To determine whether dystrophin and MTs localize to similar structures in skeletal muscle, we conducted immunofluorescence analysis on teased extensor digitorum longus muscle fibers colabeled with antidystrophin and anti–α-tubulin antibodies (). Dystrophin forms a subsarcolemmal network with transverse components along the I bands and the M line and with longitudinal components (
Williams and Bloch, 1999), whereas MTs form a subsarcolemmal lattice, which in fast fibers, has transverse and longitudinal components plus an accumulation of MTs around myonuclei (
Ralston et al., 1999). We found that the transverse MTs (, arrowheads) weave their course along the I band dystrophin staining for long distances. MTs were also associated with longitudinal lines of dystrophin (, arrows). These data identify domains of the subsarcolemmal cytoskeleton where dystrophin and MTs may interact either directly or indirectly. Next, we examined MT organization in mouse models lacking dystrophin (
mdx), dystrophin's autosomal homologue utrophin (
utrn−/−), or both dystrophin and utrophin (
mdx/
utrn−/−). Consistent with previous results (
Percival et al., 2007), loss of dystrophin resulted in MT disorganization with the costameric MTs appearing to be most severely affected () when compared with wild type (wt; ). Ablation of utrophin had no effect on MT organization (), which is likely a result of its very low expression (
Rybakova et al., 2002) and restriction to the neuromuscular junction (
Ohlendieck et al., 1991). Finally,
mdx/
utrn−/− skeletal muscle exhibited MT disorganization comparable with that of
mdx (). MT organization in 24-d-old prenecrotic
mdx skeletal muscle fibers was also disorganized, whereas age-matched wt mice displayed a MT lattice nearly identical to mature wt mice (). Collectively, these results confirm a role for dystrophin in the stabilization and proper organization of costameric MTs independent of muscle necrosis and regeneration.
Next, we performed a tissue-based MT cosedimentation assay () to determine whether dystrophin cosedimented with MTs. Under conditions that induced MT depolymerization, virtually no muscle protein pelleted (). However, numerous proteins pelleted under MT-stabilizing conditions, and this fraction of proteins represents MTs and the MAPs of skeletal muscle (). We Western blotted each fraction obtained from the tissue cosedimentation assay performed on wt mice expressing full-length dystrophin or transgenic mdx mice expressing Dp260, microdystrophin (ΔR4-23), or Dp71 (, right). Full-length dystrophin, Dp260, and ΔR4-23 all pelleted with MTs, whereas Dp 71 did not (, left). By comparing the dystrophin domains present or absent in each construct (, right) along with each construct's ability to cosediment with MTs, we suggest that spectrinlike repeat 24 through the first third of the WW domain encodes a novel MT-binding domain.
To test for a direct interaction between dystrophin and MTs, we performed MT cosedimentation using two purified recombinant dystrophin constructs and purified tubulin. The two recombinant constructs used were Dp260, which encodes from spectrinlike repeat 10 through the carboxy terminus of dystrophin, including the proposed MT-binding domain, and DysN
Term-R
10 (
Rybakova et al., 2006), which encodes the amino-terminal, tandem CH actin-binding domain and spectrinlike repeats 1–10 of the middle rod domain absent from Dp260. A small amount of Dp260 pelleted in the absence of MTs, but substantially more Dp260 shifted to the pellet fraction when MTs were present (). After subtracting self-pelleting Dp260, Dp260 displayed a concentration-dependent and saturable cosedimentation with a Dp260/α-β tubulin heterodimer stoichiometry of 1:1.4 and a K
d of 0.66 µM (). As predicted, DysN
Term-R
10 did not cosediment with MTs up to concentrations approaching 10 µM (). Next, we assessed how the presence of 1 µM Dp260 affected the tubulin–MT equilibrium in vitro. Dp260 had no significant effect on the fraction of tubulin in the MT fraction when incubated at room temperature (67.3 ± 0.72% vs. 68.6 ± 1.3%). However, the presence of Dp260 significantly increased the fraction of tubulin retained in the MT pellet (33.6 ± 2.9% vs. 42.2 ± 2.0%) when MTs were induced to depolymerize by incubating at 4°C. (). Collectively, these results demonstrate that dystrophin directly binds and stabilizes MTs from cold-induced depolymerization.
