Compared with Prdxs, catalase peroxidase activity decomposes H
2O
2 with a >1000-fold higher
KM (
Chae et al, 1994a;
Loewen et al, 2004) and therefore eliminates H
2O
2 with much higher efficiency. Thus, we cannot expect that Prdx1 scavenges H
2O
2 in considerable amounts, as shown in and
Supplementary Figure S1A. Yet, Prdx1's peroxidase activity is important in preventing H-Ras
V12 () or ErbB-2/neuT (
Supplementary Figure S5A) induced transformation. Similar to the catalase knockout mice, all other currently published Prdxs knockout mice, show phenotypically no increased susceptibility to transformation (
Ho et al, 1997). Therefore, Prdx1 may have a unique function amongst cellular peroxidases in tumour suppression, by affecting signalling directly through physical interaction with target enzymes. This was shown for c-Abl tyrosine kinase (
Wen and VanEtten, 1997) and c-Jun terminal kinase (
Kim et al, 2006). As described here for PTEN (), oxidative stress induced Prdx1 to dissociate, which in case of c-Abl (
Neumann et al, 1998) and JNK (
Kim et al, 2006) resulted in kinase activation. The Prdx1:PTEN heterodimer is most likely formed in a 1:1 molar ratio, as (1) the Prdx1 preservation of PTEN lipid phosphatase activity under oxidative stress is achieved by a 1:1 (mol:mol) ratio of Prdx1 and PTEN and could not be further increased by excess of Prdx1 () and (2) Prdx1
C51/172S, which is unable to form dimeric structures (
Chae et al, 1994b), bound to PTEN and did not dissociate under H
2O
2 treatment (). Therefore, these data provide compelling evidence that Prdx1 may bind PTEN as a monomer.
We further propose that the Prdx1:PTEN interaction is essential for protecting PTEN from oxidation-induced inactivation (), as Prdx1 C- and N-terminal peptide replica, which were designed based on our mapping studies and computer modelling to block PTEN docking sites on Prdx1 (;
Supplementary Figure S3E), resulted after H
2O
2 treatment in a 47% reduction of PTEN activity. This was comparable to PTEN activity after H
2O
2 treatment in the absence of Prdx1 (50%) (). The Prdx1 N terminus, which includes Cys51, may have an important function in regulating the H
2O
2-induced dissociation of the Prdx1:PTEN complex, as Cys51 when replaced by a serine enhances Prdx1 binding to PTEN (). X-ray crystallography of Prdxs suggested significant conformational changes, such as unwinding of the active site N-terminal helix, to form disulfides, as in reduced Prdxs, the sulfur atoms of the N- and C-terminal conserved cysteine residues are too far apart to react with each other (
Schroder et al, 2000;
Matsumura et al, 2008). Therefore, in the Prdx1:PTEN complex, increased H
2O
2 may oxidize Cys51 (Prdx1), thus, promoting unwinding of the PTEN-binding conformation of Prdx1 consequently inducing dissociation.
Over-oxidation of Prdx1 Cys51 occurs during catalysis and correlates with increasing amounts of Trx (
Yang et al, 2002). The reduction of Cys51 by Trx inhibits the folding back of Cys51 into its pocket thereby exposing it to further oxidation by H
2O
2. The binding of PTEN to Prdx1 could have similar effects on Prdx1, thereby inhibiting sufficient reduction of Cys51 by Trx and decreasing Prdx1 peroxidase activity (). Alternatively, as it has been shown that Trx binds PTEN and inactivates its lipid phosphates activity, it could be that under our experimental conditions Trx is depleted from the Prdx1 scavenging system by binding PTEN (
Meuillet et al, 2004). This seems unlikely though, as Trx was added in approximately 300-fold molar excess, which should provide a large Trx pool to reduce oxidized Prdx1 proteins.
