|Home | About | Journals | Submit | Contact Us | Français|
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
The mosquito Anopheles gambiae is a major vector of human malaria. Increasing evidence indicates that blood cells (hemocytes) comprise an essential arm of the mosquito innate immune response against both bacteria and malaria parasites. To further characterize the role of hemocytes in mosquito immunity, we undertook the first genome-wide transcriptomic analyses of adult female An. gambiae hemocytes following infection by two species of bacteria and a malaria parasite.
We identified 4047 genes expressed in hemocytes, using An. gambiae genome-wide microarrays. While 279 transcripts were significantly enriched in hemocytes relative to whole adult female mosquitoes, 959 transcripts exhibited immune challenge-related regulation. The global transcriptomic responses of hemocytes to challenge with different species of bacteria and/or different stages of malaria parasite infection revealed discrete, minimally overlapping, pathogen-specific signatures of infection-responsive gene expression; 105 of these represented putative immunity-related genes including anti-Plasmodium factors. Of particular interest was the specific co-regulation of various members of the Imd and JNK immune signaling pathways during malaria parasite invasion of the mosquito midgut epithelium.
Our genome-wide transcriptomic analysis of adult mosquito hemocytes reveals pathogen-specific signatures of gene regulation and identifies several novel candidate genes for future functional studies.
Insect blood cells (hemocytes) play a central role in mediating innate immune responses [1-4]. Hemocytes participate in defense against invading microorganisms either directly through cellular mechanisms like phagocytosis or indirectly through secretion of soluble humoral factors such as antimicrobial peptides, complement-like proteins and components of the proteolytic cascade that regulates melanization [5-12].
Much of our knowledge of insect hemocytes derives from studies with the model insect Drosophila melanogaster and Lepidoptera [13-17], but increasing evidence also implicates hemocytes as being essential to the immune response of mosquitoes including Anopheles gambiae that vectors human malaria [18,19]. In adult mosquitoes, hemocytes mediate phagocytic and/or melanotic immune responses [20-25], and express several immunity-related molecules implicated in defense against bacteria and/or malaria parasites [20-23,25-39]. As a first step in the functional genomic analysis of mosquito hemocytes, we conducted a genome-wide microarray-based transcriptomic profiling of Anopheles gambiae hemocytes in response to infection by bacteria and Plasmodium berghei. We placed particular emphasis on genes with putative functions in the mosquito's immune system.
We used our previously published "high injection/recovery" method to isolate hemocyte samples with little or no contamination by other cell types from adult female mosquitoes . This approach results in recovery of the three types of hemocytes- granulocytes, oenocytoids and prohemocytes – produced by An. gambiae that are distinguished from one another by a combination of morphological, functional, and molecular characters .
We analyzed the transcriptional profiles of hemocytes using custom-made 60-mer oligonucleotide microarrays representing the approximately 13,100 genes of the predictedtranscriptome of An. gambiae .
In order to identify hemocyte-specific and immune-responsive transcripts, we first compared transcripts expressed in hemocytes from one day old sugar-fed mosquitoes to transcripts detected in whole mosquitoes of the same age and feeding status. This resulted in identification of the hemocyte-enriched transcriptome. We then compared hemocytes from 1 day old mosquitoes, 1 hour after immune challenge with heat-killed Escherichia coli or Micrococcus luteus, to control female mosquitoes injected with sterile PBS to determine the bacteria challenge responsive transcriptomes. We used heat-killed bacteria in these assays, because our primary interest was in identifying the bacterial responsive transcriptome and to avoid the potentially confounding effects of altered gene expression due to the lethal effects of a systemic infection associated with injection of living bacteria. Lastly, we compared hemocytes from mosquitoes at 24 hours and 19 days after ingestion of a blood meal infected with Plasmodium berghei to mosquitoes of the same age fed a non-infected blood meal to determine the ookinete and sporozoite infection responsive transcriptomes, respectively. This design resulted in a total of five experimental treatments.
Overall, we detected a total of 4047 genes expressed in hemocytes expressed in at least one of the experimental treatments (Figure (Figure1a;1a; Additional file 1). Only 562 (13.9%) transcripts were detected in all experimental treatments, but 2205 (54.5%) transcripts were identified in at least two of the treatments performed. We observed some variability in detectable transcript levels between the different experimental treatments that most likely reflected differences in age, infection state or other physiological factors (i.e. sugar- versus blood-fed) (see below).
