TrkB is expressed by hippocampal neural progenitor cells
We, and others have previously demonstrated the presence of TrkB transcripts and protein in the hippocampus (
Klein et al., 1990;
Zhou et al., 1993). To determine whether transcripts are present in the neurogenic zone, we first examined TrkB expression in the postnatal and adult DG. In situ hybridization analysis showed prominent expression of both BDNF and TrkB in the granular layer and SGZ of the DG (). In particular, TrkB mRNA, represented by silver bromide grains, was detectable throughout the cellular layers of the DG (). To further examine whether the DG NPCs express TrkB, we utilized Nestin-GFP transgenic mice, in which GFP expression is confined to NPCs () (
Yu et al., 2005). Using fluorescent-activated cell sorting (FACS), GFP positive cells from the DG of transgenic mice at various ages were isolated and analysis of these cells by RT-PCR demonstrated the presence of NPCs markers and the absence of markers from the differentiated lineages (
Supplemental Figure 1). TrkB and BDNF mRNAs were detected in the GFP positive cells at all ages tested (postnatal day (P) 2, 15 and 60, n=3 animals for each, ). Similarly, TrkB and BDNF mRNAs were also detected in neurospheres derived from the DG of adult wild-type mice (n=3, ). We further analyzed the distribution of TrkB protein in the progenitor population by co-immunostaining. Consistent with its mRNA distribution, TrkB protein was detected in all layers of the adult DG; confocal microscopy revealed its presence in both proliferating progenitors that are Ki67 positive (86.2%, n=160 cells from 3 animals), and immature neurons that express Doublecortin (94.9%, n=177 cells from 3 animals) (). Taken together, our results demonstrate the presence of TrkB mRNA and protein in hippocampal NPCs.
hGFAP-Cre activity in hippocampal progenitor cells
Germline homozygous TrkB knockout animals die shortly after birth. To investigate the role of TrkB in postnatal stages, conditional knockout animals were generated by crossing mice harboring the
trkB flox alleles to transgenic mice expressing the Cre recombinase either under the human GFAP (hGFAP) promoter or the Synapsin I (Syn) promoter (
He et al., 2004;
Luikart et al., 2005). In both the hGFAP-Cre and the Syn-Cre transgenic animals, the pattern of Cre expression allows recombination throughout the forebrain, including cerebral cortex, hippocampus and olfactory bulb. In other regions of the brain, such as the midbrain (dopaminergic neurons) and brainstem (serotonergic neurons), Cre expression is minimal (
Supplemental Figure 4 and not shown). When interbred with Rosa26-stop-lacZ reporter mice (R26) (
Soriano, 1999) and analyzed at the age of 2 months, a majority of the neurons in these regions appeared to express functional beta-galactosidase (β-gal) ( and not shown). However, when such animals were analyzed at a younger age (P10), a distinct anatomical difference in the recombination patterns of the two Cre lines was observed in the DG. In the R26
hGFAP animal most cells throughout the DG expressed β-gal; whereas in the R26
Syn animal β-gal expression was confined to the outer layers of the DG, while the SGZ and inner granule layer, where NPCs and immature neurons reside, were essentially spared of recombination ().
We next enriched NPCs from 2-month old mice by culturing primary cells from the DG in neurosphere forming media (). Upon X-gal staining, only neurospheres isolated from the DG of R26hGFAP, but not those from the R26Syn or control mice stained positive for β-gal activity, indicating that recombination only occurred in the hippocampal NPCs from the R26hGFAP mice (). Thus, the masking of X-gal staining difference in the adult DG () was likely the result of the considerably reduced numbers of NPCs and immature neuron populations at this age compared to P10. Nonetheless, we demonstrate that in adult mice the Syn-Cre transgene can only elicit recombination in differentiated neurons, while the hGFAP-Cre affects both NPCs and neurons. The effective ablation of TrkB with the hGFAP-Cre was further demonstrated by immuno-blotting for TrkB in the hippocampus of adult mice (), and by RT-PCR detection of TrkB mRNA in FACS isolated Nestin-GFP positive DG NPCs (). Therefore by utilizing these two different Cre transgenic lines, differences between genetic ablation of the TrkB gene in the granule layer of the DG versus additional ablation in the SGZ where progenitors reside can be studied.
