transporters as well as other genes involved in sugar metabolism. R. ferrireducens is able to oxidize other sugars such as fructose, sucrose and mannose, but not lactose (not shown). The presence of two putative betaglucosidases in the genome (Rfer_1102 and Rfer_1111) suggested that R. ferrireducens might also be able to metabolize cellobiose, a fact confirmed in subsequent growth studies (see Additional file 3). Cellobiose degradation is of biotechnological interest because of the potential of turning common cellulosic waste products into energy. The in silico R. ferrireducens model includes the pathway for cellobiose degradation and predicts growth on this substrate.
New experimental evidence indicates that R. ferrireducens is able to grow with fumarate as the sole electron donor, electron acceptor and carbon source (Figure (Figure5).5). This type of metabolism is known as fumarate dismutation and has been previously described in Desulfovibrio sp. , and the main products in R. ferrireducens are acetate and succinate. The R. ferrireducens genome contains genes whose products account for this metabolism, including a fumarate transporter DcuB (Rfer_3576) with 79% identity to the characterized homolog from Wolinella succinogenes  and a putative malate dehydrogenase (oxaloacetate-decarboxylating) (NADP+) (malic enzyme) with 89% identity to its homolog from P. aeruginosa (Rfer_0093). In fumarate dismutation simulations, fumarate is reduced to succinate accepting electrons from reducing equivalents that are generated in: 1) from fumarate through malic enzyme to acetyl-CoA, or 2) from fumarate to acetyl-CoA and the complete oxidation of acetyl-CoA through the TCA cycle. The first route is more efficient in generating ATP, but the in silico model predicted that the second route is also active in simulations constrained with experimental data, probably due to the high activities of the TCA cycle enzymes.
Citrate tested negative as an electron donor in the initial description of Rhodoferax ferrireducens . However, other members of the Rhodoferax genus are able to utilize citrate , and examination of the genome suggests that it might be the case for R. ferrireducens as well. Rfer_2412 (CitT) is 44% identical to a putative citrate transporter from E. coli CFT073  and is located in a cluster of genes also associated with citrate metabolism. Further experimental evaluation confirmed that R. ferrireducens could utilize citrate as electron donor and carbon source with Fe(III) or nitrate as the electron acceptor (see Additional file 4). Even though other Betaproteobacteria can also use citrate , BLAST-based analyses revealed that these R. ferrireducens citrate-related proteins are more closely related to Gammaproteobacteria and Alphaproteobacteria homologs (see Additional file 5). An exception is isocitrate dehydrogenase (Rfer_2411), for which there is a lineage-specific gene duplication in the R. ferrireducens genome (Rfer_2380, 97% identity) that resembles homologs of the Betaproteobacteria. Rfer_3489, annotated as a CitB, a citrate-utilization protein, might also be involved in this metabolism.
The in silico model predicted that R. ferrireducens could completely oxidize citrate with Fe(III) as electron acceptor (Figure (Figure6A,6A, Pathway P5). However, this requires a very high Fe(III) flux, 18-fold higher than that of citrate. When culturing R. ferrireducens it was difficult to provide enough Fe(III) for complete oxidation of the citrate added. Therefore, the experimental growth of R. ferrireducens was under electron acceptor limiting conditions, which resulted in incomplete oxidation of citrate and production of acetate and succinate. The in silico model suggested four other pathways of citrate oxidation that could also produce acetate and/or succinate under acceptor limiting conditions. These pathways have different Fe(III):citrate stoichiometry and generate different amounts of ATP (Figure (Figure6A,6A, Pathways P1-P4). Citrate lyase (CITL), a key enzyme in citrate utilization, is active in pathways P1 and P2. The reversible malate dehydrogenase (MDH) can proceed in both directions: reductive in pathways P1 and P2, and oxidative in pathway P5. Succinate dehydrogenase can act in both directions, too: it is reductive in pathway P1 but oxidative in pathways P4 and P5. In order to figure out which of these pathways are the most likely to be active in vivo, citrate consumption was simulated in silico with data from two independent growth experiments applied as constraints (Figure (Figure6B).6B). The model predicted that three pathways were active. When the Fe(III):citrate ratio was low, R. ferrireducens utilized pathways P1, P2, and P3; which have low requirement of Fe(III) availability. When more Fe(III) was available, R. ferrireducens shifted towards pathway P4, which uses electron acceptors with a higher efficiency and more ATP is generated per citrate consumed (Figure (Figure6B).6B). The integration of experimental data and computational modeling in this case greatly improved our understanding of citrate metabolism, and can be readily applied to understanding other aspects of cellular physiology.