Comparing gene expression between hemocytes and whole adult female mosquitoes, we identified 279 gene transcripts with at least a 2 – fold higher presence and 266 genes with a lower abundance in hemocytes compared to whole adult female mosquitoes (Figure (Figure1b,1b, Additional file 1). Only 54.5% of the hemocyte enriched transcripts had predicted functions and these are discussed in Additional file 2, data section S1.
We identified expression of 182 (54.3%) of the 335 predicted immunity-related genes in at least one of our five experimental comparisons, reinforcing the major role of hemocytes in immune defense [41,42]. Importantly and consistent with previous studies, we detected transcription of all 11 immunity-related genes previously reported to be expressed in An. gambiae hemocytes. These genes are presented in the Additional file 2, data section S2. Contrary to expectation, however, only 9 of the 279 transcripts with higher abundance in hemocytes versus whole mosquitoes and 14 of the 266 transcripts with lower abundance were immunity-related genes. These genes are presented in detail in the Additional file 2, data section S3.
Among the pattern recognition receptors expressed in hemocytes, FBNs, PGRPs, TEP and TOLL family members were especially well represented. In contrast, relatively fewer C-type lectins (CTLs), galectins, Gram-negative binding proteins (GNBPs) and CD36-like scavenger receptors (SCRs) were transcribed in hemocytes. Seventeen members of the leucine rich repeat (LRR) family were transcribed in hemocytes, including two of the three previously reported to mediate anti-Plasmodium immune responses (LRIM and LRRD7 [APL2]) [43-45]. We also detected transcription of several members of the recently characterized Nimrod superfamily, including putative homologues of Eater and NimC-1  that are expressed in hemocytes from Drosophila melanogaser and that are involved in phagocytosis of bacteria and apoptotic cells . As many as 27 CLIP-domain serine proteases, 11 of their associated serpin inhibitors [47,48], and 8 putative target PPO zymogens were also expressed in hemocytes [49,50]. All of these factors have been predicted or are experimentally implicated in melanization reactions that occur in response to infection by bacteria and Plasmodium [28,51]. Thirty-four other genes predicted to encode serine proteases were also transcribed in hemocytes, of which 13 were enriched in hemocytes and/or exhibited differential expression following microbial exposure.
In addition to canonical immunity-related genes, we detected several gene transcripts in hemocytes belonging to the cytoskeletal/structural functional class that have conserved roles in phagocytosis [52,53]. These genes were dominated by factors involved in the biogenesis and organization/rearrangement of the actin cytoskeleton, and included 5 components of the Arp2/3 actin-nucleation complex; 3 vesicle trafficking ADP-ribosylation factors (ARFs); cofilin; various members of the Rho, Rac and Rab families of small GTPases (including rho1/L, rac1/2, cdc42, Rab5, and several SNAREs); and several WASP family members (including SCAR) [54-56].
Comparison of our microarray expression data to EST data from bacteria-challenged hemocytes of the mosquitoes Aedes aegypti and Armigeres subalbatus  revealed a relatively high degree of conservation in gene transcripts associated with pathogen recognition and humoral immune responses. Conservation of hemocyte-specific transcript expression between the three mosquito species was particularly high for the following groups of immunity-related genes: antimicrobial peptides (8 of 8 expressed in An. gambiae); PRRs (9 of 9); CLIP-domain serine proteases and their serpin inhibitors (15 of 17); melanization (6 of 7); antioxidant-related (12 of 14); and apoptosis-related (14 of 17). In contrast, there was lower concordance between the three mosquito species in gene transcripts associated with functions related to the cytoskeleton (12 of 32), signal transduction (22 of 36) and stress responses (7 of 16). We also compared our microarray expression data to transcriptional profiles for hemocytes from larval stage D. melanogaster [15,16]. This analysis suggested relatively weak conservation in hemocyte gene expression (data not shown) which may reflect differences in hemocytes from different developmental stages (adults versus larvae) and the apparent absence in mosquitoes of orthologs for many hemocyte-specific Drosophila genes (data not shown).