Ablation of TrkB in early postnatal NPCs impairs DG morphogenesis
The conditional knockout animals, either carrying the hGFAP-Cre (TrkB
hGFAP) or the Syn-Cre (TrkB
Syn) are viable at birth and have normal survival rates (up to 15 months recorded) (
Luikart et al., 2005). The TrkB
hGFAP mice displayed a significant reduction in the volume of the DG granular layer () that first became measurable at P10. The volume reduction stabilized at around 30% after the initial postnatal weeks and persisted throughout adulthood. This abnormality was not caused by changes in cell density or cell size (; p>0.2), but rather was a result of decrease in the number of granule neurons, evidenced by a significant reduction in the thickness of DG granular layer (; n=6 for each, F
2,15=5.477, p=0.0164). The number and morphology of glial cells were not appreciably affected in the TrkB
hGFAP mice (
Supplemental Figure 3 and not shown). The reduction of volume was most prominently observed in the hippocampus and DG, and did not appear to be a secondary result of broader developmental defect, as the TrkB
hGFAP mice had normal body and brain size at all ages examined (
Supplemental Figure 2). We also measured the volumes of other anatomical regions, such as the striatum, in 2-month old TrkB
hGFAP mice and found normal volume (23.62 ± 0.94 mm
3 in controls, 23.32 ± 1.06 mm
3 in TrkB
hGFAP, n=6 for each, p>0.2). The TrkB
Syn animals, contrary to the TrkB
hGFAP mice, displayed normal development of the DG granular layer (). These observations demonstrate that TrkB expression in the SGZ is required for the normal structural development of the DG. The phenotypic difference between the TrkB
hGFAP and TrkB
Syn mice suggests a cell autonomous function of TrkB in the DG NPCs. We have previously reported that conditional deletion of BDNF using the hGFAP-Cre (BDNF
hGFAP) resulted in 80% reduction of BDNF protein level in the hippocampus (
Monteggia et al., 2007), we note that these mice also displayed significantly reduced DG granular layer volume, indicating a ligand-receptor coincidence (, n=8–10 for each genotype, p<0.005).
Ablation of TrkB impairs proliferation and neurogenesis
Given the apparent reduction in the number of granule neurons in TrkB
hGFAP mice, but not TrkB
Syn mice, we examined whether lack of TrkB in the NPCs affected the neurogenic capacity of the SGZ. Control and TrkB mutant animals were evaluated at P15, during a period in which the DG undergoes dynamic morphogenesis (
Altman and Bayer, 1990). The number of newly generated neurons (NeuroD positive) was drastically reduced in the TrkB
hGFAP mice, whereas the TrkB
Syn mice were comparable to the control mice (). Thus TrkB ablation in the NPCs but not in differentiated neurons impairs hippocampal neurogenesis.
Reduced neurogenesis in the absence of TrkB could be caused by increased cell death, decreased proliferation, or a combination of both processes. We first examined programmed cell death using TdT-mediated dUTP nick end labeling (TUNEL) assay and immunohistochemistry for activated caspase 3. At all time points examined, the number of apoptotic cells detected with either method was uniformly low and no measurable increase was observed in the TrkB
hGFAP mice, indicating that lack of TrkB did not appreciably affect survival
in vivo (
Supplemental Figure 3; n=6 for each, p>0.2).
