|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
Assess the ability of label-free multimodal nonlinear optical (NLO) microscopy to characterize, and thus enable quantitative in situ analyses of, different atherosclerotic lesion types, according to the original scheme suggested by the AHA Committee.
Iliac arteries were taken from 24 male Ossabaw pigs divided into lean control and metabolic syndrome groups and were imaged by multimodal NLO microscopy where sum-frequency generation (SFG) and two-photon excitation fluorescence (TPEF) were integrated on a coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering (CARS) microscope platform. Foam cells, lipid deposits, matrices, and fibrous caps were visualized with submicron 3-D resolution. Starting from the adaptive intimal thickening in the initial stage to the fibrous atheroma or mineralization in the advanced stages, lesions were visualized without labels. Histological staining of each lesion confirmed the lesion stages. Lipid and collagen contents were quantitatively analyzed based on the CARS and SFG signals. Lipid accumulation in thickened intima culminated in type IV while the highest collagen deposition was found in Type V lesions. Luminal CARS imaging showed the capability of viewing the location of superficial foam cells that indicate relatively active locus in a lesion artery.
We have demonstrated the capability of CARS-based multimodal NLO microscopy to interrogate different stages of lesion development with subcellular detail to permit quantitative analysis of lipid and collagen contents.
Atherosclerosis, the major cause of cardiovascular diseases, has been a leading contributor to morbidity and mortality in the United States,1 and it has been on the rise globally.2 The statistics that account for the rise in incidence consequently call for new imaging techniques to advance the research and diagnosis of atherosclerosis. Current imaging methods, such as x-ray angiography, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), intravascular ultrasound (IVUS), computed tomography, and optical coherence tomography (OCT) allow exquisite delineation of advanced lesions.3 Notably, MRI can achieve molecular imaging using contrast agents.4, 5 Also, by using spectral analysis to identify lesion components, IVUS can perform virtual histology.6–8 Nonetheless, these techniques have not yet reached submicron resolution. As the gold standard, histology provides high performance in biopsy studies, but it is not feasible for live tissue imaging. In addition, with technical advances, fluorescence microscopy with one- and two-photon excitation has been applied to vascular and atherosclerosis studies5, 9 with the capability of identifying cellular and molecular compositions in vivo with labeling.10 However, these techniques are subject to possible compromises to labeling, such as photobleaching, the requirement for extra incubation, and/or limited circulation lifetime, all of which could be less optimal for arterial studies. Thus, it is intriguing to explore label-free imaging methods which can also provide chemical selectivity and submicron resolution.
Nonlinear optical (NLO) microscopy11 has become a powerful tool for imaging biological samples by its unique advantages of inherent 3-D resolution, near-IR excitation for superior optical penetration12 and lower photodamage. By utilizing endogenous sources of NLO signals, label-free NLO imaging of unstained tissues has been intensively studied, and several examples of label-free imaging methods have been reported. Specifically, two-photon excited fluorescence (TPEF) microscopy has been applied to tissue imaging with intrinsic fluorescence.11, 13 Being sensitive to non-centrosymmetric structures,14 second harmonic generation (SHG), also called frequency doubling, has been utilized for imaging membranes15 and protein fibrils.16–19 Sum frequency generation (SFG)14 derives its signal from non-centrosymmetric molecules at the sum frequency of two excitation sources with imaging capability similar to that of SHG for biological tissues.18 Third harmonic generation (THG) has been demonstrated for imaging of interface heterogeneities20 and lipid bodies.21
Most notably, a third-order NLO imaging technique known as coherent anti-stokes Raman scattering (CARS) microscopy22, 23 has been successfully applied to live tissue imaging with vibrational selectivity.24, 25 To achieve such selectivity, the CARS process involves a pump laser beam at frequency ωp and a Stokes laser beam at frequency ωs. By tuning the beating frequency (ωp–ωs) to be resonant with the symmetric CH2 vibration, CARS shows high sensitivity and selectivity to lipid droplets26 and lipid membranes.27 This unique characteristic makes CARS microscopy an attractive tool for atherosclerosis studies. Prior to the use of CARS for vascular studies, other NLO methods have been utilized to visualize the arterial wall without labeling, but these were limited to viewing collagen and elastic fibril structures.13, 28 Therefore, beyond the fibrils, cells, such as endothelial cells, smooth muscle cells, and foam cells, must be detected by TPEF with the aid of labels.29, 30 Le et al. first applied CARSto visualize lipid-laden cells in atheroma, but utilized an additional femtosecond laser for other NLO modalities.31 By integrating SFG and TPEF on a CARS platform and using the same picosecond laser source, multimodality was obtained with lower cost and lower photodamage potential.32 Using such a setup, it has been shown that the CARS signal from cell membranes and CH2-rich amino acid residues allowed the detection of arterial cells and extracellular protein fibrils in normal arteries without labeling.32
