ROS scavengers. As ROS scavengers, catalases may be important for
A. fumigatus hyphal defense (Fig. ). The deletion of the conidium-specific gene
catA or the mycelium-specific catalase gene
cat1 or
cat2 had no effect on virulence in a neutropenic rat model of IA (
101). Although the deletion of
catA resulted in an increased susceptibility to H
2O
2 and neutrophil killing,
catA conidia were killed similarly to the wild type by alveolar macrophages and were fully virulent in a neutropenic animal model of IA (
23). It is possible that
catA is not an efficient scavenger of H
2O
2 and that other scavengers (e.g., melanin or peroxidases) may limit the amount of damage done by macrophages. Regardless, it appears that
catA does not contribute significantly to the overall pathogenesis of
A. fumigatus. The deletion of either mycelial catalase resulted in a wild-type phenotype in vitro and in vivo (
101). When both mycelial catalases were deleted, a slight increase in mycelial sensitivity to H
2O
2 was observed in vitro, and reduced virulence was observed in vivo, suggesting that mycelial catalases offer some amount of protection against neutrophil-mediated hyphal killing (
101).
Some researchers have argued that superoxide and peroxide defenses do not play a significant role in
A. fumigatus pathogenesis in an immunocompromised host. The deletion of Af
yap1, a regulator of oxidative stress response genes, or the deletion of the putative AfYap1 binding partner AfSkn7 resulted in an increased susceptibility of these mutants to H
2O
2 but did not alter their virulence in a neutropenic model of IA (
72,
76,
106). The Af
yap1 mutant was killed to the same extent as the wild type by neutrophils in vitro and was unaffected by the addition of glutathione (a broad inhibitor of reactive oxygen and nitrogen intermediates) (
76). Following challenge with H
2O
2, the Af
yap1 mutant also demonstrated reduced catalase activity compared to that of the wild type (
76). These observations suggested that defense against ROS was not important for pathogenesis. However, it is also possible that the catalase activities are sufficient or higher during incubation with neutrophils or in vivo than following H
2O
2 challenge and able to protect Af
yap1 similarly to the wild type. Cat1 activity was reduced, but not absent, in the Af
yap1 mutant. Considering that the deletion of both mycelial catalases was found to be necessary for the reduced virulence of
A. fumigatus in vivo, this seems to be a plausible hypothesis (
101). Alternatively, other unidentified ROS scavenging abilities could contribute to oxidative defense in the Af
yap1 mutant. Another explanation for the similar virulence attributes of the Af
yap1 mutant and the wild-type strain could be the specific immunosuppression model used. In some neutropenic models, the severity of immunosuppression results in such high susceptibility to
A. fumigatus that minor contributions of fungal components cannot be established. In general, differences among animal models and fungal strains also make it difficult to compare data from many of these studies, as discussed above for gliotoxin mutants. These concerns are not specific to ROS defense and must be addressed by studies of
A. fumigatus pathogenicity. Overall, ROS play a significant role in the host response to
A. fumigatus, although the contribution of specific fungal ROS defenses to pathogenicity must be further investigated.
Secondary metabolites. In addition to melanin, toxins represent a class of secondary metabolites that could contribute to
A. fumigatus pathogenesis (Fig. and Table ). The biosynthesis of secondary metabolites among the aspergilli is quite diverse, and it has been hypothesized that the production of specific secondary metabolites by
A. fumigatus in vivo contributes to its pathogenicity, particularly during hyphal growth. Among the known metabolites, the epipolythiodioxopiperazine toxin gliotoxin is abundantly produced by
A. fumigatus and is the only toxin isolated in vivo from systemic aspergillosis and IA insect and animal models and from sera of patients with IA (
112,
163). The biological activity of gliotoxin is based on an internal disulfide bridge that can bind and inactivate proteins via a sulfide:thiol exchange as well as ROS produced by redox cycling between oxidized and reduced forms of the toxin (
61,
204,
217,
218).
| TABLE 2.A. fumigatus secondary metabolites implicated in pathogenesis |
One study examining the relative production of gliotoxin from clinical isolates of several
Aspergillus species found that almost all
A. fumigatus isolates produced gliotoxin (>95%), compared to other species (
103). Gliotoxin was also produced at the highest concentrations in
A. fumigatus, suggesting a link between gliotoxin production and the pathogenesis of this species. Studies of gliotoxin function in vitro have identified multiple immunosuppressive activities including an inhibition of macrophage phagocytosis, mitogen-activated T-cell proliferation, mast cell activation, and cytotoxic T-cell responses (
60,
139,
146,
188,
231); suppression of immune cell reconstitution following sublethal irradiation (
198); slowing of ciliary beat frequency and induction of epithelial cell damage (
6); and apoptosis induction in lymphocytes, phagocytes, dendritic cells, liver cells, fibroblasts, and cancer cells (
32,
45,
150,
160,
188,
195,
215,
216). Previously reported mechanisms of apoptosis induction include the induction of TNF-mediated cell death, activation of caspase-3 and ROS, inhibition of NF-κB activation, and activation of Bak, which in turn activates ROS production, mitochondrial pore formation, and cell death (
149,
154,
236). Gliotoxin has also been shown to inhibit antigen presentation by monocytes and dendritic cells to effector T cells, limiting the subsequent expansion of an antigen-specific adaptive response. Furthermore, gliotoxin may prevent the formation of the NADPH oxidase complex in neutrophils (
209,
232). Together, these studies reveal the broad nature of gliotoxin immunosuppression by preventing cellular effector functions or inducing cellular apoptosis.