We next assessed proliferation by measuring the number of cells that incorporate the DNA synthesis marker 5-bromo-2’-deoxyuridine (BrdU). P15 mice were treated with pulses of BrdU and sacrificed 24 hours after the first injection. Within the area encompassing the inner granular layer and SGZ, the number of BrdU positive cells in the TrkBhGFAP mice displayed a 48% reduction compared to control mice (; n=7–9 for each; F2,21=78.39, p<0.0001; p<0.001 for post hoc test of control to TrkBhGFAP comparison). Similarly, the number of cells positive for Ki67, an endogenous marker for actively cycling cells, was decreased by 51% in the SGZ of the TrkBhGFAP mice (; n=7–9 for each; F2,21=51.64, p<0.0001; p<0.001 for post hoc test of control to TrkBhGFAP comparison). Again, the numbers of BrdU or Ki67 positive cells were unaffected in the DG of the TrkBSyn mice (; p>0.2 for control to TrkBSyn comparisons).
To further investigate the cellular abnormality that lead to the significant decrease of proliferation in the TrkBhGFAP mice, we evaluated cell cycle exit of BrdU incorporating cells by examining their expression of Ki67 after a 2-hour chase period, at which point cells that were labeled with BrdU during the S-phase but have subsequently left the cycle would lose their Ki67 expression (BrdU+; Ki67−), whereas the ones that remained in active cell cycle would be double positive (BrdU+; Ki67+). In the TrkBhGFAP mice 23.1 ± 3.9 % of all BrdU+ cells were Ki67−, displaying a 208% increase in cell cycle exit over the control mice, where only 7.5 ± 1.3 % are Ki67− (, 1053 BrdU+ cells from 5 control, and 772 from 5 TrkBhGFAP, p<0.05). Collectively, these observations demonstrate that TrkB is required for normal precursor proliferation in the hippocampus.
Activation of TrkB in response to BDNF facilitates proliferation in vitro
Our finding that the TrkBhGFAP but not the TrkBSyn mice displayed impaired hippocampal neurogenesis suggested a cell autonomous requirement for TrkB in NPCs. To further examine their intrinsic properties, we cultured NPCs from the DG in serum-free conditions. In the presence of epidermal growth factor (EGF) and basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), DG NPCs formed neurospheres, which expressed TrkB receptor that could be activated by exogenous BDNF (). Although maintaining adult DG-derived primary neurospheres in media containing BDNF (50 ng/ml) for 7–10 days did not increase the frequency of primary neurosphere formation (not shown), there was a significant increase in the size of the neurospheres, suggesting that activation of TrkB facilitates the expansion of neurosphere-forming cells (; n=4 for each group, p<0.05 for post hoc test of with to without BDNF comparison in control cells). Primary neurospheres derived from the DG of adult TrkBhGFAP mice, when plated at equal density, displayed reduction in both the number (; n=4 for each group, p<0.005) and size (; p<0.005 for post hoc test of control to TrkBhGFAP comparison without BDNF; F1,12=102.2, p<0.0001 for genotype; F1,12=6.994, p=0.0214 for BDNF). The ability of primary neurospheres to form secondary neurospheres was also impaired in the TrkBhGFAP mice (secondary-to-primary neurosphere ratio: 0.322 ± 0.058 in TrkBhGFAP and 0.843 ± 0.096 in control, n=4 for each, p<0.005). In addition, deletion of TrkB abolished neurosphere sensitivity to BDNF stimulation (, p>0.2). Using an Annexin V labeling assay, we examined the percentage of apoptotic cells in the neurosphere cultures, and did not observe significant differences between control and TrkBhGFAP cells with or without BDNF treatment (n=4 for each; with 50 ng/ml BDNF: 14.95 ± 1.38% in controls, 16.25 ± 2.65% in TrkBhGFAP; without BDNF: 14.46 ± 1.62% in controls, 17.69 ± 2.56% in TrkBhGFAP; F1,8=1.136, p=0.3177 for genotype; F1,8=0.0498, p=0.8290 for BDNF), suggesting that the reduction in the size of neurosphere derived-from TrkBhGFAP mice was not due to survival deficits. Thus, BDNF facilitates proliferation by acting directly on NPCs and the activation of TrkB is solely responsible for this effect.
