To identify autosomal recessive mutants, we have analyzed generation-three offspring mice, in which homozygous deficiency in a particular gene should occur at a 1/16 ratio unless it is embryonic lethal. Among 70 mice in one pedigree, we found 5 mice that had a dramatic reduction in CD4 and CD8 T cells in peripheral blood (Fig. ). This phenotype was observed in both sexes and was confirmed to be heritable by the sib-pair mating of mice of the same phenotype. A slight but significant decrease of peripheral T cells was observed in heterozygous mice (Fig. ), indicating that this gene gives rise to haploinsufficiency.
FIG. 1. Peripheral T cells are reduced in ENU mutant mice. (A) CD4 versus CD8 profiles of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) from a representative 12-week-old ENU-induced mutant and wild-type (WT) mouse. (B) Percentages of total CD3+ cells, CD4 (more ...)
The flow-cytometric analysis of thymocytes from the mutant mice revealed that the number of SP thymocytes, especially the CD4SP cells, was dramatically reduced compared to that of wild-type mice (Fig. ). TCRβ expression levels on DP and SP thymocytes were indistinguishable between wild-type and mutant mice, but the expression of CD5 was lower at the DP stage in mutant mice and remained low at the SP stage (Fig. ). Wild-type SP thymocytes downregulated heat-stable antigen (CD24), reflecting their maturation (2
), whereas the heat-stable antigen levels on mutant SP thymocytes remained high. CD69 expression profiles in wild-type SP thymocytes showed two peaks, the brighter peak representing the cells that have just been positively selected (7
), whereas in mutant mice only one intermediate-intensity peak was seen. These data collectively indicate that the developmental step from the DP to SP stage that accompanies positive selection (16
) is profoundly hampered in the mutant mice. The histological analysis of the thymus revealed that the cortical regions were intact, while the medullary regions were significantly smaller in the mutant mice (Fig. ), consistently with the flow cytometry data showing normal numbers of DP thymocytes and reduced numbers of SP thymocytes (19
FIG. 2. Developmental arrest of SP thymocytes in ENU mutant mice. (A and B) Thymocytes from 8-week-old ENU mice and wild-type (WT) C57BL/6 mice were analyzed for the expression of CD4 and CD8. Representative flow-cytometric profile (A) and proportions of CD4/CD8 (more ...)
The development of NKT cells in thymus was virtually intact in mutant mice, while that of regulatory T cells looked to be slightly affected (Fig. ). Other lineage cells in bone marrow, such as erythroid, myeloid, and B cells, as well as primitive c-kit+ progenitors, were found to be largely normal (Fig. ). Based on these phenotypes, we named this mutation SPOTR (for SP thymocyte reduction).
To determine whether the SPOTR phenotype is cell autonomous, we made bone marrow chimeric mice. Wild-type mice transplanted with bone marrow cells of mutant mice after lethal irradiation exhibited a thymic phenotype similar to that of the SPOTR mice, while the reciprocal transplant had no phenotype (Fig. ). Thus, the SPOTR phenotype is due to a defect in hematopoietic cells. On the other hand, the existing splenic CD4 and CD8 T cells in the mutant mice responded well to CD3/CD28 stimulation (Fig. ), suggesting that the downstream molecules involved in TCR signaling function normally (6
). The reduction of SP thymocytes apparently is not due to accelerated apoptosis, because the proportion of annexin V+
thymocytes was the same in mutant and wild-type mice (data not shown).
FIG. 3. Defect in thymocytes but not in thymic stromal cells is responsible for the phenotype of the SPOTR mice. (A) CD4 versus CD8 profiles of thymocytes from bone marrow chimeric mice. Lethally irradiated SPOTR mice (left) or B6Ly5.1 congenic mice (right) were (more ...)
To identify the mutation responsible for the SPOTR phenotype, we mated mutant homozygous male mice with C3H/HeJ female mice, and after intercrossing the offspring, the phenotype was screened by the flow-cytometric analysis of peripheral blood T cells. As expected, one-fourth of mice (58 out of 238) exhibited low T-cell numbers (<7.24% CD3-positive cells) (Fig. ). Based on genetic linkage analysis using SNP markers (8
), the loci responsible for the SPOTR phenotype were predicted to exist in the region around D10SNP2 on chromosome 10, and further genetic mapping indicated that the responsible mutation is localized within 0.78 Mbp of the D10SNP2 marker (Fig. and ).
FIG. 4. Genetic mapping of the SPOTR mutation by SNP analysis. (A) Half of the genetic mapping results, rearranged in accordance with CD3+ cell proportions in peripheral blood, are shown. With SNP analysis between the C57BL/6J and C3H/HeJ strains, a compatible (more ...)
FIG. 5. Identification of a missense mutation in the SPOTR mouse genome. (A) A total of 254 mice were examined for genetic mapping, and the responsible loci were mapped to the 0.39 centimorgan (cM) region, including D10SNP2 (shown as a red arrow on the magnified (more ...)