The genome of R. ferrireducens harbors genes for benzoate degradation that are likely to be active under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Interestingly, unusual genes and enzymes are involved in both cases. Recently, a novel pathway for aerobic benzoate catabolism was characterized in Azoarcus evansii [28,29]. The unorthodox pathway combines features from the classical aerobic and anaerobic pathways of aromatic catabolism. In addition to an oxygen-dependent hydroxylation step similar to the aerobic route, it has the following features which are characteristic of the anaerobic pathways ; (1) the substrate is activated by co-enzyme A (CoA) formation, (2) the intermediates are processed as CoA thioesters, (3) ring cleavage is non-oxygenolytic, and (4) a β-oxidation-like reaction sequence is involved in the last steps of the pathway. In R. ferrireducens the genes of the new catabolic route are clustered and their products are most similar to orthologs from Polaromonas naphtalenivorans, one of the closest relatives of R. ferrireducens (Figure (Figure7).7). Interestingly, R. ferrireducens also possesses genes coding for protocatechuate-4,5-dioxygenase (Rfer_0330, Rfer_0331), which catalyzes the oxygen-dependent ring cleavage of protocatechuate, an intermediate in aerobic benzoate degradation pathway.
In the absence of oxygen, the first step in benzoate catabolism is the production of benzoyl-CoA. The fact that there is only one gene for benzoate-CoA ligase in the R. ferrireducens genome (Rfer_0216) suggests that benzoyl-CoA formation is catalyzed by the same enzyme under both aerobic and anaerobic conditions, as observed in the denitrifying organism Thauera aromatica . In facultative anaerobes, benzoyl-CoA is reductively dearomatized by an ATP-dependent benzoyl-CoA reductase, but the genes coding for this enzyme could not be found in the R. ferrireducens genome. It has been recently postulated that benzoyl-CoA reduction in obligate anaerobes like Geobacter metallireducens is mediated by a novel ATP-independent enzyme complex encoded by the genes bamB-I [32,33]. The genome of R. ferrireducens contains several genes whose products are moderately similar (based on percent similarity at protein-level) to some bam genes of G. metallireducens (see Additional file 6), but they do not appear to form a cluster. The possibility of R. ferrireducens having a novel system for benzoyl-CoA reduction cannot be excluded. The full elucidation of these pathways warrants further study. The R. ferrireducens model contains a pathway for benzoate degradation, and predicts the growth of R. ferrireducens on benzoate with Fe(III) as an electron acceptor.
The genome of R. ferrireducens also contains a putative pathway for the anaerobic catabolism of phenylalanine that includes a transaminase (Rfer_2174), a phenylpyruvate decarboxylase (Rfer_0518) and phenylacetaldehyde dehydrogenase (Rfer_0598). The end product of this pathway, phenylacetate, could be converted into benzoyl-CoA by the successive action of putative phenylacetate-CoA ligase (Rfer_3536) , phenylacetyl-CoA: acceptor oxidoreductase (Rfer_3093, Rfer_3094) and phenylglyoxylate:acceptor oxidoreductase (Rfer_2184-87) .
The complete oxidation of benzoate requires an elevated Fe(III):substrate ratio. This suggests that benzoate or other aromatic compounds could be a good feedstock for R. ferrireducens based microbial fuel cells to generate electricity. Thus, using aromatic waste stream for R. ferrireducens based microbial fuel cells could be an attractive idea that can achieve both bioremediation of aromatic compound contaminants and generation of electricity.
The ability to predict growth yields on various substrates can be helpful for understanding the growth of microorganisms in various environments as well as for practical applications. R. ferrireducens, growth on eight representative electron donors (acetate, glycolate, lactate, fumarate, benzoate, citrate, glucose, and cellobiose) was simulated under electron donor-limiting conditions with Fe(III) as electron acceptor (Figure (Figure8).8). Among the C6 compounds, glucose was predicted to yield more biomass than equivalent molar concentrations of citrate or benzoate. The simulations with different complex electron donors will allow a fast and easy analysis of substrate efficiency for bioremediation and electricity generation applications.