TrkB is required for induced proliferation and neurogenesis by antidepressants and voluntary exercise
Reduction in hippocampal volume has been observed in animal models of stress (
Coe et al., 2003;
Czeh et al., 2001), which may be reversed or prevented by chronic AD treatment (
Sheline et al., 2003). Similarly, reduction of hippocampal volume has been reported in some studies of human patients with major depression (
Bremner et al., 2000;
MacQueen et al., 2003) and post-traumatic stress disorder (
Gilbertson et al., 2002;
Karl et al., 2006;
Smith, 2005). Although the cellular mechanism is unclear in humans, animal studies have demonstrated that chronic exposure to various types of ADs induces DG proliferation and neurogenesis (
Malberg et al., 2000), thereby potentially contributing to the recovery of volume loss. In this context, we examined whether chronic AD treatment can restore neurogenesis in TrkB
hGFAP mice. We thus treated control, TrkB
hGFAP and TrkB
Syn mice with daily injections of the serotonin reuptake inhibitor fluoxetine (10 µg/g) or the tricyclic imipramine (20 µg/g) for 21 days (n=7–29 for each group,
Supplemental Table 1). As previously established, compared with mice receiving daily saline injections, both drugs induced substantial Ki67 immuno-reactivity in the DG of control mice (; F
2,98=40.48, p<0.0001 for treatment; p<0.001 for
post hoc test of both AD-to-saline comparisons). The induction of proliferation was echoed by an increase in the number of newly generated neurons expressing Doublecortin and NeuroD ( and not shown; F
2,98=30.79, p<0.0001 for treatment; p<0.001 for
post hoc test of both AD-to-saline comparisons). In contrast, TrkB
hGFAP mice treated with the same ADs did not show increase in the number of proliferating cells or immature neurons (; F
2,98=332.3, p<0.0001 for the effect of genotype on Ki67; F
2,98=211.6, p<0.0001 on Doublecortin). This treatment, or an extended six week treatment, also failed to restore the DG volume deficit in the TrkB
hGFAP mice (not shown). The TrkB
Syn mice responded normally to both ADs (; p<0.001 for
post hoc test of both AD-to-saline comparisons).
In rodents, voluntary exercise, such as wheel-running behavior has been demonstrated to robustly induce neurogenesis, much in the same fashion as AD treatment (
van Praag et al., 1999). Less is known, however, about the underlying mechanism of this AD-like effect of exercise. To determine whether TrkB is also required for this process, we subjected control and TrkB
hGFAP mice to 6 weeks of wheel-running (n=8–16 for each group,
Supplemental Table 2). Both the numbers of Ki67 positive and Doublecortin positive cells increased in control runners, compared to control sedentary animals (: F
1,36=13.64, p=0.0007 for exercise; : F
1,36=16.01, p=0.0003; p<0.001 for
post hoc test of both comparisons). A significant increase of BDNF protein level was also observed in the hippocampus of runners (66.44 ± 3.65 pg/mg in runners; 45.83 ± 2.99 pg/mg in sedentary controls; n=3 for each; p<0.05). The TrkB
hGFAP mice, despite normal running distance (5.96 ± 0.41 km/day in controls, 5.48 ± 0.34 km/day in TrkB
hGFAP, p>0.2) as well as elevation of BDNF level in runners (60.33 ± 4.43 pg/mg in runners; 40.94 ± 1.37 pg/ml in sedentary controls; n=3 for each; p<0.05), did not show any increase in proliferation and neurogenesis (, p>0.2 for both). Since we tested male and female mice in the voluntary exercise paradigm, we further separated the results into gender and genotype-specific groups and found no statistically significant difference between males and females of the same genotype (not shown).