As previously noted, An. gambiae produces three hemocyte types with granulocytes accounting for greater than 90% of the total number of cells in circulation during the larval, pupal and adult stage . In adults, however, the total number of hemocytes in circulation declines with mosquito age while blood feeding stimulates a transient increase in circulating hemocytes . We reasoned that infection could also affect hemocyte abundance, which together with age or blood feeding could create variation in microarray expression ratios unrelated to differential gene regulation per se between control and microbe-exposed mosquitoes. To facilitate interpretation of our transcriptome data, therefore, we assessed the effects of microbial challenge on hemocyte abundance in An. gambiae relative to non-infected controls. Sample analysis 24 h post-infection revealed no significant differences in the total number of hemocytes in circulation (F2,29 = 2.09; P = 0.14) or in the number of granulocytes (F2,29 = 2.95; P = 0.07) and prohemocytes (F2,29 = 1.30; P = 0.29) between mosquitoes injected with E. coli, M. luteus or PBS (control) (Figure (Figure2a).2a). However, injection of M. luteus did induce a significant increase in the number of oenocytoids (F2,29 = 18.78; P < 0.0001) (Fig. (Fig.2a);2a); an alteration that resulted in this hemocyte type comprising 12% of the total number of cells in circulation in M. luteus-challenged mosquitoes compared to 7% and 5% for E. coli-infected mosquitoes and PBS controls.
We infected mosquitoes with P. berghei by blood feeding 4 day old mosquitoes and then collecting samples 24 h or 19 days later. At the 24 h time point, parasites were in the ookinete stage in the midgut epithelium of the mosquito while at day 19 parasites were in the sporozoite stage and were detected in the salivary glands. Controls consisted of hemocytes collected from 4 day old, non-blood fed mosquitoes, and hemocytes collected 24 h and 19 days after mosquitoes fed on a non-infected bloodmeal. Consistent with previous results , the total number of hemocytes in circulation significantly differed among treatments (F4,49 = 45.86; P < 0.0001) with 24 h post-blood fed mosquitoes having more hemocytes in circulation than day 4 non-blood fed mosquitoes or day 19 post-blood feeding mosquitoes (Figure (Figure2b).2b). However, no significant differences were detected in the total number of hemocytes and hemocyte types in circulation between infected and control mosquitoes at 24 h or 19 days. Taken together, these results indicate that variation in hemocyte abundance likely affects transcript levels among the five experimental treatments we performed. Within a given treatment, however, the lack of differences in hemocyte abundance between experimental and control samples indicates that any differences in microarray expression ratios reflect differential gene expression in response to the pathogen.
This finding is important because global transcriptomic profiles revealed a remarkable degree of specificity with regard to pathogen and stage of immune challenge. Of the 4047 hemocyte transcripts detected in hemocytes, 959 (23.7%) exhibited differential regulation in at least one of the 4 experimental comparisons involving challenge by bacteria or P. berghei (Figure 1b–d; Additional file 1). Among these differentially expressed transcripts, immunity-related genes were significantly over-represented compared to the genes belonging to other functional classes (χ2 = 27.11, P < 0.0001). While immunity-related genes comprised only 6.1% (247/4047) of all genes expressed in hemocytes, 10.9% (105/959) of differentially regulated transcripts belonged to this functional class. In contrast, the replication/transcription/translation functional class was significantly under-represented in the group of differentially expressed genes (χ2 = 14.19, P = 0.0002), presumably indicative of the house-keeping function of many of the genes in this category. The percentage of differentially regulated transcripts was not significantly different from that expected under the assumption of no association between functional class and differential regulation upon challenge for the remaining 7 functional classes of genes (χ2 = 5.49, P = 0.356).
Further insight into the role of different functional classes of genes was provided by calculating the percentage of differentially expressed transcripts within each functional class for different microbial exposures (Figure (Figure3).3). This analysis highlighted variation in the overall levels of differential gene transcription among treatments and pathogen-specific functional class responses. For example, in hemocytes from mosquitoes challenged with E. coli, the cytoskeletal/structural class was significantly over-represented in the group of differentially regulated genes compared to other functional classes (χ2 = 8.32, P = 0.0039), while immunity-related genes were not. This likely reflects an important role for phagocytosis and hemocyte migration in defense against bacteria (χ2 = 0.63, P = 0.298). In contrast, hemocytes from mosquitoes infected P. berghei exhibited an under-representation of redox and oxidoreductive stress class genes at 24 h post-infection (i.e. day 5) (χ2 = 3.87, P = 0.049). A relatively high percentage of genes belonging to the proteolysis class were also differentially regulated although this difference was not statistically significant (χ2 = 1.30, P = 0.255 for 24 hours post-infection and χ2 = 0.78, P = 0.377 for 19 days p.i.).