Although other members of the Rhodoferax genus are capable of autotrophic growth [10,11], this is not the case for R. ferrireducens . No evidence of photosystems I or II was found in the genome. However, incomplete pathways associated with CO2 fixation are present. For instance, there is a gene coding for the large subunit of Ribulose-1,5-Bisphosphate Carboxylase/Oxygenase (RuBisCO) (Rfer_1391), but not the small subunit. Some genes encoding enzymes for the Calvin-Benson-Bassham cycle are present as well, but genes for phosphoketolase and seduheptulose-bisphosphatase are missing. The reductive carboxylate cycle, present in many photosynthetic bacteria, is also incomplete as a gene for the key enzyme ATP citrate synthase, is missing.
Well-studied Fe(III)-reducing microorganisms such as Shewanella and Geobacter species have abundant c-type cytochromes that are essential for extracellular electron transfer [36,37]. R. ferrireducens also has an abundance of c-type cytochrome genes (see Additional file 7). Based on matches to Prosite and hidden Markov Model (HMM) profiles, the R. ferrireducens genome possess 69 putative c-type cytochromes, of which 45 have matched above the high confidence scores to the Prosite profiles for the Cytochrome c family (PS51007) and multiheme cytochrome c family profiles (PS51008). Of the R. ferrireducens putative c-type cytochrome complement, approximately 45% (31/69) possess a homolog to a c-type cytochrome indentified in a previously sequenced Geobacter spp. genome and the majority appears to reside in the periplasm or outer membrane based on the presence of predicted signal peptides. One c-type cytochrome gene in R. ferrireducens, Rfer_0244, is a homolog of OmcE, an outer-membrane c-type cytochrome that is essential for Fe(III) oxide reduction in G. sulfurreducens . However, there are no homologs to several other cytochromes shown to be important in G. sulfurreducens Fe(III) oxide reduction (and electricity generation) including OmcB, OmcC, OmcF, OmcS, OmcT and OmcZ [38-40]. These results suggest that c-type cytochrome complements can vary in Fe(III) oxide reducing (and electricity producing) prokaryotes. However, whether or not a subset of c-type cytochromes essential to Fe(III) oxide reduction (or electricity generation) exists within the set shared between Rhodoferax and other Fe(III) oxide reducing prokaryotes remains to be determined. This may not be surprising as there is poor conservation of cytochromes even among Geobacter species (J. Butler, personal communication).
The genome of R. ferrireducens contains a respiratory nitrate reductase complex (Rfer_2792-95), and nitrate was previously reported to serve as an electron acceptor supporting growth . Further investigation revealed that nitrate is reduced to nitrite (Figure (Figure9A).9A). Although genes coding for nitric oxide and nitrous oxide reductases are present (Rfer_1886 and Rfer_3199, respectively), R. ferrireducens is not a denitrifier, probably due to the absence of a NO-forming nitrite reductase. Approximately 80% of the nitrate was converted to nitrite (Figure (Figure9B),9B), thus failing the criteria that at least 80% of the nitrogen ought to be recovered as gas for an organism to be considered a denitrifier .
R. ferrireducens also contains assimilatory forms of nitrate reductase (Rfer_2559) and nitrite reductase NAD(P)H (Rfer_2557-2558) that allow growth on nitrate without the addition of ammonia, although the growth rate was higher in the ammonia-amended cultures (Figure (Figure9A9A).
The R. ferrireducens model contains reactions that account for nitrate utilization as electron acceptor and nitrogen source. It predicts a 20% faster growth rate if ammonium is added to the medium, in agreement with actual experimental results (Figure (Figure9A9A and and9C).9C). The model also accurately predicted the proportion of nitrate converted to nitrite, ca. 80% (Figure (Figure9B9B and and9D).9D). The rest is likely converted to ammonium, of which 60% is predicted to be assimilated into biomass, probably via glutamine synthetase.
The R. ferrireducens genome contains a cluster of genes related to arsenic metabolism (see Additional file 8). The gene cluster Rfer_3663-3665 encode respectively: a putative arsenite efflux pump; an arsenite-activated ATPase and a arsenate reductase which are likely to be involved in removing arsenic from the cell. However, tolerance to arsenic has yet to be evaluated.