TrkB is required for behavioral improvement induced by ADs and exercise
To determine whether the lack of neurogenic response in the TrkB
hGFAP mice was coupled with general insensitivity to chronic ADs and exercise, we compared the depression and anxiety-like behaviors in control and TrkB
hGFAP mice. First, mice treated with fluoxetine, imipramine, or saline for 21 days were examined in the novelty-suppressed feeding test (NSFT), a conflict paradigm in which the latency to feed in a novel environment is used as an indicator of anxiety level (
Santarelli et al., 2003). In agreement with the general capacity of chronic ADs to ease anxiety, 24 hours after the last dose, control mice receiving fluoxetine or imipramine displayed significantly shorter latency to feed compared to saline-treated control mice (; F
2,100=8.022, p=0.0006 for treatment; p<0.001 for
post hoc test both AD-to-saline comparisons). The TrkB
hGFAP mice, on the contrary, were insensitive to the effects of either AD (; F
2,100=10.49, p<0.0001 for genotype). Similarly, TrkB
hGFAP mice exposed to 6 weeks of running showed no improvement in the NSFT, whereas the control runners displayed clear decrease in latency compared to sedentary animals (; F
1,41=15.09, p=0.0004 for genotype; p<0.05 for
post hoc test of running effect in control mice). No difference in home cage consumption, or body weight loss was observed across genotypes (not shown).
Next we examined depression-like behavior in the control and TrkB
hGFAP mice by using the tail-suspension test (TST), a paradigm of inescapable stress (
Porsolt et al., 1987). All mice were tested 48 hours after the last dose of AD or saline to exclude the acute effects on behaviors that do not correlate with prior duration of drug treatment, or clinical responses. Control runners and AD treated control mice showed decreased immobility (a state of “behavioral despair”), compared to sedentary or saline treated control mice, respectively (: F
1,41=9.082, p=0.0044 for exercise,
post hoc p<0.01; : F
2,100=20.03, p<0.0001 for AD,
post hoc p<0.01 for fluoxetine, p<0.001 for imipramine). The TrkB
hGFAP mice again failed to display any appreciable response to either treatment (: F
2,100=4.233, p=0.0172 for genotype; : F
1,41=9.082, p=0.0044 for genotype).
Despite the lack of responses to ADs and exercise in the behavioral paradigms of NSFT and TST, the saline-treated TrkB
hGFAP mice performed similarly compared to the control mice, suggesting relatively normal depression and anxiety-like behaviors at the basal level. To further investigate this finding, we examined a cohort of control and TrkB
hGFAP mice in a series of behavioral measures (
Supplemental Figure 5; n=17–21 for each). We observed no significant differences within these two groups in the dark-light test in both the length of time spent and activity in the light compartment. In the open field test, the TrkB
hGFAP mice were equivalent to controls in the time spent in the center. In the elevated-plus maze test, the TrkB
hGFAP mice spent more time in the open arm compared to littermate controls. Together these results suggest normal (and in some case reduced) baseline anxiety-like behaviors in the TrkB
hGFAP mice. Similarly, in the forced swim test, the TrkB
hGFAP mice displayed normal latency to immobility, and a non-significant trend toward decreased total length of immobility, thereby supporting earlier observations of normal baseline depression-like behavior. Based on the above observations, we conclude that the lack of responses to AD and exercise in the TrkB
hGFAP mice cannot be explained by alterations in baseline behaviors, but rather is a result of insensitivity to the molecular and cellular changes induced by chronic AD and exercise.
Normal sensitivity to chronic ADs in mice lacking TrkB in differentiated neurons
To explore whether the deficit in increased neurogenesis contributed to the abolished behavior sensitivity to chronic AD, we tested the TrkBSyn mice in the TST and the NSFT. Similar to control mice, upon chronic treatment with fluoxetine and imipramine, the TrkBSyn mice showed significant decreases in anxiety (; post hoc p<0.05 for both ADs) and depression-like behaviors (; post hoc p<0.05 for both ADs). This result, in conjunction with the observation that chronic AD treatment increased DG proliferation and neurogenesis in these mice (), indicates that despite the lack of TrkB in differentiated neurons, the unaffected TrkB signaling in the NPCs was sufficient for the TrkBSyn mice to display a behavioral response to chronic AD.
