PMCCPMCCPMCC

Search tips
Search criteria 

Advanced

 
Logo of mcgilljmedLink to Publisher's site
 
Mcgill J Med. Jan 2009; 12(1): 7–12.
PMCID: PMC2687919
Psychiatry as a career: A survey of factors affecting students’ interest in Psychiatry as a career
Mubashir Aslam,* Tahir Taj, Arif Ali, Nasira Badar, Farzan Saeed, Muhammed Abbas, Saad Muzaffar, and Bilal Abid
Dr. Mubashir Aslam graduated (M.B,B.S) from Dow Medical College, Karachi Pakistan in 2005. He worked for Community Health Science department, Aga Khan University for 2 years as a Community Medicine Resident. Currently he is enrolled at University of Sheffield, UK for a Masters in Public Health.
Dr. Tahir Taj graduated (M.B,B,S) from Sind Medical College Karachi, Pakistan in 2006. He joined Aga Khan University as a Community Medicine Resident and is currently enrolled in the second year of his training at Community Health Science Department.
Arif Ali completed his Masters in Statistics (MSc) from University of Karachi in 2005. He joined Community Health Sciences Department, Aga Khan University in 2006 for Research Officer training program and is currently enrolled in the third year of his training.
Dr. Nasira Badar graduated (M.B,B,S) from Chandka Medical College, Larkana, Pakistan in 2003. She worked for the Community Health Science department, Aga Khan University for 2 years as a Community Medicine Resident. Currently she is enrolled at Dow university of Health Sciences for a Masters program in Epidemiology and Biostatistics.
Farzan Saeed graduated in Management Sciences from Atlanta, USA. He joined the Community Health Sciences department, Aga Khan University in 2006 and is also enrolled in a Masters in Public Health program at Emory University, USA.
Muhammed Abbas is a final year Medical student at Ziauddin Medical University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Saad Muzaffar is a final year Medical student at Sindh Medical College, Karachi, Dow University of Health Sciences, Pakistan.
Bilal Abid is a final year Medical student at Aga Khan University Hospital Karachi, Pakistan
*To whom correspondence should be addressed: Dr. Mubashir Aslam, Aga Khan University Hospital, Stadium Road, P.O Box 3500, Karachi, 74800 Pakistan. E-mail: mubashir125/at/hotmail.com
The objectives of this study were to determine the characteristics of medical students and graduates interested in choosing psychiatry as a career and the obstacles in choosing this field of medicine. Two private and two public medical institutes were surveyed from June 2007 to August 2007. A self-administered questionnaire was distributed to third, fourth and final year students and to medical graduates doing their internship in these four medical institutes. A total of 909 medical students and graduates participated in the study. Seventeen percent of participants responded positively regarding their interest in psychiatry as a career. Significantly higher proportion belonged to private medical institutes (14% vs. 24%, P-value =0.001). There was no significant difference in reporting interest for psychiatry in regard to age, sex, year in medical school and whether or not the participant had done a psychiatry ward rotation. However significantly higher proportion of participants (22%, n=43) were reporting their interest in the field of psychiatry who had done more than a month long psychiatry ward rotation as compared to those participants (14%, n=54) with less than a month or no psychiatry rotation (P-value=0.01). More students were reporting their interest in psychiatry with a family history of psychiatric illness as compared to without family history (24% vs 16%, P-value=0.03). In conclusion, students and graduates with more than a month long rotation in psychiatry, studying in private medical colleges and with a family history of psychiatric illness were more interested in choosing psychiatry as a career.
Keywords: Psychiatry in Pakistan, Career in Psychiatry, medical students in Karachi
Mental health is an ignored subject in the field of medicine and in the area of public health, and less 1% health budget is spent on mental health problems in developing countries (1). This neglect accounts for students’ lack of interest in psychiatry and fewer medical students consider psychiatry as a career choice (2) as compared to other medical subspecialties. Furthermore health policy makers and investigators did not give sufficient attention on the issue of students’ disinclined attitude towards psychiatry. However since the 1960s, some educational studies have investigated the phenomenon of medical students’ interest in the field of psychiatry and their behavior towards mentally ill patients (3).