The genome contains two genes, Rfer_2447 and Rfer_2824, which have 30% and 27% identity respectively to the characterized chromate transporter homolog, ChrA, in P. aeruginosa . ChrB (Rfer_2446), on the other hand, is 58% identical to the Cr(VI)-sensing regulator ChrB in Ochrobactrum triciti, an Alphaproteobacteria isolated from chromium-contaminated sludge and able to grow in the presence of high concentrations of chromium [43-45]. A chromate reductase (ChrR) homolog was not evident. The R. ferrireducens genome also encodes a heavy metal efflux pump CzcA (Rfer_0411), which might confer resistance to Cd, Zn and Co . Other genes encoding proteins involved in metal resistance are four putative copper-translocating P-type ATPases (Rfer_0024, Rfer_0418, Rfer_1144 and Rfer_1927) and a periplasmic copper-binding protein (Rfer_3200).
Many organisms have the ability to trigger the production of carbon storage compounds under unfavorable conditions such as limited or inaccessible electron acceptors and/or lack of key nutrients (e.g., nitrogen or sulfate) . Some of these polymers have attractive physical properties that make them relevant for industrial use, particularly in biodegradable materials . Genome analysis indentified three genes well characterized for their involvement in PHA synthesis present in a putative operon in the R. ferrireducens genome: Acetoacetyl-CoA reductase (Rfer_2560), Acetyl-CoA acetyltransferase (Rfer_2561) and PHA synthase (Rfer_2562). Even though production of PHAs has been previously observed in R. ferrireducens , the in silico model does not account for this pathway. It is expected to be included once experimental data are available.
R. ferrireducens is a psychrotolerant organism that can withstand temperatures as low as 4°C, which might confer a competitive advantage in certain environments . Notably, no genes coding for major cold shock proteins (Csp) (as identified by matches above trusted cutoffs to PF00313: cold-shock DNA-binding domain or TIGR02381: cold shock domain protein CspD) could be identified in the R. ferrireducens genome or other members of the Comamonadaceae whose genomes have been sequenced (Polaromonas spp. and Acidovorax sp. JS42). Other members of the Betaproteobacteria for which whole genome sequence is available (from the genera Burkholderias, Azoarcus, Nitrobacter and Ralstonia) possess these Csp homologs. This suggests that other cold shock proteins or other mechanisms for surviving cold shock events have yet to be identified in R. ferrireducens.
R. ferrireducens is a facultative organism and can utilize atmospheric oxygen as a terminal electron acceptor. The genome contains a cytochrome c-oxidase and also several genes coding for enzymes related to the oxidative stress response, such as superoxide dismutase (Rfer_3151) and several alkylhydroxyperoxidases (see Additional file 9).
Examination of the R. ferrireducens genome revealed that this organism has potential to respond to a wide variety of stimuli, with over 30 genes coding for putative sensor histidine kinases, 23 methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins (MCPs) and 32 DNA-binding response regulator elements. The genes coding for sensor proteins and response regulators (possibly two-component systems) are often found in pairs, and at least 47 such pairs were found in the R. ferrireducens genome (see Additional file 10). Homologs of CheA, CheW, CheV and CheY are also present, though the chemotactic behavior of R. ferrireducens is largely unknown.
R. ferrireducens is motile by means of one polar flagellum . Genes coding for flagellin-like proteins have been identified (Rfer_0630 and Rfer_0631) that cluster with genes coding for a flagellar hook-associated protein (Rfer_0632) and for flagellin-specific chaperons FliS and FliT . At least 35 genes are directly (components of the flagellar apparatus) or indirectly (specific chaperones, regulators) related to flagellar motility and are grouped in two clusters in the genome.
A 5.7 kb array of clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) was identified in the chromosome of R. ferrireducens, using the CRISPR Recognition Tool . It has been previously shown in a different bacterial system that new CRISPR spacer sequences derived from phage genomic DNA are added after viral challenge . The presence of these sequences in the host genome was shown to confer phage-resistance, in association with the cas genes. Thus, the CRISPR locus in the chromosome of R. ferrireducens may protect against phage attack. In addition, there is a 1.5 kb CRISPR array in the plasmid, encoding 24 spacer sequences of 32 bp. The CRISPRs in the chromosome and plasmid are 37 bp and 32 bp respectively, and these two loci are associated with separate sets of cas genes. Thus, the plasmid-encoded CRISPR appears independent of the chromosome-encoded CRISPR. Spacer sequences in both loci have no significant matches to entries in the NCBI databases (except to themselves). The results suggest that a significant cache of horizontally transferrable genetic elements which the R. ferrireducens chromosome and plasmid have encountered previously have yet to be sequenced and identified. Alternatively, if the horizontal acquisition of these elements occurred a long time ago in terms of R. ferrireducens evolution and selective pressure to maintain the original sequence is low, these spacer regions may have been ameliorated to such a degree that homology to the original sequence is no longer detectable.