In spite of these advances, it is still unknown whether NLO microscopy can distinguish different types of plaques. In view of the increasing incidence of atherosclerosis leading to cardiovascular disease, it is critical to address this question by developing an NLO-based endoscopy capable of distinguishing different stages of atherosclerotic disease in vivo. In the current study, we demonstrate that CARS-based multimodal NLO imaging could recognize different lesion types based on the scheme of atherosclerosis classification suggested by the American Heart Association (AHA) and modified by other authorities.33–36 Furthermore, we show that the multimodal approach that employs CARS and SFG signals allows quantitation of collagen and lipid contents in lesions from early to advanced stages. As described below, we have used an Ossabaw swine model that closely mimics metabolic syndrome in humans.37
Iliac arteries in the vicinity of the bifurcation of the caudal aorta were collected from 24 male Ossabaw pigs of two diet groups (for details see online data supplement): healthy lean control pigs (n=11) and metabolic syndrome pigs (n=13). Arteries were rinsed with saline and preserved by zinc formalin fixation immediately after harvested. Phosphate buffered saline was used to wash the samples before imaging. The arteries were sliced horizontally (~1mm in thickness) for cross-sectional NLO imaging (Figures IA and IB in online data supplement) and were incised longitudinally for luminal imaging. Serial slices of each artery were collected. NLO and histology images were acquired at the most-affected sector according to the thickening severity, plaque and core size, and/or stenosis condition. The fixation process maintained the integrity of arterial structures, as validated by NLO imaging of the tissues before and after fixation.
Details of our multimodal imaging setup can be found in the online data supplement. In brief, two synchronized 5-ps lasers (Tsunami, Spectra-Physics) operating at 80 MHz repetition rate were parallel-polarized, collinearly combined, and directed into a laser scanning microscope (FV300/IX71, Olympus). Signals were detected by external photomultiplier tubes (PMT, Hamamatsu).
For CARS imaging, the beating frequency was tuned to 2840 cm−1 which matches the symmetric CH2 stretch vibration.22, 24 Bandpass filters (600/65 nm, Ealing Catalog) were used to transmit the CARS signal of ~588 nm. The average powers of the master and slave laser beams at the sample were 40 mW and 20 mW. The same lasers were used to produce the SFG signal of ~393 nm. Two bandpass filters (HQ375/50m-2p, Chroma) were used to transmit the backward SFG signal. For TPEF imaging of non-labeled samples, two bandpass filters (hp520/40m-2p, Chroma) were used to transmit auto-fluorescence. For TPEF imaging of Doxorubicin-labeled samples, two 600/65 nm filters were used. The fluorescence was generated by only using the master laser (~707nm) to avoid the CARS signal.
Artery sections adjacent to those imaged by NLO imaging were immersion-fixed in formalin and routinely processed with paraffin embedding for histological staining.38 A detailed description of staining can be found in the online data supplement. Histology samples were blindly examined by pathologist and co-author, Dr. Ingeborg Langohr, using a Nikon Eclipse E400 microscope (Nikon Corp., Japan) equipped with air objectives and a Spot Insight Camera (Diagnostic Instrument, MI).
Collagen content in the thickened intima of each lesion was calculated according to the SFG signal. By setting a signal threshold of 30 in the 8-bit (255) range, area percentage of collagen in intima was measured. Area percentage of lipid droplet content in the thickened intima was calculated according to the CARS signal. A threshold was used so that the CARS signals from cell membrane and other structures, such as elastin, were not counted (for details see online supplement). Images for quantitative analysis were derived with the use of the 20x air objective. The measurement was conducted at the most-affected sectors within the plaque shoulder of lesions. The ImageJ software was used for the percentage measurement. Data are presented as mean ±SD (P<0.01). One-way ANOVA was used to identify the significant difference among lesion types. P<0.05 was considered significant.
NLO images of the cross-sectional view of iliac arteries were analyzed and classified into different atherosclerotic lesion types according to the scheme suggested by the AHA Committee and modified by other authorities33–36 (Table I in the online data supplement). The NLO images were compared with histological evaluations. Figures 1–5 illustrate multimodal NLO images of atherosclerosis lesions. Images of normal arteries (data not shown) and the early lesions, such as type I and II, were obtained from the 11 lean control pigs. Intermediate to advanced lesions, including types III, IV, V, and VII were derived from the pigs of the metabolic syndrome group. Types VI and VIII were not found in the samples collected for this study. NLO images were representatively demonstrated around the most severe portion of the eccentric plaques or partial media-intima thickening lesions.