Because misregulation of other MAPs can alter tubulin expression and MT stability (
Harada et al., 1994;
Takahashi et al., 2003), we investigated how the loss of dystrophin affects the regulation of tubulin expression and the tubulin–MT equilibrium in skeletal muscle fibers. Tubulin levels in wt and
mdx skeletal muscle extracts were examined by quantitative Western blot analysis. With mAb B512, we observed no difference in α-tubulin expression between wt and
mdx skeletal muscle extracts (), which was consistent with what we (
Prins et al., 2008) and others (
Barton et al., 2002) reported previously. However, mAb DM1A showed an ~2.5-fold increase in α-tubulin expression in
mdx skeletal muscle (). Because levels of α- and β-tubulin are coregulated (
Gonzalez-Garay and Cabral, 1995), we investigated β-tubulin levels to determine whether α-tubulin is up-regulated in
mdx skeletal muscle. β-Tubulin expression was elevated 2.5-fold in
mdx skeletal muscle (), suggesting that expression of both α- and β-tubulin is increased in
mdx skeletal muscle. Thus, we conclude that mAb DM1A is able to recognize a population of α-tubulin not detected by mAb B512. To examine MT stability in
mdx skeletal muscle, we analyzed levels of tyrosinated α-tubulin, a marker of dynamic MTs (
Gundersen et al., 1984,
1987), and acetylated α-tubulin, a marker of long-lived MTs (
Bulinski and Gundersen, 1991). The levels of tyrosinated α-tubulin were increased ~2.5-fold in
mdx extracts (), whereas the levels of acetylated α-tubulin were not (). The loss of dystrophin's MT-stabilizing ability may explain why acetylated α-tubulin was not more abundant in
mdx skeletal muscle extracts, but alterations in the tubulin–MT equilibrium could also explain the lack of more stable MTs. Therefore, we examined the tubulin–MT equilibrium in wt and
mdx skeletal muscles and found that the loss of dystrophin did not affect the equilibrium (). Collectively, these results show that tubulins are misregulated in dystrophin-deficient skeletal muscle without affecting the tubulin–MT equilibrium. The loss of dystrophin's MT-stabilizing ability likely explains why there are not more stabilized MTs even in the presence of more tubulin dimer in dystrophin-deficient skeletal muscle.
An indirect link between dystrophin and MTs mediated by ankyrin-B was recently shown to be important for proper trafficking of dystrophin and β-dystroglycan to the sarcolemma (
Ayalon et al., 2008). However, costameric MTs are disorganized in
mdx skeletal muscle even in the presence of properly localized ankyrin-B (
Ayalon et al., 2008). Because the MT- and ankyrin-B–binding domains of dystrophin do not overlap (), our results and previous results suggest that dystrophin interacts with MTs in vivo through two distinct mechanisms. We propose that ankyrin-B delivers dystrophin to the sarcolemma dependent on MTs and that dystrophin and ankyrin-B collaborate to stabilize and organize MTs in skeletal muscle.
As with other cytolinkers, the ability to bind multiple components of the filamentous cytoskeleton likely allows dystrophin to protect the sarcolemma from mechanically induced damage. One highly truncated microdystrophin construct (ΔR4-23) is very effective in restoring function in the dystrophin-deficient
mdx mouse (
Harper et al., 2002). Interestingly, the ΔR4-23 microdystrophin contains all sequences required for interaction with the three cytoskeletal filament systems: the amino-terminal tandem CH domain, which binds actin (
Way et al., 1992) and cytokeratin filaments (
Stone et al., 2005), the spectrinlike repeat 3 and the cysteine-rich regions, which are necessary for synemin intermediate filament binding (
Bhosle et al., 2006), and the MT-binding domain. In contrast, Dp260 lacks the cytokeratin filament–binding domain and portions of the synemin- and actin-binding domains, which likely alters the binding affinities to both actin and synemin filaments and may explain why transgenic overexpression of Dp260 only partially alleviates the
mdx phenotype (
Warner et al., 2002). Because Dp116 harbors only the MT-binding domain and one of two synemin-binding sequences, an inability to bind cytokeratin filaments and actin filaments likely explains why transgenic overexpression of Dp116 fails to rescue the
mdx phenotype (
Judge et al., 2006). Finally, the mild muscle phenotypes of γ
cyto-actin (
Sonnemann et al., 2006) or keratin 19 knockout mice (
Stone et al., 2007) may be explained by dystrophin's linkage with the remaining components of the cortical cytoskeleton. Collectively, these results support the hypothesis that dystrophin must bind all three components of the cellular cytoskeleton to function properly in skeletal muscle.
Although the dystrophin–MT interaction fits well with the structural/organization functions previously ascribed to dystrophin, the importance of MTs in trafficking of proteins, vesicles, organelles, and mRNAs (for review see
Hirokawa and Noda, 2008;
Gennerich and Vale, 2009) also suggests how MT disruption in
mdx skeletal muscle could contribute to the dystrophic pathophysiology. For example, disorganized MTs are also associated with Golgi mislocalization (
Percival et al., 2007), which in combination, would likely lead to impaired trafficking of membrane-bound proteins and may explain the decreased levels of β-dystroglycan and the sarcoglycans at the sarcolemma of
mdx skeletal muscle (
Ohlendieck and Campbell, 1991). Because no MT knockout mouse has been generated, the exact function of MTs in skeletal muscle remains unknown. However, the importance of MTs in skeletal muscle biology is illustrated by the muscle weakness and increased levels of serum creatine kinase associated with colchicine toxicity in human patients (
Boomershine, 2002;
Caglar et al., 2003;
Wilbur and Makowsky, 2004;
Altman et al., 2007). Therefore, it is possible that derangement of the MT cytoskeleton contributes to some of the phenotypes associated with dystrophin deficiency.