This study demonstrates how genome-scale metabolic modeling, coupled with enhanced genome annotation and laboratory studies, can accelerate the study of the physiology of environmentally relevant, but understudied microorganisms. In relatively short order the understanding of metabolism of R. ferrireducens has advanced from a description of growth characteristics [1,2] to a detailed understanding of metabolism (Figure (Figure10)10) and the ability to predict the growth and metabolism of R. ferrireducens under a diversity of environmental conditions. The genome-scale metabolic model of R. ferrireducens is expected to be a useful tool for studying the role of this microorganism in soils and sediments and its interactions with other microorganisms, such as Geobacter species, that share some physiological characteristics. Furthermore, the genome-scale metabolic model of R. ferrireducens is likely to be a powerful tool for optimizing potential applications of R. ferrireducens such as the bioremediation of contaminants, the production of polymers, and the conversion of organic compounds to electricity.
Rhodoferax ferrireducens strain DMS 15236 (ATCC BAA-621)  was obtained from our laboratory collection. A defined freshwater medium was used to culture and propagate this bacterium . Electron donors were added as follows: acetate 10 mM, lactate 0.1%, glycolate 10 mM, citrate 10 mM, glucose 0.1%, mannose 0.1%, sucrose 0.1%, cellobiose 0.1%. Electron acceptors were added as follows: fumarate 30 mM, ferric citrate 56 mM, Fe(III)NTA 5 mM, nitrate 20 mM.
Rhodoferax ferrireducens cells were collected at stationary phase, centrifuged at 4000 RPM for 15 minutes at 4°C and washed with isotonic buffer . Any remaining liquid was carefully removed with a pipette and the pellets were flash-frozen for storage at -80°C. Cell pellets were subsequently resuspended in 5% SDS and boiled for 10 minutes. Protein concentrations were determined with the bicinchoninic acid (BCA) method using bovine serum albumin as standard . Dry weight was calculated assuming that protein accounts for 55% of the cell mass according to the biomass equation derived from E. coli model . Biomass yield from published acetate and Fe(III) data  was calculated using the value from E. coli (10-12 g/cell).
Growth of fumarate cultures was assessed by measuring optical density at 600 nm with a Genesys 2 spectrophotometer (Spectronic Instruments, Rochester, NY). The organic acid content of the culture medium was determined by high-pressure liquid chromatography (HPLC) using an LC-10AT high-pressure liquid chromatograph (Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan) equipped with an Aminex HPX-87H column (300 by 7.8 mm; Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA). Organic acids were eluted in 8 mM H2SO4 and quantitated with an SPD-10VP UV detector (Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan) set at 215 nm. Nitrate and nitrite concentrations were determined with a Dionex DX-100 ion chromatograph. Fe(II) concentrations were determined with the ferrozine assay as previously described .
The R. ferrireducens genome was originally sequenced and annotated at the DOE Joint Genome Institute (JGI) http://www.jgi.doe.gov/ and assigned GenBank accession number CP000267 and CP000268 for the chromosome and plasmid, respectively. In order to enhance our ability to perform comparative genomic analyses and to generate a more accurate in silico constraints based model, further manual curation of the original genome assembly (chromosome and plasmid) was completed at the J. Craig Venter Institute (JCVI) as indicated in the following description. Results of the manual curation (as well as the original annotation from the JGI) are available at the Comprehensive Microbial Resource http://www.jcvi.org/cms/research/projects/cmr maintained by the JCVI. An initial set of CDSs that likely encode proteins was identified using GLIMMER 3 and those shorter than 90 base pairs (bp) as well as some of those with overlaps eliminated. There are 4451 CDSs that have been predicted on the main chromosome and 319 on the plasmid for a total of 4770 CDSs in the genome. 4333 CDSs from the JCVI annotation mapped to JGI annotation in GenBank. For clarity and ease of access to data, locus tags as assigned by GenBank are used to indicate CDSs referred to specifically in the work presented here unless otherwise indicated. For clarity and ease of access to data, locus tags as assigned by GenBank are used to indicate CDSs referred to specifically in the work presented here unless otherwise indicated.