Figures 1 and and22 show the representative results of early lesions. In Figures 1A–1C, the stratification of arterial composition is similar to a normal artery except the observation of the adaptive intima thickening with scattered lipid-laden cells viewed by CARS. The adaptive thickening, ordered collagen fibrous tissues, and elastic lamella, which were imaged by CARS, SFG, and TPEF respectively, elucidated the status of the artery as a Type I lesion. In comparison, the histology observations also showed the intimal thickening (Figures 1D–1F) referring to the location of the internal elastic lamina (Figure 1F), which is also in keeping with the observation in Figures 1C and and1G.1G. In addition, the histology images of collagen staining in Figures 1D and and1E1E highly support the SFG signal shown in Figures 1B and and1H.1H. The scattered foam cells specifically identified by CARS31 (Figures 1G–1I, arrows) further confirm the adaptive thickening milieu.35, 36
Figures 2A–2C show the NLO images of the cross-section of a typical Type II lesion. The CARS image (Figure 2A) shows a fatty streak lesion characterized by the accumulation of closely spaced foam cells around the luminal area. This observation compares favorably to the histology images in Figures 2D–2F which also show the thickening milieu. The bubbly and granular scenario in the thickened part, which implies lipid accumulation, agrees with the same lesion viewed in NLO imaging. Moreover, the Masson's trichrome staining in Figure 2F agrees with the collagen distribution in Figures 2B and and2G.2G. Figure 2G shows a smaller collagen deposit in the intima in the proximity of lumen. These conditions match the observation stipulating that collagen secretion is mainly attributed to modified smooth muscle cells.39 Along with the foam cell accumulation (Figures 2G–2I), the adaptive thickening is suggested to associate with pathological thickening and future lesions.40 When CARS imaging of lipids is combined with TPEF imaging of internal elastic lamina, the results show that the foam cells resided inside the intima layer (Figure 2H). The TPEF signal around foam cells and arterial cells is likely attributed to the auto-fluorescence of oxidized-LDL41 and NAD(P)H species.42 Because the TPEF signal from foam cells only minimally contributes to the CARS channel,31 the strong CARS signal from the foam cells specifically shows the distribution of granulated lipid (Figure 2I).
The intermediate lesion of atherosclerosis, which is defined as Type III, contains scattered lipid pools (Figure 3A) in a relatively thicker intima (Figures 3A–3C). Images of histological morphology (Figures 3D–3F) are in agreement with this scenario. The accumulation of interstitial lipid droplets, which can be viewed in CARS imaging (Figures 3A, ,3H,3H, and and3I),3I), has not yet formed a confluent and well-defined lipid core within the thickened intima (as compared to Type IV and V). The disordered collagen fibrils around the lipid pools were detected (Figures 3B and and3H).3H). The randomly distributed lipid droplets underscored the observation of a Type III lesion.
Compared with a Type III lesion, a Type IV lesion, as shown in Figure 4, consists of a well-defined lipid core which renders a strong CARS signal (intense, bright) starting from the shoulder region of the plaque (Figure 4A). Intimal disorganization is obvious in the images (Figures 4A–4C). The lesion episodes and fibril distributions viewed in the NLO images are confirmed by Masson's trichrome (Figures 4D–4E) and H&E staining (Figure 4F). Furthermore, the predominant cellular milieu with abundant foam cells can be viewed at the shoulder (Figures 4A and and4G)4G) and around the luminal regions of the atherosclerotic plaque (Figures 4A and and4H).4H). The foam cells appeared much more circular and densely packed with lipid at this stage (arrows). Doxorubicin labeling (Figure 4I), which is specific to nuclei, highlights the extracellular lipid accumulation within the lipid core viewed by CARS.
Figure 5 shows a typical type V (or Va) lesion. The dense core of lipid and necrotic debris accumulation viewed by CARS (Figure 5A) and the surrounding collagen fibrous cap imaged by SFG (Figure 5B), together with stronger auto-fluorescence viewed by TPEF in the core area (Figure 5C), illustrate a Type V lesion.35, 36 The NLO imaging result is consistent with histology analyses of serial sections shown in Figures 5D–5F. The surrounded collagen cap identified by the Masson's trichrome staining (Figures 5D and and5E)5E) and the light-microscope features of lipid gruel,43 which give the bubbly, granular, and anucleate necrotic debris (Figures 5E and and5F),5F), highly support the NLO imaging results. The location of internal elastic lamina (Figures 5A and and5C)5C) and cell organizations (Figures 5G and and5H)5H) viewed in NLO images are in keeping with the histology observation. The lipid gruel inside the lipid core viewed by CARS (Figure 5I) suggests that the relatively higher TPEF signal in the core area (Figure 5C) probably arose from oxidized-LDL.
In a calcific atheroma classified as Type VII (or Vb),35, 36 the intima-media interface is dominated by mineralization, where no significant NLO signals were obtained (Figure II in the online data supplement). A complex lesion milieu can be observed. Staining by the von Kossa's method confirmed the calcification lesion.