Challenge with either heat-killed E. coli or M. luteus resulted in the differential regulation of 641 transcripts (Figure 1b, c; Additional file 1), while only 44 transcripts (6.9%) exhibited similar regulation upon challenge with both elicitors. Challenge with M. luteus regulated 3.8 times more genes compared to challenge with E. coli: 543 genes were differentially regulated by M. luteus, while only 143 were regulated by E. coli. The percentage of expressed genes differentially regulated was also much greater for M. luteus than for challenge with E. coli (21.4% versus 7.2% of transcribed genes, respectively). This difference in gene regulation was primarily due to a lack of transcriptional up-regulation following challenge with E. coli: only 17 genes were induced by this bacterial species compared to 334 by M. luteus.
In total, 52 immunity-related genes exhibited significantly different transcription following bacterial challenge. Thirteen and 44 immunity-related genes, respectively, were differentially transcribed following challenge with either E. coli or M. luteus (5 and 17 up- and 8 and 27 down-regulated). Only 4 (7.7%) genes differentially transcribed following bacterial challenge were comparably regulated by E. coli and M. luteus, and these are discussed in a greater detail in the Additional file 3, data section S4 (Figure 1b, c; Additional file 1). M. luteus challenge resulted in the up-regulation of 5 genes previously identified during an in vivo screen for factors in An. gambiae associated with phagocytosis: cactus, CED6L, PGRPLA, PGRPLC and TEP3 . For more details on this expression signature see Additional file 2, data section S5. Four genes encoding protein products with putative roles in melanization were transcriptionally up-regulated in hemocytes following bacterial challenge, and are discussed in Additional file 2, data section S6. A number of other genes belonging to diverse functional classes and previously implicated in phagocytosis [54-59] were also differentially regulated upon bacterial challenge and most of them showed distinct patterns of transcriptional regulation for the two bacterial species and are discussed in a greater detail in the Additional file 2, data section S7.
Previous studies with the mosquitoes Anopheles albimanus, Aedes aegypti and Armigeres subalbatus suggest that E. coli is primarily phagocytosed by hemocytes, while Micrococcus spp. are melanized extracellularly within the hemolymph [20-22]. Our own results (see above) noted a significant increase in the abundance of oenocytoids, which constitutively express phenoloxidase activity, following infection by M. luteus. Prior studies with An. gambiae in contrast indicate that granulocytes are the only hemocytes that phagocytize foreign targets and also inducibly express phenoloxidase activity following immune challenge by bacteria . We therefore characterized phagocytosis and melanization toward E. coli or M. luteus in An. gambiae to assess whether: 1) oenocytoids and granulocytes differentially respond to these two bacterial species and 2) whether this response is qualitatively consistent with transcriptomic profiles. Phagocytosis assays revealed that significantly more granulocytes phagocitized E. coli than M. luteus (t-test; P < 0.01) (Figure (Figure2c).2c). However, we also noted that a higher proportion of granulocytes with internalized M. luteus contained bacteria that were melanized compared to granulocytes with internalized E. coli (t-test; P < 0.01) (Figure (Figure2d).2d). Although oenocytoids cannot phagocytize bacteria, challenge with M. luteus also induced a significantly greater proportion of these hemocytes to melanize than E. coli (t-test; P < 0.01) (Figure (Figure2e).2e). These results indicate that similar to other mosquitoes, M. luteus induces a much stronger melanization response than E. coli in An. gambiae, even though granulocytes phagocytize both species of bacteria. Although broadly consistent with the up-regulation of phagocytosis and melanization-related genes following M. luteus challenge, these results also do not explain why so few genes with phagocytic or immune functions are up-regulated by E. coli.
