The MMPs play an important role in proteolytic degradation and remodeling of various ECM components in both physiologic and pathologic situations, including tissue repair, angiogenesis, and tumor cell invasion and metastasis. Under normal physiologic conditions, MMPs are expressed at very low levels, whereas overexpression and activation have been found in many types of tumors (
8,
29-
31). Several previous studies examined the associations between the MMP polymorphisms and the development of tumors, such as lung cancer, breast cancer, and melanoma metastasis (
11,
13-
17).
Here we assessed the associations between six non-synonymous SNPs in the
MMP3, MMP8, and
MMP9 genes and the risk of three types of skin cancer. We observed a significant inverse association between the
MMP9 Gln668 allele and SCC risk, mirrored in the haplotype analysis as well. MMP9 (gelatinase B) is produced by multiple cells including keratinocytes (
32). Expression of the
MMP9 gene was detected in malignantly transformed keratinocytes in SCC but not in normal keratinocytes (
32). Furthermore, overexpression of
MMP9 has been linked to the dyskeratotic foci of Bowen’s disease, which is cutaneous SCC
in situ (
32-
34). In addition, MMP9 protein expression was upregulated in SCC of the skin when compared with BCC (
35). In a transgenic mouse model the absence of
MMP9 was shown to delay angiogenesis and to reduce the frequency of SCC (
33).
The results of the computational prediction of the functional significance for the SNPs in this study indicated the possible functional effects of the
MMP9 non-synonymous SNPs, such as Pro574Arg and Arg668Gln, on the MMP9 protein. We showed that the
MMP9 Pro574Arg and Arg668Gln had two predictions of being less evolutionarily conservative or deleterious. The
MMP9 Pro574Arg is predicted by BLOSUM62 to be evolutionarily less acceptable and by PMut to be pathological to protein function; the
MMP9 Arg668Gln is predicted by PMut to be pathological and by SNPs3D to be deleterious to the protein structural stability. Similarly, a synthetic 3D structure of MMP9 derived by Cotignola et al. reflects the potential alteration of MMP9 protein function due to an amino acid change of non-synonymous SNPs in the
MMP9 gene including Arg668Gln, Pro574Arg, and Gln279Arg evaluated in this study (
13). Presumably, the Gln allele of the
MMP9 Arg668Gln is associated with reduced activity of the MMP9 protein, reducing the degradation of ECM. This could help explain our finding that women carrying the variant allele of
MMP9 Arg668Gln have lower risk of SCC than those carrying the wild-type allele. On the other hand, compared to melanocytes and basal cells, keratinocytes are less tolerant of DNA damage and have a lower apoptotic threshold, which makes easier to enter the apoptosis pathway as a protective mechanism for SCC (
36-
38). This further supports the impact of MMP9 protein on SCC risk rather than melanoma or BCC risks because it has been proposed that MMP9 contributes to apoptosis (
39-
41). However, further biochemical studies are needed to confirm this, because the role of MMPs in tumorigenesis is much more complex. Individual MMPs may play different roles in different cell types or in different states of transformation. For example, it has been demonstrated that MMP9 can induce tumorigenesis and also inhibit it by enhancing angiostatin production (
42-
44).
For melanoma and BCC risks, we did not observe any suggestive associations with the six non-synonymous SNPs we evaluated. Previous studies focused on the association between the SNPs in the
MMP2, MMP3, and
MMP9 genes and melanoma progression, showing significant inverse associations of the three
MMP9 SNPs (Gln279Arg, Pro574Arg, and Arg668Gln) with metastasis of melanoma (
13,
45). No studies have assessed the effects of SNPs in the MMP genes on the risks of SCC and BCC. To our knowledge, this is the first simultaneous evaluation of the associations between non-synonymous SNPs in the MMP genes and the risks of three most common types of skin cancers.
In summary, we found an inverse association between the
MMP9 Arg668Gln polymorphism and SCC risk. The nested case-control design, high follow-up rate, and high response rate for the retrospective supplementary questionnaire are among strengths of this study. The limitations of the study include the misclassification of the self-reported assessment of pigmentary phenotypes and sun exposure-related information. Our previous report demonstrated that the retrospective assessment of risk factors was not likely to substantially bias the estimate of risk in this study (
19). Because we selected incident cases after blood collection at the mean age of 58.7 years, the cases had an older age at diagnosis than that in the general population. The sample size in each cancer type in this study was modest, and additional studies are warranted to confirm these associations. Further biochemical studies are warranted to explore the biological characteristics of the MMP genetic variants.