Pailhez G et al compared the attitude of Spanish and United States medical students toward psychiatry in a cross sectional study (4), which revealed that Spanish students showed a positive attitude towards Psychiatry as compared to U.S. students. Only 6% of Spanish students were considering psychiatry as a career which was slightly higher than U.S. medical students where only 4.5% students were interested in the field of psychiatry. The most common concerns expressed by the students relate to the lack of scientific rigor in psychiatry, is the non-efficacy of treatment, and the psychiatrists’ low social status among physicians.
Similarly in Pakistan, Psychiatry is not considered a popular field of medicine among students (5), and as such Pakistan is also facing shortage of physicians in this medical subspecialty. Even though a Department of Psychiatry have been established in most of the tertiary care teaching hospitals in the country (6), there are only 250 Psychiatrists in Pakistan and these practice mainly in urban settings (7). Data from population-based studies in urban settings revealed that one third of Pakistan’s population have anxiety/depression (8). Even though effective treatments are available for most of these disorders (9), there is a shortage of psychiatrists and other trained professionals like psychologists, nurses, and paramedics. The available one Psychiatrist for 0.64 million Pakistanis are absolutely insufficient; in addition a large proportion of Psychiatrists do not have postgraduate qualifications (1, 10). WHO reported that millions are affected by mental illnesses and the incidence is on the continuous rise. As high as 154 million people faces major depression and 25 million suffer from schizophrenia. In addition addiction and substance abuse also contribute a major burden among mental health problems, as many as 91 million people get disorders which are directly or indirectly alcohol related and 15 million by other addictive drugs (1).
Medical graduates with a good attitude towards psychiatry are sometimes unable to pursue their career in this medical subspecialty. Even though some studies have been done in our part of world regarding psychiatry as a career and most of them have tended to identify only attitude of medical students (1114), yet hindrances in opting for psychiatry as a career have not been studied. Furthermore, most of the studies included medical students and have overlooked medical graduates and interns, who are at critical point of choosing their medical career in a particular specialty. Therefore the objective of this study was to compare medical students and graduates’ perceptions around hindrances in choosing Psychiatry as a specialty in Pakistan.
This cross sectional study was conducted in two public (Dow Medical College and Sindh Medical College) and two private medical institutes (Aga Khan Medical College and Ziauddin Medical College) from June 2007 to August 2007 in Karachi. There are three public medical institutes in Karachi and Dow and Sindh Medical College are the two largest public institutes. Average number of student varied from 200 to 250 for each class in these public medical institutes. Aga Khan and Ziauddin medical college were selected out of six private medical institutes in Karachi. There is a significant difference between public and private medical institutions as to the technique of teaching. Some private medical institutions are following a problem based learning system (PBLS) (15), whereas all the public medical institutions follow a conventional lecture based curriculum (LBL). In addition, there are certain postgraduate specialty training programs, like Family Medicine, which is only offered in private medical institutions (16). In Pakistan, medical schools offer a five (5) year program leading to an M.B.B.S (Bachelor of Medicine; Bachelor of Surgery) degree. Basic health sciences are the primary focus of instruction during the first two years, with gradually increasing exposure to clinical rotations over the next three years (15). After graduation, there is one-year compulsory internship in a teaching hospital in order to obtain medical licensure. Fellowship training starts after completing an internship and passing a postgraduate medical exam (16).
The authors developed a self-administered questionnaire in English as all of these medical institutes have English as an official teaching language. The questionnaire included demographics, undergraduate courses, satisfaction in medical profession, and first, second and third career choices of medical students (questions regarding a particular field of medicine will be reported separately). The questionnaire was kept anonymous to maintain confidentiality of the participants. Pre-testing of questionnaire was done on 30 participants from each of the four medical institutes to determine response rate and applicability of the tool; changes were made in the questionnaire accordingly (unpublished data). The same questionnaire was used for data collection from all four medical institutes.