During the two major spatial transition stages of infection by Plasmodium sp., ookinete invasion of the midgut and sporozoite migration through the hemolymph, the parasite experiences considerable loss of abundance in An. gambiae [60,61] that is in part attributed to hemocyte-mediated immune responses [28,32]. Overall, transcripts of 431 genes were differentially expressed in hemocytes during malaria parasite infection (either at 24 hours and/or 19 days after P. berghei infection) (Figure (Figure1b1b and and1d;1d; Additional file 1). When considered relative to the total number of expressed genes, the magnitude of gene regulation was similar for the two different stages of malaria parasite infection (12.1 versus 11.0% of transcribed genes were differentially expressed, respectively, at 24 hours and19 days after P. berghei infection). Strikingly, only 23 (5.3%) of the differentially regulated transcripts had similar expression profiles during the two infection stages, while 16 (3.7%) transcripts were expressed in opposite directions. The remaining 392 (91.0%) transcripts were differentially expressed exclusively during one of the two stages of parasite infection. Only 5 (6.8%) of the 74 putative immune genes were regulated in the same direction while 7 (9.5%) transcripts were regulated in opposite directions at 24 hours and 19 days after P. berghei infection.
At 24 hours after infection with P. berghei, 293 genes exhibited differential transcription in hemocytes, with 137 being up-regulated and 156 down-regulated (Figure (Figure1b1b and and1d;1d; Additional file 1). This included 42 immunity-related genes, and 3 other genes involved in lipid transport which are of particular interest because of their previously reported effects on malaria parasite infection; the retinoid and fatty-acid binding glycoprotein (RFABG), which encodes apolipophorins I and II of the insect lipid transporter ; apolipophorin III ; and an apolipoprotein D (ApoD; ENSANGT00000010586). RFABG transcription has previously been reported to be induced in the midgut epithelium during P. berghei ookinete invasion, and RNAi-mediated silencing of this gene significantly increases malaria parasite infection . Another immune-responsive ApoD (ENSANGT00000028106), which was also expressed in hemocytes, is necessary for antibacterial and defense against at least some species of Plasmodium [64,65].
Although transcribed in hemocytes, we did not detect differential transcription of the majority of PRRs previously implicated in immune responses against Plasmodium sp.: AgMDL1, CTL4, CTLMA2, LRIM1, LRRD7 (APL2), LRRD19 (APL1), and TEP1 [28,51,64,66]. This was especially surprising for CLT4, LRIM1 and TEP1, which are known to be induced 24 hours after P. berghei infection [28,32,51]. However, transcripts encoding the PPRs FBN9 and DSCAM, which have are also implicated in defense against P. berghei and the human malaria parasite P. falciparum [64,67], were significantly up-regulated (data not shown).
Four members of the Imd/REL2 pathway were up-regulated (IAP2, TAK1, IKK2 and REL2), and one member was down-regulated (Imd). The Imd/REL2 pathway has previously been reported to limit P. berghei oocyst infection in An. gambiae , although others have been unable to replicate this finding . In Drosophila, cross-regulation between the Imd/Relish and JNK signaling pathways is well-established [43-45,69-71] (This expression signature is discussed in detail in Additional file 2, data section S8). Nine genes encoding factors predicted to belong to the proteolytic cascades regulating melanization were differentially transcribed in hemocytes 24 hours after P. berghei infection and included serine proteases and their serpin inhibitors (Additional file 1). (This expression signature is discussed in detail in Additional file 2, data section S9). Four other factors with known or putative roles in melanization defense reactions were differentially transcribed in hemocytes during the period of ookinete invasion of the midgut epithelium. LYSC1 was significantly down-regulated in hemocytes at both 24 hours and 19 days after P. berghei infection, as well as following challenge with M. luteus. LYSC1 has previously been reported to be induced by bacterial challenge , and to inhibit melanization of Sephadex beads through interfering with PO activity . Three enzymes implicated in melanogenesis were transcriptionally up-regulated, including: phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH; also known as phenylalanine 4-monooxygenase, EC 22.214.171.124), tryptophan 2,3-dioxygenase (TO; EC 126.96.36.199) and dopamine N-acetyltransferase (DAT; EC 188.8.131.52). [72,74-77]. The expression of TO in hemocytes, and its significant differential expression during both ookinete invasion of the midgut epithelium and following challenge with M. luteus suggest a role for TO in melanotic defense reactions. DAT has not previously been implicated in insect melanization reactions, but its substrate dopamine is an intermediate in melanin production suggesting a potential role in the biochemical pathways mediating melanization.
