In this study we show that the ablation of p53 both profoundly rescues a number of characteristics of the acd phenotype and increases tumorigenesis. These results underscore the importance of p53 activation as a driving force in the development of major characteristics of the adrenocortical dysplasia phenotype. The acd mouse is the first viable animal model that permits analysis of the selective deficiency of an integral part of the shelterin complex. Moreover, acd mice allow for analysis of the contribution of telomere deprotection in the absence of telomere shortening to genetic instability and tumorigenesis. In contrast telomere dysfunction in Terc−/− mice is less defined and only observed after significant telomere shortening following breeding over successive generations. Deprotection versus shortening may underlie the distinct phenotypes of acd mice and Terc−/− mice.
Phenotypic rescue through the ablation of
p53 in the
Acdacd/acd mice was most profound in the skin where hyperpigmention was macroscopically completely absent in
Acdacd/acd p53−/− mice. Two possible scenarios are discussed as the basis for hyperpigmentation in
acd mice. Elevated ACTH and MSH levels in the setting of adrenocortical insufficiency could directly stimulate melanocytes or, alternatively, melanocytes that progressed to senescence could be more active in terms of pigment production. The first possibility seems to be unlikely because mouse models of adrenocortical insufficiency like the
Mc2r−/− (ACTH receptor) mouse do not develop hyperpigmentation (personal communication D. Chida) (
Chida et al., 2007). Furthermore, we were not able to detect significant differences in baseline ACTH and corticosterone levels (data not shown). Overall it seems more likely that skin hyperpigmentation is induced by telomere deprotection and direct activation of p53-sensitive pathways in melanocytes as it has been shown for other mouse models (
Atoyan et al., 2007;
Cui et al., 2007;
Hadshiew et al., 2008;
Khlgatian et al., 2002).
Male germ cells have a very high proliferative rate and therefore, seem to depend more than other tissues on telomere integrity and perhaps telomerase activity (
Hemann et al., 2001;
Lee et al., 1998). We did not observe any rescue of the testicular
Acdacd/acd phenotype through
p53 ablation in
Acdacd/acd animals, which is in contrast to the moderate rescue observed in late generation
Terc−/− p53−/− mice (
Chin et al., 1999). Therefore, it can be hypothesized that unlike other tissues, germ cells do not completely depend on p53-sensitive pathways to induce their removal from the proliferative cell pool. It is also possible that different degrees of severity of telomere dysfunction can induce alternative pathways in an organ-dependent manner. The observation of completely empty SCOS-like tubules adjacent to seminiferous tubules with grossly normal spermatogenesis suggests a developmental defect in
Acdacd/acd mice, as it seems unlikely that the complete germ cell epithelium of some tubules but not others disappears at the same time as the result of postnatal germ cell failure. For a degenerative mechanism in adult life, one would expect random losses of germ cells and an overall reduction of spermatogenesis rather than the observed “all-or-nothing” phenomenon. It is worthwhile mentioning that
TPP1/
ACD expression and telomerase activity are reduced in biopsies of SCOS testes (
Feig et al., 2007;
Schrader et al., 2002).
A main characteristic of the
acd phenotype is cytomegalic adrenal hypolplasia congenita (AHC) which is not observed in late generation
Terc−/− mice (data not shown) and has not been reported for any other mouse model of telomere dysfunction. In this study we show that the adrenal
acd phenotype is caused by the induction of p53-dependent senescence. In the adrenal cortex of
Acdacd/acd p53−/− mice we observe a normalization of organ size and architecture. In humans, cytomegalic AHC is observed in random pediatric or fetal autopsies as well as part of several syndromes. The majority of humans with cytomegalic AHC (with hypogonadotropic hypogonadism) have a germ line mutation in
NR0B1 (
DAX1) (
Achermann et al., 1999;
Zanaria et al., 1994). The emerging role of NR0B1 in embryonic and tumor stem cell physiology suggests that cytomegalic adrenal failure may reflect a common morphological endpoint of stem cell failure and exhaustion of organ maintenance capacity due to a number of causes, including telomere dysfunction (
Kim et al., 2008;
Mendiola et al., 2006;
Niakan et al., 2006).
In summary, ablation of
p53 rescues the
Acdacd/acd phenotype to varying degrees and in an organ-specific manner. The differences of the
Acdacd/acd and the
Terc−/− phenotype and their different rescue by
p53 ablation can be explained by distinct molecular mechanisms induced by either short telomeres or deprotected telomeres. Alternatively, telomere dysfunction induced by deprotection in
Acdacd/acd mice could be more severe than telomere dysfunction induced by telomere shortening in
Terc−/− mice and therefore not as readily rescued by simple
p53 ablation. Indeed, one would expect some telomere deprotection on every telomere in
Acdacd/acd mice due to the severe deficiency in Tpp1/Acd as opposed to
Terc−/− mice, where telomere decapping gradually develops with the loss of telomere sequences, resulting in the inability to bind shelterin components. Furthermore, it would be of interest to investigate potential roles of TPP1/Acd independent of its function in telomere protection. Such functions have been discovered for the protein component of telomerase TERT that participates in telomere-independent stem cell physiology (
Choi et al., 2008;
Sarin et al., 2005).