Specific ablation of TrkB in adult NPCs is sufficient to block sensitivity to AD
To further delineate whether TrkB function in adult NPCs alone was required for AD induced neurogenic and behavioral responses, we utilized a tamoxifen-inducible form of Cre recombinase, CreERT2, expressed under the regulatory element of the Nestin gene in which TrkB ablation could be confined to the adult neurogenic niches. When interbred with the R26 reporter mice (R26Nestin), Cre activity in the Nestin-CreER mice could be visualized either in embryonic or in adult CNS, in a tamoxifen-dependent manner. Specifically, when 1-month old R26Nestin mice were injected with vehicle or tamoxifen and analyzed 1 month afterwards, spontaneous recombination (vehicle treated) was minimal, while tamoxifen-induced recombination was restricted to the DG, sub-ventricular zone (SVZ), rostral migratory stream, olfactory bulb and cerebellum ( and not shown). In the DG, recombination occurred specifically in the inner granular layer and SGZ. To evaluate the efficiency of the Nestin-CreER to target NPCs, we induced R26Nestin mice at 1 month and analyzed them at 2 months and 7 months of age. The number of X-gal stained cells was dramatically increased in the 6 months post-injection group, indicating effective recombination in the NPCs that were capable of proliferation and self-renewal (). Additional confirmation was obtained by double-immunostaining for β-gal and doublecortin at 4 months of age, where the majority of doublecortin positive cells also co-express β-gal ().
As described above, hGFAP-Cre mediated ablation of TrkB resulted in a smaller DG that we attribute to the lack of TrkB signaling in early postnatal NPCs to sustain rapid proliferation required for normal structural development. To bypass this essential phase of DG postnatal morphogenesis, we subjected TrkB
flox/flox; Nestin-CreER mice to tamoxifen (TrkB
Nestin) at 1 month of age. Littermate TrkB
flox/flox; Nestin-CreER mice injected with vehicle, and TrkB
flox/flox mice injected with tamoxifen were analyzed, and collectively presented as the control group. At the age of 6 weeks and 3 months, TrkB mRNA was virtually undetectable by RT-PCR in the DG NPCs of TrkB
Nestin mice, using FACS sorted Nestin-GFP positive cells (). TrkB protein was also absent from the proliferating cells of the SGZ, while its level in the majority of granular neurons was unaffected (). As expected, ablation of TrkB at 1 month did not lead to reduction in DG granular layer volume, when examined at 3 months of age (; n=6 for each; p>0.2). Basal proliferation in the SGZ at this age (Ki67 positive) was modestly decreased in the TrkB
Nestin mice, whereas no aberrant cell death was observed (
Supplemental Figure 6). Upon exposure to fluoxetine (10ug/g) or imipramine (20ug/g) for 21 days (n=8–10 for each), the TrkB
Nestin mice did not display increased proliferation as measured by the numbers of Ki67 (; F
1,50=176.7, p<0.0001 for genotype; F
2,50=12.45, p<0.0001 for treatment; F
2,50=13.57, p<0.0001 for interaction) and phosphorylated histone-H3 positive cells (
Supplemental Figure 6; F
1,50=131.9, p<0.0001 for genotype; F
2,50=17.46, p<0.0001 for treatment; F
2,50=17.34, p<0.0001 for interaction). The number of newly generated neurons as labeled by Doublecortin also did not change in the TrkB
Nestin mice (; F
1,50=141.9, p<0.0001 for genotype; F
2,50=7.014, p=0.0021 for treatment; F
2,50=12.56, p<0.0001 for interaction). The absence of neurogenic response in the TrkB
Nestin mice coincided with a lack of behavioral improvements both in the NSFT (; F
1,50=13.68, p=0.0005 for genotype) and the TST (; F
1,50=18.15, p<0.0001 for genotype). These observations refine and confirm the preceding studies, indicating that ablation of TrkB from adult NPCs alone is sufficient to block sensitivity to chronic ADs.