At 19 days after P. berghei infection, 177 genes were differentially transcribed in hemocytes, of which 81 were up-regulated and 96 were down-regulated (Figure 1b, d; Additional file 1). This included 43 immunity-related genes of which 28 were repressed and 15 were induced. Notably, 16 (37.2%) of the immunity-related genes differentially regulated during sporozoite migration through the hemolymph belonged to the FBN family of immunolectins: 9 FBNs were down-regulated, while 7 uncharacterized FBNs were up-regulated. The role of FBNs in anti-sporozoite defense has not been investigated, but the discrete patterns of FBN expression observed at 24 hours and 19 days after P. berghei infection suggests that distinct FBN subsets are involved in mosquito immune responses to ookinetes and sporozoites. The remaining 8 immunity-related genes transcriptionally up-regulated during the period of sporozoite presence in the hemolymph were: the putative MD-2-like lipid-receptor AgMDL13, TEP3, the An. gambiae ortholog of the Drosophila scavenger receptor croquemort (SCRBQ2), the CLIP-domain serine proteases CLIPB8 and CLIPB13, the serpins SRPN9 and SRPN17, and a thioredoxin peroxidase (TPX4). The role of these factors in infection by Plasmodium sp. has not been investigated, except for CLIPB8 which has been shown to promote melanization of ookinetes during invasion of the midgut epithelium and foreign bodies such as Sephadex beads inoculated into the thorax [78,79]. CLIPB8, CLIPB13, SRPN9 and CLIPA12, are all specifically regulated by sporozoite infection and it is tempting to speculate that are part of a common mechanism.
The 19 immunity-related genes exhibiting significant down-regulation during sporozoite migration through the hemolymph included 5 pattern recognition receptors: 9 antimicrobial effectors, and four prophenoloxidases (Additional file 1). The down-regulation of PPOs associated with sporozoite migration through the hemolymph may represent a host homeostatic mechanism to prevent "toxic shock" following the massive release of these parasite stages into the hemocoel. The remaining immunity-related genes exhibiting significant down-regulation were various and disparate components of the major immunity-related signaling pathways (Additional file 1).
Other notable genes significantly up-regulated during sporozoite passage through the hemolymph included several implicated in phagocytosis (the p41 subunit of the Arp2/3 complex, gelsolin and troponin C) and redox metabolism (a cytochrome P450 and a glutathione S transferase). Additionally, the transcript of an uncharacterized gene (ENSANGT00000032065), encoding a domain with homology to mammalian β-defensin, was significantly up-regulated in hemocytes at day 19 after P. berghei infection. The Drosophila homolog of this gene has previously been reported to be up-regulated in oncogenic larval hemocytes , and it possibly represents a novel antimicrobial peptide induced by, and with activity against, sporozoites.
We have identified 4047 genes expressed in adult female An. gambiae hemocytes, including 959 genes that were differentially expressed following bacterial challenge and/or malaria parasite infection. A dominant proportion of these regulated genes was represented by 105 recognized immunity-related genes, of which many have known or putative roles in defense against P. berghei and other species of Plasmodium. This pattern is fully consistent with hemocytes having an important role in regulating mosquito innate immune responses. Transcriptomic profiling of An. gambiae hemocytes following exposures to various microbes also revealed distinct transcriptomes in response to different species of pathogen and at different stages of infection with the same pathogen. A closer examination of these differential transcriptome signatures provided numerous insights to potentially important functional attributes of hemocyte -mediated defenses. For example, the profound transcriptional response upon challenge with M. luteus and the much weaker and mainly down-regulated gene response after E. coli challenge, taken together with the reported higher virulence of E. coli to An. gambiae, suggests that the potency of the immune response activated by these two bacterial species is quite different [27,81].
The distinct transcriptional profiles associated with the two different stages of the malaria parasite infection likely reflects differences in where parasites are located within the mosquito, antigenic differences between ookinetes and sporozoites, and/or temporal differences associated with blood-feeding or age of the mosquito hosts [20,21,60,82]. Of particular interest was the co-regulation in hemocytes of different members of the Imd/REL2 and JNK immune signaling pathways, together with various components of HAT/HDAC multiprotein complexes that regulate immune gene expression through modification of chromatin structure. These gene expression signatures are discussed in Additional file 2, data section S8. The lack of a transcripional phagocytic response to sporozoite infection is in agreement with the recent finding that the rapid disappearance of P. berghei sporozoites from the hemolymph of An. gambiae apparently results from currently uncharacterized, non-phagocytic and humoral immune mechanisms [20,21,35,61]. Finally, the transcriptomic profiles of hemocytes described in our study revealed that several factors known to influence Plasmodium infection are not only induced in the midgut epithelium during ookinete invasion but are also simultaneously up-regulated in hemocytes (e.g. CLIPB4, CLIPB17, SRPN6, and RFABG) [29,62,79]. This observation raises questions about the site of action of these immunity-related factors, and whether these molecules have similar or different functions in different tissues. Future challenges, therefore, will be to dissect the contribution of differential gene expression in hemocytes in defense against different species of Plasmodium, and to investigate the functional significance of the many novel candidate immunity-related and other genes, identified in this study.