The onset of tumor development was significantly accelerated in
Acdacd/acd p53−/− and
Acdacd/acd p53+/− mice when compared to their
Acd+/+ p53−/− and Acd+/+ p53+/− littermates, respectively. This underscores the role of telomere dysfunction in the induction of tumorigenesis as it has been described for
Terc−/− mice (
Artandi et al., 2000;
Chin et al., 1999). For the
Acdacd/acd phenotype, the sole driving force for genomic instability can be attributed to the telomere deprotection phenotype (
Else et al., 2007;
Hockemeyer et al., 2007). In contrast to the
Terc−/− mice, no telomere shortening was necessary for tumor development. Though our experiments do not entirely exclude the possibility that a small fraction of telomeres reach a critical short length and dysfunctional state, this possibility seems to be unlikely as we did not observe any differences in telomere length comparing normal tissues from
Acdacd/acd and
Acd+/+ animals. Some degree of telomere shortening was inconsistently observed comparing tumor tissue and normal tissue (liver) from the same animal and was independent of the
Acd genotype. Furthermore, a hallmark of telomere dysfunction in
Terc−/− mice is the presence of chromosomal fusions lacking telomere signals at the fusion site (
Hande et al., 1999). In contrast, we have previously shown that telomere signals are detectable at the non-homologous fusion sites in
Acdacd/acd MEFs (
Else et al., 2007). The lack of significant telomere length differences between
Acdacd/acd and
Acd+/+ animals shows that
Tpp1/
Acd deficiency
in vivo does not lead to average telomere length differences as opposed to reports in human cells where the acute loss of
TPP1/
ACD, or the use of a dominant negative isoform, leads to excessive telomere lengthening (
O’Connor et al., 2006;
Xin et al., 2007;
Ye et al., 2004).
Considering the role of telomeres and telomerase in the telomere-based two step model of carcinogenesis, the
acd mouse is a useful tool to selectively investigate the
in vivo consequences of telomere deprotection (
Artandi and DePinho, 2000;
Cosme-Blanco et al., 2007;
Ju and Rudolph, 2006). Telomere dysfunction is hypothesized to lead to genomic shuffling via BFBs, which contributes to tumorigenesis. Later, the genome becomes stabilized through a telomere maintenance mechanism such as telomerase activity or alternative telomere length maintenance mechanisms (ALT) (
Farazi et al., 2003;
Maser and DePinho, 2002;
Rudolph et al., 2001). Telomere deprotection has been recently suggested to participate in oncogenesis in a variety of human cancers (
Poncet et al., 2008;
Vega et al., 2008). Our studies of the
Acdacd/acd p53−/− mouse model reproduce the genomic alterations proposed by the telomere-based model of carcinogenesis (
Chin et al., 2004;
O’Hagan et al., 2002). The multiple chromosomal amplifications and cytogenic changes observed in
Acdacd/acd tumors together with an increased number of anaphase bridges support BFBs as a main mechanism of ongoing genomic alterations in tumorigenesis. Additionally, we argue that BFB-induced losses of genetic material are also responsible for the increased frequency of loss of the
wt p53 allele in
Acdacd/acd p53+/− vs.
Acd+/+ p53+/− tumors.
The observations of marked senescence in the adrenal cortex of
Acdacd/acd mice and the development of ACC in
Acdacd/acd p53+/− mice, suggests that the escape from senescence may contribute to adrenocortical carcinogenesis. Although ACC is not the main neoplasia (5% of tumors in
Acdacd/acd p53+/−) observed in this study, it is a finding of great importance as there is currently no mouse model that specifically develops ACCs. ACC in humans is a rare disease with a dismal prognosis. Mouse models of telomere dysfunction may be further exploited to study this rare type of cancer and may serve as a useful tool to understand the pathogenesis and pathophysiology of this disease. In humans ACC is one of the syndrome-defining pathologies in Li-Fraumeni syndrome. The specific occurrence of this tumor in
Acdacd/acd p53+/− mice may further suggest a participation of telomere dysfunction in Li-Fraumeni associated carcinogenesis. Indeed it has recently been shown that telomere length correlates with age at tumor onset in patients with Li-Fraumeni (
Tabori et al., 2007).
It has been assumed for a long time that telomere deprotection can provide the basis for generating a pro-cancer genome during tumorigenesis in human tissues. We believe that the acd mouse provides an excellent model for the in vivo dissection of these mechanisms underlying this phenomenon and will increase our understanding of how telomere pathophysiology impacts the origin of tumors in mammalian organisms. Lastly TPP1/ACD and other genes of the shelterin complex may facilitate both our understanding of a genetic basis in patients with dyskeratosis congenital-like heritable cancer syndromes that do not exhibit significant changes in overall telomere length.