Embryonic stem cell
transplantation therapies have significant potential for treating a broad spectrum of human diseases either by replacement or by regeneration of lost or damaged tissues [1
]. ESCs are pluripotent and have the capacity to differentiate into multiple adult cell types in vitro, such as cardiomyocytes [2
], pancreatic islet cells [3
], and neurons [4
]. These ESC derivatives have demonstrated therapeutic potential in vivo [5
]. One potential benefit of ESC-based transplantation over adult cells is their suggested immune-privileged properties [6
]. Human (h) and murine (m) ESCs have been shown to express low levels of major histocompatibility (MHC) antigens [7
]. Previous studies have reported that both mESCs [9
] and hESCs [10
] are capable of inhibiting allogeneic T-cell proliferation in vitro. Furthermore, mESCs have been shown to evade immune recognition and survive in immunocompetent rats [11
] and sheep [12
] for many weeks after transplantation. Nevertheless, our group and others have found that mESCs transplanted into allogeneic mouse hearts can elicit local graft infiltration of inflammatory cells resulting in rejection [13
]. Similarly, other reports have questioned the alleged immune privilege of mESCs following xenotransplantation into immunocompetent baboons [15
Clearly, the extent to which immunologic rejection of ESCs and/or ESC derivatives occurs following allogeneic transplantation is a crucial question that has not yet been clarified. The results of aforementioned studies were primarily based on immunohistological evaluation, which provide only a “snapshot” representation rather than a comprehensive picture of cell survival over time [16
]. Such limited techniques may partly contribute to the conflicting observations of mESC survival in allogeneic or xenogeneic hosts. To address these limitations, we have previously validated in vivo bioluminescent imaging (BLI) to be a reliable technique for assessing engraftment and survival of mESCs following transplantation in vivo [17
]. An important advantage in using BLI to track cell transplantation is that the expression of the firefly luciferase (Fluc) reporter gene, which is integrated into the DNA of the transplanted cells, is expressed only by living cells, making it a highly accurate tool for following cell graft rejection in the living subject [18
]. We have previously shown that the transduction of mESCs with reporter genes that allow in vivo tracking does not alter cellular viability and their ability to differentiate into cells of all three germ layers [19
]. To further delineate the novel field of ESC transplantation immunobiology, we used in vivo BLI to visualize patterns of survival and rejection of mESCs following transplantation across histocompatibility barriers.
To track the mESCs in vivo by BLI as well as ex vivo by immunohistochemistry, a double fusion (DF) reporter gene construct carrying Fluc and enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP) driven by a constitutive ubiquitin promoter (pUB) was transduced into undifferentiated mESCs (D3 cell line, derived from the 129/Sv mouse strain), using a self-inactivating (SIN) lentiviral vector (), as described previously [20
]. After transduction, mESCs robustly expressed Fluc () and eGFP (). In agreement with the previous reports [9
], flow cytometric analysis showed the expression of pluripotency marker SSEA-1 and minimal expression of H-2kb
MHC class I (MHC-I) or I-Ab
MHC class II (MHC-II) antigens on undifferentiated mESCs. In contrast, mESC-derived teratoma cells (mES–TCs) isolated from 6-week-old surgically explanted teratomas by a 2-h enzymatic digestion in Collagenase D (2 mg/mL in RPMI medium) clearly expressed both MHC-I and MHC-II antigens (). In culture, mES–TCs displayed a heterogeneous single cell morphology, as opposed to mESCs, which grow in tight clusters ().
FIG. 1. Characterization of the double fusion (DF) firefly luciferase (Fluc) and enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP) transduced D3 murine embryonic stem cells (mESCs). (A) Schema of the DF reporter gene containing Fluc and eGFP driven by an ubiquitin promoter. (more ...)
Transduced mESCs (1
) were transplanted by direct injection into the gastrocnemius muscle of syngeneic (129/Sv, H-2kb
8) and allogeneic (BALB/c, H-2kd
8 recipient mice, after which BLI was performed weekly. The BLI protocol involved intraperitoneal administration of the d
-Luciferin reporter probe at a dose of 375 mg/kg body weight and imaging was performed using the Xenogen In Vivo Imaging System as described previously [17
]. Clearly, impaired survival of mESCs in the allogeneic recipients was observed as compared to the syngeneic animals, reaching statistical significance at day 14 after transplantation (BLI signal: 129/Sv 9.00
0.57 vs. BALB/c 7.54
0.01 by t
-test). (). By 28 days, BLI signal in the allogeneic recipients had decreased to background levels, whereas signal in the syngeneic recipients continued to increase. These results suggest alloantigen-specific rejection of the transplanted mESCs. At 28 days following transplantation, gastrocnemius muscles were surgically explanted. In syngeneic recipients, intramuscular tumors could be observed, whereas the shape of the allogeneic recipient muscles appeared normal (). Differentiated structures originating from all three germ layers could be demonstrated by H&E staining in the syngeneic muscles, indicating teratoma formation. Correlating with our findings using BLI, no teratoma formation and/or signs of surviving mESCs could be found in the allogeneic muscles ().