All experiments were conducted using the G3 strain of An. gambiae reared as previously outlined .
Phagocytosis assays were performed as previously described . Briefly, 2 × 103 heat-killed. fluoresceing isothiocyanate (FITC)-conugated E. coli or M. luteus were injected intrathoracically into cold anethetized mosquitoes. After 1 h at room temperature, hemocytes were collected, placed into primary culture, and identified as outlined by Castillo et al (2006) . Briefly, granulocytes were identified by their spread morphology, oenocytoids were identified by morphology, differential labeling with monochlorobimane (MCB) and an anti-phenoloxidase antibody (PP06, generously donated by K. Michel and F. Kafatos), and prohemocytes were identified by morphology and an absence of labeling by MCB and the anti-PO antibody. The proportion of granulocytes that had ingested particles was determined by counting 100 cells in a randomly selected field of view using the fluorescent quenching method . Melanization was quantified by counting hemocyte-internalized bacteria. The proportion of oenocytoids and granulocytes that had melanized without ingesting any bacteria was also determined by visual inspection. We infected mosquitoes with malaria parasites by allowing 4 day-old adult females to feed on a BALB C mouse infected with the PbGFPCON strain of P. berghei, which constitutively expresses green fluorescent protein (GFP) under control of the P. berghei elongation factor 1α promoter . A Plasmodium berghei reference line that constitutively expresses GFP at a high level throughout the complete life cycle. Molecular and Biochemical Parasitology [137, [23-33]]. Only mice exhibiting 3–5% parasitemia were used for infection of mosquitoes. Hemocytes were collected either 24 hours or 19 days after blood-feeding. All cohorts of infected mosquitoes were also monitored by dissection to determine levels of midgut infection by oocysts at 24 h and infection of salivary glands by sporozoites on day 19. Only cohorts in which ≥ 80% of individuals were infected were used for analysis. Controls included day 4 mosquitoes with no bleed feeding and mosquitoes blood-fed on uninfected mice. All data were analyzed by ANOVA followed by Dunnetts comparison procedure or t-test using the JMP 7.0 statistical platform (SAS, Gary, NC). Proportional data were arcsin transformed before analysis.
Hemocyte samples from bacteria-infected, P. berghei-infected and control mosquitoes were prepared and collected as described above. A minimum of 30 individuals were bled and their hemocytes pooled to obtain at least 500 ng of total RNA per replicate. However, for the day 19 post-blood feeding samples, more than 100 mosquitoes were bled per sample due to the reduced number of hemocytes present per individual (see Results). Total RNAs were then isolated from hemocytes using the RNAEasy kit (Qiagen) as outlined by the manufacturer. For each treatment and time point, three independent samples were prepared for use in subsequent microarray and QRT-PCR analyses.
300–400 ng of total RNA was used to synthesize Cy-3 or Cy-5 fluorochrome-labeled cRNA probes for each hemocyte or whole adult female sample using Agilent's Low RNA Input Linear Amplification Kit (Cat. No. 5184-3523; Agilent Technologies, Inc., Wilmington, DE) according to the manufacturer's instructions. Two-color microarray hybridizations were performed using Agilent's In situ Hybridization Kit Plus (Cat. No. 5184-3568) and custom-made 60-mer oligonucleotide microarrays purchased from Agilent as previously reported . Arrays were hybridized for 16 hours, washed, dried with pressurized air and immediately scanned using an Axon 4200AL scanner and GenePix Pro (version 6.0) software (Axon Instruments, Union City, CA). Scanned microarray images were aligned to annotation files and flagged for bad spots in GenePix Pro, using a combination of automatic and manual curation. For our analysis, good spots were defined as expressed if the mean foreground intensity of the spot was at least three standard deviations above the mean local background signal for the same spot. ExpressConverter (version 1.7), MIDAS (version 2.19) and MeV (version 4.0) packages of the TIGR TM4 microarray software suite  were used for subsequent downstream analyses of the processed output from GenePix Pro. The array data were normalized with LOWESS and graphically explored using the MIDAS package , while significantly differentially expressed transcripts were identified using the significance analysis of microarrays (SAM)  feature of the MeV software, with a false discovery rate (FDR) of 5% . Hierarchical clustering was performed with Cluster 3.0 software, using uncentered Pearson correlation distance metric and average linkage clustering method, and the resulting expression clusters visualized using TreeView (version 1.6) software [6,88].