Only third, fourth and final year medical students and house officers were included in this study. First and second year students were excluded because of little exposure to clinics in beginning years of medical studies and less number of students were able to report their commitment for any particular medical specialty. After seeking verbal consent, data collectors distributed self-administered anonymous questionnaires to medical students after lectures, tutorials and PBL (Problem based learning) in medical colleges and were recollected after few minutes. To target house officers, questionnaires were distributed and collected in different wards of the attached teaching hospitals within these four medical institutes. The department of Community Health Sciences, Sindh Medical College issued study approval. An information sheet was attached with each questionnaire to provide project details, rights of the participants and suggesting that filling the questionnaire implies informed consent.
Data were entered and analyzed in SPSS version 15 (17); categorical variable of self-reporting interest in choosing Psychiatry as a career was the defined outcome. Interested in choosing Psychiatry is defined as “those who find the subject interesting to take as a career however may not actually be taking it as postgraduate specialization field”. Chi-square and t-test were applied for categorical and continuous variables respectively to test the statistical significance at 95% confidence level.
A total of 909 medical students and graduates participated in the study (response rate was 90% of individuals who received questionnaire), of which 285 (31%) belonged to one of the two private medical institute and 624 (69%) participants were part of public medical institute in Karachi. Age of participants ranged from 19 to 28 years (mean=22 years, s.d=1.7). Six hundred and fifty (71%) participants were male. Overall 157 (17%) participants reported their dedication in opting psychiatry as a career including 67 (24%) of individuals from private medical institutes and 90 (14%) from public medical institutes showing that significantly higher proportion of individuals were reporting their interest in psychiatry in private institute as compare to public medical institutes (P-value=0.001). There was no significant difference in reporting interest for Psychiatry with regards to age (mean=22.1±1.8 vs. mean=22.3±1.9, P-value=0.28), sex (15% vs. 18%,P-value=0.38), year of study (3rd yr=22%, 4th yr=17%, 5th yr=14%, Interns=17%, P-value=0.17) and whether or not the participant had done a psychiatry ward rotation (17% vs. 18%, P-value=0.68). However a significantly higher proportion of participants (22%, n=43) were reporting their interest in the field of Psychiatry who had done more than a month long psychiatry ward rotation as compare to those participants (14%, n=54) with less than a month rotations (P-value=0.01). Furthermore it was noticed that 24% (n=27) of participants reported their interest in psychiatry who had a family history of psychiatric illness while only 16% (n=126) were reporting their interest in Psychiatry with no family history revealing a significant difference in two groups (P-value=0.03) [Table 1].
Table 1:
Table 1:
Characteristics of Medical students and graduates (participants) in regard to interest in Psychiatry
The evaluation of hurdles in choosing psychiatry as a career in private and public institutes demonstrated that mean score of the component “stressful conditions with patients” was highest among the participants of both private (mean=3.4, SD=1.5) and public medical institutes (mean=3.3, SD=1.4). However mean scores of each of the other components was higher among the participants of private institutes as compared to the medical students and graduates in Government medical institutes given rise to the total sum of mean scores are 13.9 and 14.7 for public and private medical institutes respectively [Table. 2].
Table 2:
Table 2:
Hindrances in choosing Psychiatry as a career
This study results revealed that 17% of medical students and graduates reported interest in choosing Psychiatry as a career. However a much higher proportion of students belonged to private medical education system who were reporting interest in psychiatry. Mandatory undergraduate courses of psychiatry in private medical schools might be the reason for this difference, as it is mostly taken as an optional subject in public medical institute in Karachi. This study also unmasked the finding that is consistent with Walters et al. that the higher proportion of medical students and graduates were reporting positive interest in psychiatry who had taken psychiatry as undergraduate subject (18). Furthermore it has been determined that those participants who had done more than a month of clinical rotation in psychiatry were reporting a significantly positive response towards choosing a career in psychiatry. These results are consistent with other studies including a prospective study to evaluate the effects of a psychiatry rotation on the attitude of medical students towards psychiatry (1921). Moreover the results regarding a positive association between choosing psychiatry as a career and a family history of mental illness is also consistent with other studies (22). Another study shows that positive educational experiences as well as personal experiences increase the probability of students’ recruitment into the field of psychiatry. Nevertheless it is still ambiguous whether the focus should be on increasing the educational level regarding psychiatry as a subject and clinical rotation, or if it should be on issues which are related to the incentives in this field including career opportunities, income potential and establishment of better structure for the post graduate studies programs in the field of psychiatry (2). Results of Raja Gopal et al. and Olaf et al. revealed that there is no association of gender, age and year of study with higher interest of students in choosing Psychiatry as a career that is consistent with the results of this study but with a larger sample size (2, 22).