FIG. 2. In vivo bioluminescent imaging (BLI) of transplanted mESCs. (A) Representative BLI images of animals following intramuscular (gastrocnemius muscle) transplantation of mESCs show a decrease in BLI signal in allogeneic animals (BALB/c), as opposed to syngeneic (more ...)
We next investigated the local immune response elicited by mESCs in a second group of allogeneic BALB/c and syngeneic 129/Sv mice (n
8 per group). At 10 days following transplantation, the muscles of these mice were explanted and investigated for graft-infiltrating cells. Immunofluorescent staining of allogeneic muscle sections demonstrated massive infiltration of CD45+
inflammatory cells surrounding the eGFP+
mESC grafts (). Quantification and further characterization of graft-infiltrating cells was carried out by enzymatic digestion (2 h in 2 mg/mL collagenase D in RPMI medium) of the explanted muscles followed by FACS analysis. Live cells were gated out from debris and further analyzed for the expression of a panel of hematopoietic cell surface markers. Comparison of the syngeneic to the allogeneic mESC recipient muscles confirmed severe infiltration of various types of immune cells involved in both adaptive and innate types of immunity (). At this time-point, both the CD3+
cells (total T-cell population) and CD8+
cells (cytotoxic T-cells) were present at a significantly higher frequency in allogeneic versus syngeneic recipients (p
0.05 by t
-test), suggesting a prominent role for T-cell-mediated immunity in mESC rejection.
To investigate whether mESCs could induce immunologic memory, we next performed infusion of 1
D3 mESCs or 1
irradiated (3,000 rad) 129/Sv splenocytes (as control) into the tail vein of allogeneic BALB/c recipients (n
4 and 5 per group, respectively). Four weeks later, these same mice received intramuscular transplantation with the same number of transduced mESCs and cell survival was quantified using longitudinal BLI. Accelerated BLI signal loss was observed in both groups, with BLI signal reaching background levels as soon as post-transplant day 4 (control group) and day 7 (mESC group) (). These findings confirm that a donor (129/Sv)-specific adaptive immune response is generated against transplanted mESCs.
FIG. 3. Accelerated rejection following presensitization of the host. (A) Representative BLI images of animals following intramuscular allotransplantation of mESCs show an accelerated decrease in BLI signal in animals that were presensitized with both nontransduced (more ...)
Clinical ESC-based transplantation protocols will require differentiation of the donor cells into the desired cell type before transplantation, due to the risk of teratoma formation following transplantation of undifferentiated ESCs [13
]. Therefore, we thought that it would be relevant to study the survival of mESC derivatives following allotransplantation. A group of BALB/c mice (n
5) was injected with 1
mES–TCs and longitudinal BLI was performed. In comparison with undifferentiated mESCs, the BLI signal displayed a similar pattern up until 7 days following transplantation (). However, BLI signal in the mES–TC animals decreased substantially by day 10 (mESC 7.74
0.58 vs. mES-TC 5.46
0.01 by t
-test) and reached background levels at day 14. These results show that differentiated mESCs have impaired survival capacity as compared to undifferentiated mESCs when transplanted over histocompatibility barriers.
FIG. 4. Impaired survival capacity of differentiated mESCs as compared to undifferentiated mESCs following allotransplantation. (A) Representative BLI images of animals following intramuscular allotransplantation of mESCs or mES–TCs. Clearly, BLI signal (more ...)
In a recent report, higher numbers of transplanted undifferentiated mESCs (5
) were shown capable of survival and formation of teratoma in allogeneic recipients [22
]. Similarly, in this study we found that when 10
mESCs were transplanted into allogeneic BALB/c recipient muscles, BLI signal could be followed out beyond 28 days following transplantation in 2 out of 10 animals (20%) and intramuscular teratomas could be observed in these two animals. However, when mESCs were allowed to differentiate for 14 days in vitro prior to transplantation, 10
cells were rejected by 10 out of 10 animals (100%) (data not shown).
Undifferentiated mESCs have been reported to possess immune-privileged properties, which has been attributed to the low expression of MHC molecules [21
], expression of perforin-deactivating Serpin-6 [9
] and/or production of lymphocyte-inhibiting TGF-β [22
] by the cells. However, our study clearly shows that the transplantation of mESCs in vivo can result in donor-specific immune recognition and rejection, which leads to immunologic memory. Importantly, post-transplant cell death is accelerated when mESCs are allowed to differentiate before transplantation, a scenario likely to occur in clinical ESC-based transplantation settings in the future. Whether the latter phenomenon is truly a result of increased immunogenicity of the cells, as suggested by their increased expression of MHC antigens (), or if other factors such as a decreased proliferation rate of differentiated cells play part in this process remains to be evaluated in detail. Nevertheless, the results of this study emphasize that immunologic rejection of ESCs or ESC derivatives is likely to occur and the need exists for solutions that reduce or eliminate immunologic response following ESC-based transplantation [23
]. To develop and test such strategies, there will also be a need for reliable imaging technologies to track and assess behavior of the cells following transplantation. In vivo BLI serves these needs and has the potential to play a prominent role in future ESC-based transplantation research.