It is established that CARS microscopy permits label-free quantitation of lipid droplets in cells and tissues.26, 44 To validate the SFG signal, we performed a correlation study of collagen content measured by SFG and that by Masson's trichrome staining and obtained a correlation coefficient of ~0.75 (Figure III in the online supplement). Based on the CARS and SFG intensities, we have calculated the lipid and collagen contents in thickened intima of different lesions (see Materials and Methods). The quantitative results are summarized in Table 1. As expected,45 the area percentage of lipid deposition was lower in early-stage lesions than in advanced lesions. The Type IV lesion demonstrated the highest percentage of lipid accumulation (>45% of intima). The lower lipid deposition found in Types V and VII implies the likelihood of retrogression of lipid accumulation and the development of fibrous deposition and mineralization. With respect to collagen content, the type V lesion showed a higher area percentage of collagen (>40% of intima) than earlier stages. Notably, the type IV lesion with a necrotic core and a low degree of fibrosis formation33, 35 showed a lower collagen-to-lipid ratio than early lesions.
We have shown that CARS-based multimodal NLO microscopy is capable of viewing the various pathological components of atherosclerotic lesions and, as such, can act as an in situ histological tool that is free from the labeling requirement of conventional methods. Moreover, based on the CARS and SFG signal intensities, we were able to carry out a quantitative analysis of collagen and lipid deposition in intima of different lesions. Thus, NLO microscopy gives us both a morphological, as well as quantitative, tool by which to characterize lesions and the percentage contents of lipid and collagen, respectively. The importance of this capability arises from the fact that lipid and collagen contents dominate the formation of soft and hard tissues that affect the mechanical properties of atherosclerotic arteries.46, 47 In this context, our results show the potential of NLO microscopy in providing microenvironmental information for mechanical modeling of atherosclerosis.
In this study, we manually stitched images at the most severe location of each lesion because of the limited field of view of NLO microscopy. Imaging the whole cross-section will be very helpful to identify lesions and for quantitative studies. This technical challenge can be overcome by combining laser-scanning with sample scanning on a stepping motor stage.48–50 Photodamage effects in a femtosecond NLO system51 were not observed in our CARS-based NLO system. Instead of femtosecond pulse excitation, we used two 5-ps lasers at 707 nm and 884 nm with 40 mW and 20 mW at sample, respectively. At constant damaging potential, it was demonstrated that signals may even be larger with ps pulses because the exponent of the power law of damage is higher than that of the signal.52
Lilledahl and colleagues recently demonstrated that SHG and TPEF imaging of fibrous caps can be used for identifying vulnerable plaques.51 The vulnerability and tendency to rupture, however, depend not only on the fibrous cap thickness, but also on its superimposition with other complex factors, such as accumulation of lipid and macrophage foam cells, infiltration of inflammatory cells, and secretion of collagen degradation factors.53, 54 By adding the capability of viewing foam cells and lipid deposition, CARS-based multimodal NLO imaging provides a significant improvement for mapping the superficial area of a plaque and assessing its vulnerability to rupture and exposure of the lipid core. Luminal scanning of subendothelial scenario (Figure IV in the online data supplement) could potentially be used for assessing instability or vulnerability. In this work, however, such imaging was restricted by the penetration depth of around 60 μm. Nonetheless, with adaptive optics,55 microprobe objective,56 or longer excitation wavelength,25 the imaging depth could be remarkably increased to hundreds of microns. Since the empirical definition of plaque cap was 60–65 μm in unstable lesion43, 45, 57 and about 25–35 μm in disrupted coronary arteries,43, 45, 58 the improved penetration depth is expected to meet the need for vulnerability studies.
Towards the goal of intravital NLO biopsy, multiphoton fluorescence endoscopy has been reported.59, 60 It is also notable that SHG contrast-enhanced OCT is emerging for in situ cross-sectional imaging.61–63 More recently, the preliminary concept of CARS endoscopy has been proposed.64 An advantage of CARS and SHG imaging is that tissues are not required to undergo slicing, paraffin embedding, or freeze-thaw processes, thus maintaining the potential of intravital imaging. With the capability of quantifying lipid body and collagen fibril contents as shown in the present study, it is foreseeable that a multimodal NLO intravascular catheter with miniaturized probing devices could facilitate and benefit in vivo studies and diagnosis in the years to come.
A multimodal nonlinear optical (NLO) microscope, which integrated CARS, TPEF, and SFG on the same platform, was applied to interrogate atherosclerotic lesions without labels. Early and advanced lesions were distinguished with subcellular resolution and with compositional specificity such that in situ quantitative analyses of lipid and collagen contents could be performed.
The authors cordially thank Thuc Le for the insightful discussion.
Sources of Funding This work was supported by a NIH R01 grant EB007243 to Cheng, NIH grants RR013223 and HL062552 to Sturek, and the Comparative Medicine Program.