Hindrances in choosing Psychiatry as a career were also evaluated in this study as studies have shown that for most of the students, psychiatry is the last choice to be taken as postgraduate training even though students consider it an intellectually challenging field (1). A 5 item Likert questionaire was used to quantify the major factors responsible for the lower recruitment in psychiatry in our circumstances. Four of the items including “less incentives in the field”, “less popularity among other medical specialists”, “stressful conditions with patients” and “less career opportunities” were used for evaluation in other studies as well. However a fifth component which was “discouragement from family” was included in this questionnaire because of the local scenario in Asian countries particularly Pakistan, where families also play a crucial role regarding career decision of students. Most of the medical students were concerned with stress in the field of psychiatry due to prolong contact with Psychiatric patients which was also determined in a study by Cutler JL et al (23).
One of the limitations of this study was that structured items were given in the questionnaire for evaluating hindrances in psychiatry as a career even though there could be more concerns, which would prevent them from choosing this field. However this can be explained on the basis that response rates were expected to decline if these questions were left open ended because of the time required to write answers. Another limitation was that the outcome variable was self-reported interest in psychiatry as a career so there could be variations in expected and observed responses. Nevertheless the variations were expected to be minimal by obtaining similarity in data from comparable institutes including two private and two public medical institutes. The reason for taking this outcome variable instead of analyzing highly committed students who wrote psychiatry as a first career choice in open ended question, which were estimated to be only 2.5% in total (Data not shown), was that because with a larger sample the characteristic of students interested in psychiatry as a career can grossly be identified which may increase interest towards psychiatry as a career compared to the control population. It was assumed that increasing students interest towards this field could eventually increase the recruitment of students in the field of Psychiatry. Selection bias may have been a factor since more students were reporting interest in psychiatry who had more than a month rotation in the psychiatry ward, however it was not determined whether they had selectively done it or it was a mandatory rotation.
The strength of this study includes having a large sample size and inclusion of house officers (interns) because they are the one who are at a critical stage in deciding about their medical specialty and can better report their interest in and commitment to a particular career.
Students and graduates who have had more than a month long rotation in psychiatry, studying in a private medical college and a family history of psychiatric illness are more interested in choosing psychiatry as a career. Stressful working conditions with patients ranked highest as a hindrance in not choosing psychiatry as a career. In addition appropriate incentives in the field of psychiatry in terms of money and career opportunities are lacking in Pakistan. More structured post graduate programs in psychiatry with better guidelines for the career opportunity in this field may help raise enrollment in psychiatry. Furthermore there is an immediate need to make psychiatry a mandatory undergraduate subject in all of the medical institutes in Pakistan.
Acknowledgments
Authors acknowledge the significant cooperation of the administrative staff of in the study settings for the permission and facilitation of data collection by students.
Footnotes
DECLARATION OF INTEREST
Authors declare no conflict of interest with any organization or funding agencies.
CONTRIBUTION OF AUTHORS
Dr Mubashir and Dr Tahir started the initial planning of the project and worked until the final manuscript submission. Dr Ali Abbas, Dr Saad Muzafar, Dr Nasira Badar, Mr Farzan Saeed and Dr Bilal Abid were involved in the collection, entry and analysis of data and helped write the initial draft of the manuscript. Arif Ali supervised data management and all the statistical analysis.
1. Integrating mental health into primary care: A global perspective WHO Library Cataloguing-in-Publication DataWorld Health Organization and World Organization of Family Doctors (Wonca) 2008. ISBN 978 92 4 156368 0. URL : http://www.who.int/mental_health/policy/Mental%20health%20+%20primary%20care-%20final%20low-res%20120109.pdf.