CDSs were searched against a non-redundant protein database as previously described . Frameshifts and point mutations were detected and corrected where appropriate. Remaining frameshifts and point mutations are considered authentic and corresponding regions were annotated as 'authentic frameshift' or 'authentic point mutation', respectively. The CDS prediction and gene family identifications were completed as follows. Two sets of HMMs were used to determine CDS membership in families and superfamilies. These included 721 HMMs from Pfam v22.0 and 631 HMMs from the TIGR ortholog resource. TMHMM  was used to identify membrane-spanning domains (MSD) in proteins. Manual annotation, included adjustment of start sites, gene names and assignment to putative functional role categories.
Criteria for the identification of cytochrome genes used the Perl script "ps_scan.pl" and 3 Prosite profiles: PS51007 cytochrome c family profile, PS51008 multiheme cytochrome c family profile, and PS51009 cytochrome c class II profile. A gene scoring a low confidence cutoff (level = -1) was qualified as "putative" compared to a gene scoring above the reliable cutoff (level = 0). Additional HMM evidence and matches to a database of experimentally characterized genes maintained in house sometimes provided greater specificity to the corresponding gene name.
All predicted proteins from the R. ferrireducens genome were compared using bidirectional BLASTP to those from all other completed Proteobacterial genomes. Significant BLAST matches were scored for each CDS using cutoffs of 10-5 for the P value, and 70% for the length of the alignment compared to both query and database proteins. CDSs with a top match to another R. ferrireducens protein rather than to a protein in another species were considered candidates for which recent lineage-specific duplication events have occurred.
The R. ferrireducens metabolic network was reconstructed in SimPheny (Genomatica, Inc., CA) by modifying previously published procedures . The annotated genes of the R. ferrireducens genome as well as genes from several high-quality genome-scale metabolic models, including previously published Escherichia coli , Geobacter sulfurreducens , and Bacillus subtilis  models, were utilized for BLASTP sequence similarity search to generate a draft network as a starting point for model reconstruction. Among the base models used, E. coli was the phylogenetically closest to R. ferrireducens and provided about half of all reactions in the draft model, which captured significant portions of central metabolism, biosynthetic pathways for amino acids, nucleotides, and lipids. The reactions and their gene associations in the draft model of R. ferrireducens were evaluated manually based on gene annotations, published biochemical and physiological information, and external references as previously described  The remaining genes were also reviewed for inclusion in the reconstructed network. During this process, reactions and pathways not in the base models were identified, validated, and added into the R. ferrireducens model. A biomass demand reaction based on biomass compositions of the published E. coli model  was used in the R. ferrireducens model (See Additional file 1 for details). Exchange reactions for all extracellular compounds were added. The resulting reconstructed network was then subjected to the gap filling process where gaps were identified and filled manually through simulations to allow biomass formation under physiological growth conditions that include growth with Fe(III)-NTA, nitrate and oxygen as electron acceptors and acetate, propionate, lactate, pyruvate, malate, succinate, benzoate and glucose as electron donors [1,2].
Energy parameters of the metabolic model including GAM, NGAM and proton translocation stoichiometry were estimated as follows. The GAM requirement for the R. ferrireducens model was assumed to be the same as the E. coli model at 59.81 mmol ATP/gdw h  based on their similar biomass compositions. The NGAM requirement and the proton translocation stoichiometry (H+/2e-, number of protons per pair of electrons) for NADH dehydrogenase and cytochrome reductase were estimated by iterating for optimization between in silico-predicted and experimentally determined growth yields. Observed experimental growth rates were all less than 0.04 h-1, so all in silico simulations were constrained with a growth rate less than 0.04 h-1. The experimental data used to determine the energetic parameters were obtained from three independent experiments where R. ferrireducens was cultivated in batch under the following conditions: a) acetate and fumarate, b) citrate and Fe(III), and c) acetate and Fe(III) .
The metabolic capabilities of the R. ferrireducens network were calculated using flux balance analysis and linear optimization  in SimPheny. Biomass synthesis was selected as the objective function to be maximized in growth simulations, and ATP consumption was selected as the objective function to be maximized in energy requirement simulations. The simulations resulted in flux values in units of mmol/gdw h. The following external metabolites were allowed to freely enter and leave the network for simulations of anaerobic growth on minimal media: CO2, H+, H2O, K+, Mg2+, NH4+, phosphate, and sulfate. A minimal amount of oxygen was allowed for biomass component requirements. The electron donors or acceptors tested were allowed a maximum uptake rate into the network of 5 mmol/gdw h or as specified in the results. All other external metabolites were only allowed to leave the system.