This microarray gene expression platform has been previously validated  and we compared real-time quantitative PCR – based expression data to the microarray expression data for four control genes in the 24 hr P. berghei challenged and 24 hr non-infected blood fed samples. Total RNA samples were reversed transcribed using dT20 primers and Superscript III (Cat. No. 18080-93; Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA). Real-time quantitative PCR assays were performed using QuantiTect SYBR Green PCR Kit (Cat. No. 204143; Qiagen Inc., Valencia, CA) and ABI Detection System ABI Prism 7000 (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). The ribosomal protein S7 gene was used for normalization of cDNA templates, the specificity of the PCR reactions was confirmed by melting curves analysis. Primer sequences used for microarray validation have been previously published . The expression ratio (infected/non-infected) for the control genes in the microarray (first number) and real-time quantitative PCR (second number) – assays were: DEF1: 0.34, 0.63; CLIPA9: 1.89, 1.71; SRPN9: 3.00, 2.05; AgMDL1: 1.38, 2.18. Minor differences in the magnitude of regulation relate to differences in the sensitivity and dynamic range between the two types of assays, while the direction of regulation was consistent. Microarray data sets have been submitted to GEO: GSM402884/Uninf Bf Hemo vs Pla Hemo 19d C, GSM402883/Uninf Bf Hemo vs Pla Hemo 19d B, GSM402882/Uninf Bf Hemo vs Pla Hemo 19d A, GSM402881/Uninf Bf Hemo vs Pla Hemo 24 hr C, GSM402880/Uninf Bf Hemo vs Pla Hemo 24 hr B, GSM402879/Uninf Bf Hemo vs Pla Hemo 24 hr A, GSM402874/Hemo m luteus vs hemo unchallenge C, GSM402873/Hemo m luteus vs hemo unchallenge B, GSM402872/Hemo m luteus vs hemo unchallenge A, GSM402871/Hemo E coli vs hemo unchallenge C, GSM402870/Hemo E coli vs hemo unchallenge B, GSM402869/Hemo E coli vs hemo unchallenge A, GSM402868/hemo vs whole 2, GSM402867/Hemo vs whole 3, GSM402830/Hemo vs whole.
AMP: antimicrobial peptide; AP-1: adaptor protein complex 1; CEC: cecropin; cfu: colony forming unit; DEF: defensin; FBN: fibrinogen-domain-containing immunolectin; GALE: galectin; GAM: gambicin; GNBP: Gram-negative binding protein; HAT: histone acetyltransferase; HDAC: histone deacetylase; LPS: lipopolysaccharide; LYS: lysozyme; PGRP: peptidoglycan-recognition protein; PO: phenoloxidase; PPO: prophenoloxidase; PPR: pattern recognition receptor; RTQ-PCR: real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction; TEP: thio-ester containing protein.
LB carried out microarray assays and analyses, and participated in writing the manuscript. AR carried out hemocyte assays. EW carried out microarray assays and analyses. MS conceived of the study, and participated in its design and coordination and participated in writing the manuscript. GD conceived of the study, and participated in its design and coordination, the analysis of data and writing the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Table S1. Log2 transformed expression ratio microarray data for the various experimental comparisons. Significantly up- and down-regulated genes are indicated with either "Up" or "Down" in separate columns.
Additional text files S1 – S9. Additional texts that are complementary to their respective main text sections.
We thank the microarray core facility at the Johns Hopkins Malaria Research Institute for assistance with microarray analyses and D. Champagne at the University of Georgia for sharing the eGFP expressing clone of P. berghei. This work is also supported by the National Institutes of Health/National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Disease R01AI061576, R21AI063605, United Nations Development Program/World Bank/World Health Organization Special Program for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases, the Ellison Medical Foundation, the Johns Hopkins School of Public Health, and the Johns Hopkins Malaria Research Institute.