2. Feifel D, Moutier CY, Swerdlow NR. Attitudes toward psychiatry as a prospective career among students entering medical school. Am J Psychiatry. 1999;156(9):1397–402. [PubMed]
3. Kuhnig kO, Strebel B, Schilauske J, Jueptner M. Attitude of medical students towards psychiatry. Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract. 2006;12(1):87–101. [PubMed]
4. Pailhez G, Bulbena A, Coll J, Balon R. Attitude and views on psychiatry: a comparison between Spanish and U.S medical students. Acad Psychiatry. 2005;29(1):82–91. [PubMed]
5. Lawari S, Martin K, Mecneil G. General practitioner attitude to psychiatry and mental illness. Psychol Med. 1998;28:1463–7. [PubMed]
6. Wasif SA. Mental Health Services in Pakistan. 2006.
7. Gadit AA, Khalid N. Human rights and international recruitment of psychiatrists: dilemma for developing countries. J Pak Med Assoc. 2006;56(10):474–6. [PubMed]
8. Muhammad Gadit AA, Mugford G. Prevalence of depression among households in three capital cities of Pakistan: need to revise the mental health policy. PLoS ONE. 2007;2(2):e209. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
9. Patel V, Araya R, Chatterjee S, et al. Treatment and prevention of mental disorders in low-income and middle-income countries. Lancet. 2007;370(9591):991–1005. [PubMed]
10. Ahmad K. Shortage of psychiatrists a problem in Pakistan. Lancet. 2007;370(9590):817–8. [PubMed]
11. Maqsood N, Ali W, Niaz S, Chaudhry HR, Malik JA, Ahmad I. Attitudes of medical students towards psychiatry in QMC (Bahawalpur) Pakistan. Ann King Edward Med Coll Jun. 2006;12(2):320–4.
12. Niaz U, Hassan S, Hussain H, Saeed S. Attitudes towards Psychiatry in Pre-clinical clerkships and Post-clinical clerkship in different medical colleges of Karachi. Pak J Med Sci. 2003;19:253–63.
13. Minhas F, Mubbashar MH. Attitudes of Medical Students towards Psychiatry in Pakistan. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. 2000;10(2):69–72.
14. Karim R, Ayub M, Izhar N, Asif A, Aziz R. What do the Doctors in Lahore Think about Psychiatry. Ann King Edward Med Coll. 1999 Jun;5(2):170–3.
15. Khan H, Taqui AM, Khawaja MR, Fatmi Z. Problem-based versus conventional curricula: influence on knowledge and attitudes of medical students towards health research. PloS ONE. 2007;2(7):632. [PMC free article] [PubMed]
16. Biggs SG. Postgraduate Medical Training in Pakistan: Observations and Recommendations. J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. 2008;18(1):58–63. [PubMed]
17. Statistical Software for Social Sciences (SPSS 14) for Windows. Chicago. SPSS2005.
18. Walters K, Raven P, Rosenthal J, Russell J, Humphrey C, Buszewicz M. Teaching undergraduate psychiatry in primary care: the impact on student learning and attitudes. Med Educ. 2007;41(1):100–8. [PubMed]
19. Garyfallos G, Adamanopoulou A, Lavrentiadis G, Giouzepas J, Parashos A, Dimitriou E. Medical Students’ Attitudes Toward Psychiatry in Greece. Acad Psychiatry. 1998;22:92–97. [PubMed]
20. Goldacre MJ, Turner G, Fazel S, Lambert T. Career choices for psychiatry: national surveys of graduates of 1974–2000 from UK medical schools. Br J Psychiatry. 2005;186:158–64. [PubMed]
21. Reddy JP, Tan SM, Azmi MT, et al. The effect of a clinical posting in psychiatry on the attitudes of medical students towards psychiatry and mental illness in a Malaysian medical school. Ann Acad Med Singapore. 2005;34(8):505–10. [PubMed]
22. RajaGopal S, Rehill KS, Godfrey E. Psychiatry as a career choice compared with other specialties. Psychiatric Bulletin. 2004;28:444–46.
23. Cutler JL, Harding KJ, Wright LL, Graham MJ. Medical students’ perceptions of psychiatry as a career choice. Academic Psychiatry. 2006;30(2):144–9. [PubMed]
Articles from McGill Journal of Medicine : MJM are provided here courtesy of
McGill University