AADH: acetaldehyde dehydrogenase; ACAT: acetyl-CoA acetyltransferase; ACKr: acetate kinase; ACL: acetate-CoA ligase; ACONT: aconitase; ADH: aldehyde dehydrogenase; AKGD: 2-oxoglutarate dehydrogenase; ASL: argininosuccinate lyase; AT: acetate transporter; CITL: citrate lyase; CS: citrate synthase; FBP: fructose-1,6-bisphosphate phosphatase; FUM: fumarase; gdw: grams of dry weight; GlyR: glycolate reductase; ICDHy: isocitrate dehydrogenase; ICL: isocitrate lyase; IDH: isocitrate dehydrogenase; LDH: lactate dehydrogenase; MDH: malate dehydrogenase; ME2: malic enzyme (NADP); MS: malate synthase; NAR: nitrate reductase; NTA: nitriloacetic acid; PDH: pyruvate dehydrogenase; PEPC: phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase; PFK: phosphofructokinase; PK: pyruvate kinase; POR: pyruvate oxidoreductase complex; PPDK: pyruvate phosphate dikinase; PTAr: phosphotransacetylase; SCS: succinyl-CoA synthetase; SDH: succinate dehydrogenase; SUCOAS: succinyl-CoA synthetase; SUCD1: succinate dehydrogenase.
CR carried out all the growth and physiology experiments, analyzed the data, drafted part of the manuscript and coordinated the project. JS and OB developed the genome-scale metabolic model. JS completed the in silico simulations, analyzed the experimental data and drafted part of the manuscript. KZ and KM developed the computational algorithm for analyzing the energetic parameters. RD performed comparative genome analyses including evaluations of CRISPRs, conceived and wrote the program for BLAST Curves, and aided in data interpretation. WI performed the analysis of the pathways for the degradation of aromatic compounds. SS, HH, and SK performed manual annotation of the genome. SD performed manual annotation of the genome, completed comparisons between original JGI genome annotation and the improved version used for modeling and produced all files needed as input for modeling. BAM coordinated and contributed to all genome annotation and comparative genomic analyses, interpreted data, conceived ideas and contributed with text for the manuscript. JS, KM, CHS and DRL conceived the study and revised the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
List of reactions, genes and metabolites included in the R. ferrireducens in silico model. This spreadsheet includes a detailed list of all the reactions included in the model: intracelullar reactions, exchange reactions and biomass equation.
Carbohydrate metabolism in R. ferrireducens genome. Spreadsheet listing putative genes related to the transport and metabolism of mannose, fructose and cellobiose.
R. ferrireducens can use cellobiose as electron donor and carbon source. Growth curve of R. ferrireducens on 0.1% cellobiose and 0.5 mM Fe(III)NTA.
Citrate metabolism in R. ferrireducens. Spreadsheet listing putative genes involved in the transport and metabolism of citrate.
Citrate as the sole electron donor and carbon source. Growth curve of R. ferrireducens on 56 mM ferric citrate.
Putative genes involved in aromatic catabolism in R. ferrireducens. Table listing genes in the aerobic "hybrid" and the putative anaerobic pathways of benzoate and other aromatic compounds degradation in R. ferrireducens.
Putative cytochromes c in the R. ferrireducens genome.
Putative genes involved in metal resistance in the R. ferrireducens genome. Spreadsheet listing genes involved in the resistance to arsenite, chromate, copper and heavy metal efflux pumps.
Chemotaxis proteins (Che) and Two-Component systems. Spreadsheet listing genes coding for Che proteins, putative sensor histidine kinases, response regulators and methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins (MCPs).
Oxygen metabolism. Spreadsheet listing putative cytochrome c oxidases as well as genes involved in oxidative stress.
This research was supported by the Office of Science (BER), U. S. Department of Energy, Cooperative Agreement No. DE-FC02-02ER63446.
We thank the Department of Energy Joint Genome Institute for completing and making publicly available the genome sequence and automated annotation that was used as the starting material for further analyses presented in this manuscript.