The von Hippel-Lindau tumor suppressor gene product (VHL) is an essential component of the cellular response to hypoxia (
8,
9). To gain insight into the role of VHL in β-cell formation and function, we have specifically inactivated
Vhlh in β-cells by
Cre-loxP mutagenesis. Elimination of
Vhlh in embryonic and mature β-cells reveals that VHL is dispensable for β-cell formation and differentiation. However, loss of VHL has profound effects on β-cell function, demonstrating a novel role for VHL in maintaining glucose homeostasis.
Mice lacking Vhlh in adult β-cells develop severe glucose intolerance. The phenotype onset occurs with a slight delay that is not completely understood, and future work could address whether slow turnover of the existing stores of VHL might provide an explanation. Our results show that total insulin protein content in Vhlh-deficient islets is not significantly reduced. These results point to a specific defect in insulin secretion as the underlying cause of the glucose intolerance phenotype. Basal unstimulated insulin secretion in Vhlh-deficient mice parallels that of control littermates. In fact, when challenged with high glucose, mice lacking VHL in β-cells normalize blood glucose ~3 h after the control group, an effect that might be explained by basal insulin secretion. In vitro, Vhlh-deficient islets fail to secrete elevated levels of insulin when incubated with high glucose, uncovering a role for VHL in regulating the metabolic response. The ability of Vhlh-deficient islets to secrete insulin in the presence of KCl indicates the presence of a competent secretory system, placing the defect further upstream. As absolute levels of insulin secreted in the presence of KCl are lower in Vhlh-deficient islets, a defect in the exocytotic machinery cannot be ruled out. It is, however, important to note that the relative increase in insulin secretion in the presence of KCl compared with basal levels is similar between control and mutant mice.
These results raise the question of how the loss of VHL affects insulin secretion. Previous work has demonstrated that hypoxia impairs insulin secretion (
32–
34). VHL inactivation, via HIF-1α stabilization, mimics certain aspects of the cellular response to hypoxia, and canonical target genes of the HIF complex, including
Vegf and
Glut1, are significantly upregulated in VHL-depleted islets. Similar to our in vivo studies, in vitro experiments performed on isolated islets have shown that hypoxic conditions lead to an almost complete block in glucose-stimulated insulin secretion, while basal secretion is only slightly reduced (
32,
34). While the mechanism by which hypoxia impairs insulin secretion is not completely understood, it is generally believed to involve the depletion of energy stores in β-cells. During hypoxia, and through HIF-1α function, a switch from oxidative phosphorylation to aerobic glycolysis occurs, resulting in impaired ATP production (
1). The ATP-to-ADP ratio has been proposed as a major regulator of insulin secretion (rev. in
29). Defects in ATP production have been linked to impairment of insulin secretion in response to glucose (
27,
33,
35). Furthermore, mitochondrial mutations that result in decreased ATP production have been linked to diabetes in humans (
36–
38).
Both hypoxia and loss of VHL induce the expression of genes related to the glycolytic pathway that could lead to decreased ATP production. We observe upregulation of several genes that indicate a switch from oxidative phosphorylation to glycolytic metabolism in
Vhlh-deficient islets. Among other genes, increased expression of
Gapdh,
Pfk, and
Pgm2 is observed. Further evidence of a shift away from oxidative phosphorylation as the primary energy source in
Vhlh-deficient islets was the dramatic increase in expression of genes involved in lactate formation (
LDHa), regulation of lactate formation (
PDK), and lactate secretion (
MCT4) as well as increased lactate in the culture medium. Overexpression of
LDHa has been shown to attenuate glucose-induced insulin secretion in the mature β-cell line MIN6 (
39). Together, these observations point to defects in glucose metabolism as a possible cause for β-cell dysfunction in
Vhlh-deficient mice. The VHL–HIF-1α axis controls the expression of a large number of genes. We cannot formally exclude that alterations in other genes might influence β-cell function. Indeed, expression of the glucose transporter,
Glut-2, is reduced in
Vhlh-deficient islets. Decreased expression of
Glut-2 has been reported in several animal models of diabetes (
40–
42). In vitro, islets of
Glut-2–deficient mice display impaired glucose-stimulated insulin secretion (
43). Therefore, defective islet glucose uptake could play a role in β-cell impairment in
Vhlh-deficient mice. However, a reduction but not elimination of
Glut-2 expression () might not hinder glucose uptake below the
Km threshold for glucokinase. Under these circumstances, the contribution of
Glut-2 in the development of the observed phenotype might be minor. Further analysis will elucidate the precise consequence of decreased levels of
Glut-2 in
Vhlh−/− islets.
Additional evidence points to defective signaling due to hypoxia as a contributor to diabetes. Upregulation of hypoxia-related genes has been observed in pre-diabetic and diabetic Zucker diabetic fatty (ZDF) rats (
44). Recent studies suggest that inhibition of the hypoxic response also affects β-cell function. A dramatic decrease in HIF-1β (ARNT), the partner of HIF-1α, was reported in islets obtained from type 2 diabetic patients, indicating an involvement of the hypoxia genes in β-cell dysfunction (
45). Furthermore, the authors showed that a β-cell–specific knockout of HIF-1β in transgenic mice leads to abnormal glucose tolerance, and the genetic changes in islets overlap with those found in islets from diabetic patients. In agreement with our results, some of the genes affected in β-cells lacking HIF-1β are involved in glucose sensing and metabolism. It is possible that dysregulation of the glycolytic pathway (either by upregulation or downregulation) impairs β-cell function.
Although our results strongly suggest that cell autonomous changes in β-cells impair glucose regulation, we cannot formally exclude the scenario that the aberrations in islet architecture caused by increased
Vegf expression might influence β-cell function. However, previously reported studies in other existing mouse models that ectopically express
Vegf either in β-cells or in the pancreas have failed to report glucose-intolerant phenotypes (
46,
47). Nonetheless, it cannot be excluded that inappropriately increased vascularization might impede insulin secretion, possibly through incorrectly established contacts between the β-cells and the endothelium. Future work will need to address this issue.
VHL is a tumor suppressor gene. Germline
VHL mutations in humans predispose to certain types of tumors, affecting several organs, including the kidney and pancreas (
10). Although the most frequent pancreatic manifestation of VHL disease is serous cysts, a small percentage of VHL patients develop nonfunctional islet cell tumors (
17,
18). We have not observed islet tumor formation in
Vhlh-deficient mice. However, it is important to note that in our studies, inactivation of
Vhlh has been restricted to β-cells. The cell of origin of islet tumors in VHL patients is not known. Therefore, islet tumor formation might require loss of VHL in other non–β-cells. Alternatively, islet tumor formation in
Vhlh-deficient β-cells might involve a second event, as has been described for other VHL-related tumors such as in the kidney (
48).
In summary, we have shown that loss of VHL in β-cells leads to defects in glucose homeostasis. We believe that the β-cell–specific
Vhlh-deficient mice might be a useful tool as a “genetic hypoxia” model, to unravel the possible link between hypoxia signaling and impairment of β-cell function. This is particularly important, since the β-cell response to hypoxia could also be relevant for therapeutic approaches to diabetes. Islet transplantation studies have noted a dramatic increase in HIF-1 levels soon after transplantation that causes apoptosis and a block in insulin secretion (
49). Thus, preventing hypoxic conditions might not only affect transplant survival but also prevent changes in insulin secretion.