The contribution of gliotoxin in vivo was first characterized by using mutants of two genes involved in gliotoxin biosynthesis, the transcriptional regulator
gliZ and the nonribosomal peptide synthetase
gliP. Mutants of either gene were found to be deficient in gliotoxin production (
25,
47,
103,
186,
197). In a neutropenic murine model of IA, both
gliZ and
gliP mutants were found to be as virulent as wild-type strains despite showing reduced cytotoxicity or cellular inhibitory activity of culture filtrates (
25,
47,
102). However, in cortisone-treated nonneutropenic mouse models, a reduced virulence of
gliP mutant strains compared to that of the wild type was observed (
186,
197). Furthermore, Spikes et al. found reduced neutrophil apoptosis at the site of fungal lesions in
gliP mutant strain-infected mice (
186). Interestingly, supernatants from a
gliZ mutant cultured in vitro induced less PMN apoptosis than did supernatants from a wild-type strain (
25). These analyses suggest that gliotoxin affects the contribution of neutrophils to host defense, likely via the induction of neutrophil apoptosis.
Specific roles for other toxins in the pathogenesis of IA have not been well defined. The deletion of the
res gene to create mutants deficient in the ribonucleotoxin restrictocin did not have an effect on virulence or fungal burden in neutropenic models of IA (
185). However, culture filtrates of restrictocin mutants were unable to suppress neutrophil-mediated hyphal damage, in contrast to filtrates from wild-type strains (
84). Restrictocin may therefore be important under nonneutropenic conditions, but this has yet to be determined. It is possible that, as with other fungal components, the contribution of individual toxins to pathogenesis may be overlooked. In studies supporting the role for multiple toxins in virulence, Bok and Keller identified the first global regulator of secondary metabolite production,
laeA (
26). The deletion of
laeA led to an almost complete loss of secondary metabolite production. Impaired virulence of the
laeA mutant in a neutropenic model of IA correlated with increased uptake by macrophages and reduced killing of neutrophils by live hyphae or culture filtrates (
24). The deletion of
laeA in another pathogenic strain of
A. fumigatus also resulted in reduced gliotoxin production and virulence in a nonneutropenic model of IA (
196). Given that the
laeA, but not the
gliZ, mutant showed reduced virulence in a neutropenic animal model, those authors speculated that other toxins contribute to the pathogenesis of
A. fumigatus. Indeed, microarray analysis of cultures grown in vitro revealed 13 secondary metabolite cluster loci regulated by
laeA, almost all of which (97%) were suppressed under the conditions tested (
157). Furthermore, microarray analysis of wild-type and
laeA strains from murine lung following infection revealed a significant overlap in the regulation of genes, in particular secondary metabolite genes, by
laeA compared to in vitro culture (
129).
Candidate metabolites that may be involved in LaeA-regulated pathogenesis include clavine ergot alkaloids and the product of Af
pes1 (
164). Ergot alkaloids have been detected in conidial extracts of
A. fumigatus as well as in broth cultures (
44,
152,
187). One ergot alkaloid, festuclavine, could interfere with several mammalian regulatory systems via the ability to bind serotonin, dopamine, and α-adrenalin receptors (
151). Although genes regulating the production of clavine ergot alkaloids have been identified for
A. fumigatus (
152,
211,
212), the role of these metabolites in the pathogenesis of IA has yet to be explored. AfPes1 is an atypical nonribosomal peptide synthetase with homology to nonribosomal peptide synthetases that produce siderophores or destruxins (
164). However, since
A. fumigatus produces no known destruxins and Af
pes1 expression is regulated differently than siderophores, the gene product is expected to be a different compound (
145,
164). The deletion of Af
pes1 resulted in altered conidial surface morphology, hydrophobicity, and melanin production; an increased susceptibility to oxidative stress in vitro and killing by human neutrophils; and reduced virulence in a
G. mellonella model of IA. The similarities between the Af
pes1 and
laeA mutants suggest a potential role for the Af
pes1 metabolite in virulence.
Other LaeA-regulated toxins have been implicated in contributing to pathogenicity. Maiya et al. identified a gene cluster responsible for fumitremorgin biosynthesis in
A. fumigatus, yet those authors could not detect fumitremorgin (or its precursors) under reported fumitremorgin-inducing conditions, and the role of this compound in pathogenesis has not been tested (
124). Fumagillin, a potent angiogenesis inhibitor, is a sesquiterpene implicated in IA (
85,
184). This metabolite could alter endothelial cell function associated with hyphal invasion (
118). At high concentrations, fumagillin and the metabolite helvolic acid are cilioinhibitory, as mentioned previously (
96). The genes required for helvolic acid synthesis have recently been identified (
117), which should assist in genetically exploring the role of this metabolite in IA.