We defined a novel interaction site of Prdx1 with PTEN in the C2 domain of PTEN (;
Supplementary Figure S3D and E), which together with the N-terminal PTD, are both required for enzyme activity. Surface plasmon resonance analysis revealed that the C2 domain is essential for high-affinity membrane binding of PTEN (
Das et al, 2003). Our data support this finding, as it has been shown recently through chemical proteomic strategy using cleavable lipid baits, that Prdx1 is a potential novel phosphoinositides-binding protein (
Pasquali et al, 2007). Prdx1 may, therefore, stabilize PTEN binding to the plasma membrane, which in a recent analysis using single-molecule TIRF microscopy, lasts only for a few hundred milliseconds (
Vazquez et al, 2006). Such short time of membrane binding could explain why we (;
Supplementary Figure S2B and D) and others see only small amounts of PTEN oxidized after cell exposure to H
2O
2 or PDGF (
Kwon et al, 2004). PDGF-induced H
2O
2 stems either from metabolized superoxide released by NADPH oxidases (NOXs) or the mitochondria and is considered a signalling molecule (
Rhee, 2006). As discussed earlier (
Leslie et al, 2003), such finding may be attributed to the proximity of NOXs complexes and PIP
3. Over-expression of Nox1, in PDGF-stimulated NIH 3T3 cells rapidly increases PIP
3 levels, in contrast to PI3K activity, suggesting that Nox1-induced superoxide enhances PIP
3 levels by inactivating PTEN rather than activating PI3K. Expression of a peroxidase inactive Prdx2 leads to a rapid increase of PIP
3 levels in growth factor stimulated cells, which is reversed by Prdx2
WT (
Kwon et al, 2004). In our hands however, Prdx2 did not bind PTEN, as we were unable to detect an interaction of Prdx2 and PTEN by immunoprecipitation (data not shown).
PTEN lipid phosphatase activity has an important function in tumour suppression (
Tolkacheva and Chan, 2000;
Koul et al, 2002) and Akt1 ablation protects (MMTV)-ErbB2/neu, MMTV-polyoma middle T and MMTV-v-H-Ras mice from breast cancer initiation (
Skeen et al, 2006;
Maroulakou et al, 2007). Here, we show that loss of Prdx1 increased basal, H
2O
2 and PDGF-induced Akt activity () and Prdx1 peroxidase activity was essential in suppressing H-Rasv12 and ErbB-2/neuT-induced transformation (;
Supplementary Figure S5A). Along those lines, Prdx1 ablation accelerated mammary tumorigenesis in MMTV-v-H-Ras mice and increased levels of pAkt
Ser473 and PTEN oxidation in MECs from these mice (). Prdx1 tumour suppression seemed to occur largely via regulation of the PTEN and Akt. Knock down of Prdx1 in PTEN
−/−MEFs did not significantly enhance H-Ras or ErbB-2-induced transformation (), whereas in transformed PTEN-containing MEFs, decrease in Prdx1 levels resulted in a gain of transformation: 1.5-fold for H-RasV12 and only 1.35-fold for ErbB-2/neuT, which we contributed to decreased Prdx1 knock down in PTEN
−/−;shPrdx1;GFP−PTEN;ErbB−2/neuTMEFs compared with PTEN
−/−;shPrdx1;GFP−PTEN;H−RasV12MEFs). Lack of PTEN also did not result in Prdx1 over-oxidation nor reduced expression (), suggesting that in PTEN-deficient cells, Prdx1 is acting as peroxidase.
However, we have to consider the regulation of other phosphatases or kinases by Prdx1 or H
2O
2 in Akt-driven tumorigenesis. SHIP-1 and 2 are known to dephosphorylate PIP
3 to PtdIns (3,4)P
2 (
Vivanco and Sawyers, 2002). However, SHIP2 is not inactivated by oxidative stress (
Leslie et al, 2003). PTEN
−/−;shPrdx1MEFs showed decreased pAKT
Ser473 levels compared with PTEN
−/−MEFs (), perhaps due to the activation of SHIP2 by small amounts of H
2O
2. However, H
2O
2 treatment of PTEN
−/−;shPrdx1MEFs increased pAKT
Ser473 levels comparable to PTEN
−/−MEFs, suggesting maybe a H
2O
2-induced inactivation of PP2A (
Rao and Clayton, 2002), as loss of Prdx1 also inactivated PP2A activity (
Supplementary Figure 2E). We also cannot exclude a regulation of PI3K by Prdx1, as H-Ras and ErbB-2/neuT transformed Prdx1
−/−MEFs display a lesser sensitivity towards PI3K inhibitors (;
Supplementary Figure 5B), compared with Prdx1
+/+MEFs.
In summary, oxidative stress and carcinogenesis are closely linked, however, molecular details, especially how oxidative stress promotes pro-oncogenic signalling pathways are scarce. Our studies shed some light on how H2O2 can promote oncogenic Ras and ErbB-2 signalling by providing evidence for the first time that the tumour suppressive function of PTEN and Prdx1 are closely related. The mechanistic details of the Prdx1 and PTEN interaction and its regulation in terms of Prdx1 peroxidase activity and PTEN oxidation will be important in future work.