To our knowledge, this is the first report of a polymorphism in
CYP11A1 and risk of endometrial cancer. We found no association with the [TTTTA]
n repeat in the promoter region that we tested. This polymorphism has been studied mainly in relation to PCOS (polycystic ovarian syndrome), a condition marked by high levels of androgens. While genotypes with more than 4 repeats have been found to be associated with risk of PCOS and with androgen levels in women with PCOS, other studies have not supported these results [
21]. No functional differences have been reported for repeats of different lengths and no associations with hormone levels have been found in normal women [
21]. There are other polymorphisms in this gene that may be functional [
22] and may be candidates for future study in relation to risk of endometrial cancer.
For
CYP17A1, results from earlier studies have been mixed. Some smaller studies (with the number of cases ranging from 51 to 184) reported reduced risk associated with the C/C genotype (reviewed in 22), consistent with our results, while a larger study in Poland (497 cases, 1,024 controls) found no association [
23]. The study by Gaudet et al[
23] found, as we did, no difference in results according to levels of BMI, while Haiman et al [
24] found a stronger effect in obese women. The C allele was originally thought to be associated with an Sp-1 binding site that would lead to higher expression [
25]; however, a later study did not support this [
26]. Several studies have examined the relationship between
CYP17A1 genotype and serum levels of androgens, estrogens, or progesterone. While there is some evidence that the variant allele is associated with higher levels of serum estrogens, other studies have not supported these findings and overall the evidence for an association of genotypes with estrogens is weak (reviewed in [
21]). In addition, there is no evidence of association of genotype with serum levels of androgens, the precursors of estrogens (). Higher levels of estrogens in women with the C allele have been reported in saliva [
27], urine [
28], and follicular fluid [
29]. The association of the variant with higher levels of estrogen found in some studies would lead to the hypothesis that it would increase risk of endometrial cancer, in contrast to the reductions in risk noted in this and some other studies. Haplotypes have been described [
30,
31] but the only study to evaluate them in endometrial cancer found no associations with risk [
23].
We found a strong reduction in risk for the 3bp [−/TCT] polymorphism in
CYP19A1; the one other study of this variant also reported reduced risk, but the effect was smaller and not statistically significant (OR=0.71, 95% CI 0.39–1.27) [
32]. Earlier studies [
32,
33] reported higher risk associated with longer repeats in the intronic [TTTA]
n polymorphism; while results for the n=7/7 genotype compared to the n>7/>7 genotype in the present study are in the same direction, the association is weak and not statistically significant (OR=0.79, 95% CI 0.52–1.19). A number of other variants in
CYP19A1 have been studied in relation to endometrial cancer [
32,
34] and several have been found to be related to risk, particularly in postmenopausal women. Most of those related to endometrial cancer are in an area of linkage disequilibrium (designated as Block 4 [
35]) which includes the Ins/Del and the [TTTA]
n repeat reported here. A study in China [
36] found associations between BMI and variants in genotypes in Block 4 in healthy women, although different polymorphisms were studied and the association was found only in premenopausal women in that study.
There is little information on the functional relevance of the variants we studied in these genes. Our finding of reduced risk for women homozygous for the 3bp deletion in
CYP19A1 is consistent with reports of lower ratios of estrogens to androgens in serum of unaffected women with this genotype. However, this is based on only two studies, and studies of associations between genotype and androgens and estrogens individually are inconsistent (reviewed in [
21]). Associations between the [TTTA]
n repeat and these measures are conflicting and inconsistent. There is, however, growing evidence that variants in
CYP19A1 influence hormone levels in blood. A recent analysis of three cohort studies [
37] found 7 of the 19 tag SNPs (single nucleotide polymorphisms) studied to be strongly associated with serum levels of estrone and estradiol in postmenopausal women. Four of these 7 SNPs are located in Block 4.
We selected the variants for this study based on reports in the literature at the time we undertook genotyping; however, a tagging approach using HapMap data would have been a preferable alternative. For each of the variants studied, the distributions of genotypes in controls reported in are similar to those reported in other studies and, for
CYP17A1, among Europeans in HapMap [
38]. The EDGE Study includes a reasonably large number of cases and controls chosen from the population of northern New Jersey, a state with high incidence of endometrial cancer [
39,
40]. Although our response rate was less than optimal for both cases and controls, the differences between cases and controls shown in are similar to those reported in other studies [
41–
44], somewhat reducing concerns about non-response bias; in addition, participation is unlikely to be influenced by genotype. Our study included a large proportion of cases with BMI ≥30, perhaps reflecting national trends in obesity through 2000 [
45]. In addition, we had relatively few women who had ever used HRT compared to other recent studies [
11]. We had only moderate power to investigate gene-environment interactions. Our genotyping was limited to a small number of SNPs in these genes; studies using a larger number of markers are warranted, particularly for
CYP19A1. We did not use genetic methods to control for the influence of race or ethnicity; however, the similar distributions between cases and controls and the lack of change in the ORs when ancestry was included in logistic regression models make it unlikely that population stratification affected the results.
Overall, we conclude that the −34 T/C change in CYP17A1 may be related to somewhat reduced risk of endometrial cancer, although results from other studies are inconsistent. Functional studies and investigation of additional variants in this gene will further understanding of this relationship. For CYP19A1, there is growing evidence that some SNPs are related to estrogen levels and to risk; however, additional studies are needed to determine the specific changes that affect estrogen levels and risk of endometrial cancer.