Among candidate genes, we focused on two genes located nearest to the center of the 0.78-Mbp region, ptpr
κ (encoding a receptor-like protein tyrosine phosphatase type κ; RPTPκ) and E430004N04Rik
, since corresponding genes in the rat have been reported to be deleted in the LEC (Long-Evans Cinnamon) rat strain (Fig. ). LEC rats are known to have a reduction in CD4 SP T cells in the thymus and periphery, resulting in a defective immune response, a phenotype designated thid
(for T helper immunodeficiency), which is inherited in an autosomal recessive manner (14
). Two independent studies reported that the large genomic deletion that eliminates ptpr
κ and RGD1560849
(the rat analog of E430004N04Rik
) function causes the thid
phenotype. These previous studies proposed that ptpr
κ, rather than RGD1560849
, is responsible for the thid
phenotype based on an in vitro functional analysis of these genes (1
We have sequenced these two genes in SPOTR mice and found a missense mutation in exon 4 of the E430004N04Rik gene, A1779C, resulting in a T512P amino acid substitution (Fig. ). This Thr 512 is well conserved among a broad range of Placentalia species (Fig. ). In contrast, no mutation was detected in the coding region as well as 2 kbp upstream of the first exon of the ptprκ gene (data not shown). These findings suggested that E430004N04Rik is the most likely gene candidate for the SPOTR mutation. In the process of manuscript submission, we noticed that several other groups also have found this gene and named it themis. We decided to use this name.
FIG. 6. themis protein orthologs in various Placentalia species. ClustalW protein alignment of themis protein orthologs between mouse, rat (91% identical to mouse), human (80%), chimpanzee (80%), horse (81%), and cow (75%) (more ...)
κ is broadly expressed on various tissues, including brain, lung, liver, kidney, and ovary (9
), according to the Gene Expression Omnibus profile database, themis
is expressed almost exclusively in T cells in thymus and periphery (18
). We then examined the expression of ptpr
κ and themis
mRNA in mutant and wild-type littermate thymocytes by quantitative RT-PCR. The level of ptpr
κ and themis
message was comparable between mutant and wild-type mice, indicating that mRNA expression/stability was not affected by the SPOTR mutation (Fig. ). However, Themis protein expression was dramatically reduced in SPOTR mouse thymocytes (Fig. ).
Themis protein contains 636 amino acids, but we found no homology to known proteins, and there were no recognizable protein domains that might provide clues to Themis function. Histochemical analysis indicated that Themis protein mainly resides in the cytoplasm and not in the nucleus (Fig. ). Since T512P amino acid substitution results in decreased Themis protein expression, it is probable that this threonine is a key residue that determines the proper folding and/or stability of the protein.
We next generated themis gene-deficient mice by exchanging the coding region of exon 1 with green fluorescent protein (GFP) (Fig. ). By analyzing heterozygotes, we found the prominent upregulation of this gene at the transition from the double-negative to DP stage (Fig. ). The themis expression level looked to be maintained in CD4SP and CD8SP cells in thymus but reduced in peripheral T cells (Fig. ). The homozygous themisgfp/gfp mice had a phenotype very similar to that of the SPOTR mice (Fig. ). Confirming the effectiveness of the themis knockout, Themis protein was completely lost in themisgfp/gfp thymocytes, while in the themis+/gfp thymocytes the protein level was reduced by half (Fig. ). Since ptprk and themis genes are closely linked, it is possible that the deletion of exon 1 of the themis gene exerts some effects on ptprk gene expression. However, in combination with our finding that the SPOTR mice bearing a single point mutation in the themis gene exhibit a quite similar phenotype, it is almost certain that themis itself is essential for SP cell development.
FIG. 7. themis-deficient mice showed a phenotype similar to that of SPOTR mice. (A) themis gene targeting strategy. The coding region of first exon was replaced by GFP and a neomycin (neo) cassette. The open box of exon 1 indicates the 5′ untranslated (more ...)
A decrease in CD4 lineage T cells is a common phenotype seen in LEC rats (14
) and themis
-deficient mice, but a decrease in CD8 T cells is seen only in the themis
-deficient mice. However, since the reduction of CD8 T cells in these mice is not as prominent as the CD4 T-cell defect, it is probable that this phenotype is masked in LEC rats through unknown compensatory mechanisms. We thus presume that the phenotype of themis
-deficient mice as well as that of SPOTR mice is identical to the thid
phenotype in LEC rats. Although ptpr
κ has been proposed as the gene responsible for the thid
phenotype in LEC rats (1
), our data indicate that the deletion of the themis
gene alone can bring about the thid
phenotype. The possibility is not excluded that each of these genes is responsible of CD4 T-cell development; however, whether ptpr
κ really is playing a role in T-cell development remains to be proven by making knockout mice.
In summary, through a forward genetics approach, we have identified a novel gene, themis, that is essential for the development of SP thymocytes. Since themis is a totally unknown gene whose functional domains are unknown so far, further studies of the SPOTR mutation will provide insight into the role of this gene in T-cell development.